Page 74 of 94

Re: God and morality

Posted: Mon Nov 09, 2026 4:32 pm
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Mon Nov 09, 2026 4:29 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 09, 2026 2:14 pm
We might ask, what's bad about optimism about human potential? And the answer is, "Nothing -- so long as it does not involve becoming blind to the inevitability that some humans will always behave badly, and that all humans will sometimes behave badly." But naive failure to safeguard against human fallenness and sinfulness opens up society to exploitation, crime, abuses, corruption and even full-on totalitarianism. And this is exactly what we have seen happen in all perfectionistic and utopian social plans. Inevitably, along come people who will not play by the idealistic expectations of the social plan, and who recognize the opportunity to take advantage, and who do so.

100%. That's the failure rate of Socialism. That should say something.
You are ignoring that a society need not be helpless in the face of "people who will not play by the rules" nor need it be totalitarian dealing with them.
But here's what it will require: a justified moral code. The alternative is unjust punishment, arbitrary authority, unexplained uses of power.
A perfectionist SOCIETY does not depend on having perfect people.
It actually does. That mistake is exactly what's doomed all perfectionist social plans...100% of the time. Isn't it time that we recognized the problem and addressed it?

Re: God and morality

Posted: Mon Nov 09, 2026 5:35 pm
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 09, 2026 4:32 pm
A perfectionist SOCIETY does not depend on having perfect people.
It actually does. That mistake is exactly what's doomed all perfectionist social plans...100% of the time. Isn't it time that we recognized the problem and addressed it?
You are supporting the proposition "a system cannot exist/be constructed that will function properly unless all components function properly". You are arguing "error correction"/"fault tolerance" cannot be built in.

Let's perhaps be more precise determining what you believe.

A) You believe that true in general. For example, I cannot construct a system for transmitting information capable of tolerating N errors? (N random bits flipped by error). Our biological reproduction does no work because a single error (wrong atom) in DNA cannot be corrected?

B) You do expect systems can be fault tolerant in general but for some reason a systems composed of individual humans are an exception and no way to make them "fault tolerant" exists.

If you believe B, explain why. We have made no assumptions about what sort of faults involved or what the error correction/fault tolerance might be. Are you arguing that there is something magical abut "sin"?

If you believe A, well this is simple, since a topic of "information theory". In other words, can give a mathematical proof of what is required for error detection, error correction, etc.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Mon Nov 09, 2026 5:57 pm
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Mon Nov 09, 2026 5:35 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 09, 2026 4:32 pm
A perfectionist SOCIETY does not depend on having perfect people.
It actually does. That mistake is exactly what's doomed all perfectionist social plans...100% of the time. Isn't it time that we recognized the problem and addressed it?
You are supporting the proposition "a system cannot exist/be constructed that will function properly unless all components function properly". You are arguing "error correction"/"fault tolerance" cannot be built in.
Quite the opposite. I'm arguing that no system of politics or governance can succeed without taking a realistic look at human nature, and adjusting the system to meet human nature as it actually is -- not as we wish it were, or as we imagine it to be.

What we need is a system that has compensatory strategies for human fallibility and human sin. And that means that it recognizes that there are no perfect people or perfect systems of rule, and that all power must be limited as to time and scope, so that human opportunism, greed, avarice, cruelty and meanness doesn't have free rein. That means there has to be a constitution that regulates against abuses of power, that removes the corrupt from office, that separates functions by things like judicial, legislative and executive functions. It means we realize we have to live on a tightrope between delegating power to some, out of necessity, and making those in power accountable again -- not in some comfortable Never-never Land, where the people in power always do the right thing for all of us, and we are always ideal citizens.

And the reason for this is simple: a political or social structure must be tailored to manage human beings as they are, not as we wish they were, or as we flatter them to be, or as we wrongly imagine we can engineer them to become. Utopian schemes all fall afoul of this: they imagine that if there are any problems, they're not inherent to human nature -- perhaps they're only "systemic" -- and we can remove them by engineering the "right" social system.

But we cannot. Human beings need to be rescued not merely from "systems," but from being the kinds of thing they intrinsically are. There's something fundamentally wrong with human nature, and that is why none of our aspirational political fixes every produce lasting improvement. They're all undermined by human nature.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Mon Nov 09, 2026 9:07 pm
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 09, 2026 5:57 pm
But we cannot. Human beings need to be rescued not merely from "systems," but from being the kinds of thing they intrinsically are. There's something fundamentally wrong with human nature, and that is why none of our aspirational political fixes every produce lasting improvement. They're all undermined by human nature.
I agreed with MOST of that. For some reason you don't consider the particular "controls" to be "error correcting mechanisms" and "fault tolerance mechanisms" and I do.

But this last part, that is just YOUR religious beliefs. There is nothing "wrong" with human nature. We are not imperfect humans. We are humans.

You really believe we have made no lasting improvements? We still keep chattel slaves? We still allow political rights only men with property? We still allow women no civil or political rights? We still allow employers to combine against workers but do not allow workers to combine against employers? I could go on.

