What is morality?

Should you think about your duty, or about the consequences of your actions? Or should you concentrate on becoming a good person?

Moderators: AMod, iMod

User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: What is morality?

Post by Immanuel Can »

Gary Childress wrote: ↑Mon Oct 26, 2026 12:47 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sun Oct 25, 2026 10:46 pm
Gary Childress wrote: ↑Sun Oct 25, 2026 6:21 pm

But IC. You seem to insist that humans can choose to believe or not believe what they believe. Is that true or is that not true?
Well, what do you believe about it? Or should I ask what the impersonal universe made you believe about it? Which is the right question to ask you?
So, since you didn't provide confirmation one way or the other
Actually, I did, if you noticed. You asked whether or not humans could choose to believe. And I pointed out to you that even in posing the question, you're having to assume they do. If they don't, if they can't, one cannot even ask the question.

Too indirect for you? I hope the point is now clear.
MikeNovack
Posts: 1453
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm

Re: What is morality?

Post by MikeNovack »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Oct 26, 2026 3:14 pm And I pointed out to you that even in posing the question, you're having to assume they do. If they don't, if they can't, one cannot even ask the question.

Too indirect for you? I hope the point is now clear.
Uh IC, at the heart of the matter is "do we have free will?" (does free will exist). So you cannot assume that they can (choose to believe or not) because they can ask the question. It's not CAN we ask the question but did we CHOOSE to ask the question.
Gary Childress
Posts: 13620
Joined: Sun Sep 25, 2011 3:08 pm
Location: It's my fault

Re: What is morality?

Post by Gary Childress »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Oct 26, 2026 3:14 pm
Gary Childress wrote: ↑Mon Oct 26, 2026 12:47 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sun Oct 25, 2026 10:46 pm
Well, what do you believe about it? Or should I ask what the impersonal universe made you believe about it? Which is the right question to ask you?
So, since you didn't provide confirmation one way or the other
Actually, I did, if you noticed. You asked whether or not humans could choose to believe. And I pointed out to you that even in posing the question, you're having to assume they do. If they don't, if they can't, one cannot even ask the question.

Too indirect for you? I hope the point is now clear.
OK. So a person can choose what to believe. At least that's cleared up now. So does that mean that you believe what you choose to? And what you choose is to believe the Bible? If so, then perhaps I should rephrase my point as "Well, believe what you choose." Instead of "Well, believe what you want." Just replace "want" with "choose" in the following:
Gary wrote:Well, believe what you want. Believe I'm going to Hell and warmongers, militant nationalists, greed-filled industrialists, and xenophobes are going to Heaven. Believe my mental illness is all my fault. Believe that my mental illness resulted from rejecting God. Whatever floats your boat and allows you to think highly of yourself. I think you've wasted your time on what is no more than 2000 year old human mythology. I may be the one diagnosed, leaving loons like you to run around free, barking at "leftists" and "atheists", but I guess that's the way an absurd, godless world works.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: What is morality?

Post by Immanuel Can »

Gary Childress wrote: ↑Mon Oct 26, 2026 3:32 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Oct 26, 2026 3:14 pm
Gary Childress wrote: ↑Mon Oct 26, 2026 12:47 pm

So, since you didn't provide confirmation one way or the other
Actually, I did, if you noticed. You asked whether or not humans could choose to believe. And I pointed out to you that even in posing the question, you're having to assume they do. If they don't, if they can't, one cannot even ask the question.

Too indirect for you? I hope the point is now clear.
OK. So a person can choose what to believe. At least that's cleared up now. So does that mean that you believe what you choose to?
No, I didn't choose in a vacuum, Gary. Nobody does, really. There's always got to be a reason involved. And in my case, it's that I saw what the Bible was saying, and found I had good reason to believe it.
Gary Childress
Posts: 13620
Joined: Sun Sep 25, 2011 3:08 pm
Location: It's my fault

Re: What is morality?

Post by Gary Childress »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Oct 26, 2026 4:04 pm
Gary Childress wrote: ↑Mon Oct 26, 2026 3:32 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Oct 26, 2026 3:14 pm
Actually, I did, if you noticed. You asked whether or not humans could choose to believe. And I pointed out to you that even in posing the question, you're having to assume they do. If they don't, if they can't, one cannot even ask the question.

