Page 35 of 41

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Fri Nov 13, 2026 9:38 pm
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 9:12 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 7:33 pm
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 4:20 pm

A) We are not using the term "culture" in the same way.
If you have a definition to stipulate for that word, go ahead. If not, then I think we are using it in the same way.
I am NOT stipulating an unusual meaning for "culture".
Then we are both using it in the same way.
I AM NOT USING "MORALITY" TO MEAN THE ASSIGNMENTS.
Then you'd better say what you mean by "morality," too...because I'm going with the standard definition, unless I know you're stipulating something different.
Morality is about choosing actions,

Not about motives, or character? Kant thought motives mattered; and Aristotle to Aquinas, there is a strong tradtion of Virtue Ethics...and you dismiss all that, in favour of just choosing action? I'm asking, not telling.
...the action classified as right and not doing the action classified as wrong.
Whoops. You've slipped into passive voice language. You haven't said who's doing the "classifying," or on what basis they are doing it. Let's state it plainly, in active voice.

There is some unspoken "they" in your last sentence, who is supposed to be doing the "classifying." Who are they? How do they know about right and wrong, and we should we believe them?
...we have evolved ...

This has no relevance, even if it were true. Evolution has no moral views. It can't. It's an impersonal, unguided, unteleological natural process, allegedly. So it cannot have any opinion about what you do.
Now I don't believe that all of these assignments are arbitrary
Apparently, you do. Because you believe that morality changes with culture.

Whatever you can say about the Nazis, they certainly had a culture. They were Germanic, and occultic, and norse, and had a metanarrative of history, and they were strongly nationalistic. They had schemes of purity and uncleanness, and rituals, and moral codes, an educational system, and a politics, and a hierarchy of authority, and they even had a key post-evolutionary "science" called "eugenics." And on the basis of all that, they hated Jews.

If culture determines morality, you'd have to conclude the Nazis were as "moral" as anybody else can be, because what they did was the most perfect kind of expression of their faith in social evolution, and in their creed.

So do you believe they were right or wrong?
we see all humans making the same FUNDAMENTAL classification
We do not, so far as I can see. You'll have to make that case, if you can do it.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Fri Nov 13, 2026 10:26 pm
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 9:38 pm
we see all humans making the same FUNDAMENTAL classification
We do not, so far as I can see. You'll have to make that case, if you can do it.
You don't see ANY examples of this? Remember, talking about the fundamental classification not the detail of implementation.

1) It is right to cover your nakedness (wear clothes), wrong not to ---- a detail would be WHAT are the right clothes to wear. That would be purely by the culture and what I call arbitrary (the culture has to choose what constitutes "appropriate clothes" --- and might well end up with elaborate rules). The point here is that it is unlikely people of any culture will distinguish between, think of the detail as well as the fundamental "morality" unless perhaps if asked to "think about it".

2) It is right to eliminate from the body in certain ways, wrong to do this randomly.

3) It is right to eat in certain ways, wrong to do so randomly (even though effective in getting food into your mouth)

4) LANGUAGE implies right and wrong ways to say things (even though the wrong way might convey the meaning). All humans use language. Of course what the right and wrong details are depend on the culture (depend on the language).

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Fri Nov 13, 2026 11:02 pm
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 10:26 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 9:38 pm
we see all humans making the same FUNDAMENTAL classification
We do not, so far as I can see. You'll have to make that case, if you can do it.
1) It is right to cover your nakedness (wear clothes), wrong not to...
Except on French beaches. Or in jungle communities in the Amazon. And porn, which is rife in the world right now. You'll need another example.
2) It is right to eliminate from the body in certain ways, wrong to do this randomly.
Unless you are from certain south Asian places, in which case, doing it in the streets is just fine. You'll need another example.
3) It is right to eat in certain ways, wrong to do so randomly (even though effective in getting food into your mouth)
Unless you live in the Orient, and eat with chopsticks, or live in Ethiopia, where you eat with your hands. Or if you come from India, where your left hand must, at all costs, not be used to eat, and not even be on the table. You'll need another example.
4) LANGUAGE implies right and wrong ways to say things (even though the wrong way might convey the meaning). All humans use language.
That they talk about "right" and "wrong" doesn't suggest they are speaking of the same things. They aren't.

