Page 2 of 18
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Tue Oct 27, 2026 7:51 pm
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 7:47 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 6:16 pm
Let us pretend neither of us knows how many cats are in the box, if any. Still, the question remains: is it possible for more than one answer to end up being right, when we open the box and see? For at that point, we will know the right answer: but long before that, we will know for certain
how many right answers there can possibly be.
When are you going to answer the question?
Well IC, when you die...
No, don't run away.
Cats.
Box.
How many answer can even possibly be right?
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Tue Oct 27, 2026 8:11 pm
by Greatest I am
Any entity, God or not, that wishes to be relevant to another, would insure constant contact, if possible.
If impossible for a God, this is proof against the notion that God can do all he wishes to do.
If you want to be relevant to me, you would have to contact me. Right?
The same restriction applies to all entities including God.
Jesus, in the Bible, is clear. We invent all of our Gods.
That is why none ever show up.
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Tue Oct 27, 2026 8:14 pm
by Greatest I am
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 7:51 pm
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 7:47 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 6:16 pm
Let us pretend neither of us knows how many cats are in the box, if any. Still, the question remains: is it possible for more than one answer to end up being right, when we open the box and see? For at that point, we will know the right answer: but long before that, we will know for certain
how many right answers there can possibly be.
When are you going to answer the question?
Well IC, when you die...
No, don't run away.
Cats.
Box.
How many answer can even possibly be right?
Where the F did my cat go.
I tried the experiment and wow, what a surprise.
I don't care, but why is the cat always there when we look?
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2026 10:11 am
by Fanman
Unfortunately, Mike didn't answer my question, so I worked on the basis of what he stated and came up with the following:
"Human beings have access to different aspects of reality, but due to our biological limitations, we cannot access all of reality. That does not mean we can posit that anything and everything can exist. But it does mean that we should remain open-minded to what can exist, providing the framework is coherent, cogent, and supported by some kind of evidence."
My original question was:
What I'm thinking is, when you say "limited," could you explain that? I wasn’t aware that we could perceive the divine at all. Through what human mechanisms would that be possible?
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2026 1:35 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
Look people, in some respects the cat is in the box. And in some sense it is not. Then it is also possible to say that it is and is not. So there’s that. In another sense the entire issue is inexpressible. Then you could affirm “cat-box-in” while simultaneously realizing the condition, whatever it is, is inexpressible. Similarly, that it is not (not-cat not-box not-in) and is also inexpressible. Finally, cat is, is not, is not in, is in — and it remains inexpressible.
Why limit yourself?
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2026 2:01 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 3:49 pm
No, that Jain story
IS about what it is possible for people to know. You are holding that "truth" is meaningful even if it CANNOT be known. Or in very modern terms, either the cat is alive or the cat is not alive, not in some in between state by probability.
If we bring the matter home, we must say that a zealous religious presents a strict and very defined “picture” of God and an elaborate picture of God’s actions in the world at a specific time. The picture is held as being absolute, accurate and inviolable. So you are not allowed to see (the elephant) in any other way except the way determined to be correct.
Here we have, in a nutshell, our own IC’s version of “what is seen”. That view, that picture, is defended against all comers.
But along comes someone else from, say, another corner of the world and presents an alternative “picture”. It is not entirely dissimilar but it is different enough in aspects that it challenges the Absolutist Picture of the religious zealot. His version nonetheless
must be defended. The reasons are various and complex. A theological solidity provides man with convicted certainty. The personality becomes, say, dependent on a posture of absolute certainty. The “self” becomes associated with the absolute picture, and an assault even minor on the cohesion of the picture is perceived as “threat” to the self.
But what do our pictures
represent? Ah, that’s where the kernel is discerned and exposed. You can diagram an elephant and, unless I am very wrong here, we know what is an elephant and there is no argument about its form. But a totalized metaphysical picture constructed in language-fables? in mythic snippets? in story-like rehearsals that exist in the imagination?
The thing represented is not the representation that is presented. The allusion is literally non-commensurate with the Story and the Picture.
