Ad blocker detected: Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors. Disable your ad blocker to continue using our website.
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 8:20 pm
We can argue later over which of the three are false, but we can't debate the inevitable realization that at least two of the three have to be, logically.
Why argue over the unknowable
It's not "unknowable." It's certain, in fact. The Law of Non-Contradiction proves inclusivism, universalism and relativism to be dead as doornails. That's a very useful starting point. That's what we need to know: that in seeking a definite answer, we have every reason, based on impartial logic, to believe it is possible for us to find one, since we can be certain that either way, one exists.
And we certainly now know what sorts of things are NOT the right answer.
That's a whole lot of useful information from an allegedly "unknowable" situation.
... which are false and which one is true: atheism, monotheism, or polytheism?
That's the next question, not the first one. But it's a good one. And we're about to rule out two.
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 8:20 pm
We can argue later over which of the three are false, but we can't debate the inevitable realization that at least two of the three have to be, logically.
Why argue over the unknowable
It's not "unknowable." It's certain, in fact. The Law of Non-Contradiction proves inclusivism, universalism and relativism to be dead as doornails. That's a very useful starting point. That's what we need to know: that in seeking a definite answer, we have every reason, based on impartial logic, to believe it is possible for us to find one, since we can be certain that either way, one exists.
And we certainly now know what sorts of things are NOT the right answer.
That's a whole lot of useful information from an allegedly "unknowable" situation.
... which are false and which one is true: atheism, monotheism, or polytheism?
That's the next question, not the first one. But it's a good one. And we're about to rule out two.
Determining which is the correct case between "atheism, monotheism, and polytheism" is "certain"? How do you figure that? By what instruments do we measure what is beyond what exists in the physical universe? Certainly, if we're talking about God, gods or lack of any, then we're talking about something that physical instruments are incapable of confirming. Do you disagree?
It's not "unknowable." It's certain, in fact. The Law of Non-Contradiction proves inclusivism, universalism and relativism to be dead as doornails. That's a very useful starting point. That's what we need to know: that in seeking a definite answer, we have every reason, based on impartial logic, to believe it is possible for us to find one, since we can be certain that either way, one exists.
And we certainly now know what sorts of things are NOT the right answer.
That's a whole lot of useful information from an allegedly "unknowable" situation.
... which are false and which one is true: atheism, monotheism, or polytheism?
That's the next question, not the first one. But it's a good one. And we're about to rule out two.
Determining which is the correct case between "atheism, monotheism, and polytheism" is "certain"?
Well, we'll see, of course.
But no, not that: I only meant that the thing that's certain is that we can rule out things like universalism, inclusivism and relativism, because logic itself identifies them as irrational.
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 10:59 pm It's not "unknowable." It's certain, in fact. The Law of Non-Contradiction proves inclusivism, universalism and relativism to be dead as doornails. That's a very useful starting point. That's what we need to know: that in seeking a definite answer, we have every reason, based on impartial logic, to believe it is possible for us to find one, since we can be certain that either way, one exists.
And we certainly now know what sorts of things are NOT the right answer.
That's a whole lot of useful information from an allegedly "unknowable" situation.
That's the next question, not the first one. But it's a good one. And we're about to rule out two.
Determining which is the correct case between "atheism, monotheism, and polytheism" is "certain"?
Well, we'll see, of course.
But no, not that: I only meant that the thing that's certain is that we can rule out things like universalism, inclusivism and relativism, because logic itself identifies them as irrational.
By the same token, logic identifies freedom as "irrational" (if you mean impossible to achieve 100% perfectly without dysfunctional contradictions arising). Is freedom "irrational"? And by "irrational," what are you suggesting the word "irrational" implies with respect to things like "universalism, inclusivism, and relativism"?
Determining which is the correct case between "atheism, monotheism, and polytheism" is "certain"?
Well, we'll see, of course.
But no, not that: I only meant that the thing that's certain is that we can rule out things like universalism, inclusivism and relativism, because logic itself identifies them as irrational.
By the same token, logic identifies freedom as "irrational"
No, that's not the same logic. It does not involve the Law of Non-Contradiction.
