Page 14 of 18
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2026 5:58 am
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 5:06 am
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Thu Nov 05, 2026 4:10 pm
...you lose the ability to think of atheists different from believers in "false gods"
The Atheist's god is himself. That's a false god, alright.
No, I was speaking of believers in deities your don't consider qualifying as gods (not just false gods but not gods). The atheist believes in no god, but you would have to group together these folk who believe, but not in what you consider qualifies as a god. That is different than ones who believe in god, just the wrong/false god.
Look, you believe in the truth of the Elephant (so does the Jain). The Jain says because the human condition is blindness with regard to the Elephant, cannot know the truth of the Elephant. You, as a Christian (along with the Muslim and the Jew) believe that the Elephant has chosen to REVEAL this truth to you.
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2026 6:30 am
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 5:58 am
No, I was speaking of believers in deities your don't consider qualifying as gods (not just false gods but not gods).
It makes absolutely no difference which conception of God or god...there's always one, more than one, or none. And two of three are wrong, in every single case.
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2026 6:33 am
by MikeNovack
Sorry, I need to make that clearer for you, IC, given your limited range of human religions. Spell it out without gaps.
Take an animist, for example. The animist understands the divine/sacred/holy as everything having a spirit (think soul) and perhaps also a group/species having a spirit. If you misuse a deer (do not kill it with respect, use it improperly, etc.) then this is known by the "Spirit of Deer" which will then withhold deer from you. But the "Spirit of Deer" is not exactly what you would class as a god.
Or the Spinoza Pantheist for whom everything that is is of the divine/sacred/holy substance but that does not extend beyond, exist apart from the material and so again not qualifying as a "god".
But that's NOT what we ordinarily mean by "atheist"
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2026 6:38 am
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 6:33 am
Sorry, I need to make that clearer for you, IC, given your limited range of human religions.
Hilarious. I can pretty much guarantee you know less about those than I do, but roll on.
But the "Spirit of Deer" is not exactly what you would class as a god.
Completely irrelevant. There is one spirit of deer, there is more than one spirit of deer, there is no spirit of deer. Two of three will be false.
But that's NOT what we ordinarily mean by "atheist"
"Atheist" analytically, means "[there are] no god(s)." And that's claim #3. But if claim #1 is right, it's false; and if claim #2 is true, it's false. So again, only one can be true.
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2026 11:14 am
by Alexis Jacobi
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 6:38 am
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 6:33 am
Sorry, I need to make that clearer for you, IC, given your limited range of human religions.
Hilarious. I can pretty much guarantee you know less about those than I do, but roll on.
But the "Spirit of Deer" is not exactly what you would class as a god.
Completely irrelevant. There is one spirit of deer, there is more than one spirit of deer, there is no spirit of deer. Two of three will be false.
But that's NOT what we ordinarily mean by "atheist"
"Atheist" analytically, means "[there are] no god(s)." And that's claim #3. But if claim #1 is right, it's false; and if claim #2 is true, it's false. So again, only one can be true.
IC is a most interesting intellectual creature. He represents a stance and an attitude of Christian Evangelical realism, of Bible literalism. He knows, and you should know, that if he deviates on even a minor point, if he concedes that any non-Christian relationship with “the Divine” has validity (that is, that God himself would validate a Vedantist or a Buddhist etc.), that the admission, on the pages of a small Internet forum, would cost him his position in the sense that he’d be seen as
uncertain. He therefore sticks absolutely with the Hebrew-Christian view that was an operating principle in the 1st century: Only the God of the Jews has genuine realness; the gods of the Nations are fabrications, fantasies, deviancies. It is the ultimate cultural underminer’s position. It is a kind of psychological warfare. Again, no concessions will be given.
The “game” has been played here on the basis of an absolutist declaration. Since “logically” (if God exists) there must therefore be that personality of God in absolute, concrete form as IC states. And he has his mental ways-and-means that supports this view. If there is any admission that a man’s stance toward the Divine is subjective, he knows he is brought into that territory of relativism (etc.) which is dangerous to the very structure of sheer adamancy. The tool used is The Law of Non-Contradiction.