So...you've got precisely nothing here. Do you have any real examples?

Meanwhile, back to that clarifying question:
...the action classified as right and not doing the action classified as wrong.
Whoops. You've slipped into passive voice language. You haven't said who's doing the "classifying," or on what basis they are doing it. Let's state it plainly, in active voice.

There is some unspoken "they" in your last sentence, who is supposed to be doing the "classifying." Who are they? How do they know about right and wrong, and we should we believe them?
Got an answer? Who gets to say what's "classified" as right or wrong?

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sat Nov 14, 2026 2:18 pm
by FlashDangerpants
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 10:26 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 9:38 pm
we see all humans making the same FUNDAMENTAL classification
We do not, so far as I can see. You'll have to make that case, if you can do it.
You don't see ANY examples of this? Remember, talking about the fundamental classification not the detail of implementation.

1) It is right to cover your nakedness (wear clothes), wrong not to ---- a detail would be WHAT are the right clothes to wear. That would be purely by the culture and what I call arbitrary (the culture has to choose what constitutes "appropriate clothes" --- and might well end up with elaborate rules). The point here is that it is unlikely people of any culture will distinguish between, think of the detail as well as the fundamental "morality" unless perhaps if asked to "think about it".

2) It is right to eliminate from the body in certain ways, wrong to do this randomly.

3) It is right to eat in certain ways, wrong to do so randomly (even though effective in getting food into your mouth)

4) LANGUAGE implies right and wrong ways to say things (even though the wrong way might convey the meaning). All humans use language. Of course what the right and wrong details are depend on the culture (depend on the language).
You're making a mess of this. This is another thread where you started out with a misshapen argument and then have spent all your efforts trying to ignore the actual meanings of words in order to keep the plates spinning. It requires a do-over. I will attempt to explain.

The title of the discussion asks a question of "what is morality?" and in the OP you attempt to explain moral knowledge in terms of practical reason - the knowing what to do.

How you got from that starting point to the above quoted text is a comedy of errors. The problem emerged right at the start of the whole thing where you used your own definitions of both moral and of knowing. Take the above attempt at an argument and it doesn't answer anything to do with moral knowledge if the actual meanings of moral and knowing as understood by all of humanity except Novak are applied.

Nobody who argues in support of moral facts which can be known would ever highlight the difference between Japanese and Danish table manners as an example.

Nor would they reference the non-moral basic prudence of not shitting in your own bed, rather than the actual moral problems of breaking into somebody's house and shitting in their bed instead.

You are presenting morality as a necessary way of life that all people must engage in as part of the general cost of being a social animal. That's all well and good, but no basis for moral facts at all. IC knows that and is easily able to use that against you, anybody more talented than he would just get there quicker and make the point with fewer pages of rubbish.

Instead of this Procrustean effort to force the concepts of knowledge and morality to adopt the form of simple etiquette and arbitrary social norms, you should reconsider your effort entirely. You aren't a moral realist, you just don't seem to have noticed yet.

You consider something called Hermeneutic Moral Fictionalism. Under that description of moral living morality is, as you would no doubt agree, an essential component of our lives. In many ways we engage with it very much as if it is also a matter of real factual existence, but underneath there is no assumption that there is a factual basis of the sort that can be observed by observing the world. It supports all the statements such as "torturing kittens for amusement is obviously wrong" without needing any product of pure reason to explain that.

