Is this directed to me?!?
God and morality
Re: God and morality
Well, butter my butt and call me a biscuit!!!
This is a completely unexpected (yet interesting) turn of events.
That familiar style of evasive posturing has me now wondering if Alexis Jacobi might actually be a sock puppet of Age? Or (more likely), Age might be a sock puppet of Alexis Jacobi?
Come clean, you rascal.
Anyway...
Now ^^that^^ (if only it were true) would be wonderful.Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 5:22 pm I attempt — singlehandedly! — to resurrect the possibility of belief in a source of intelligence outside and beyond the world of Nature, where we are inevitably stuck unless we can revision things. And I do this by attempting a newer, metaphysical definition: to revivify a Conceptual Pathway.
Indeed, it is what I wish was the goal and M.O. of your - equal in eloquence interlocutor - IC.
However, like IC, the credibility of your assertions has been severely diminished by what you have repeatedly revealed to be your core beliefs.
In other words (or at least according to “Mr. ellipsis”),...
...just as everyone of IC’s eloquent defenses of Christianity and of the infallible (unquestionable) “righteousness” of the Christian God all bear the underlying “watermark” of IC’s ridiculous belief that it is perfectly justifiable for the Christian God to condemn billions of defenseless lifeforms to an eternity of torture for something they did (or did not do) during the few fleeting moments they spent on Earth,...
...again, just as the idiocy of ^^that^^ core belief held by IC automatically demonstrates the shallowness of his worldview and therefore calls into question the logic of anything else he has to say, no matter how eloquently expressed,...
...likewise, Alexis, you also have a similar problem.
Indeed, everything we need to know about the value of your attempt to singlehandedly...
...has been made exceedingly clear to us by you not only admitting to being a Trump supporter, but also by you constantly referring us to the works of white nationalist racists such as Jonathan Bowden and Nick Fuentes, just to name a few.“...resurrect the possibility of belief in a source of intelligence outside and beyond the world of Nature..."
Now, of course, I could be wrong, and you may indeed have a newer...
If so, then how about you stop with the Ageian hints and teases and present your proposal?“...metaphysical definition: to revivify a Conceptual Pathway...”
_______
- Alexis Jacobi
- Posts: 9244
- Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am
Re: God and morality
If Alexis Jacobi is to speak for all of humankind the answer tips toward the former and the latter is uniquely for special cases who are, I think, pretty rare.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 9:02 pm Is the purpose of "religion" to "function" for "needs"? Or is it supposed to be a description of truth, no matter what "needs" it does or does not address?
Your question, when examined, is really kind of odd. It presupposes that along comes a man who has not been raised up in a conceptual system that infuses into him knowledge and understanding of the real nature of the world, of existence, and that as a result of developing an inquiring mind — which is a complex training all to itself — that he realizes he does not really understand and know, then sits down and organizes, like with a list, sets of questions in order to arrive at “Truth”.
“Imagine men in a cave …”
That is a pretty good “eikasia” of the human situation. A human hits the ground running with an inherited, even rather automatic, operating system that doesn’t ask questions. You arrive within your inheritance.
You, who attempts to ground himself in a solid A=A belief that what is, is nothing more than what it is, eschews any special gnosis that arises when penetrating questions are asked. I think this is why Bible Literalism is the most solid intellectual grounding for you. Just take things as they are presented. No need to inquire really if appearances are real. Safer to stay affixed within givens.
As I constantly say, if I were to rely on the Forum or its Denizens to give even minimal clues about “the real nature of reality” or even to solve the most basic material questions, I would be stuck forever in a Gingerbread House in a deep, dark wood with horrifying, tortured spirits who loom at the windows and haunt sleep (I refrain from naming names) who are obviously stuck in a mire and unable to escape.
So, I have no choice but to be entirely “out for myself” and always to choose, by an act if the will, to gain never to lose, to be illumined, to develop philosophical and spiritual wings to sail out of the Dreary Forest of depressing murk and up UP into the airy blueness among shining silver-edged clouds of supernal intelligence.
I think that in your System which is completely pre-fabricated and is in a sense the alternative to Profound Inquiry, it is “logical” why any other system, and any ideas like those that Aurobindo explores, must be utterly rejected. In this sense you illustrate that the function of a dogmatic religion is comparable by allegory to that Wall and Screen upon which the viewers see things A=A and cannot see any other way.
What happens when a man, like unto Alexis Jacobi though surely there must be others (?) has unfettered himself from the harnesses and binding restraints of Rote Interpretation and Conditioned, Determined Seeing?
Suite à la prochaine, mes enfants! It may well happen that all is soon revealed!
