MikeNovak wrote:No, that Jain story IS about what it is possible for people to know.
IC wrote:Yes, it is...which is what makes it utterly irrelevant to the question I'm asking. I'm asking what's TRUE, what's REAL, not how many people know it, or how complete or partial their knowledge might be. That's a different issue.
The Christian conversation on Philosophy Now has a long history. I assume that such a conversation, among those who would rather discuss strict philosophical questions, has been distressing and maddening. Now, we are at the tail-end of it and there is still no way to move forward. The entire conversation dead-ends. That reveals, again, what appears to be the main thing, the underlying thing: there can be no substantial and no profound agreements among “us” in our present. (In any case this is how I see the problem. And the larger culprit? The collapse of the possibility of an agreed-upon metaphysical diagram.)
The advantage that IC has, and frankly that no other participant in the conversation has, is in his absolute and adamantine religious picture. It is effectively unassailable. That is, that has been IC’s declared project here: “Present to me an argument that could challenge the structure of my religious view.” In IC’s view there have been no such substantial arguments presented. No arguments with ‘teeth’ and he has only been ‘gummed’.
But for those actually concerned for the issue and its implications I think that the conversation has not helped anyone, and I mean those who are in that marginal zone where a specific coalesced religious picture had dissolved, but there was still enough ‘shadow’ or ‘residue’ of the former ingrained metaphysical certainty (of a passing age) so that “holding on” to some picture, even if vague, was still possible.
I have said and I still maintain that IC, despite himself, is an extremely destructive agent for an Apology that could move any ‘modern’. This critique is thoroughly meaningless and valueless to him and has never been addressed. But let’s face it: There is no argument, no contrary idea, no contributing idea, no footnote, literally nothing that could ever be said that could move IC from his particular seat in Absolute Certainty.
The effect if witnessing such a performance however is, for many (?) maybe for most (?)
fatal. Reduced to the very essence, IC’s position is a mechanism, not really an “idea”. You could write-out the core belief-elements like a list. It’s Genesis turned into a belief-list. There are the most fundamental truths about “world” and “being”. These are declared as true substances. And there are no others. Orient yourself to “believe” these, and by that insistence you can locate yourself in the
real realness.
There is, we must say, no one ‘round these parts who can go along with this. Conducted in
that way, for most (?) for all (?) it simply cannot be done. So — and since this appears to be true — IC as an “emblem” of a very late movement in Modernism is like unto a nail in the coffin!