Other forms of fictionalism exist, you can read more here.
https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/fict ... rmRevoFict

If you adopt that theory - which I would argue fits your own arguments much better than your current way of expressing this stuff - you can rest assured that it is much too complicated to explain to IC. He is a psychopath and cannot understand how we would arrive at morality by way of having preferences for it rather than by way of coercion by a superior power anyway. Your efforts to explain by way of evolution are valiant, but he can't grasp the moral instinct that other people have and will never get it. So you will still get your 100 page thread that goes nowhere. But there's something to gain from the effort in that your own analysis will be tidier and fewer of the problems self-inflicted.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sat Nov 14, 2026 4:13 pm
by MikeNovack
FlashDangerpants wrote: ↑Sat Nov 14, 2026 2:18 pm
You're making a mess of this. This is another thread where you started out with a misshapen argument and then have spent all your efforts trying to ignore the actual meanings of words in order to keep the plates spinning. It requires a do-over. I will attempt to explain.

The title of the discussion asks a question of "what is morality?" and in the OP you attempt to explain moral knowledge in terms of practical reason - the knowing what to do.

How you got from that starting point to the above quoted text is a comedy of errors. ....
Nobody who argues in support of moral facts which can be known would ever highlight the difference between Japanese and Danish table manners as an example.

Nor would they reference the non-moral basic prudence of not shitting in your own bed, rather than the actual moral problems of breaking into somebody's house and shitting in their bed instead.

You are presenting morality as a necessary way of life that all people must engage in as part of the general cost of being a social animal. That's all well and good, but no basis for moral facts at all.
For some reason you are (also) treating "what is morality" with "what are moral facts" as being identical. You are also treating "what moral behaviors you have learned/been taught" with prudential reasons you might later be able to give for why this "rule of behavior". Orv at least you imagne I am combining these things.

When I say "table manners" (how one consumes food) will be "moral" I am saying the Danes, the Japanese, etc. will have "table manners", not that the particular method satisfying the (local) rules will be moral)

When I say you learned "shitting in the bed, wrong, and shitting in the potty right" prudence had nothing to do with the teaching. As for the prudential reasons, we can perhaps correctly theorize WHY cultures that shat throughout the living area of the cave were at a disadvantage relative to cultures where this was not done (and so only the latter cultures survived).

You are right, I have NOT been talking abut "moral facts" and where they might come from. When we get there, I am likely to be saying that in many cases the particular assignments (what you call "moral facts") are arbitrary << not in and of themselves moral >> Understand? In am NOT arguing that the detailed assignments (in Denmark, use fork and spoon --- in Japan, chopsticks and spoon) are "moral" in the same way "eat in the appropriate way" is.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sat Nov 14, 2026 5:14 pm
by FlashDangerpants
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sat Nov 14, 2026 4:13 pm
FlashDangerpants wrote: ↑Sat Nov 14, 2026 2:18 pm
You're making a mess of this. This is another thread where you started out with a misshapen argument and then have spent all your efforts trying to ignore the actual meanings of words in order to keep the plates spinning. It requires a do-over. I will attempt to explain.

The title of the discussion asks a question of "what is morality?" and in the OP you attempt to explain moral knowledge in terms of practical reason - the knowing what to do.

How you got from that starting point to the above quoted text is a comedy of errors. ....
Nobody who argues in support of moral facts which can be known would ever highlight the difference between Japanese and Danish table manners as an example.

Nor would they reference the non-moral basic prudence of not shitting in your own bed, rather than the actual moral problems of breaking into somebody's house and shitting in their bed instead.

You are presenting morality as a necessary way of life that all people must engage in as part of the general cost of being a social animal. That's all well and good, but no basis for moral facts at all.
For some reason you are (also) treating "what is morality" with "what are moral facts" as being identical. You are also treating "what moral behaviors you have learned/been taught" with prudential reasons you might later be able to give for why this "rule of behavior". Orv at least you imagne I am combining these things.
I am a moral fictionalist, so I would not ever confuse "what is morality" with "what are moral facts" as there are no moral facts.

The opening sentence of this thread, composed by yourself reads... I will start this off by giving my sense of what morality is. Morality is KNOWING in a specific situation what is the "right" choice of action and what the "wrong" choice of action.

