What is morality?

Should you think about your duty, or about the consequences of your actions? Or should you concentrate on becoming a good person?

Moderators: AMod, iMod

popeye1945
Posts: 3263
Joined: Sun Sep 12, 2021 2:12 am

Re: What is morality?

Post by popeye1945 »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 7:59 pm
popeye1945 wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 7:46 pm Morality is humanity's self-interest in its common biology, its survival, and well-being; any other source is at least one step removed from reality.
Well, you're one person. When your self-interest is no longer invested in cooperating with others (say, when you're competing with them for resources, opportunities or survival...) why should you continue to cooperate, instead of pursuing your own self-interest and survival? :shock: How is that adaptive or evolutionary for you? What good is it to you, if the race goes on, but you and yours simply die? Why should you prioritize these unknown "thems" of the human race over yourself and your family and friends?
Your perspective places you back in the jungle; society is a survival tool for a common species. Humanity is a social species, as most organisms are. Morality arises from the process of identifying oneself in the self of other creatures; it is the foundation of all societies. When one violates the standards of society, one is in trouble with society, for one is violating the means of survival for the collective.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: What is morality?

Post by Immanuel Can »

popeye1945 wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 8:10 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 7:59 pm
popeye1945 wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 7:46 pm Morality is humanity's self-interest in its common biology, its survival, and well-being; any other source is at least one step removed from reality.
Well, you're one person. When your self-interest is no longer invested in cooperating with others (say, when you're competing with them for resources, opportunities or survival...) why should you continue to cooperate, instead of pursuing your own self-interest and survival? :shock: How is that adaptive or evolutionary for you? What good is it to you, if the race goes on, but you and yours simply die? Why should you prioritize these unknown "thems" of the human race over yourself and your family and friends?
Your perspective places you back in the jungle;
Wait...aren't you the one who believes in "evolution"? Aren't you the one who says humans came from random processes, and are merely animals? Aren't you the one who thinks we all started with "survival of the fittest?" Who's in the jungle now?
society is a survival tool for a common species.

From an evolutionary perspective, why should you care? That the species survives might have some interest to you -- but not much; and only if you, your family and your own tribe survive. If not, why should you care about something as abstract as "the species"? And just where is such a command written to you?

Would you sacrifice your self, your family and your friends, on the theory that it will "help the human race survive"? Why would you?
popeye1945
Posts: 3263
Joined: Sun Sep 12, 2021 2:12 am

Re: What is morality?

Post by popeye1945 »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 8:23 pm
popeye1945 wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 8:10 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 7:59 pm
Well, you're one person. When your self-interest is no longer invested in cooperating with others (say, when you're competing with them for resources, opportunities or survival...) why should you continue to cooperate, instead of pursuing your own self-interest and survival? :shock: How is that adaptive or evolutionary for you? What good is it to you, if the race goes on, but you and yours simply die? Why should you prioritize these unknown "thems" of the human race over yourself and your family and friends?
Your perspective places you back in the jungle;
Wait...aren't you the one who believes in "evolution"? Aren't you the one who says humans came from random processes, and are merely animals? Aren't you the one who thinks we all started with "survival of the fittest?" Who's in the jungle now?
society is a survival tool for a common species.

From an evolutionary perspective, why should you care? That the species survives might have some interest to you -- but not much; and only if you, your family and your own tribe survive. If not, why should you care about something as abstract as "the species"? And just where is such a command written to you?

Would you sacrifice your self, your family and your friends, on the theory that it will "help the human race survive"? Why would you?
You are displaying your profound ignorance of the evolutionary process. There is nothing random about evolution; it is tied to a changing world, the larger reality, just as the world is tied to the changing cosmos. If the species does not survive, neither do you or your family. You really need to do more thinking about this. You're a believer; I can tell." Where is such a command written for you?" You need to get a bit more cognitive about this; the thunder god is not real.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: What is morality?