So if you grant: “OK, yes, I see the logic that if there is one God that that God can only be one thing, a unity, not a plurality” you too have stepped onto an uncertain ground of argumentation. Because, in a strict logical-argument sense you have conceded his primary point: I know who the real God is, and it is Yahweh (who, BTW, you will meet after you have left the mortal frame and who, according to IC’s rigid interpretation, will be none too pleased you did not realize his Ultimate Realness when you lived). It turns ”God” into a type of brute who is most similar to the mist failed human type: that man possessed by religious intolerance (and it is not only in religion that we find men of this type).
God becomes “human, all too human” instead of an Ultra-Intelligence that sees through all human foibles & concoctions directly into the most inner part of a human soul. God is turned into an ugly
mechanism. It is all quite plain if it is really thought through.
None of this has anything to do with
anything, say, genuinely human or that turns on tangible values. IC does not ever focus on values, inner transformation, service to decency or even to ‘goodness’. His “Jesus Christ” is a vehicle of theological violence, and of psychological manipulation.
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2026 1:36 pm
by promethean75
"would cost him his position in the sense that he’d be seen as uncertain. He therefore sticks absolutely with the Hebrew-Christian view"
This phenomenon is interesting and had its origins when wealth disparity allowed a privileged class to educate themselves. These two classes - the educated and the dumb worker - would be antagonistic to each other and in constant conflict. Eventually, ignorance became an article of shame and inferiority, and the lower uneduated classes were always contending with it. This is the origin's of the phenomenon known as doubling-down.
Faced with sophistication too complicated to understand and under the duress of being thought of as dumb, the uneducated man will do the only thing he can... and that's hold fast to what he believes.
All of this exists because of intellectual fetishism. Only because wealth and privilege disparity allows education for only a few could there ever be a sense of shame before someone smarter. Knowledge did not become power until the dumb workers were tricked into believing big vocabularies meant you were superior. How can knowledge have any power when it is pure epiphenomena? No... it's not the knowledge that got the philosophers their high stations but the failure of intimidated dummies to stop them.
You'll know what i mean if you ever drop a complicated Schopenhauer quote on some dummies on the street you're talking to. They freeze in fear and begin to shrink back. But why? It's just wordz, bruh! Philosophers are pussies in real life. They'ont do shit.
Anyway that's what IC is doing. He don't know what's going on so he goes back to his safe space in the barn with the other dumb workers and holds a sermon. Same shit that happened back in ancient Greece. Regular folks and intellectuals mixing in the public square. Nothing good ever came of it. The philosophers would humiliate the dumb peasants and then the peasants would chase the philosophers around threatening to kick their asses. Then the philosophers would call them brutes and escape up into the towers where they could get back to work writing about a bunch of nothing.
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2026 1:49 pm
by promethean75
See what'um sayin? Only if you were able to feel shameful and weak before a superior intelligence would you refuse to admit you were wrong. It used to not be like this. A fellow used'ta could admit he was ignorant without everyone else shaming him. Not after the intellectual revolution, though, mate. Lack of education was associated with low social standing, so ignorant people fought back... and they did so by doubling-down, goddammit.
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2026 3:00 pm
by Immanuel Can
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 11:14 am
Since “logically” (if God exists) there must therefore be that personality of God in absolute, concrete form as IC states.
That's not an argument I've made, for sure. I would provide much better reason than the LONC to believe such a thing. All I've pointed out is that a basic law of logic applies to all things that have real existence.
My actual argument has stopped at the point of indicating that inclusivism, universalism and relativism are wrong -- and not wrong by any ideological position, but merely wrong by the basic principles of universal logic. One would think that was uncontroversial, among philosophers. However, not everybody here may realize what logic requires of him. I'm just happy to point it out.
Now, as to
which answer in the trilemma is correct, I have not yet made my case. You didn't even wait to see what it would be; rather, you rushed of to try to make it yourself, so as to produce a convenient
reductio, a fallacy of false mockery. Anybody who goes back to the earlier phases of this conversation could easily see that that is all you're doing. But you should not, of course; you should wait until you see what I offer, and then you can find out if the real argument matches that which you have generated from your own imagining. However, that's up to you.
So you're getting ahead of yourself, AJ. So far, all I've asserted is the necessity of the logical trilemma. So the rest of what you present is merely a rave: the observable facts here will not back your "analysis," such as it is.