So yes, you introduced "knowing" into this, not me and not Mannie. You can't do that without either introducing or just assuming a theory of what makes knowledge a knowing, or in other words, what makes the object of the known factual. So you may as well quit squirming on that topic and address it if you can, or better still recant what you cannot.
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sat Nov 14, 2026 4:13 pm When I say "table manners" (how one consumes food) will be "moral" I am saying the Danes, the Japanese, etc. will have "table manners", not that the particular method satisfying the (local) rules will be moral)
Then you are back to your familiar problem of having mutually exclusive fact claims. If in Denmark it is known that you should never slurp your soup as it is boorish and rude, then in Japan it must be known that you should not slurp your food. Yet in Japan it is actually known that you ought to slurp your soup.

Casting these arbitrary conventions as knowings is a mistake you have made and one which you should just recant. Your habit of doubling down isn't going to help.
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sat Nov 14, 2026 4:13 pm When I say you learned "shitting in the bed, wrong, and shitting in the potty right" prudence had nothing to do with the teaching. As for the prudential reasons, we can perhaps correctly theorize WHY cultures that shat throughout the living area of the cave were at a disadvantage relative to cultures where this was not done (and so only the latter cultures survived).
Noting to do with it? I find that quite implausible.
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sat Nov 14, 2026 4:13 pm You are right, I have NOT been talking abut "moral facts" and where they might come from. When we get there, I am likely to be saying that in many cases the particular assignments (what you call "moral facts") are arbitrary << not in and of themselves moral >> Understand? In am NOT arguing that the detailed assignments (in Denmark, use fork and spoon --- in Japan, chopsticks and spoon) are "moral" in the same way "eat in the appropriate way" is.
You opened up a thread asking what morality is. You defined it as knowing under specific circumstances which action to take. So if you did that without talking about moral facts, you haven't been talking about anything at all.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sat Nov 14, 2026 8:33 pm
by MikeNovack
FlashDangerpants wrote: ↑Sat Nov 14, 2026 5:14 pm
How you got from that starting point to the above quoted text is a comedy of errors. ....
Nobody who argues in support of moral facts which can be known would ever highlight the difference between Japanese and Danish table manners as an example.

Nor would they reference the non-moral basic prudence of not shitting in your own bed, rather than the actual moral problems of breaking into somebody's house and shitting in their bed instead.
A) I am saying that "there will be a right/wrong" way to eat your soup << morality >> I am NOT saying that what the Danes choose to be right and what the Japanese choose to be right will be the same, or that slurping or not slurping moral outside the cultural context. I do not believe in "moral fact" at the level you mean.

B) And no, I deny you were taught/learned there was a right way/place to shit by prudential reasoning. You were how old when you were potty trained? I have been using this example precisely because should be obvious reason not involved. And evolution does not work by reason. Yes of course, you can look back and understand the "pragmatic"(or should I say scientific) reason why say a half a million years ago our ancestor cultures that just happened to go outside the cave or immediate campsite to shit had a competitive advantage over those that did not. And thus why we have no examples of the latter. BUT THAT WAS NOT ON THEIR MINDS. They didn't know about germs and the relationship to disease. They weren't doing it for any pragmatic reason. We can't know the reason each culture that incorporated this rule did so, maybe something like "wrong, disgusting, will offend the spirit of the cave" (for those of you who insist "morals come from the Great Pink Unicorn")

It is less than 200 years ago that we began to understood exactly what the pragmatic reason would be (if you were asked to give one). It was less than 200 years ago that Ignaz Semmelweis was committed to an insane asylum for insisting his staff wash their hands in lime chlorate solution between autopsies and touching patients, between patients, etc. << it was young medical students exposed to his lectures who proved "germ theory >>

But yes, I am denying "objective morality". Which is why I started this section"What IS morality". Thus I say all cultures will have a "do not murder", but we still have to investigate "what is murder" and expect that to vary culture by culture (when is killing "murder"). That we can speak of "killing" as objective but "murder" (killing that is wrong) only) as moral.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sat Nov 14, 2026 9:21 pm
by FlashDangerpants
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sat Nov 14, 2026 8:33 pm
FlashDangerpants wrote: ↑Sat Nov 14, 2026 5:14 pm
How you got from that starting point to the above quoted text is a comedy of errors. ....
Nobody who argues in support of moral facts which can be known would ever highlight the difference between Japanese and Danish table manners as an example.

