Page 29 of 41

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sat Nov 07, 2026 1:43 am
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sat Nov 07, 2026 12:37 am
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sat Nov 07, 2026 12:21 am
For all you know the Atheist even has RELIGIOUS beliefs
No, then, by definition, he's no longer acting as an Atheist. He's become a hypocrite, perhaps, for not believing his own claimed worldview, but he's definitely left the field of true Atheism in order to acquire values that his claimed worldview would deny him.
No, ATHEISM means not believing in any gods. It does not necessarily mean disbelieving in the holy/sacred/divine.
Actually, it does. If there is a transcendent realm, then one loses one's ability to be dogmatic about what exists in it. Suddenly, one is thrown back on some kind of softer agnosticism, at best. But one can hardly remain dogmatic if one cannot insist that the material, observable realm is the totality of the real. That's the whole premise on which Atheism rests.
Yes, some atheists are secular materialists.
All the consistent ones are.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sat Nov 07, 2026 1:25 pm
by promethean75
Alright, well, I'm gonna have to back out of this one, too, because it'll go nowhere.

I will leave viewers with this, though. You'll notice that IC acts skeptical and demands proof of these social behaviors i described earlier, but no such skepticism appears when voices from the sky, ressurrections, virgin births, a whole seas parting at the wave of a hand are in question.

The social behaviors theory, while not something we could observe without a time machine, is an extremely reasonable inference about the behavior of old homos S. So reasonable that we really can't imagine them not doing those things in social groups.

What do we have then? First, not an emergency. Which is to say the misinformation and manipulation you receive as the audience of IC isn't putting you in danger since you weren't gonna do or be anything, anyway. So don't be all like 'omg omg, i better avoid IC because i want the troof" because you wouldn't know what to do with it if you had it.

Philosophical troofs are severe... they are not little knickknacks you collect on your shelf to draw dust.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sat Nov 07, 2026 1:33 pm
by Impenitent
Jack Nicholson severe...

-Imp

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sat Nov 07, 2026 1:36 pm
by promethean75
Just aks yourself which you have a harder time believing:

1. Cavepeople hugging and eating fleas out of each other's hair.
2. One dude and his two boys building a boat big enough to house two specimens of every existing species on erf... and then collecting said specimens. All within a few days time.

If you were to demand proof, which of the two would it be for?

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sat Nov 07, 2026 1:46 pm
by promethean75
Excellent choice, Imp. One can't see how cuckcoo the troof is until one flies over it!

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sat Nov 07, 2026 1:48 pm
by Impenitent
promethean75 wrote: ↑Sat Nov 07, 2026 1:46 pm Excellent choice, Imp. One can't see how cuckcoo the troof is until one flies over it!
hadn't considered nurse Ratchet... maybe she could handle the troof

-Imp

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sat Nov 07, 2026 5:14 pm
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sat Nov 07, 2026 1:43 am
No, ATHEISM means not believing in any gods. It does not necessarily mean disbelieving in the holy/sacred/divine.[/quote]
Actually, it does. If there is a transcendent realm, then one loses one's ability to be dogmatic about what exists in it. Suddenly, one is thrown back on some kind of softer agnosticism, at best. But one can hardly remain dogmatic if one cannot insist that the material, observable realm is the totality of the real. That's the whole premise on which Atheism rests.
Yes, some atheists are secular materialists.
All the consistent ones are.
[/quote]

Here I am assuming you mean "transcendent realm" in its usual theological sense. No, does not necessarily believe in that. A Pantheist does not. And in spite of the "thei" in Pantheist, no equivalent of a god possible.

Again, your equating of "religion", concern with the holy/sacred/divine wit GODS is causing your take that an atheist who believes there are no gods but there is a sacred/holy/divine is causing you to think inconsistent.

And IC, HOW can you say "belief in a transcendent realm inability to be dogmatic abut it". You seen to have no difficulty with that.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sat Nov 07, 2026 5:31 pm
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sat Nov 07, 2026 5:14 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sat Nov 07, 2026 1:43 am
No, ATHEISM means not believing in any gods.
No, that could be mere agnosticism. To be an Atheist, one has to say, by definition, "There are no gods." If there is the possibility of one or some, then you're only an agnostic.
I am assuming you mean "transcendent realm" in its usual theological sense.
No. I mean that either the material world is all there is, or you are opening the door to metaphysics again, and you're not able to be Atheistic. You'd only be rationally capable of being agnostic.

Unless materialism/ physicalism / naturalism is all there is, Atheism has no traction for its argument...which is that there are no gods, because the Atheist doesn't see any.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sat Nov 07, 2026 6:28 pm
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sat Nov 07, 2026 5:31 pm
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sat Nov 07, 2026 5:14 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sat Nov 07, 2026 1:43 am
No, ATHEISM means not believing in any gods.
No, that could be mere agnosticism. To be an Atheist, one has to say, by definition, "There are no gods." If there is the possibility of one or some, then you're only an agnostic.
Fine ---- THERE ARE NO GODS (as a firm belief)
For some reason you believe that a person who believes that there is a sacred/holy/spiritual but not in a separate realm from the material (fully embedded in the material) is being inconsistent. Or agnostic about there being a god/gods in a realm separate (as well as possibly overlapped).

You have a sense what god/gods means. What qualifies. You do not recognize the possibilities of religious beliefs that have sacred/holy/spiritual that do not include anything of the sort you label god/gods. That disbelieve in that.

