Page 27 of 41

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Tue Oct 27, 2026 8:06 pm
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 7:32 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 6:13 pm But let's suppose Aristotle HAD done it. The secularists cannot accept Natural Law theory. It would force him to become non-secular. So if Aristotle had succeeded, it wouldn't help secularism even a stroke. He can't follow Aristotle's trail; it's inherently teleological, and the secularist has to deny the possibility of teleology.
Sorry, IC, you can't just add a requirement to "secular" that it necessarily be non-teleological.
I didn't. They did.
Arguing "morality inherent in humans" (because of the kind of animal they are) involves no gods.
But it's immediately afoul of Hume's critique...namely, that it's a factoid that does not imply a value. It might be the case that a belief in moralties (because there are various ones, obviously) is inherent to human beings. That doesn't tell us whether they're real or delusory, good or bad, something to continue or something to overcome and eliminate. And cases have been made -- most notably by Nietzsche -- for just that.
Natural Law theory is teleological but puts the "purpose" simply as inherent to a things being.

No, actually; it goes well beyond any such vague notion, and aims to deduce the intended function, ethical usage and teleological purpose of things from naturalistic observation.

You'll find it helpful to be able to realize the actual critiques philosophers have already raised. There's good reason why most ethicists and moral philosophers are not Natural Law theorists.

Natural law theory faces several classic philosophical and metaethical objections.

The Is-Ought Fallacy (Hume's Guillotine)

• The Argument: Scottish philosopher David Hume argued that you cannot logically derive a moral duty ("ought") merely from a factual observation of nature ("is").
• The Problem: Natural law claims that because an organ or biological process has a specific "natural" function (e.g., reproduction), acting against that function is morally wrong. Critics argue this treats biological facts as if they were already moral commands.

Rejection of Teleology

• The Argument: Classical natural law depends on a teleological view of the universe—the idea that nature and living things have an intrinsic purpose, goal, or design.
• The Problem: Modern science (from Darwinian evolution to modern physics) describes nature as mechanistic, random, and driven by blind natural selection rather than purposeful design. Without a built-in purpose in nature, deriving moral rules from it loses its foundation.

Disagreement Over Human Nature

• The Argument: Natural law assumes there is a universal, fixed "human nature" that all people share and can recognize through reason.
• The Problem: Anthropologists, sociologists, and philosophers point out that human beings have vastly different cultures, biological drives, psychological traits, and moral intuitions across history and geography. There is no universal agreement on what is "natural" for humans.

Cultural Relativism and Diversity

• The Argument: Proponents claim natural law principles are self-evident to human reason.
• The Problem: Practices considered "unnatural" or taboo in one society (such as specific family structures, economic arrangements, or social roles) have been viewed as completely normal and moral in others, suggesting that moral ideas are socially constructed rather than hardwired into nature.

Absolutism vs. Complex Moral Dilemmas

• The Argument: Natural law frameworks often treat certain moral norms as absolute and exceptionless (e.g., prohibitions against interfering with natural reproductive or biological ends).
• The Problem: These rigid rules frequently clash with considered moral judgments in real-world scenarios—such as medical interventions, self-defense, or complex pregnancy complications—where strict adherence to "natural" outcomes leads to tragic or harmful results.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Tue Oct 27, 2026 9:58 pm
by FlashDangerpants
Did IC just paste a huge block of AI text?

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Tue Oct 27, 2026 11:26 pm
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 8:06 pm
Disagreement Over Human Nature

• The Argument: Natural law assumes there is a universal, fixed "human nature" that all people share and can recognize through reason.
• The Problem: Anthropologists, sociologists, and philosophers point out that human beings have vastly different cultures, biological drives, psychological traits, and moral intuitions across history and geography. There is no universal agreement on what is "natural" for humans.

Cultural Relativism and Diversity

• The Argument: Proponents claim natural law principles are self-evident to human reason.
• The Problem: Practices considered "unnatural" or taboo in one society (such as specific family structures, economic arrangements, or social roles) have been viewed as completely normal and moral in others, suggesting that moral ideas are socially constructed rather than hardwired into nature.
The real problem with this critique is that it is making up what the proponents of "natural to humans" are claiming.

1) There is a fixed "human nature" in that humans are obligatory social animals, and as such they have "culture".
NOT BEING CLAIMED --- what the details of those cultures will be. The objection "human beings have vastly different cultures, biological drives, psychological traits, and moral intuitions across history and geography" is no objection at all because not being claimed that the details of culture are from human nature. Human nature dictates that humans will have culture, and cultures will evolve.

2) moral ideas are socially constructed rather than hardwired into nature --- absolutely correct. It was NOT being claimed that these were hardwired from nature. The cultures are "entities" subject to the rules of evolution << change in random ways, but changes resulting in an advantage for a society relative to other societies will result in the society "surviving" and those resulting in disadvantage societies disappearing. So we will only see the former in existing societies. >>

There are not going to be many details in common across all human societies. I can suggest a few.......... and I think it might be profitable for us to consider not the differences between societies but what is absolutely in common, when these are learned, and how they might act to cause humans to believe in morality (that there is a right way and a wring way to act).

