Page 3 of 18

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2026 8:10 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Oct 28, 2026 7:38 pm
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Wed Oct 28, 2026 7:37 pm You can’t weasel out here, IC,
Hey, just wait. You'll find out where I go with it, alright.

But for now, the only conclusion is very simple: one's right. The other two are wrong.
So yes: the way our minds work is that a) if God exists then b) that God is singular, then c) that the historical revelation Judaism/Christianity is the “real revelation” or “the best” or “the fullest”.

But it is also ‘logical’ that The Christian view corresponds to one of the blind men of Hindustan grabbing at that danged elephant. Why ‘blind’ in this case? Because we only see and perceive and order our perceptions through the subjective lens and field that is our own self.

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2026 8:29 pm
by Immanuel Can
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Wed Oct 28, 2026 8:10 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Oct 28, 2026 7:38 pm
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Wed Oct 28, 2026 7:37 pm You can’t weasel out here, IC,
Hey, just wait. You'll find out where I go with it, alright.

But for now, the only conclusion is very simple: one's right. The other two are wrong.
So yes: the way our minds work is that a) if God exists...
No, no...try to track. You've (pretended to have) misunderstood the argument again. (Or else you've slipped off your ritalin. :wink: )

Nobody in the present thread of discussion has [yet] said, or tried to prove WHICH is true. At this point, let's say it's any of the three. The whole point is simply "how many CAN be true"? And that's it, so far.


So the answer is....

Drumroll, please. 🥁

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2026 8:55 pm
by popeye1945
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Wed Oct 28, 2026 8:10 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Oct 28, 2026 7:38 pm
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Wed Oct 28, 2026 7:37 pm You can’t weasel out here, IC,
Hey, just wait. You'll find out where I go with it, alright.

But for now, the only conclusion is very simple: one's right. The other two are wrong.
So yes: the way our minds work is that a) if God exists then b) that God is singular, then c) that the historical revelation Judaism/Christianity is the “real revelation” or “the best” or “the fullest”.

But it is also ‘logical’ that The Christian view corresponds to one of the blind men of Hindustan grabbing at that danged elephant. Why ‘blind’ in this case? Because we only see and perceive and order our perceptions through the subjective lens and field that is our own self.
Apparent reality is not ultimate reality. We do not experience ultimate reality; what we do experience is the limited range of the energies that are capable of altering the standing state of our biological natures. Thus, you are not experiencing reality; you are experiencing the alterations reality has made to your standing state of biology. You experience your body as affected by the energy forms around you. Apparent reality is a biological readout, particular to species/biologys.

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2026 9:09 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Oct 28, 2026 8:29 pm Nobody in the present thread of discussion has [yet] said, or tried to prove WHICH is true. At this point, let's say it's any of the three. The whole point is simply "how many CAN be true"? And that's it, so far.
OP wrote:I've seen it expressed here, that if person A has beliefs about the divine, and person B has beliefs about the divine, and these beliefs are mutually contradictory, the following is certain ......... both can be false, one can be false and the other true, but both cannot be true.

Really? Let me tell you a story about a group of blind men and an elephant…

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2026 10:10 pm
by Immanuel Can
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Wed Oct 28, 2026 9:09 pm Really? Let me tell you a story about a group of blind men and an elephant…
It's ir-elephant. 🐘 That story does not solve the trilemma at all. It doesn't even help.

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2026 11:18 pm
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Oct 28, 2026 8:29 pm
Nobody in the present thread of discussion has [yet] said, or tried to prove WHICH is true. At this point, let's say it's any of the three. The whole point is simply "how many CAN be true"? And that's it, so far.
No IC, it's about whether "which is true" has meaning if it is IMPOSSIBLE to make a determination which is true, or better what the real truth is.

Look IC, your view is that it IS possible (through faith?)

The view of the Jains (and other Eastern religions) is that it is NOT possible. They are saying that this "blindness" (to what is really true, in your sense) is precisely what keeps us bound on the wheel of birth, life, suffering, death, and rebirth.

I'll repeat, what is the MEANING of "One of these is true" if there is no way you could possibly determine which?

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2026 11:46 pm
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Wed Oct 28, 2026 11:18 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Oct 28, 2026 8:29 pm
Nobody in the present thread of discussion has [yet] said, or tried to prove WHICH is true. At this point, let's say it's any of the three. The whole point is simply "how many CAN be true"? And that's it, so far.
No IC,
Yes, Mike. That's all I've asked here. No more.