Does that mean I believe a PERFECT SOCIETY is possible? << and by perfect I do NOT mean without error control/fault tolerance mechanisms >>
NO -- further improvements will likely always be possible.
Does that mean I believe we still have a long way to go?
YES

Do I believe "God created us as imperfect/sinful and there is no possibility of a just society on Earth, just pie in the sky in when you die"
NONSENSE --- but you can believe that if you like, just keep out of the way of us trying to make things better.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Mon Nov 09, 2026 9:29 pm
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Mon Nov 09, 2026 9:07 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 09, 2026 5:57 pm
But we cannot. Human beings need to be rescued not merely from "systems," but from being the kinds of thing they intrinsically are. There's something fundamentally wrong with human nature, and that is why none of our aspirational political fixes every produce lasting improvement. They're all undermined by human nature.
I agreed with MOST of that. For some reason you don't consider the particular "controls" to be "error correcting mechanisms" and "fault tolerance mechanisms" and I do.
Well, they don't really "correct." They "compensate imperfectly for." There are no ideal systems, or any systems that are 100% proof against human cunning. But there are options that do better and worse; and one key determinant of that is whether or not they are based on a realistic anthropological view.
We are not imperfect humans. We are humans.
Are you suggesting that imperfection is so natural to human beings, that we should simply absorb it into the word "human"? But if we do, the danger is that we will forget the imperfection, and then fail to attempt to compensate for it adequately: and that's been the problem with utopian and perfectionist political systems, that they've failed to reckon with the imperfection.
You really believe we have made no lasting improvements?
I never said so. But it's clear that for every step forward we've made in the moral realm, we've also made one backward. For example, we may have more and better technologies for curing disease; but also for making war. We have more freedom in regard to sexual mores, and more social diseases, familial disintegration and even death, as a result. We have technologies for prolonging life, but also for murdering babies...and so on.

And I'm not the only person to point it out: Sigmund Freud did, among others. Read his Civilization and Its Discontents, if you think that perspective owes anything to my Theism. It doesn't. Good ol' Siggy was Jewish, you'll recall; and very secular, as well.
but you can believe that if you like, just keep out of the way of us trying to make things better.
I wish it were that simple. But it is naive and misguided attempts to "make things better" that have killed hundreds of millions in the last century with wars between people who had different ideas of how to do that -- and who seemingly shared only one common belief, the belief that they could do it, if only they were ruthless enough.

And I live in this world, too, and have to experience the effects of these misguided attempts to create human perfection through social engineering of various kinds. It doesn't seem altruistic to me to let the misguided optimists continue to kill people...of which I am likely to be one, give that the social engineers tend to hate those who point out their follies to them.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Mon Nov 09, 2026 11:14 pm
by phyllo
There is nothing "wrong" with human nature. We are not imperfect humans. We are humans.
Next up ...

There's something fundamentally wrong with cats. They need to be changed. They need to be saved.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Mon Nov 09, 2026 11:19 pm
by Impenitent
the only good cats are hep cats

-Imp

Re: God and morality

Posted: Tue Nov 10, 2026 12:14 am
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 09, 2026 9:29 pm And I live in this world, too, and have to experience the effects of these misguided attempts to create human perfection through social engineering of various kinds. It doesn't seem altruistic to me to let the misguided optimists continue to kill people...of which I am likely to be one, give that the social engineers tend to hate those who point out their follies to them.
A) People seeking to envision and then create a "perfect" society are not (usually) trying to perfect people. Most are assuming people will stay pretty much the same in terms of how good, how bad.

B) I will say that most of them see the problem as simpler than you do, think people are mostly good, all sometimes a LITTLE bad, few usually bad. This is different than your sense that all people are inherently evil sinners. In other words, you envision the amount of "error correction"/"fault tolerance" necessary to be impossibly high.

C) "Get out of the way" is not necessarily a treat to remove you by force and violence. I believe in democracy and consider democracy a form of social negotiation. I might convince you to get out of the way of my favored projects by making that the price for me to get out of the way of yours. I think you underestimate the possibilities of non-violent coercion (most people do).

Re: God and morality

Posted: Tue Nov 10, 2026 1:27 am
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Tue Nov 10, 2026 12:14 am
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 09, 2026 9:29 pm And I live in this world, too, and have to experience the effects of these misguided attempts to create human perfection through social engineering of various kinds. It doesn't seem altruistic to me to let the misguided optimists continue to kill people...of which I am likely to be one, give that the social engineers tend to hate those who point out their follies to them.
A) People seeking to envision and then create a "perfect" society are not (usually) trying to perfect people.
But Marxists decidedly are.

A set of assumptions are always what's behind any utopian project. Those assumptions are that human beings, if not quite perfect now, are at least sufficiently "perfectable" to serve as citizenry for the promised bliss to come -- once the utopian engineers have been allowed to complete their work on the system and its people.
C) "Get out of the way" is not necessarily a treat to remove you by force and violence.
But in practice, it is. The utopians inevitably look around for scapegoats to explain why their promised utopia has failed to materialize. At first, they blame those who opposed them -- saying that there were "counter-revolutionaries" who spoiled the plan, and who are very evil, since they hold back everybody else from their heaven-on-earth. These must be killed.

