Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 10:34 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 9:51 pm
Whose? If you say "God's," I agree. If you say "man's," I say, "Don't be silly. Man is a contingent being; he's not even capable. He can produce demands that are arbitrary, cultural and unwarranted. He isn't the source of any moral truth."
There was a time (you do not believe this because you are a Bible literalist) when mankind were pre-humans living primitively on savannas, hunting and foraging like animals.
Not "like animals." But there was certainly a phase in which hunting and foraging were important activities...as was farming, making war...and a whole bunch of other such things. So far, so good.
Yet there were primitive proto-moral rules, laws, and observances enforced by some standards.
From whence?
Hard to say how humans thought and acted 20,000 years ago, but their morals and ethics arose in Nature and in a natural context.
You don't have the foggiest idea whether or not that's true. You're making it up.
The “Revelations” of the Prophets
Why should anybody pay attention to any such thing?
[The fact is — this by the way — everything seen as uniquely Hebrew had actually developed in Egypt long before. These “revelations” had another, previous source.]
Ah, the old Frazer hypothesis! This hasn't been trotted out in a long time now.
This is an old, dead hypothesis. Somebody might have been fooled by it early in the last century...not now, and not today. The actual comparisons don't match well. And Frazer mistakenly assumed that the Hebrews had to believe that previous people had no light or knowledge of the truth at all. In fact, we don't find they had to think this at all; so any similarities are easily explained by a better and more charitable hypothesis...namely, that the Egyptians, while possessing only a distorted and stunted version of the truths the Hebrews articulated better, were not devoid of genuine revelation of some things.
In such a case, some similarities, however pallid, would be exactly what one would expect to find -- but they would not be evidence that the Egyptians originated their own insights, nor that the Hebrews merely copied them; rather, the better explanation is that the Hebrews retained what was true from their time in Egypt, and discarded the greater body of polytheistic falsehoods with which the Egyptians had invested their tradition. And that is precisely what we seem to see.