Nor would they reference the non-moral basic prudence of not shitting in your own bed, rather than the actual moral problems of breaking into somebody's house and shitting in their bed instead.
A) I am saying that "there will be a right/wrong" way to eat your soup << morality >> I am NOT saying that what the Danes choose to be right and what the Japanese choose to be right will be the same, or that slurping or not slurping moral outside the cultural context. I do not believe in "moral fact" at the level you mean.
If you don't believe in moral fact, then you don't believe in moral knowledge either. Known things are facts. Facts are the things that are known. 'No moral facts' entails 'no moral knowing'. How is this complicated? Why are we not past this stage of the conversation yet?
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sat Nov 14, 2026 8:33 pm B) And no, I deny you were taught/learned there was a right way/place to shit by prudential reasoning. You were how old when you were potty trained? I have been using this example precisely because should be obvious reason not involved. And evolution does not work by reason. Yes of course, you can look back and understand the "pragmatic"(or should I say scientific) reason why say a half a million years ago our ancestor cultures that just happened to go outside the cave or immediate campsite to shit had a competitive advantage over those that did not. And thus why we have no examples of the latter. BUT THAT WAS NOT ON THEIR MINDS. They didn't know about germs and the relationship to disease. They weren't doing it for any pragmatic reason. We can't know the reason each culture that incorporated this rule did so, maybe something like "wrong, disgusting, will offend the spirit of the cave" (for those of you who insist "morals come from the Great Pink Unicorn")
?

I never implied that your mum persuaded you to shit in a hole in the ground by presenting you with an airtight syllogism and a 3 hour lecture about Socrates.

The hypothetical imperative that if you don't want to feel bad about smelling like shit, you ought to not shit in your trousers and sit there squishing it about is clearly prudential in type. Not all normative judgements are moral. Most aren't. Trying to pass them all off as moral is not going to work for you.
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sat Nov 14, 2026 8:33 pm It is less than 200 years ago that we began to understood exactly what the pragmatic reason would be (if you were asked to give one). It was less than 200 years ago that Ignaz Semmelweis was committed to an insane asylum for insisting his staff wash their hands in lime chlorate solution between autopsies and touching patients, between patients, etc. << it was young medical students exposed to his lectures who proved "germ theory >>
You are wildly wrong. The smell is a perfectly good enough pragmatic reason not to shit in your ownbed. Divorce is another.
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sat Nov 14, 2026 8:33 pm But yes, I am denying "objective morality". Which is why I started this section"What IS morality". Thus I say all cultures will have a "do not murder", but we still have to investigate "what is murder" and expect that to vary culture by culture (when is killing "murder"). That we can speak of "killing" as objective but "murder" (killing that is wrong) only) as moral.
Then just drop the talk of moral knowing. That talk invites questions of how the knowing is known to be true, which you can't answer.

You can only know objective stuff, unless you are dealing in a highly risky theory of truth that is not going to be understood very well by IC, nor explained very well by you.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sat Nov 14, 2026 11:38 pm
by MikeNovack
How do you know wrong to shit on the floor?
My mommy taught me that was wrong when I was very little.
How did she know wrong to shit on the floor?
Her mommy taught her that it was wrong when she was very little.
How did grandma know it was wrong to shit on the floor?
.........

Are you arguing that at any point the knowledge "wrong to shit on the floor" was for a pragmatic reason?

Doing the wrong thing (as you were taught/learned) causes a FEELING of wrongness.

You don't get a feeling from just knowing what are wrong things, but "moral knowledge" is just that. It's the doing (or not doing) that results in the feelings.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sat Nov 14, 2026 11:54 pm
by Impenitent
monkeys shit on the floor

then they throw it at you

moral imperative: don't arm the monkeys

-Imp

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 12:12 am
by FlashDangerpants
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sat Nov 14, 2026 11:38 pm How do you know wrong to shit on the floor?
My mommy taught me that was wrong when I was very little.
How did she know wrong to shit on the floor?
Her mommy taught her that it was wrong when she was very little.
How did grandma know it was wrong to shit on the floor?
.........