And by "irrational," what are you suggesting the word "irrational" implies with respect to things like "universalism, inclusivism, and relativism"?
Very simple: that because genuinely contradictory claims cannot simultaneously be true, as Aristotle argues, and because these beliefs require us to suppose they can, they are irrational.
Aristotle is right, and logical: they're wrong, and illogical. And we can be quite certain of that.
So though we don't yet have established for us WHICH of the three possibilities in the trilemma is right, we are certain that one is. That's an excellent first step.
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sat Nov 07, 2026 12:19 am
Well, we'll see, of course.
But no, not that: I only meant that the thing that's certain is that we can rule out things like universalism, inclusivism and relativism, because logic itself identifies them as irrational.
By the same token, logic identifies freedom as "irrational"
No, that's not the same logic. It does not involve the Law of Non-Contradiction.
And by "irrational," what are you suggesting the word "irrational" implies with respect to things like "universalism, inclusivism, and relativism"?
Very simple: that because genuinely contradictory claims cannot simultaneously be true, as Aristotle argues, and because these beliefs require us to suppose they can, they are irrational.
Aristotle is right, and logical: they're wrong, and illogical. And we can be quite certain of that.
So though we don't yet have established for us WHICH of the three possibilities in the trilemma is right, we are certain that one is. That's an excellent first step.
So "inclusivism" isn't just the idea that we should try to include every member of society in the making and shaping of society but rather what you are talking about is that it's impossible to include everything in a single thing without there being more than one thing? Or what exactly do you mean by "universalism", "inclusivism," and "relativism"? They sound like social terms that various people throw around. I take it that you are not referring to that?
So being free to be a slave is not "irrational" in the same way that "universalism" is "irrational"?
By the same token, logic identifies freedom as "irrational"
No, that's not the same logic. It does not involve the Law of Non-Contradiction.
And by "irrational," what are you suggesting the word "irrational" implies with respect to things like "universalism, inclusivism, and relativism"?
Very simple: that because genuinely contradictory claims cannot simultaneously be true, as Aristotle argues, and because these beliefs require us to suppose they can, they are irrational.
Aristotle is right, and logical: they're wrong, and illogical. And we can be quite certain of that.
So though we don't yet have established for us WHICH of the three possibilities in the trilemma is right, we are certain that one is. That's an excellent first step.
So "inclusivism" isn't just the idea that we should try to include every member of society in the making and shaping of society but rather what you are talking about is that it's impossible to include everything in a single thing without there being more than one thing?
No. I mean the idea that all "religions" and all ideologies, with their different beliefs about God, can be true at the same time. We know they can't. Logic shows us.
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sat Nov 07, 2026 1:47 am
No, that's not the same logic. It does not involve the Law of Non-Contradiction.
Very simple: that because genuinely contradictory claims cannot simultaneously be true, as Aristotle argues, and because these beliefs require us to suppose they can, they are irrational.
Aristotle is right, and logical: they're wrong, and illogical. And we can be quite certain of that.
So though we don't yet have established for us WHICH of the three possibilities in the trilemma is right, we are certain that one is. That's an excellent first step.
So "inclusivism" isn't just the idea that we should try to include every member of society in the making and shaping of society but rather what you are talking about is that it's impossible to include everything in a single thing without there being more than one thing?
No. I mean the idea that all "religions" and all ideologies, with their different beliefs about God, can be true at the same time. We know they can't. Logic shows us.
OK. So there cannot possibly be only one God, many gods or else no gods (at the same time)? One being true means the other two are false. Is that your contention? Is it logically impossible for all three of those conditions to be true? What about the quality of baldness? Is it impossible for a person to be both "bald" and not "bald"? Is that also "logically impossible"?
Inclusive Christianity, also called inclusive theology,[7] is an interpretation of the Bible that maintains that God desires and has the power to save individuals irrespective of the tradition in which they are born.
Gary Childress wrote: ↑Sat Nov 07, 2026 2:21 am
OK. So there cannot possibly be only one God, many gods or else no gods (at the same time)?
Right.
One being true means the other two are false.
Right.
