It sure gets you something like God. It gets you a Supreme Being, intelligently and purposefully creating the world.MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sat Nov 21, 2026 12:20 amThat intelligent design/creationism does not get you to a "god".Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 10:51 pm
There's all the proof you're going to need, that living matter did not come from non-living, that meaning doesn't arise from randomness, and that impersonal, unguided forces did not create a world.
Now, what does the other side have?
The purpose of that argument is not to explain WHICH God. It's only to show you that there IS a God. There are other, better arguments to exposit His character.
The argument is that God exists. It will take further arguments to show WHICH God, it's true; but that doesn't damage the value of the argument for the purpose it's offered.But IC, back to those questions:
1) Do you believe in Oshun, Chnago, Yemejah, et.do not exist ? WHY?
See above. That's not the question the argument is answering.2) Do you feel it necessary to give reasons for your belief they do not exist? Reasons based upon the material realm?
I've explained that. The Atheist has nothing, and the Theist has lots of evidence. The Atheist is claiming he can prove a negative; the Theist only has to show a positive. The Atheist cannot meet his own burden of proof; the burden on a Theist is only to show one single genuine evidence. It's by no means equivalent.3) Why are you asking something different from the atheist?
He's not claiming a God. He's claiming gods. They're quite different predications, you'll find. And all I'd ask him is what makes him think these "gods" are good?4) If faced with an initiate of Santeria, who tells you "I have evidence. I have danced and experienced the gods in my body" what do you say?
The Atheist actually is insisting he won't believe in ANY God, whether mine or the Muslim's. But once again, the Atheist has misunderstood the purpose of the argument: it's not to show which God is being asserted; just that some Supreme Being and First Cause actually exists....the atheist says "But I see the Muslim in the other corner of the room saying the same thing. Why should I believe you and not him?
Beyond that, the Atheist can't ask about that, because he's rendered his own question stupid. He's believing there's no God or gods; so he's essentially asking, "What kind of God doesn't exist?"
Dumb question: things that (he assumes) cannot exist cannot have characteristics, either. He's in no position to pose the question.