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2026 3:10 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 3:00 pm
But you should not, of course; you should wait until you see what I offer, and then you can find out if the real argument matches that which you have generated from your own imagining. However, that's up to you.
So you're getting ahead of yourself, AJ. So far, all I've asserted is the necessity of the logical trilemma. So the rest of what you present is merely a rave: the observable facts here will not back your "analysis," such as it is.
Pu-
leese. I have been reading what you write for years. This is not a conversation occurring for the first time. It is a reiteration of a reiteration.
The logical trilemna
cannot apply as you wish to apply it. But you can undertake a comparative analysis of religious perspectives and then apply intelligent skill to the analysis and possibly arrive at some conclusions.
And note: you avoided, once again, dealing with the content of what I wrote. As I say: you cannot sacrifice
any ground.
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2026 3:24 pm
by promethean75
"and not wrong by any ideological position, but merely wrong by the basic principles of universal logic. One would think that was uncontroversial among philosophers."
It's the statements and assertions of moral objectivists that are illogical or not truth-apt, haus. There is no essence 'goodness' floating around in platonic space that behaviors either meet the standard of or not. The 'goodness' of something is relative to so many different contingencies that it almost doesn't exist at all except in the expression of pure pleasure. So Spinz was right. Right and wrong judgments are determined by degrees of pleasure and pain. What increases one's capacity and joy is good, what decreases it, limits or retards it, is bad. Bad, bad, bad, Mannie.
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2026 4:23 pm
by Impenitent
masochists be damned
-Imp
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2026 5:50 pm
by promethean75
There are no such things as 'masochists', Imp. A 'masochist' is simply a poser who hasn't been in enough pain yet and still thinks the shit is fun.
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2026 6:53 pm
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 3:00 pm
That's not an argument I've made, for sure. I would provide much better reason than the LONC to believe such a thing. All I've pointed out is that a basic law of logic applies to all things that have real existence.
There is conditional truth and falsity (you have to look) and unconditional truth ans falsity (you don't need to look).
The trilemma of conditional truth/falsity does not apply "to all things". Might only have a dilemma if unconditional truth comes into play.
Thus, hold an election. There may be no majority or there might be a majority (conditional truth/falsity) There cannot be two or more majorities, unconditionally false. The prerequisites of "majority" cause that.
IC, you DON'T have to consider "more than one "god" because your prerequisites for a "god" preclude that. Just like you can have no 7x7x7 cube inside a 12x12x12 cube, one 7x7x7 cube, but you can't have more than one (you don't have to look inside the box to say that). But suppose the inside cube were 5x5x5? Now you could have more than one. It was the properties/characteristics of the the "thing" that determined that-- the prerequisites of being that "thing".
You and the Jain agree the Elephant is true. The Jain says we humans are inherently "blind" to that truth. You say not relevant because the Elephant can choose to reveal its truth to us. Judaism, Christianity, and Islam are agreed on this, truth by revelation. Now you can choose to equate "religion" to one of these three, but I do not.
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2026 8:20 pm
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 6:53 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 3:00 pm
That's not an argument I've made, for sure. I would provide much better reason than the LONC to believe such a thing. All I've pointed out is that a basic law of logic applies to all things that have real existence.
The trilemma of conditional truth/falsity does not apply "to all things".
Don't cut that phrase short. It's "all things
that have real existence."
IC, you DON'T have to consider "more than one "god" because your prerequisites for a "god" preclude that.
"My prerequisites" are not invoked here, nor do I use them as any part of my premise. All I'm pointing out is what options are available
to a rational person, regardless of his/her "prerequisites."
Whatever you prefer, there are still but three options. And two are bound to be false. We can argue later over which of the three are false, but we can't debate the inevitable realization that at least two of the three have to be, logically.
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2026 10:34 pm
by Gary Childress
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 06, 2026 8:20 pm
We can argue later over which of the three are false, but we can't debate the inevitable realization that at least two of the three have to be, logically.
Why argue over the unknowable when you can simply admit you don't know and possibly never will? Or are you suggesting that logic tells you which two options are false and which is true? And if so, which are false and which one is true: atheism, monotheism, or polytheism?