Et n'oubliez pas: ne restez pas trop longtemps à regarder les ombres sur le mur …
- Alexis Jacobi
- Posts: 9244
- Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am
- Alexis Jacobi
- Posts: 9244
- Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am
Re: God and morality
What I can say, my most esteemed and reverend Seeds, is that my “intellectual journey” has been quite bizarre. I have to credit my reading of The Genealogy of Morals for its strong influence of blowing up inherited assumptions about, well, everything. (But I am not a Nietzschean if such really exists).
Once you start asking questions, Seeds, and supposing you will allow the ground upon which you have constructed your views to shift dramatically (to allow discomfort), the process seems to continue by its own accord.
On this Forum, and over time, I have have indeed referenced not so much “Bowden” (though this discourse had an effect on me and is useful as a didactic tool) but rather a Spirit of Inquiry that can slaughter and possibly roast Sacred Cows of numerous sorts.
But you must know: I am not an activist and I exist in a rather solitary space of theory.
But because it is fun, and also interesting (and bizarre) I submit for your perusal if not your edification a short talk by a man who is part of a rising movement in the US. His ideas are radical, but he presents them as grounded in defensible Christian theology. Not unethical mind you, but ethical and moral.
- Alexis Jacobi
- Posts: 9244
- Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am
Re: God and morality
Did I ever share the time I actually met Seeds?
Re: God and morality
Where is 'whiteness' in Christian theology?His ideas are radical, but he presents them as grounded in defensible Christian theology.
- Alexis Jacobi
- Posts: 9244
- Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am
Re: God and morality
Is this directed to me?!
They define it by way of the notion of “kin”.
[before 900; Middle English; Old English cyn; c. Old Saxon, Old High German kunni, Old Norse kyn, Gothic kuni; akin to Latin genus, Greek génos, Skt jánas. compare gender.]
See Phyllo? What happens when you (when one) begins to think about things that had been placed in a category of forbidden thought?• jána = a person, a creature, a folk, a tribe
• jánas = the people, in the collective sense — a people, a community, the folk
• jánāḥ (plural) = peoples, tribes
This is — for good or for evil we cannot say with certainty — what is going on today: the examination of received ideas, received ethical formulations by people who are situated in reaction.
Love your neighbor, love your kin.
Re: God and morality
Where is that in Christian theology?
If one gives special status to one's 'tribe', the current logical replacement of 'tribe' would be the nation-state. So Americans would be the "kin" and that would be color-blind. White Americans, black Americans, Chinese Americans, etc would be sharing kinship. But oddly, the kinship proposed is based on skin-color. That's something which is divisive and is going to exclude large segments of the population of the nation-state.
If one gives special status to one's 'tribe', the current logical replacement of 'tribe' would be the nation-state. So Americans would be the "kin" and that would be color-blind. White Americans, black Americans, Chinese Americans, etc would be sharing kinship. But oddly, the kinship proposed is based on skin-color. That's something which is divisive and is going to exclude large segments of the population of the nation-state.
- Alexis Jacobi
- Posts: 9244
- Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am
Re: God and morality
Well, you are asking ME that question? In Catholic social teaching (doctrine) the notion of kin (a people) is understood to be defensible and therefore ethical. Your people are your people.phyllo wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 2:42 pm Where is that in Christian theology?
If one gives special status to one's 'tribe', the current logical replacement of 'tribe' would be the nation-state. So Americans would be the "kin" and that would be color-blind. White Americans, black Americans, Chinese Americans, etc would be sharing kinship. But oddly, the kinship proposed is based on skin-color. That's something which is divisive and is going to exclude large segments of the population of the nation-state.
Multi-culturalism is, pretty obviously, an idea and an event that does harm to kin-relations, and its motive is not Christian-Ethical but motivated by business interests and other ranges of motives.
So, the rising reactionary movements — in this case grounded in theological interpretation — turn against an entire current of postwar Liberal impositions. They see the attack on “whiteness” (kin relations and solidarity) through a Christianesque lens which is not altogether incomprehensible but is certainly radical.
Who is my neighbor? they ask.
- Alexis Jacobi
- Posts: 9244
- Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am
Re: God and morality
An encapsulation of Alexis Jacobi’s view on neighborhood.
- Immanuel Can
- Posts: 30600
- Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm
Re: God and morality
AJ, as usual, it seems, has got Christian theology dead wrong here. He hasn't even apparently read Christ's response to the question, "And who is my neighbour?" (Luke 10:25-36)phyllo wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 2:42 pm Where is that in Christian theology?
If one gives special status to one's 'tribe', the current logical replacement of 'tribe' would be the nation-state. So Americans would be the "kin" and that would be color-blind. White Americans, black Americans, Chinese Americans, etc would be sharing kinship. But oddly, the kinship proposed is based on skin-color. That's something which is divisive and is going to exclude large segments of the population of the nation-state.
