MikeNovack wrote: ↑Mon Nov 09, 2026 9:07 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 09, 2026 5:57 pm
But we cannot. Human beings need to be rescued not merely from "systems," but from being the kinds of thing they intrinsically are. There's something fundamentally wrong with human nature, and that is why none of our aspirational political fixes every produce lasting improvement. They're all undermined by human nature.
I agreed with MOST of that. For some reason you don't consider the particular "controls" to be "error correcting mechanisms" and "fault tolerance mechanisms" and I do.
Well, they don't really "correct." They "compensate imperfectly for." There are no ideal systems, or any systems that are 100% proof against human cunning. But there are options that do better and worse; and one key determinant of that is whether or not they are based on a realistic anthropological view.
We are not imperfect humans. We are humans.
Are you suggesting that imperfection is so natural to human beings, that we should simply absorb it into the word "human"? But if we do, the danger is that we will forget the imperfection, and then fail to attempt to compensate for it adequately: and that's been the problem with utopian and perfectionist political systems, that they've failed to reckon with the imperfection.
You really believe we have made no lasting improvements?
I never said so. But it's clear that for every step forward we've made in the moral realm, we've also made one backward. For example, we may have more and better technologies for curing disease; but also for making war. We have more freedom in regard to sexual mores, and more social diseases, familial disintegration and even death, as a result. We have technologies for prolonging life, but also for murdering babies...and so on.
And I'm not the only person to point it out: Sigmund Freud did, among others. Read his
Civilization and Its Discontents, if you think that perspective owes anything to my Theism. It doesn't. Good ol' Siggy was Jewish, you'll recall; and very secular, as well.
but you can believe that if you like, just keep out of the way of us trying to make things better.
I wish it were that simple. But it is naive and misguided attempts to "make things better" that have killed hundreds of millions in the last century with wars between people who had different ideas of how to do that -- and who seemingly shared only one common belief, the belief that they could do it, if only they were ruthless enough.
And I live in this world, too, and have to experience the effects of these misguided attempts to create human perfection through social engineering of various kinds. It doesn't seem altruistic to me to let the misguided optimists continue to kill people...of which I am likely to be one, give that the social engineers tend to hate those who point out their follies to them.