Are you arguing that at any point the knowledge "wrong to shit on the floor" was for a pragmatic reason?
What other reason do you have to offer?
Is Grandma's word on the matter equivalent to a divine command?
Or is it your claim that the only reason you aren't shitting on your floor right this minute is mere obedience to a custom?

I don't shit on the floor because I don't like the smell of shit very much. But it is highly questionable whether I would be morally wrong to shit on my own floor if I did happen to like the smell for some reason. Some people are into really weird stuff, and I am less comfortable with imposing deep conformity than you seem to be.
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sat Nov 14, 2026 11:38 pm Doing the wrong thing (as you were taught/learned) causes a FEELING of wrongness.
... a feeling. That famously subjective thing.
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sat Nov 14, 2026 11:38 pm You don't get a feeling from just knowing what are wrong things, but "moral knowledge" is just that. It's the doing (or not doing) that results in the feelings.
That's incoherent babble. You get feelings from all sorts of stuff. Feelings aren't any particular source of knowledge.

You are using words wrong. You aren't using them to mean the same things other people mean by them. do you not get a feeling of wrongness when you do that? What are these feelings of wrongness for if not for correcting linguistic errors and calling that morality? Who can tell when we're all Humpty Dumpty meaning whatever we jolly want to with words like 'knowledge' derived from nothing but inchoate feeling?

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 2:47 am
by popeye1945
Morality equals a compassionate self-interest as an extended concept of self, formulated into a system.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 1:57 pm
by MikeNovack
FlashDangerpants wrote: ↑Sun Nov 15, 2026 12:12 am
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sat Nov 14, 2026 11:38 pm How do you know wrong to shit on the floor?
My mommy taught me that was wrong when I was very little.
How did she know wrong to shit on the floor?
Her mommy taught her that it was wrong when she was very little.
How did grandma know it was wrong to shit on the floor?
.........

Are you arguing that at any point the knowledge "wrong to shit on the floor" was for a pragmatic reason?
What other reason do you have to offer?
Is Grandma's word on the matter equivalent to a divine command?
Or is it your claim that the only reason you aren't shitting on your floor right this minute is mere obedience to a custom?
You really don't get it. I am arguing against "morality comes from commands of some Great Pink Unicorn". Or is it the orange one? We seem to find all peoples have "morality" (classify things right or wrong) but they do not all believe in the same unicorn or any unicorn at all.

You really don't understand evolution (as it would apply to cultures). OF COURSE there had to have been a real benefit gradient. But "pragmatic" means knowing of and consciously choosing to change in the direction of this gradient.

And no, I deny that you are simply "following custom", choosing to follow or disobey. I am saying that the way you learned/were taught instilled a FEELING "wrong to do that".

But let me propose something to those of you who insist "divine command" ------ if you choose to obey this the dictates of this Great Pink Unicorn because if you do will be rewarded with some heaven and if not punished by banishment to some hell is that decision moral or pragmatic?

PS --- Another reason I introduced "behaviors related to shitting" is that I could derive as divine command (I know the Biblical command I would use as my starting point). I am surprised that none who argue "commands from some Great Pink Unicorn" have not done so.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 4:07 pm
by Impenitent
anyone with half a brain knows that the Great Pink Unicorns are nothing but the chorus line for the Purple Wombats...

left hemisphere?

-Imp

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sun Nov 15, 2026 5:06 pm
by MikeNovack
Impenitent wrote: ↑Sun Nov 15, 2026 4:07 pm anyone with half a brain knows that the Great Pink Unicorns are nothing but the chorus line for the Purple Wombats...

left hemisphere?

-Imp
I (strongly) disagree, impenitent. I do not think the believers in some Great Pink Unicorn are lacking in intelligence. That is not why they believe in the Great Pink Unicorn, or for that matter, the orange one (I observe as much dispute about the color of the unicorn as to whether a Purple Wombat.