But when utopia again fails to come, they start blaming "foreign plotters," or "ignorant commoners who didn't buy in far enough," or "traitors within the Party." And so the purges begin. Eventually, it's "traitors in high places," too. Nobody ends up safe, because utopia never comes, and the need for the next scapegoat is perpetual. All these must be brought to heel -- by re-education (i.e. psychological manipulation and torture) if possible, and if it's not possible, by being eliminated altogether.

The only thing that will not be considered is that the utopian plan was wrong in the first place.
I might convince you to get out of the way of my favored projects by making that the price for me to get out of the way of yours.
That would be fine if we had a free-market situation; I could pursue my interests, and you, yours. But the engineers need everybody. The lack of everybody is part of their explanation for utopia's failure to come: not enough people believe in "the Project," and so it's not working. Only when enough people -- all the people -- do what the utopians want will there be enough. And somehow, the utopians always believe that there are enough people in existence to staff their plans...after dissenters are all eliminated, of course.

Well, so their story goes, anyway.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Tue Nov 10, 2026 4:35 pm
by MikeNovack
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Nov 10, 2026 1:27 am
I might convince you to get out of the way of my favored projects by making that the price for me to get out of the way of yours.
That would be fine if we had a free-market situation; I could pursue my interests, and you, yours. But the engineers need everybody. The lack of everybody is part of their explanation for utopia's failure to come: not enough people believe in "the Project," and so it's not working.
Do you understand how most "primitive" societies deal with people who refuse to comply with the rules? Not by killing them but smply kicking them out.

The "social engineers" (as you put it) do NOT necessarily "need everybody" or even want "everybody". They might be perfectly content to allow those who wish to live without the benefits of their society survive outside of it if they can.

As for the above part of what you wrote, just because the CP is "democratic centralist" doesn't mean all accept that concept of democracy (you have done a reasonable job of pointing out the issues with "democratic centralism" --- which I would express as "lack of error correction or "fault tolerance"). BTW. lest you think of "democratic centralism" as a left wing thing, I will refer you to The Farm Bureau and its manual. The Farm Bureau is the opposite of "left wing", and its manual gives the best description/justification of "democratic centralism" ----- it just happens that this concept was in fashion at the time both the CP and the Farm Bureau were organized.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Tue Nov 10, 2026 7:17 pm
by Immanuel Can
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Tue Nov 10, 2026 4:35 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Nov 10, 2026 1:27 am
I might convince you to get out of the way of my favored projects by making that the price for me to get out of the way of yours.
That would be fine if we had a free-market situation; I could pursue my interests, and you, yours. But the engineers need everybody. The lack of everybody is part of their explanation for utopia's failure to come: not enough people believe in "the Project," and so it's not working.
Do you understand how most "primitive" societies deal with people who refuse to comply with the rules? Not by killing them but smply kicking them out.
Is that what you really believe? Interesting. You'll find it otherwise, I assure you. Islamists certainly furnish a counterexample: if you leave Islam, they kill you. However, let's pretend.

Let's pretend that eviction, not execution, is the chosen punishment. Still, the question remains: why should somebody be punished for refusing to do what some group of others wants them to do?
The "social engineers" (as you put it) do NOT necessarily "need everybody" or even want "everybody".
Well, Socialist social engineers are renowned for their refusal to accept any dissent, any rivals, or any other agenda but their own. Hence, the need for confiscations, "re-education" camps, torture chambers, gulags, and unmarked graves.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Tue Nov 10, 2026 7:50 pm
by phyllo
Let's pretend that eviction, not execution, is the chosen punishment. Still, the question remains: why should somebody be punished for refusing to do what some group of others wants them to do?
Let's extend that ...

Why should somebody be punished for refusing to do what God wants them to do?

Re: God and morality

Posted: Tue Nov 10, 2026 7:57 pm
by Immanuel Can
phyllo wrote: ↑Tue Nov 10, 2026 7:50 pm
Let's pretend that eviction, not execution, is the chosen punishment. Still, the question remains: why should somebody be punished for refusing to do what some group of others wants them to do?
Let's extend that ...

Why should somebody be punished for refusing to do what God wants them to do?
Oh, that's easy. Because He's God. The whole reason for our existence is relationship to Him. We are better or worse people depending on how well we achieve that.

But why should we obey men?

Re: God and morality

Posted: Tue Nov 10, 2026 8:12 pm
by phyllo
Oh, that's easy. Because He's God. The whole reason for our existence is relationship to Him.
That doesn't explain why somebody should be punished for refusing to do what God wants.

Noncompliance could simply be ignored. Noncompliance could be rewarded as "initiative".

But it really comes down "God is going to get you if you don't obey". Or at least that is what religion says. That's allegedly how it works.

Re: God and morality

Posted: Tue Nov 10, 2026 8:56 pm
by promethean75
"But why should we obey men?"

Because a bro can actually be dangerous while a non-existent god and its threats of an imaginary hell can not be dangerous.

People only obey anything under duress and in fear or because they've been promised a reward for being obedient. So, even the Christian's obedience is an implicit egoism, and he does not commit for the sake of the god he commits to. He commits to save his own ass and to get a piece of a reward.