henry quirk wrote: ↑Wed Jun 30, 2021 5:18 pm
"Spiritual" "Atheism" = Lacewing - a contradiction
Nah, lace ain't an atheist, she's a monist...
Monism is the philosophy that asserts oneness as its fundamental premise, and it contradicts the dualism-based theistic premise that there is a creator God that is eternal and separate from the rest of existence. There are two types of monism, namely spiritual monism which holds that all spiritual reality is one, and material monism which holds that everything including all material reality is one and the same thing.
...
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Creator_deity
And
that, seeds, is the point.
WHERE did this idea/notion that thee Creator God is separate from the rest of Existence?
And, when you say and claim that, " 'material monism' holds that "everything" including all material reality is one and the same thing ", would the "including all material" part, just be redundant anyway with, and by, the words "material monism"?
Now, if, to you,"spiritual monism" holds that all 'spiritual reality' is one, then it would just go without saying that "material monism" would then just hold that all "material reality" is one. But, WHY does "material monism, to 'you', "henry quirk", supposedly also HOLD 'all spiritual reality' as well?
That is what you are 'trying to' say and are alluding to here, correct?
I can agree with and accept that 'monism', itself, holds EVERY thing together as One Everything, but, by definition, 'material monism' implies that there is NO spiritual, matter.
Also, that "athiests" see a 'world' of material ONLY, and that they do NOT see 'anything spiritual' is what I think "attofishpi" has been 'trying to' say. Although it is NOT correct, and what "attofishpi" would be much better of saying is, "Of those who only SEE or BELIEVE that there is ONLY physical matter and NO spiritual context to the "world"/Universe, then ....".
Because OBVIOUSLY one who BELIEVES God does NOT EXIST, in other words, an "athiest", does NOT necessarily ALSO BELIEVE that there is NO 'spiritual matter' AT ALL in nor to thee Universe, Itself.
But as, "attofishpi", 'tries to' fit or squeeze particular people into one hole, or group, then that OBVIOUSLY does NOT WORK. And, coversely, 'trying to' CLAIM that "theists" view and see things the same, then that will ALSO NOT WORK.
This happening BOTH WAYS can be CLEARLY SEEN in the words, of 'one':
Well psychosis isn't really a choice, it usually just happens and it's quite unstoppable.
Theists in general however, even on this forum: what I find funny about them is that they have so wildly different ideas about their Gods, that they hardly could agree on anything in a hundred years. But this somehow never seems to bother them.
Which was AGREED UPON in the words, by "another":
Yes! They are unbothered by so many contradictions...
Which can be CLEARLY SEEN is these people were 'trying to' fit and squeeze particular people into one hole, or group, which although ALSO OBVIOUSLY does NOT WORK, but is the EXACT SAME thinking and behavior of the "other" human being.
That is; ALL of these adult human beings, in the days when this was written, were ALL 'trying to' squeeze and fit "themselves" into SEPARATE groups, as in what we referred to as 'pigeon holing'.
The "us AND them", and the, "we AND they", which can be VERY CLEARLY OBSERVED and SEEN here, IS WHY ALL of those human beings could NOT and DID NOT come together Peacefully AND Harmoniously, in those days.