Post by Immanuel Can »

popeye1945 wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 8:37 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 8:23 pm
popeye1945 wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 8:10 pm
Your perspective places you back in the jungle;
Wait...aren't you the one who believes in "evolution"? Aren't you the one who says humans came from random processes, and are merely animals? Aren't you the one who thinks we all started with "survival of the fittest?" Who's in the jungle now?
society is a survival tool for a common species.

From an evolutionary perspective, why should you care? That the species survives might have some interest to you -- but not much; and only if you, your family and your own tribe survive. If not, why should you care about something as abstract as "the species"? And just where is such a command written to you?

Would you sacrifice your self, your family and your friends, on the theory that it will "help the human race survive"? Why would you?
You are displaying your profound ignorance of the evolutionary process.
And yet...you don't answer the question. Noted.
There is nothing random about evolution;
Oh? So you believe in God? Because unless there's some hand capable of purpose behind it, it's just an accidental result of time and chance. I agree that the randomness hypothesis is absurd, but it's the one that sponsors your Evolutionism...so that's kind of unfortunate for you.
If the species does not survive, neither do you or your family.
Umm...so...your response is that if you are ever selfish, the species will die? :shock:

I'm sorry...that's ridiculous. It's obviously not true. Your personal choice whether to be selfish or altruistic in a given decision is not going to kill the whole species, or even significantly disrupt most of society. So I'll ask you again: would you sacrifice yourself, your family and your friends, because you thought it was good for "the species"?
MikeNovack
Posts: 1453
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm

Re: What is morality?

Post by MikeNovack »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 9:21 pm
I'm sorry...that's ridiculous. It's obviously not true. Your personal choice whether to be selfish or altruistic in a given decision is not going to kill the whole species, or even significantly disrupt most of society. So I'll ask you again: would you sacrifice yourself, your family and your friends, because you thought it was good for "the species"?
You really don't understand evolution. It has nothing to do with the individual. The choice of action by the individual is NOT thinking "this would be good for the species".

As an obligatory social animal we have culture, and our cultures evolve independently from our biology. The culture will have evolved mechanisms to induce the behaviors that are of advantage (relative to other cultures)

In other words, cultures where all individuals are selfish do not exist (they were less "fit" than cultures that co-operate)
Cultures will have mechanisms to teach their children how to co-operate.
Cultures will also have mechanisms to teach how to deal with the few individual(s) who persists in choosing selfish behavior.

The choice of actions (by the selfish individual) will be affected by that << if I act selfishly, what will happen >>

By and large, people will not act selfishly because have learned/been taught "wrong". Are you asking about the few individuals who will act selfishly? The society will attempt to teach them "doesn't pay". They are STILL "acting selfishly" (protective self interest) in choosing not to act selfishly (original situation).
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: What is morality?

Post by Immanuel Can »

MikeNovack wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 10:28 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 9:21 pm
I'm sorry...that's ridiculous. It's obviously not true. Your personal choice whether to be selfish or altruistic in a given decision is not going to kill the whole species, or even significantly disrupt most of society. So I'll ask you again: would you sacrifice yourself, your family and your friends, because you thought it was good for "the species"?
You really don't understand evolution. It has nothing to do with the individual.
We're talking about morality. Evolution is just his explanation for why people do it. I'm pointing out what a bad explanation that is...and one of the reasons is precisely that: that "evolution" has nothing to do with the individual, or his making of choices.

So you're right about that much: and he's wrong.
MikeNovack
Posts: 1453
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm

Re: What is morality?

Post by MikeNovack »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 11:28 pm
We're talking about morality. Evolution is just his explanation for why people do it. I'm pointing out what a bad explanation that is...and one of the reasons is precisely that: that "evolution" has nothing to do with the individual, or his making of choices.

