Page 1 of 1

Let's go ad hominem

Posted: Tue Sep 08, 2020 8:28 pm
by Harbal
We all have our heroes and villains amongst the big guns of philosophy. We will quote so and so, and ridicule the ideas of so and so, but it never seems to lead to any kind of resolution or agreement. For this reason, I propose a new approach. Let's forget about discrediting the ideas of those leading figures of philosophy, and attack them on a personal level, instead. If you want to disparage Descartes, focus on the size of his nose. Likewise with Nietzsche's moustache, or Kant's silly wig. I feel that arguments based on these things will be much harder to refute.

Let's give it a try, let's forge a new direction in philosophy.

Re: Let's go ad hominem

Posted: Wed Sep 09, 2020 9:17 am
by attofishpi
Harbal wrote: Tue Sep 08, 2020 8:28 pm We all have our heroes and villains amongst the big guns of philosophy. We will quote so and so, and ridicule the ideas of so and so, but it never seems to lead to any kind of resolution or agreement. For this reason, I propose a new approach. Let's forget about discrediting the ideas of those leading figures of philosophy, and attack them on a personal level, instead. If you want to disparage Descartes, focus on the size of his nose. Likewise with Nietzsche's moustache, or Kant's silly wig. I feel that arguments based on these things will be much harder to refute.

Let's give it a try, let's forge a new direction in philosophy.
..another fantastic well thought out thread from you Harbal, well done.


These dudes were all poopy heads:-

David Hume, Russell, Heidegger, Deleueze, Schopenauer, Nietzsche, Satre, Albert Camus, Derrida, Dewey, Diderot, Rorty, Santayana, Serle, Singer, Feuerbach, Bagini, Bentham, De Bauvoir.

...and don't get me started on David Hume. He loved tea so much that he stole his Mum's tea cosy and wore it on his head.

Re: Let's go ad hominem

Posted: Wed Sep 09, 2020 3:30 pm
by Advocate
Only assholes and idiots would want to reply to a topic like that.

Re: Let's go ad hominem

Posted: Wed Sep 09, 2020 3:33 pm
by Advocate
[quote=attofishpi post_id=470023 time=1599639449 user_id=6293]
[quote=Harbal post_id=469956 time=1599593332 user_id=9107]
We all have our heroes and villains amongst the big guns of philosophy. We will quote so and so, and ridicule the ideas of so and so, but it never seems to lead to any kind of resolution or agreement. For this reason, I propose a new approach. Let's forget about discrediting the ideas of those leading figures of philosophy, and attack them on a personal level, instead. If you want to disparage Descartes, focus on the size of his nose. Likewise with Nietzsche's moustache, or Kant's silly wig. I feel that arguments based on these things will be much harder to refute.

Let's give it a try, let's forge a new direction in philosophy.
[/quote]

..another fantastic well thought out thread from you Harbal, well done.


These dudes were all poopy heads:-

David Hume, Russell, Heidegger, Deleueze, Schopenauer, Nietzsche, Satre, Albert Camus, Derrida, Dewey, Diderot, Rorty, Santayana, Serle, Singer, Feuerbach, Bagini, Bentham, De Bauvoir.

...and don't get me started on David Hume. He loved tea so much that he stole his Mum's tea cosy and wore it on his head.
[/quote]

Anyone who respects Guattari is Deleuzional.

Re: Let's go ad hominem

Posted: Wed Sep 09, 2020 7:31 pm
by Harbal
Advocate wrote: Wed Sep 09, 2020 3:30 pm Only assholes and idiots would want to reply to a topic like that.
Thanks for your reply, Advocate. :)