I didn't. They did.MikeNovack wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 7:32 pmSorry, IC, you can't just add a requirement to "secular" that it necessarily be non-teleological.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 6:13 pm But let's suppose Aristotle HAD done it. The secularists cannot accept Natural Law theory. It would force him to become non-secular. So if Aristotle had succeeded, it wouldn't help secularism even a stroke. He can't follow Aristotle's trail; it's inherently teleological, and the secularist has to deny the possibility of teleology.
But it's immediately afoul of Hume's critique...namely, that it's a factoid that does not imply a value. It might be the case that a belief in moralties (because there are various ones, obviously) is inherent to human beings. That doesn't tell us whether they're real or delusory, good or bad, something to continue or something to overcome and eliminate. And cases have been made -- most notably by Nietzsche -- for just that.Arguing "morality inherent in humans" (because of the kind of animal they are) involves no gods.
Natural Law theory is teleological but puts the "purpose" simply as inherent to a things being.
No, actually; it goes well beyond any such vague notion, and aims to deduce the intended function, ethical usage and teleological purpose of things from naturalistic observation.
You'll find it helpful to be able to realize the actual critiques philosophers have already raised. There's good reason why most ethicists and moral philosophers are not Natural Law theorists.
Natural law theory faces several classic philosophical and metaethical objections.
The Is-Ought Fallacy (Hume's Guillotine)
• The Argument: Scottish philosopher David Hume argued that you cannot logically derive a moral duty ("ought") merely from a factual observation of nature ("is").
• The Problem: Natural law claims that because an organ or biological process has a specific "natural" function (e.g., reproduction), acting against that function is morally wrong. Critics argue this treats biological facts as if they were already moral commands.
Rejection of Teleology
• The Argument: Classical natural law depends on a teleological view of the universe—the idea that nature and living things have an intrinsic purpose, goal, or design.
• The Problem: Modern science (from Darwinian evolution to modern physics) describes nature as mechanistic, random, and driven by blind natural selection rather than purposeful design. Without a built-in purpose in nature, deriving moral rules from it loses its foundation.
Disagreement Over Human Nature
• The Argument: Natural law assumes there is a universal, fixed "human nature" that all people share and can recognize through reason.
• The Problem: Anthropologists, sociologists, and philosophers point out that human beings have vastly different cultures, biological drives, psychological traits, and moral intuitions across history and geography. There is no universal agreement on what is "natural" for humans.
Cultural Relativism and Diversity
• The Argument: Proponents claim natural law principles are self-evident to human reason.
• The Problem: Practices considered "unnatural" or taboo in one society (such as specific family structures, economic arrangements, or social roles) have been viewed as completely normal and moral in others, suggesting that moral ideas are socially constructed rather than hardwired into nature.
Absolutism vs. Complex Moral Dilemmas
• The Argument: Natural law frameworks often treat certain moral norms as absolute and exceptionless (e.g., prohibitions against interfering with natural reproductive or biological ends).
• The Problem: These rigid rules frequently clash with considered moral judgments in real-world scenarios—such as medical interventions, self-defense, or complex pregnancy complications—where strict adherence to "natural" outcomes leads to tragic or harmful results.