Too indirect for you? I hope the point is now clear.
OK. So a person can choose what to believe. At least that's cleared up now. So does that mean that you believe what you choose to?
No, I didn't choose in a vacuum, Gary. Nobody does, really. There's always got to be a reason involved. And in my case, it's that I saw what the Bible was saying, and found I had good reason to believe it.
So you chose what seemed most reasonable to you. Can the same be said of people who choose other religions or belief systems? I mean, to you there's no other reasonable choice than believing the Bible. What if someone else feels drawn to Buddhism or Taoism but not the Bible? What do you make of that? Are they just wrong? And if so, how do you determine or measure "untruthfulness" when it comes to theology or religion?
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: What is morality?

Post by Immanuel Can »

Gary Childress wrote: ↑Mon Oct 26, 2026 4:25 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Oct 26, 2026 4:04 pm
Gary Childress wrote: ↑Mon Oct 26, 2026 3:32 pm OK. So a person can choose what to believe. At least that's cleared up now. So does that mean that you believe what you choose to?
No, I didn't choose in a vacuum, Gary. Nobody does, really. There's always got to be a reason involved. And in my case, it's that I saw what the Bible was saying, and found I had good reason to believe it.
So you chose what seemed most reasonable to you. Can the same be said of people who choose other religions or belief systems? I mean, to you there's no other reasonable choice than believing the Bible. What if someone else feels drawn to Buddhism or Taoism but not the Bible? What do you make of that? Are they just wrong? And if so, how do you determine or measure "untruthfulness" when it comes to theology or religion?
Aristotle helps us answer your question, Gary. If two opinions are genuinely equivalent and opposite, then it is possible both are untrue, or one is untrue, but it is impossible for both to be true.

When it comes to theology, we all have to make a choice about what to believe. That means we need to know what's "out there," so to speak, so as to be able to make a reasoned choice. And I think that when you do the comparison, if you do, you'll also know the answer to that question.
Gary Childress
Posts: 13620
Joined: Sun Sep 25, 2011 3:08 pm
Location: It's my fault

Re: What is morality?

Post by Gary Childress »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Oct 26, 2026 4:54 pm
Gary Childress wrote: ↑Mon Oct 26, 2026 4:25 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Oct 26, 2026 4:04 pm
No, I didn't choose in a vacuum, Gary. Nobody does, really. There's always got to be a reason involved. And in my case, it's that I saw what the Bible was saying, and found I had good reason to believe it.
So you chose what seemed most reasonable to you. Can the same be said of people who choose other religions or belief systems? I mean, to you there's no other reasonable choice than believing the Bible. What if someone else feels drawn to Buddhism or Taoism but not the Bible? What do you make of that? Are they just wrong? And if so, how do you determine or measure "untruthfulness" when it comes to theology or religion?
Aristotle helps us answer your question, Gary. If two opinions are genuinely equivalent and opposite, then it is possible both are untrue, or one is untrue, but it is impossible for both to be true.

When it comes to theology, we all have to make a choice about what to believe. That means we need to know what's "out there," so to speak, so as to be able to make a reasoned choice. And I think that when you do the comparison, if you do, you'll also know the answer to that question.
Knowing what's "out there" in terms of a "spirit" world is unfortunately not within our abilities. We can fake it, fool ourselves, or assume we know, but we really don't know, in all honesty. So it's pretty pointless to say "we need to know what's out there" because it can never theoretically happen.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: What is morality?

Post by Immanuel Can »

Gary Childress wrote: ↑Mon Oct 26, 2026 6:59 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Oct 26, 2026 4:54 pm
Gary Childress wrote: ↑Mon Oct 26, 2026 4:25 pm

So you chose what seemed most reasonable to you. Can the same be said of people who choose other religions or belief systems? I mean, to you there's no other reasonable choice than believing the Bible. What if someone else feels drawn to Buddhism or Taoism but not the Bible? What do you make of that? Are they just wrong? And if so, how do you determine or measure "untruthfulness" when it comes to theology or religion?
Aristotle helps us answer your question, Gary. If two opinions are genuinely equivalent and opposite, then it is possible both are untrue, or one is untrue, but it is impossible for both to be true.

