(I did read your ultra-inspired post, but after I’d posted the following)
Atla wrote: ↑Sat Feb 22, 2025 12:55 pm
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Sat Feb 22, 2025 12:40 pm
You have side-stepped both the question and an answer, Atla. You must have your reasons.
Then I don't understand your question. Perhaps by spiritual stuff I mean something real and you mean something imaginary.
I am consciously trying to stick with both the gist in the thread title, and to continue a critique of BigMike’s ultra-materialism — which necessarily rejects the spiritual, the possibility of the existence of the •soul• and everything Cartesian in the sense of dualist. My stance is that BigMike’s position (a position that defines our age) is extremely consequential, and in a negative sense.
You have not defined any position at all (as far as I am aware).
Guénon is interesting for numerous reasons. One being that he was trained as a mathematician, so here we have an interesting connection with BigMike. And he studied Advaita philosophy. And since you say that you are a non-dualist, it seems in order to see if you can be provoked to offer some comments.
If you refer to “real stuff” and contrast it with “imagined stuff” it seems to me you’d need to define both. Similarly to BigMike (and a notable 1,500 years old Canadian-German galoot) you imply that you have a line on ‘the real’ and with certainty distinguish what is real from the unreal. I have a sense that I understand what you mean but I’d prefer you to lay it out.
I may also perceive things ultimately through a non-dualist lens, but my definition of what is ‘metaphysical’ to man complicates the issue. Perhaps “qualified dualism” would be more accurate.
Myself, I will say that spirituality, to be “spiritual”, most certainly depends on recognition of metaphysical categories. I cannot conceive how the term could have meaning if it were not intertwined with metaphysical ideas. (I have explained many times my definition of ‘the metaphysical’).
So here is an opportunity: what is “spiritual” in your view?
Take it away Atla ….