Does this negate the value of the Story? No, because the story is a conveyor contrivance. Stories can be told in different ways. And stories are the means by which emphasis is placed and values are accentuated. And remember: Children love stories. Start telling a story and they go into a “trance”. It holds them, and in it they travel along with the story-teller …
For this reason we might well say:
“Trust your mother, but cut the cards, son.” [Are you paying attention Wilbur?]
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2026 2:15 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
Did I ever tell the one about “The Seven Trunked Elephant”?
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2026 3:37 pm
by Impenitent
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Wed Oct 28, 2026 2:15 pm
Did I ever tell the one about “The Seven Trunked Elephant”?
he could never live up to "Octopus face"
-Imp
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2026 6:35 pm
by Immanuel Can
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 7:51 pm
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 7:47 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 6:16 pm
Let us pretend neither of us knows how many cats are in the box, if any. Still, the question remains: is it possible for more than one answer to end up being right, when we open the box and see? For at that point, we will know the right answer: but long before that, we will know for certain
how many right answers there can possibly be.
When are you going to answer the question?
Well IC, when you die...
No, don't run away.
Cats.
Box.
How many answer can even possibly be right?
I'm going to answer my own question, Mike...because I see that although, as I'm quite sure, you know the answer, you apparently don't want to say it. I get that. It's a slam-dunk against your objections, and I think a person as sagacious as you cannot possibly miss the point.
In cases of three comprehensive and genuinely contradictory options (i.e. a trilemma),
no more than one can be true. That's the answer.
And that has profound implications.
Firstly, the majority of answers, in such a case, are wrong.
And that means, in the case of the God question, it is inevitable that whatever the answer we suppose,
the majority of the world is bound to be wrong. And
there is simply no other way it can be. (Best to stop fighting against logic, with poems about elephants, then.)
Secondly, in a genuine trilemma (that is, one that covers all possible cases, such as I gave you) SOMEBODY has got to be right. That's because logically, there are no options left uncovered. One of the three
must be true.
So the laws of logic, not any ideological, religious, or otherwise partisan view is involved at all in that deduction. It's plain, it's universal and it's inescapable. One who denies it simply cannot be doing logic; they must be doing something else.
So which of the three is the truth?
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2026 6:57 pm
by Impenitent
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Oct 28, 2026 6:35 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 7:51 pm
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 7:47 pm
Well IC, when you die...
No, don't run away.
Cats.
Box.
How many answer can even possibly be right?
I'm going to answer my own question, Mike...because I see that although, as I'm quite sure, you know the answer, you apparently don't want to say it. I get that. It's a slam-dunk against your objections, and I think a person as sagacious as you cannot possibly miss the point.
In cases of three comprehensive and genuinely contradictory options (i.e. a trilemma),
no more than one can be true. That's the answer.
And that has profound implications.
Firstly, the majority of answers, in such a case, are wrong.
And that means, in the case of the God question, it is inevitable that whatever the answer we suppose,
the majority of the world is bound to be wrong. And
there is simply no other way it can be. (Best to stop fighting against logic, with poems about elephants, then.)
Secondly, in a genuine trilemma (that is, one that covers all possible cases, such as I gave you) SOMEBODY has got to be right. That's because logically, there are no options left uncovered. One of the three
must be true.
So the laws of logic, not any ideological, religious, or otherwise partisan view is involved at all in that deduction. It's plain, it's universal and it's inescapable. One who denies it simply cannot be doing logic; they must be doing something else.
So which of the three is the truth?
Thor
-Imp
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2026 7:00 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Oct 28, 2026 6:35 pm
In cases of three comprehensive and genuinely contradictory options (i.e. a trilemma), no more than one can be true. That's the answer.
And that has profound implications.
Firstly, the majority of answers, in such a case, are wrong.
And that means, in the case of the God question, it is inevitable that whatever the answer we suppose, the majority of the world is bound to be wrong. And there is simply no other way it can be. (Best to stop fighting against logic, with poems about elephants, then.)