So you're right about that much: and he's wrong.
You persist in ignoring "culture" and the process by which those "coming into a culture" (that is, born in it, raised in it) learn the culture. A human culture is composed of human individuals but it is not a human individual, not a person at all. Cultures are systems that evolve just as the human species evolved << I use a tense difference because of the great difference in speed -- relative to cultural evolution our biological evolution stands still >>

Yes, the culture GREATLY influences how the individual person makes choices. Any (normal) individual thinking of making a "selfish choice" is taking into account how those around him will respond to that. Going to be part of the cost/befit analysis << and I would argue part of our biological evolution is to have "quick calculation" for that analysis ---- we perceive ourselves as "not having to think about it", we KNOW how the others will respond >>
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: What is morality?

Post by Immanuel Can »

MikeNovack wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 5:23 am
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 11:28 pm
We're talking about morality. Evolution is just his explanation for why people do it. I'm pointing out what a bad explanation that is...and one of the reasons is precisely that: that "evolution" has nothing to do with the individual, or his making of choices.

So you're right about that much: and he's wrong.
You persist in ignoring "culture"
That's because it's another answer so bad it doesn't deserve more than passing rejection. Cultures are contingent in every dimension: they not only differ from place to place, but one culture differs in its practices from time to time. To try to anchor morality in culture would mean that, for example, slavery is right in Arab countries or in China, even though England thinks it is wrong, or right when it was done in the 18th Century American South, but somehow become desperately wrong by the 19th Century... even though culture of the South was still supporting it. Or it would imply that killing Jews would have been a horrendous act to perform in American culture, but perfectly fine for German culture. :shock:

In other words, such a view provides us with absolutely no way to know what's REALLY right or wrong, and whether we would be right to stand for something like slavery or genocide, or to stand against it, or when, or where, or why. So it's just a useless hypothesis with no explanatory value for morality at all.
Yes, the culture GREATLY influences how the individual person makes choices.
Obvious, but irrelevant. Culture can be wrong -- as German culture was, when it advocated genocide of the Jews.
Will Bouwman
Posts: 1645
Joined: Sun Sep 04, 2022 2:17 pm

Re: What is morality?

Post by Will Bouwman »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 4:33 pm
Will Bouwman wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 11:15 am
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 11:06 pm
"In your world." Yes, quite.

There is such a thing. It's a one-statement ideology, in fact.
Well, you can broadly identify ideologies by one statement, but only in your creationist/Christian apologetics bubble could that constitute an entire ideology.
Not so. For though it is thin and negative, it's not without its own very, very sweeping implications.
'Atheism' does not have its own implications; it only has those imputed by the people who made it up, none of whom, I am confident, are atheists.
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 4:33 pmIf Atheism were true then an awful lot of beliefs would have to be set aside as fictional...
Mr Can, it is necessarily true that the vast majority of beliefs are fictional, one example being yours regarding 'Atheism'.
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 4:33 pmAtheism, if actually believed and applied (as it almost never is)...
Well duh! You make up something that no one believes and then wonder that no one believes it.
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 4:33 pm...an "accidentally-composed" kind of brain cannot be trusted to yield any aptitude to truth...
Well, a brain that has evolved, "accidentally" if you wish, is the latest in a very long line of brains that have successfully guided their owners through life, at least to the point where they could get jiggy and make babies. Since most beliefs are not true, an aptitude for truth doesn't seem particularly important.
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 4:33 pm
Will Bouwman wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 11:15 am
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 11:06 pmAre you recommending that to anybody else, or just making a claim for yourself?

Why won't you answer that question?
Does it relate to atheism or Atheism?
Of course.
So which is it?
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 11:06 pmIt shows what you are asking us to believe about your kind of belief: are you expecting us, assuming we are rational, to share it, or are you merely making a statement about a personal quirk you say you have. We don't know, unless you tell us.

