Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 6:38 am
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 6:33 am
Sorry, I need to make that clearer for you, IC, given your limited range of human religions.
Hilarious. I can pretty much guarantee you know less about those than I do, but roll on.
But the "Spirit of Deer" is not exactly what you would class as a god.
Completely irrelevant. There is one spirit of deer, there is more than one spirit of deer, there is no spirit of deer. Two of three will be false.
But that's NOT what we ordinarily mean by "atheist"
"Atheist" analytically, means "[there are] no god(s)." And that's claim #3. But if claim #1 is right, it's false; and if claim #2 is true, it's false. So again, only one can be true.
IC is a most interesting intellectual creature. He represents a stance and an attitude of Christian Evangelical realism, of Bible literalism. He knows, and you should know, that if he deviates on even a minor point, if he concedes that any non-Christian relationship with “the Divine” has validity (that is, that God himself would validate a Vedantist or a Buddhist etc.), that the admission, on the pages of a small Internet forum, would cost him his position in the sense that he’d be seen as
uncertain. He therefore sticks absolutely with the Hebrew-Christian view that was an operating principle in the 1st century: Only the God of the Jews has genuine realness; the gods of the Nations are fabrications, fantasies, deviancies. It is the ultimate cultural underminer’s position. It is a kind of psychological warfare. Again, no concessions will be given.
The “game” has been played here on the basis of an absolutist declaration. Since “logically” (if God exists) there must therefore be that personality of God in absolute, concrete form as IC states. And he has his mental ways-and-means that supports this view. If there is any admission that a man’s stance toward the Divine is subjective, he knows he is brought into that territory of relativism (etc.) which is dangerous to the very structure of sheer adamancy. The tool used is The Law of Non-Contradiction.
So if you grant: “OK, yes, I see the logic that if there is one God that that God can only be one thing, a unity, not a plurality” you too have stepped onto an uncertain ground of argumentation. Because, in a strict logical-argument sense you have conceded his primary point: I know who the real God is, and it is Yahweh (who, BTW, you will meet after you have left the mortal frame and who, according to IC’s rigid interpretation, will be none too pleased you did not realize his Ultimate Realness when you lived). It turns ”God” into a type of brute who is most similar to the mist failed human type: that man possessed by religious intolerance (and it is not only in religion that we find men of this type).
God becomes “human, all too human” instead of an Ultra-Intelligence that sees through all human foibles & concoctions directly into the most inner part of a human soul. God is turned into an ugly
mechanism. It is all quite plain if it is really thought through.
None of this has anything to do with
anything, say, genuinely human or that turns on tangible values. IC does not ever focus on values, inner transformation, service to decency or even to ‘goodness’. His “Jesus Christ” is a vehicle of theological violence, and of psychological manipulation.