And your reluctance to respond tells the whole story, of course. You know the answer. You just wish not to say it.

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2026 12:50 am
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Oct 28, 2026 11:46 pm And your reluctance to respond tells the whole story, of course. You know the answer. You just wish not to say it.
Consider this possibility
There are two lights in a box. They turn on and off at two second intervals, but are not in synch (one second difference). There is only ONE possibility at any time you open the box and look. No lights on, one light on, or more than one light on. At any instant, only one of these is true.

For some reason (unclear to me) you are assigning meaning to truth EVEN IF CAN NEVER BE KNOWN. You are not explaining why.

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2026 1:18 am
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 12:50 am
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Oct 28, 2026 11:46 pm And your reluctance to respond tells the whole story, of course. You know the answer. You just wish not to say it.
Consider this possibility
There are two lights in a box. They turn on and off at two second intervals, but are not in synch (one second difference). There is only ONE possibility at any time you open the box and look. No lights on, one light on, or more than one light on. At any instant, only one of these is true.
That's a problem of epistemology, not ontology, just like the elephant story.

You can't disprove the Law of Non-Contradiction by saying, "we don't know which one is true." Because the thing we DO know from the trilemma, and cannot doubt, is HOW MANY ANSWERS CAN BE TRUE.

There can only be one of the three...and even if we leave it unknown which one it is, it's still never going to be more than one of the three.
For some reason (unclear to me) you are assigning meaning to truth EVEN IF CAN NEVER BE KNOWN. You are not explaining why.
It should be apparent, from the above. Again, the point is going to turn out to be that only one of the three can be right.

So there's also something else we're going to know from that: and it's that relativism, or inclusivism, or universalism -- which all are based on the idea that all three answers can, in some sense, be "true" is false. So much for the elephant in the room.

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2026 12:35 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
MikeNovak wrote:No, that Jain story IS about what it is possible for people to know.
IC wrote:Yes, it is...which is what makes it utterly irrelevant to the question I'm asking. I'm asking what's TRUE, what's REAL, not how many people know it, or how complete or partial their knowledge might be. That's a different issue.
The Christian conversation on Philosophy Now has a long history. I assume that such a conversation, among those who would rather discuss strict philosophical questions, has been distressing and maddening. Now, we are at the tail-end of it and there is still no way to move forward. The entire conversation dead-ends. That reveals, again, what appears to be the main thing, the underlying thing: there can be no substantial and no profound agreements among “us” in our present. (In any case this is how I see the problem. And the larger culprit? The collapse of the possibility of an agreed-upon metaphysical diagram.)

The advantage that IC has, and frankly that no other participant in the conversation has, is in his absolute and adamantine religious picture. It is effectively unassailable. That is, that has been IC’s declared project here: “Present to me an argument that could challenge the structure of my religious view.” In IC’s view there have been no such substantial arguments presented. No arguments with ‘teeth’ and he has only been ‘gummed’.

But for those actually concerned for the issue and its implications I think that the conversation has not helped anyone, and I mean those who are in that marginal zone where a specific coalesced religious picture had dissolved, but there was still enough ‘shadow’ or ‘residue’ of the former ingrained metaphysical certainty (of a passing age) so that “holding on” to some picture, even if vague, was still possible.

I have said and I still maintain that IC, despite himself, is an extremely destructive agent for an Apology that could move any ‘modern’. This critique is thoroughly meaningless and valueless to him and has never been addressed. But let’s face it: There is no argument, no contrary idea, no contributing idea, no footnote, literally nothing that could ever be said that could move IC from his particular seat in Absolute Certainty.

The effect if witnessing such a performance however is, for many (?) maybe for most (?) fatal. Reduced to the very essence, IC’s position is a mechanism, not really an “idea”. You could write-out the core belief-elements like a list. It’s Genesis turned into a belief-list. There are the most fundamental truths about “world” and “being”. These are declared as true substances. And there are no others. Orient yourself to “believe” these, and by that insistence you can locate yourself in the real realness.

There is, we must say, no one ‘round these parts who can go along with this. Conducted in that way, for most (?) for all (?) it simply cannot be done. So — and since this appears to be true — IC as an “emblem” of a very late movement in Modernism is like unto a nail in the coffin!