Or am I getting that wrong? You do entertain the possibility of God not existing separate from the material world? You are willing to call Spinoza's one substance "God". The Buddhist? The Animist? << referring back to my "spirit of deer" example, your belief about having to exist outside makes you see that as "a false god" and thus the possibility of your trilemma "many spirits of deer" -- as opposed to how the animist sees it "in all deer", the collective of the spirit in each individual deer >>

It is one thing for you to call Spinoza wrong, another to call him inconsistent.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sat Nov 07, 2026 6:57 pm
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sat Nov 07, 2026 6:28 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sat Nov 07, 2026 5:31 pm
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sat Nov 07, 2026 5:14 pm No, ATHEISM means not believing in any gods.
No, that could be mere agnosticism. To be an Atheist, one has to say, by definition, "There are no gods." If there is the possibility of one or some, then you're only an agnostic.
Fine ---- THERE ARE NO GODS (as a firm belief)
Well, that would imply you're saying you (if you were an Atheist, which I know you say you're not) know something, and know it firmly; and that nobody ought to believe in any God or gods..assuming, of course, you don't think departing from reality is good for folks. And in that case, you owe them some explanation for why they ought to believe you.

What's your evidence for the non-existence of a God or gods?
You have a sense what god/gods means.
Let's leave it at its broadest. Let's just say a "god" is whatever holds first position in your personal evaluation of reality, because that means everything else gets oriented around that first belief...which is to say, in a broad way, "worshipped." Everything in life becomes secondary and tribute to that entity, whatever it is.
...your belief about having to exist outside makes you see that as "a false god" and thus the possibility of your trilemma "many spirits of deer" -- as opposed to how the animist sees it "in all deer", the collective of the spirit in each individual deer >>
No, the trilemma works, either way. Either there is a "spirit of [all] deer," or there is none. We can eliminate option #2 from their worldview...and all that happens is that the trilemma simplifies to a dichotomy. Same result, though. Somebody's wrong, and somebody's right.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sat Nov 07, 2026 7:18 pm
by Impenitent

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sun Nov 08, 2026 4:27 am
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sat Nov 07, 2026 6:57 pm
You have a sense what god/gods means.


Let's leave it at its broadest. Let's just say a "god" is whatever holds first position in your personal evaluation of reality, because that means everything else gets oriented around that first belief...which is to say, in a broad way, "worshipped." Everything in life becomes secondary and tribute to that entity, whatever it is.
Oh no, IC, I do NOT believe that you believe that. I believe you have required attributes/prerequisites for a god/gods. Things like existing in a realm outside the material realm (but possibly also in it), being eternal, having a "persona", etc.

And THAT is what the atheist is denying. The atheist is not denying anything holding first position in his/her evaluation of reality, orienting around belief in that, to be held in awe. But see, you revert thinking only in terms of "entity" (necessary attribute/prerequisite).

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sun Nov 08, 2026 5:01 am
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sun Nov 08, 2026 4:27 am
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sat Nov 07, 2026 6:57 pm
You have a sense what god/gods means.


Let's leave it at its broadest. Let's just say a "god" is whatever holds first position in your personal evaluation of reality, because that means everything else gets oriented around that first belief...which is to say, in a broad way, "worshipped." Everything in life becomes secondary and tribute to that entity, whatever it is.
Oh no, IC, I do NOT believe that you believe that.
I'm just giving you a definition we can both agree on. And it's general enough that most people could live with it, actually. All it asks of you is to identify whatever it is that holds the role-of-God for you. And everybody has something. Even Atheists do. Usually, it's themselves.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sun Nov 08, 2026 10:23 am
by Will Bouwman
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sat Nov 07, 2026 6:28 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sat Nov 07, 2026 5:31 pm
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sat Nov 07, 2026 5:14 pm No, ATHEISM means not believing in any gods.
No, that could be mere agnosticism. To be an Atheist, one has to say, by definition, "There are no gods." If there is the possibility of one or some, then you're only an agnostic.
Fine ---- THERE ARE NO GODS (as a firm belief)
Bollocks. A theist is someone who believes there is at least one god. An atheist is anyone who doesn't. The end.
Mr Can cannot distinguish between
I don't believe gods exist
and
I believe gods don't exist
He also uses the popular understanding of agnosticism, essentially 'I don't know', rather than the technical meaning 'It is unknowable'.
As an atheist, MikeNovack, you are no more obliged to demonstrate that gods don't exist than fairies. It is up to believers to make their case.

Re: What is morality?

Posted: Sun Nov 08, 2026 4:29 pm
by Immanuel Can
Will Bouwman wrote: ↑Sun Nov 08, 2026 10:23 am
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sat Nov 07, 2026 6:28 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sat Nov 07, 2026 5:31 pm
No, that could be mere agnosticism. To be an Atheist, one has to say, by definition, "There are no gods." If there is the possibility of one or some, then you're only an agnostic.
Fine ---- THERE ARE NO GODS (as a firm belief)
Bollocks. A theist is someone who believes there is at least one god. An atheist is anyone who doesn't. The end.
Really? Let's see if you can hold that position.

Well, then, are you, speaking as an Atheist, recommending Atheism? Or are you just saying "I happen, personally, to have chosen Atheism, but nobody else needs to be seriously concerned to agree?" Which way is it?

If you are recommending your view, then you owe some line of reasoning. And "I don't believe" simply won't warrant anything.

I think you ARE trying to recommend your view. This can be the only explanation for why you call the contrary "bollocks," (unless we are to suppose you favour bollocks).

So on what basis do you recommend we disbelieve in God? What's your evidence?