Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 7:51 pm
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 7:47 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 6:16 pm
Let us pretend neither of us knows how many cats are in the box, if any. Still, the question remains: is it possible for more than one answer to end up being right, when we open the box and see? For at that point, we will know the right answer: but long before that, we will know for certain
how many right answers there can possibly be.
When are you going to answer the question?
Well IC, when you die...
No, don't run away.
Cats.
Box.
How many answer can even possibly be right?
I'm going to answer my own question, Mike...because I see that although, as I'm quite sure, you know the answer, you apparently don't want to say it. I get that. It's a slam-dunk against your objections, and I think a person as sagacious as you cannot possibly miss the point.
In cases of three comprehensive and genuinely contradictory options (i.e. a trilemma),
no more than one can be true. That's the answer.
And that has profound implications.
Firstly, the majority of answers, in such a case, are wrong.
And that means, in the case of the God question, it is inevitable that whatever the answer we suppose,
the majority of the world is bound to be wrong. And
there is simply no other way it can be. (Best to stop fighting against logic, with poems about elephants, then.)
Secondly, in a genuine trilemma (that is, one that covers all possible cases, such as I gave you) SOMEBODY has got to be right. That's because logically, there are no options left uncovered. One of the three
must be true.
So the laws of logic, not any ideological, religious, or otherwise partisan view is involved at all in that deduction. It's plain, it's universal and it's inescapable. One who denies it simply cannot be doing logic; they must be doing something else.
So which of the three is the truth?