Is it logically impossible for all three of those conditions to be true?
Right.
What about the quality of baldness? Is it impossible for a person to be both "bald" and not "bald"?
Define your term "bald." Do you mean "having once had hair, but now having no hair at all?" Or do you mean, "having a little less hair than the average?" Or do you mean, "never having had any hair?" What is it you are trying to signify in your usage of "bald"?
Gary Childress wrote: ↑Sat Nov 07, 2026 2:21 am
OK. So there cannot possibly be only one God, many gods or else no gods (at the same time)?
Right.
One being true means the other two are false.
Right.
Ask the Hindus or the Jains, etc. Try to understand their concept of Maya.
"Maya" means "illusion," and particularly, the allegedly deceptive nature of reality, as supposed by various gnostic dualisms like Hinduism. But that would destroy Atheism, for sure, because Atheism depends on the empirical and personal.
Maya has many connotations, and if we — for example — admit it into the Christian conceptions we could propose that Satan and the fallen angels and spirits said to have great power within the world, and down on the plane of The Fallen, corresponds conceptually to Maya: the illusion of mistaking some gain, some advantage, as being beneficial to the person, to the soul.
In the Christian story of the temptation of Jesus, Satan proposes that he will grant dominion over the Earth and all its kingdoms if Jesus will relinquish the Higher Value for the Lower Value and turn the stone into bread. If he will opt to satisfy an immediate material need and forget about the realm of higher principles.
The mythology of Christianity begins in a similar paradigm: Adam & Eve were deceived by desire, appetite and the seduction of a small gain offered, and thereby tricked into sacrificing the eternal for the temporal. What power was it that approached them with the Bad Bargain?
The spiritual doctrine of Maya states that because we are in a fallen condition (trapped in Nature and processes that are mindless and amoral) we are always inclined to be duped by our own needs and desires to sacrifice those principles that are metaphysical to material life.
Yoga (I use the general term Vedanta) is based on the concept that because we are subsumed in prakriti (nature) that the more we give ourselves over to those processes (material needs, appetites, desires) the more trapped we become in the wiles of the satanic power that had been allowed tremendous power here. Satan is defined as a liar. You cannot get truth from a lie.
Yoga is based in the concept that man’s object — the reason for having life and awareness — is to realize that there is a higher plane that is more real, and eternal, than that of the perishable and constantly mutating world in which we live. The object is to become willing to surrender the lower order (defined by Maya, illusion, deception and sin) and strive by force of will to align oneself with God. (The concept of Grace is also strong in Vedanta. If a person resolves not to be tricked, God will and does respond).
Christianity is in truth highly dualistic. Satan is perceived as immensely powerful and extremely dangerous to man’s soul. Vedanta sees it similarly but offers a wider picture of the dilemma.
One could legitimately say that dearest IC is trapped in “mayic” notions based in ignorance. “Vidya” means knowledge in Sanskrit. And so dies the Greek word “gnosis”. If IC were not so trapped by his zealousness he would long ago have understood the points we have tried hard to bring to his attention.
But: “Obstinacy makes it impossible for a man to hear for all that he has ears”. That in a sense is Maya’s object.
OK Mr. Weasel: The floor is again yours. Take it away!
OK. So there cannot possibly be only one God, many gods or else no gods (at the same time)? One being true means the other two are false.
If you think there is no god, then you cannot know that there no god or multiple gods.
Similarly, if you know for certain that there is a god, you cannot know that there not more gods.
Human knowledge is limited and logical reasoning has to take that into account. That's why multi-value logic is superior to binary logic. If you have logical values true, false, both true and false, neither true nor false, then you can deal with lack of knowledge and contradictory knowledge.
OK. So there cannot possibly be only one God, many gods or else no gods (at the same time)? One being true means the other two are false.
If you think there is no god, then you cannot know that there no god or multiple gods.
Similarly, if you know for certain that there is a god, you cannot know that there not more gods.
Human knowledge is limited and logical reasoning has to take that into account. That's why multi-value logic is superior to binary logic. If you have logical values true, false, both true and false, neither true nor false, then you can deal with lack of knowledge and contradictory knowledge.