When you answer, we know exactly whether you're advocating for "Atheism" of the proscriptive kind, or "atheism" as a mere descriptive term. The two are by no means identical.
I don't think you mean "proscriptive". I already have told you what I recommend, but being rational myself, I do not expect you to share it:
Will Bouwman wrote: ↑Mon Nov 09, 2026 2:59 pmPhilosophically, Mr Can, I would recommend that one doesn't invest too heavily in any belief, and be prepared to change them.
MikeNovack
Posts: 1453
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm

Re: What is morality?

Post by MikeNovack »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 3:01 pm
Yes, the culture GREATLY influences how the individual person makes choices.
Obvious, but irrelevant. Culture can be wrong -- as German culture was, when it advocated genocide of the Jews.
A) We are not using the term "culture" in the same way.

B) You persist in arguing as if I am using the term "morality" in the same way that you are. You can say I should not be using "morality" for the there being a classification right/wrong instead of your "correct" way associating "morality" with the particular assignments of choices of action into one of those two categories. But you can't sensibly argue that I am wrong saying "morality is from culture" because cultures do not always make good/correct assignments WHEN YOU KNOW I AM NOT USING "MORALITY" TO MEAN THE ASSIGNMENTS.
User avatar
FlashDangerpants
Posts: 9356
Joined: Mon Jan 04, 2016 11:54 pm

Re: What is morality?

Post by FlashDangerpants »

MikeNovack wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 4:20 pm B) You persist in arguing as if I am using the term "morality" in the same way that you are. You can say I should not be using "morality" for the there being a classification right/wrong instead of your "correct" way associating "morality" with the particular assignments of choices of action into one of those two categories. But you can't sensibly argue that I am wrong saying "morality is from culture" because cultures do not always make good/correct assignments WHEN YOU KNOW I AM NOT USING "MORALITY" TO MEAN THE ASSIGNMENTS.
Are you making up your own definition of morality?

Why would you do something like that? It's self-defeating. You punch yourself in the dick a lot.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: What is morality?

Post by Immanuel Can »

Will Bouwman wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 3:11 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 4:33 pm
Will Bouwman wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 11:15 am
Well, you can broadly identify ideologies by one statement, but only in your creationist/Christian apologetics bubble could that constitute an entire ideology.
Not so. For though it is thin and negative, it's not without its own very, very sweeping implications.
'Atheism' does not have its own implications...
Oh, it certainly does. To banish everything that is not "materials" or "nature" is bound to have consequences. But I agree with you, if what you are saying is that few Atheists ever think about those implications. I'm certain they rarely do, except when it suits them to do so, as with undermining moral responsibilities, or advocating permissiveness of some kind, or escaping consequences of choices. Suddenly, at that point, they become perceptive about the implications; but rarely when the negatives are considered.

However, Nietzsche, Dostoevsky, Kierkegaard, and even Dawkins have pointed some of them out.
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 4:33 pm...an "accidentally-composed" kind of brain cannot be trusted to yield any aptitude to truth...
Well, a brain that has evolved, "accidentally" if you wish, is the latest in a very long line of brains that have successfully guided their owners through life,
That's merely suppositional. There's no evidence that the human brain ever "evolved." It's a pure speculation.

That argument is called, "assuming the conclusion," which makes it invalid from a logical perspective.
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 4:33 pm
Will Bouwman wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 11:15 am Does it relate to atheism or Atheism?
Of course.
So which is it?
Both...the ideology (Atheism) and the personal confession (atheism).
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 11:06 pmIt shows what you are asking us to believe about your kind of belief: are you expecting us, assuming we are rational, to share it, or are you merely making a statement about a personal quirk you say you have. We don't know, unless you tell us.

When you answer, we know exactly whether you're advocating for "Atheism" of the proscriptive kind, or "atheism" as a mere descriptive term. The two are by no means identical.
I don't think you mean "proscriptive".
Sorry...my error. I meant "prescriptive."
I already have told you what I recommend,
If you would think others ought to believe it, and not just be confessing your own view, then you've become an Atheist, and not merely privately atheistic.

But then, another question arises: on what basis do you suppose others "ought" to believe your Atheism? What's the evidence that would warrant them agreeing?
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: What is morality?