ESPECIALLY if for these clearly not learned "because my god decreed them to me"

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2026 1:49 am
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 11:26 pm ... humans are obligatory social animals...
But they are not animals that are obligated to be moral? Because nothing says that an "animal" that just, as a matter of chance, happens to be born in a particular social group, owes anybody to do anything. To be "obliged" to be in a society is not the same as to be "obligated" to be moral.
2) moral ideas are socially constructed...
The word you should use is, to be kind "invented," or to be blunt, "imagined." That's the truth, if "moral" means the same as "what a society creates."
There are not going to be many details in common across all human societies.
No, and very few morals, if cultures "construct" their own...that is, make them up to suit their own purposes.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2026 3:03 pm
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Oct 28, 2026 1:49 am That's the truth, if "moral" means the same as "what a society creates."
There are not going to be many details in common across all human societies.
No, and very few morals, if cultures "construct" their own...that is, make them up to suit their own purposes.
Uh, is this part of you attachment to "design"?

A culture is not a conscious entity choosing to "make up to suit purposes". Think of "pruning". Cultures which evolve practices that do not serve to their advantage are pruned out of existence. But in any case you are hung upon DETAILS (of what is considered "right conduct") rather than the category of action.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2026 4:01 pm
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 3:03 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Oct 28, 2026 1:49 am That's the truth, if "moral" means the same as "what a society creates."
There are not going to be many details in common across all human societies.
No, and very few morals, if cultures "construct" their own...that is, make them up to suit their own purposes.
A culture is not a conscious entity choosing to "make up to suit purposes".
That's exactly what "constructed" implies. I think that was your word, was it not?
Think of "pruning". Cultures which evolve practices that do not serve to their advantage are pruned out of existence.
The problem with pruning, as an analogy, is that it's a take-away process. Something has to already exist, if you're going to "prune" it. Things don't come into existence by "pruning": they are cut out by "pruning."

To "construct," on the other hand, is not to "prune." It's to compile, or arrange, or add to. So something's wrong with that analogy, I think.

But perhaps you're thinking of an undifferentiated mass of human behaviours that pre-exist the "pruning"? And maybe you're thinking that morality is all about interdictions -- about things that are not to be done, about negatives? And the "pruning" is the negating of the wrong?

But then you've lost any account of morality's positives, of the things it doesn't simply interdict but encourages, approves, lauds or promotes. That would leave you with a very hamstrung account of morality, since moral philosophy generally recognizes not just blame but praise as axiomatically included in a concept of "morality."

So again, something's really fundamentally wrong with that paradigm, I think.

Cultures both instruct and instruct-against various behaviours. And they do so on what basis? You say "their advantage." Well, that sure sounds to me exactly like "making up" things, in order to suit some purpose of their own. I think it's an apt description of exactly what you claim they're doing.
But in any case you are hung upon DETAILS (of what is considered "right conduct") rather than the category of action.
Well, "conduct" is "action." So I can't see exactly what your objection is here...can you clarify?

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2026 5:15 pm
by MikeNovack
IC, you simply do not understand the CONCEPT of evolution.

Cultures do not DECIDE those details. No pick and choose. But wrong (in the functional sense) leads to non-existence.

If we consider some general category (will wear "clothes") the details how (properly) fulfilled will be arbitrary (how a society does that) BUT those details will be perceived by the people of that society as part of "wearing clothes".

But the society did not CHOOSE the detail, no committee sat down and decided.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2026 5:31 pm
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 5:15 pm IC, you simply do not understand the CONCEPT of evolution.
:D Tell yourself that, if it helps you.
Cultures do not DECIDE those details. No pick and choose. But wrong (in the functional sense) leads to non-existence.
Then explain why Islam is able to survive, despite having the most suicidal sort of beliefs about what's morally right and wrong. Or explain how animists managed to find sacrificing their children to Ba'al helpful to their survival. I'll wait.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2026 10:03 pm
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 5:31 pm
Then explain why Islam is able to survive, despite having the most suicidal sort of beliefs about what's morally right and wrong. Or explain how animists managed to find sacrificing their children to Ba'al helpful to their survival. I'll wait.
a) Islam is a religion, not a culture. There are MANY cultures where Islam is the dominant religion. If you do not understand the difference between a culture and a religion it's going to be difficult to discuss culture.

b) The Ba'al worshipers were NOT "animists". If you know nothing about ancient religions, best not talk about them. Or about animists.
Ba'al is not the name of a god. Baal is a title. If you read, for example that some place back them was worshiping Ba'al Shamyim (shortens to just Ba'al) you DON'T know what God they meant by "Master of the heavens". Could be different gods in different places.