When it comes to theology, we all have to make a choice about what to believe. That means we need to know what's "out there," so to speak, so as to be able to make a reasoned choice. And I think that when you do the comparison, if you do, you'll also know the answer to that question.
Knowing what's "out there" in terms of a "spirit" world is unfortunately not within our abilities.
I don't think that's true at all. I think that most people simply have never tried.
MikeNovack
Posts: 1453
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm

Re: What is morality?

Post by MikeNovack »

You've referred to Aristotle, IC

That presumably means you've seen him discuss ethics and morality. Did he seem to be incoherent and/or inconsistent even though not basing on "given by the gods"? If not, then why are you arguing that a modern "secularist" cannot do so.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: What is morality?

Post by Immanuel Can »

MikeNovack wrote: ↑Mon Oct 26, 2026 7:45 pm You've referred to Aristotle, IC

That presumably means you've seen him discuss ethics and morality. Did he seem to be incoherent and/or inconsistent even though not basing on "given by the gods"? If not, then why are you arguing that a modern "secularist" cannot do so.
Oh, I don't give a blanket approval to everything Aristotle said. After all, he thought the brain was a radiator, and a woman was a disfigured man. He said some nutty stuff. But his laws of logic are not content-based...they're procedural. And they apply to all logical thought, without regard for any particular ideology or belief.

Aristotle was in the "natural law" tradition, which I would say is at best a flawed and partial way to look at ethics. But the secularism problem is not with the gods; it's inherent to secularism itself. It cannot ground any morality...and that would remain true, no matter what other schools of thought might say, or what real-world people who profess to be secular do. The key problem would only appear to those who attempted to live by way of secularism itself; and for them, it's quite terminal.
popeye1945
Posts: 3263
Joined: Sun Sep 12, 2021 2:12 am

Re: What is morality?

Post by popeye1945 »

Morality is a structured system of active compassion, as a biological extension of the nature of humanity. Where there is no identification with others, there arises no compassion; without compassion, there is no morality.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: What is morality?

Post by Immanuel Can »

popeye1945 wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 2:47 am Morality is a structured system of active compassion,
Why is anybody obligated to accept the pronouncements of this "system" of yours?
MikeNovack
Posts: 1453
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm

Re: What is morality?

Post by MikeNovack »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Oct 26, 2026 8:40 pm Aristotle was in the "natural law" tradition, which I would say is at best a flawed and partial way to look at ethics. But the secularism problem is not with the gods; it's inherent to secularism itself.
But flawed/partial is not the issue, nor is wrong the issue. The issue is whether or not rational, consistent, etc. You are claiming that is impossible for the "secularist" to do what Aristotle did.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: What is morality?

Post by Immanuel Can »

MikeNovack wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 5:08 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Oct 26, 2026 8:40 pm Aristotle was in the "natural law" tradition, which I would say is at best a flawed and partial way to look at ethics. But the secularism problem is not with the gods; it's inherent to secularism itself.
You are claiming that is impossible for the "secularist" to do what Aristotle did.
No, I'm claiming Aristotle couldn't really pull it off. He tried; but he didn't succeed. "Natural Law" isn't the right theory. You can find the critiques online, so I won't repeat all of them here.

So that's slim consolation to the secularist, who's also trying, but who still inevitably finds he can't ground a single moral requirement.

But let's suppose Aristotle HAD done it. The secularists cannot accept Natural Law theory. It would force him to become non-secular. So if Aristotle had succeeded, it wouldn't help secularism even a stroke. He can't follow Aristotle's trail; it's inherently teleological, and the secularist has to deny the possibility of teleology.
MikeNovack
Posts: 1453
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm

Re: What is morality?

Post by MikeNovack »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 6:13 pm But let's suppose Aristotle HAD done it. The secularists cannot accept Natural Law theory. It would force him to become non-secular. So if Aristotle had succeeded, it wouldn't help secularism even a stroke. He can't follow Aristotle's trail; it's inherently teleological, and the secularist has to deny the possibility of teleology.
Sorry, IC, you can't just add a requirement to "secular" that it necessarily be non-teleological. Just because the non-secular deist is almost always teleological doesn't mean the teleological necessarily involve a god or gods.

Arguing "morality inherent in humans" (because of the kind of animal they are) involves no gods. << again, this is NOT saying that the particular classification of actions as right or wrong inherent; just that humans WILL classify actions this way >> Natural Law theory is teleological but puts the "purpose" simply as inherent to a things being. That's not more "spooky" than belief some deity inserted the purpose.
Post Reply