Then we are both using it in the same way.MikeNovack wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 9:12 pmI am NOT stipulating an unusual meaning for "culture".Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 7:33 pmIf you have a definition to stipulate for that word, go ahead. If not, then I think we are using it in the same way.
Morality is about choosing actions,Then you'd better say what you mean by "morality," too...because I'm going with the standard definition, unless I know you're stipulating something different.I AM NOT USING "MORALITY" TO MEAN THE ASSIGNMENTS.
Not about motives, or character? Kant thought motives mattered; and Aristotle to Aquinas, there is a strong tradtion of Virtue Ethics...and you dismiss all that, in favour of just choosing action? I'm asking, not telling.
Whoops. You've slipped into passive voice language. You haven't said who's doing the "classifying," or on what basis they are doing it. Let's state it plainly, in active voice....the action classified as right and not doing the action classified as wrong.
There is some unspoken "they" in your last sentence, who is supposed to be doing the "classifying." Who are they? How do they know about right and wrong, and we should we believe them?
...we have evolved ...
This has no relevance, even if it were true. Evolution has no moral views. It can't. It's an impersonal, unguided, unteleological natural process, allegedly. So it cannot have any opinion about what you do.
Apparently, you do. Because you believe that morality changes with culture.Now I don't believe that all of these assignments are arbitrary
Whatever you can say about the Nazis, they certainly had a culture. They were Germanic, and occultic, and norse, and had a metanarrative of history, and they were strongly nationalistic. They had schemes of purity and uncleanness, and rituals, and moral codes, an educational system, and a politics, and a hierarchy of authority, and they even had a key post-evolutionary "science" called "eugenics." And on the basis of all that, they hated Jews.
If culture determines morality, you'd have to conclude the Nazis were as "moral" as anybody else can be, because what they did was the most perfect kind of expression of their faith in social evolution, and in their creed.
So do you believe they were right or wrong?
We do not, so far as I can see. You'll have to make that case, if you can do it.we see all humans making the same FUNDAMENTAL classification