But again I will repeat, you DON'T understand evolution. It is generally pointless to ask WHY something is advantageous or disadvantageous until you know whether it is or not << does this culture thrive relative to its competition or fall by the wayside >> and even then you generally do not know the specifics. Rome overcame Carthage, but I seriously doubt killing babies had anything to do with that << they both did >>

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2026 11:21 pm
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 10:03 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 5:31 pm
Then explain why Islam is able to survive, despite having the most suicidal sort of beliefs about what's morally right and wrong. Or explain how animists managed to find sacrificing their children to Ba'al helpful to their survival. I'll wait.
a) Islam is a religion, not a culture.
It's very much both. Islam makes no differentiation between the political and the religious. Submission in all dimensions is required. It's called "Sharia."

So...just how is that survival-helpful?
Ba'al is not the name of a god. Baal is a title.
Both are true. There was both a specific deity known as "Ba'al," and it means "lord." But let's switch to Moloch, or to any of the other child-sacrifice gods, and you tell me how that's survival-apt.
But again I will repeat, you DON'T understand evolution.
Yeah, I do. But you don't get Hume's critique, obviously, or you'd quit raising the irrelevant.

Evolution, if true, would only be a fact, not a value. Evolution does not come with a moral code. It has no terms, no teleology, and in fact, kills more of its participants than are said to survive.

Meanwhile, you have vastly different "moralities" proposed by different societies. And they certainly aren't all survival-enhancing. In fact, Indian culture, with its emphasis on male heirs and horrendous dowry duties, has resulted in the murder of 45.8 million little girls, according to the UN. Nice culture. Very survival-enhancing, for boys. Not so much, for girls.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Fri Oct 30, 2026 1:43 am
by popeye1945
Morality is compassion as a working model or system; the rights and welfare of the individual are somewhat guaranteed by the system, the working model, societies become that working model.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sat Oct 31, 2026 3:41 pm
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 11:21 pm And they certainly aren't all survival-enhancing. In fact, Indian culture, with its emphasis on male heirs and horrendous dowry duties, has resulted in the murder of 45.8 million little girls, according to the UN. Nice culture. Very survival-enhancing, for boys. Not so much, for girls.
You REALLY don't get it, do you. There is no "should" in evolution. You don't know what "culture" means.

a) There is no "Indian culture". There are LOTS of cultures in India.

b) It would be an empirical matter, how do the Indian cultures with emphasis on male heirs and dowries fare vs the Indian cultures without these features.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sat Oct 31, 2026 6:42 pm
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sat Oct 31, 2026 3:41 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 11:21 pm And they certainly aren't all survival-enhancing. In fact, Indian culture, with its emphasis on male heirs and horrendous dowry duties, has resulted in the murder of 45.8 million little girls, according to the UN. Nice culture. Very survival-enhancing, for boys. Not so much, for girls.
There is no "should" in evolution.
Exactly! But you don't get it, apparently.


"Should" is exactly what morality is about. With no entailed "should," evolution has zero to say about morality. It can't tell us even one little thing about right and wrong.
You don't know what "culture" means.
Now, don't be silly. In any case, "culture" can no more ground morality than "evolution" can. Both are mere facts, not any basis for grounding values of any kind.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2026 3:22 am
by promethean75
But evolution has bred in us an ability to recognize that cooperative behavior in groups can be pretty f_ckin' beneficial to the cooperator. So much so that our 'shoulds' are almost inherent fixtures in our instincts. We sense that stealing and attacking and betraying will get us into trouble... and even little childrens will hand over their toy to another children if he's got the blues. Out of nowhere. I mean, the kid hadn't even taken one home economics class yet, and already, at three years old, he's doing charity work.

Now, he wouldn't do that unless his species had been trialed and tested for so long that anything less than behavior like that meant danger to the group somehow. It's like grooming. Sharing is the same kind of affectionate behavior, and it's down there in the DNA.

You're taking a simple thing, obfuscating its simple nature with unnecessary semantic twists and turns and then, to solve the imaginary problems you've just invented, you bring god in to make the mess you've made salvageable again. But there was no problem. There's a reason why our brains don't wire us to want to kill everyone around us. And that's because that usually doesn't work out well for anyone.

All our little reasons - we wanna be virtuous, do the right thing, be responsible - are what we think we are doing the cooperating for... but they aren't. We're cooperating because we don't know what else to do and are nearly incapable of not cooperating in some way or another. That's how natural and without the need for any supernatural foundation our species' morality is, mate.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2026 5:05 am
by Immanuel Can
promethean75 wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 3:22 am But evolution has bred in us an ability to recognize that cooperative behavior in groups can be pretty f_ckin' beneficial to the cooperator.
Well, remember playing games like D&D, when you were a kid? The most advantageous player position was to be what they called "radical neutral," with regard to morality. That's where the player can play along with conventional morality when it serves his/her purpose, but has the ability to break with it whenever it doesn't. And that's by far the most survival-apt strategy as well: it lets the player reap all of the benefits of being seen as "moral," while never having to pay much of a price for it.

So no, evolution doesn't breed "cooperative behaviour," except when it is to the advantage of the individual organism. It really would be conducive to "radical neutral" pseudo-morals, so that same organism can seize survival advantages beyond the norm.