The argument seems, let’s say on paper, to be adamantine. OK, yes, if we consider the question as it is set up, only one answer can stand. But the actual fact is that no matter if there is one God, everyone perceives and defines “that” in very different ways. So if those many are wrong, it is quite likely that the Religious Absolutist is also wrong (to some degree).
What IC desires to communicate is that the Christian Revelation is the true one and all others are false (though he might admit they are only partially tight).
So yes: the way our minds work is that a) if God exists then b) that God is singular, then c) that the historical revelation Judaism/Christianity is the “real revelation” or “the best” or “the fullest”.
But it is also ‘logical’ that The Christian view corresponds to one of the blind men of Hindustan grabbing at that danged elephant. Why ‘blind’ in this case? Because we only see and perceive and order our perceptions through the subjective lens and field that is our own self.
You can do it IC! You are on the verge of momentous realization!
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2026 7:03 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
In Hindustan, six blind men were set
To trace by hand what none had seen yet,
A mountain moved beneath a tent of hide,
An Elephant, vast in evening tide.
The first found Wall, the second found a Snake,
A Spear, a Fan, a Tree, a Rope to take -
Each certain, each naming the part he'd won,
Six certainties, and truth in none.
But on that seventh touch, the hand pulled back,
For what they held escaped all tactual track -
It was not rough nor smooth, nor cool nor hot,
It was IS and IS-NOT, in one knot.
It was the AVAKTAVYA, the unsayable seam,
Where language snaps and falls into dream.
No logic holds it, no ledger can chart
The whole of a Beast that exceeds the part.
Aristotle would say: Choose! Yes or No!
The Jain would smile: Seven ways to know!
But neither can speak it - the thing slips through
All syllogisms the schools ever knew.
For this you need not proof, but a poet's art,
A tongue that can shape what has no part,
A weaving of word so fine and so rare
It can clothe the unclotheable air.
And only one — Alexis Jacobi — has the phrase,
The minted word, the incandescent blaze,
Where others grope and call it wall or rope,
He alone gives the Indescribable a trope.
He does not argue the tail or the ear -
He sings what the blind hands strain to hear,
And in his line, the Elephant stands whole,
Not in the hand, but entire in the soul.
Trust your mother, IC,
but cut the cards!
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2026 7:05 pm
by Immanuel Can
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Wed Oct 28, 2026 7:00 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Oct 28, 2026 6:35 pm
In cases of three comprehensive and genuinely contradictory options (i.e. a trilemma), no more than one can be true. That's the answer.
And that has profound implications.
Firstly, the majority of answers, in such a case, are wrong.
And that means, in the case of the God question, it is inevitable that whatever the answer we suppose, the majority of the world is bound to be wrong. And there is simply no other way it can be. (Best to stop fighting against logic, with poems about elephants, then.)
The argument seems, let’s say on paper, to be adamantine. OK, yes, if we consider the question as it is set up, only one answer can stand. But the actual fact is that no matter if there is one God, everyone perceives and defines “that” in very different ways.
A completely irrelevant claim, so far as the adamantine claim goes. It's not an argument for the nature of the God in question: it's an argument for the necessity of only one answer in trilemmas.
So call it "cats," if you want. You'll get the same result, regardless of the nature of the cat. (And you'll find that Schrodinger doesn't specify the cat, anyway...he's not trying to do animal husbandry, but logic. And I'm not doing theology in this argument; I'm doing logic.)
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2026 7:37 pm
by Alexis Jacobi
You can’t weasel out here, IC, because you know as well as I do (as I think does the readership) that you are a One Trick Pony and you circle the ring in just one direction and with one purpose.
You know perfectly well where you are going with your trilemna!
Re: Can't both be right?
Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2026 7:38 pm
by Immanuel Can
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Wed Oct 28, 2026 7:37 pm
You can’t weasel out here, IC,
Hey, just wait. You'll find out where I go with it, alright.
But for now, the only conclusion is very simple: one's right. The other two are wrong.