MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sat Nov 07, 2026 6:28 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sat Nov 07, 2026 5:31 pm
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sat Nov 07, 2026 5:14 pm
No, ATHEISM means not believing in any gods.
No, that could be mere agnosticism. To be an Atheist, one has to say, by definition, "There
are no gods." If there is the possibility of one or some, then you're only an agnostic.
Fine ---- THERE ARE NO GODS (as a firm belief)
Well, that would imply you're saying you (if you were an Atheist, which I know you say you're not) know something, and know it firmly; and that nobody ought to believe in any God or gods..assuming, of course, you don't think departing from reality is good for folks. And in that case, you owe them some explanation for why they ought to believe you.
What's your evidence for the non-existence of a God or gods?
You have a sense what god/gods means.
Let's leave it at its broadest. Let's just say a "god" is whatever holds first position in your personal evaluation of reality, because that means everything else gets oriented around that first belief...which is to say, in a broad way, "worshipped." Everything in life becomes secondary and tribute to that entity, whatever it is.
...your belief about having to exist outside makes you see that as "a false god" and thus the possibility of your trilemma "many spirits of deer" -- as opposed to how the animist sees it "in all deer", the collective of the spirit in each individual deer >>
No, the trilemma works, either way. Either there is a "spirit of [all] deer," or there is none. We can eliminate option #2 from their worldview...and all that happens is that the trilemma simplifies to a dichotomy. Same result, though. Somebody's wrong, and somebody's right.