Re: God and morality
Posted: Mon Nov 09, 2026 4:32 pm
But here's what it will require: a justified moral code. The alternative is unjust punishment, arbitrary authority, unexplained uses of power.MikeNovack wrote: ↑Mon Nov 09, 2026 4:29 pmYou are ignoring that a society need not be helpless in the face of "people who will not play by the rules" nor need it be totalitarian dealing with them.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 09, 2026 2:14 pm
We might ask, what's bad about optimism about human potential? And the answer is, "Nothing -- so long as it does not involve becoming blind to the inevitability that some humans will always behave badly, and that all humans will sometimes behave badly." But naive failure to safeguard against human fallenness and sinfulness opens up society to exploitation, crime, abuses, corruption and even full-on totalitarianism. And this is exactly what we have seen happen in all perfectionistic and utopian social plans. Inevitably, along come people who will not play by the idealistic expectations of the social plan, and who recognize the opportunity to take advantage, and who do so.
100%. That's the failure rate of Socialism. That should say something.
It actually does. That mistake is exactly what's doomed all perfectionist social plans...100% of the time. Isn't it time that we recognized the problem and addressed it?A perfectionist SOCIETY does not depend on having perfect people.