Post by Immanuel Can »

MikeNovack wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 4:20 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 3:01 pm
Yes, the culture GREATLY influences how the individual person makes choices.
Obvious, but irrelevant. Culture can be wrong -- as German culture was, when it advocated genocide of the Jews.
A) We are not using the term "culture" in the same way.
If you have a definition to stipulate for that word, go ahead. If not, then I think we are using it in the same way.
I AM NOT USING "MORALITY" TO MEAN THE ASSIGNMENTS.
Then you'd better say what you mean by "morality," too...because I'm going with the standard definition, unless I know you're stipulating something different.
MikeNovack
Posts: 1453
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm

Re: What is morality?

Post by MikeNovack »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 7:31 pm
'Atheism' does not have its own implications...[/quote]
Oh, it certainly does. To banish everything that is not "materials" or "nature" is bound to have consequences.

[/quote]Well, a brain that has evolved, "accidentally" if you wish, is the latest in a very long line of brains that have successfully guided their owners through life,[/quote]
That's merely suppositional. There's no evidence that the human brain ever "evolved." It's a pure speculation.


But then, another question arises: on what basis do you suppose others "ought" to believe your Atheism? What's the evidence that would warrant them agreeing?
[/quote]

a) ATHEISM is disbelief any god exists. While many modern atheists are materialists, that is necessarily the case. An atheist can believe in the non-material, a spiritual realm, just not one with any gods.
Discuss what YOU consider a god (you can use God as an example). Does, for example, Spinoza's "there is only one substance" qualify? Or, as I believe you will say, to be God must also exist "outside" the material realm. How about Buddhism?

b) LOL --- well I would consider evolution as a driving factor in biology to have MUCH better evidence backing it up than the "evidence" backing ANY of our religions. Do keep in mind, however, that in saying that I am not considering religious beliefs unimportant. And saying ANY (one) religion is not the same as saying there is evidence the negation for any and all.

c) There are SOME "evangelical" atheists. You should limit that question to one of those. Until/unless you have reason to believe you are talking to one of those, the question is inappropriate. Nor is this simply about atheism but anybody whose beliefs about religion are different from your own. Just because YOUR religion seeks to convince humanity it is the one true faith doesn't mean others have this same interest. Understand? I have not the least interest in trying to convince you that your beliefs about gods are wrong and mine correct.
MikeNovack
Posts: 1453
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm

Re: What is morality?

Post by MikeNovack »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 7:33 pm
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 4:20 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 3:01 pm
Obvious, but irrelevant. Culture can be wrong -- as German culture was, when it advocated genocide of the Jews.
A) We are not using the term "culture" in the same way.
If you have a definition to stipulate for that word, go ahead. If not, then I think we are using it in the same way.
I AM NOT USING "MORALITY" TO MEAN THE ASSIGNMENTS.
Then you'd better say what you mean by "morality," too...because I'm going with the standard definition, unless I know you're stipulating something different.
A) That you ask this implies you haven't had Anthropology 101. I am NOT stipulating an unusual meaning for "culture".

B) Morality is about choosing actions, in any situation doing the action classified as right and not doing the action classified as wrong. Morality is about choosing actions when there is conflict between the classification (the situation looked at in more than one way). You may believe the classification itself (what puts actions into the correct bucket, either the right bucket or the wrong bucket) is OBJECTIVE (eternal truth). I disbelieve this because we have evolved and a classification correct for the animal we were a million years ago likely different now. Yes I know, you don't believe that we are animals and have evolved over time.

Now I don't believe that all of these assignments are arbitrary and I believe we are best served by first considering those which we are pretty sure are not << we see all humans making the same FUNDAMENTAL classification >>. But even here we need to be careful to separate out what might be arbitrary in implementation (purely cultural). AFTER we have considered what we think re universal categories is time enough to consider what does NOT appear to be universal.
Post Reply