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2026 12:57 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
What “manoeuvre” do we have available to us? This is where it seems to me that the most stolid representative of a “modern philosophical stance” — I conjure here Wilbur Boneman though there are I guess others — would have something substantial to say. But actually (this is my impression) he has nothing to say. “It is all aesthetics” and the rest is footnotes. But that is no answer. In fact it is completely sophomoric. “And that is what your investment has been?! That is the price paid for some letters to folliw your patronymic?” says Alexis Jacobi in exasperated tone.

But here is the actual thing (again, my view) men, man, men and women, will not live without a “metaphysical picture”. You could totally undermine every and any such picture and create the absolute negating functionary (of the negating picture) and still people will require a metaphysical picture: “a metaphysical dream of the world”.

So sociologically what happens, what has happened and what continue to happen, is the abandonment of a “picture” and an adamantine commitment to a specific diagram that no longer can function as it once did, and a rummaging around for believable alternatives. I do not mean to be disparaging because that rummaging around is quite a serious affair it seems to me. But “common people” don’t need much of a peg to hang their “belief” on, do they? Many things can serve in a moment of necessity.

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2026 1:06 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Oct 28, 2026 7:38 pm
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Wed Oct 28, 2026 7:37 pm You can’t weasel out here, IC,
Hey, just wait. You'll find out where I go with it, alright.

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2026 2:18 pm
by Immanuel Can
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 12:35 pm
MikeNovak wrote:No, that Jain story IS about what it is possible for people to know.
IC wrote:Yes, it is...which is what makes it utterly irrelevant to the question I'm asking. I'm asking what's TRUE, what's REAL, not how many people know it, or how complete or partial their knowledge might be. That's a different issue.
Now, we are at the tail-end of it and there is still no way to move forward. The entire conversation dead-ends.
Why? Just because you have to realize that relativism is absurd, and that the trilemma sticks? I don't see why that has to be a "dead end." Rather, it seems to me the beginning of wisdom on the subject, and the start of a line of inquiry that actually promises an answer.

It's really relativism that causes a dead-end, and that kills the intellect: because it says, essentially, "There is no answer, can be no answer, and we shouldn't look for an answer anymore." It puts truth out of reach of everybody. Now THAT looks like a real "dead end." But to have discovered, for the first time, perhaps, that truth is not so inaccessible, that we can at least eliminate two out of three wrong answers...that seems to be in every way an advance on knowledge.

It even offers us a way to arbitrate disagreements of opinion. Instead of being bogged down in the brainless "I'm okay, you're okay" of the 1970s, it allows us to break some basic cognitive deadlocks between positions. And we have our first big win in this: relativism is false. That's a great launch pad for further thought. And I think we can easily get farther than that...if we're careful and honest in our inquiry.

And there's this: the Law of Non-Contradiction is completely non-partisan. It's not a "Christian" view. It comes from Aristotle and from the very basics of logic. It's absolutely universal and inclusive in its implications, and does not require beforehand any particular religious or ideological beliefs. It's truly a "handle that fits all pots," in that sense. It couldn't be more fair.

So I think we're doing very well, contrary to your fears of a "dead end."

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2026 2:35 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
What would happen, IC, if you were to deal honestly not with one mere sentence in what I (and many others) attempt to say to you (or in relation to you) but instead with the totality? Are you even aware that you did not? Are you even aware of the “larger problems”?

Alexis Jacobi is not some sort of weapon of dialectical warfare, but rather a battering ram that bashes through the Gate behind which a whole world of Spiritual Truth and experience is visible and conversable, and he sketches out a map by which we might head toward “new noons” of understanding.

Re: Can't both be right?

Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2026 3:14 pm
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 1:18 am You can't disprove the Law of Non-Contradiction by saying, "we don't know which one is true." Because the thing we DO know from the trilemma, and cannot doubt, is HOW MANY ANSWERS CAN BE TRUE.
There is a fundamental difference between "don't know" and "cannot know". "Don't know" includes the potential of knowing while "cannot know" does not.

And that trilemma is NOT so simple. You are a Christian. Please explain to non-Christian how three can be one and one can be three. And then try to discuss that with a Hindu who believes many can be one and one many arguing your view is completely different than his/hers.