There's a reason the parable is nowadays known as "The Good Samaritan." A "Samaritan" was a hated, sworn enemy of Jewish folks. That such a wretch would turn out to be "good" would have come as a total surprise to any Jew.
Christ's answer is that one's "neighbour" is the person in need, be he friend or enemy. In fact, Christ's "tribe" or "kin" come off much worse in the parable, since they ignore the wounded man, and the Samaritan shows the exemplary compassion Christ is encouraging.
The upshot is the the message there is the dead opposite of what AJ is saying it is: it's not "love your kin," or "love the person you want to love," but "love your enemy" -- a message Christ repeated quite often, much to everybody's surprise.
Now, about the Gita, AJ's right: it teaches, "Hate your enemy, and don't worry about killing him; because the Destroyer has already doomed him, and he's as good as dead already." (Ch. 11 again) But that's not the message of Jesus Christ. That's somebody else's message.
- Alexis Jacobi
- Posts: 9244
- Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am
Re: God and morality
My view? We have to see nearly everything going on in the States, and in Europe, by way of resistance and reaction. The reaction of these radical Christians arose by way of specific causes. For example the social engineering campaign known as “multiculturalism”. If my understanding is correct this was a big deal in the 80s and 90s. Didn’t Hillary Clinton write a book on The Global Village? These were (are they still?) mass cultural engineering projects directed by agencies which are directed by business interests. I.e. nothing “organic” about them, all too-down.If one gives special status to one's 'tribe', the current logical replacement of 'tribe' would be the nation-state. So Americans would be the "kin" and that would be color-blind. White Americans, black Americans, Chinese Americans, etc would be sharing kinship. But oddly, the kinship proposed is based on skin-color. That's something which is divisive and is going to exclude large segments of the population of the nation-state.
It used to be the Left that opposed these mass machinations! They were the ones who wrote about it, warned of its consequences on “the working man” and the family. Now, to speak in such terms is for cultural fascists.
The heart of reaction is really to be located in the Anti-White Movement connected, as it is, with DEI which has been identified as radical, Marxian, and demoralizing. So rises up as “defense” against such a thread is a) a blind and emoted resistance like when you strike someone who presents a threat, or 2) a thought-out rational and intellectually organized reactionary response. But a platform of counter-activism has a greater likelihood of success if it is based in ethical, religious and even metaphysical concepts and principles. Hence the rise of a Radical Christian Right that takes on fearlessly every accusation (Nazi, racist, sexist, xenophobe) leveled against it, wrestles it to the ground, and strangles it.
- Immanuel Can
- Posts: 30600
- Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm
Re: God and morality
Maybe to you. But it's an obvious one.Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 1:06 pmYour question, when examined, is really kind of odd.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 9:02 pm Is the purpose of "religion" to "function" for "needs"? Or is it supposed to be a description of truth, no matter what "needs" it does or does not address?
You're assuming that morality is simply a human artifact, I must suppose, one crafted deliberately (rather than, say culturally by accretion or accident) in order to meet some human need. But there's another way to conceive morality, a better way, and one more historically precedented; that is, to understand morality as a divine imposition...which, while it still meets particular human needs, often conflicts with other perceived or preferred goals, because it is objectively right, regardless of human wishes.
Indeed, one is never identifiable as "moral" until the code conflicts with something one feels one wants or needs. For example, "Thou shalt not steal" conflicts with the human desire to take the shortest and most effective route to instant acquisition at the expense of others. And one is behaving "morally" not when one responds to one's own needs and thus steals, but when one suppresses the self-need of the moment, in favour of the higher principle that stealing is wrong.
So human needs are not the basis of morality. And morality does not exist for the satisfaction of some human preference or goal, but rather to suppress and redirect the bad instincts of humanity.
That's certainly not a "needs" function. However, morality also has the salutary side-effect of producing social cohesion and harmony, at times (and at times, not, of course). So it does produce human good, despite the human impulse toward the bad. That, however, must not be mistaken for the reason morality exists; it doesn't exist because it pleases humans, or by their calculations of long-term good, but rather because certain things are objectively (as we say) "the right thing to do," regardless of human preferences.
- Alexis Jacobi
- Posts: 9244
- Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am
Re: God and morality
My view? I am referencing views expressed by American Chritian radicals. And trying to explain on what basis they present their notions.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 3:52 pm There's a reason the parable is nowadays known as "The Good Samaritan." A "Samaritan" was a hated, sworn enemy of Jewish folks. That such a wretch would turn out to be "good" would have come as a total surprise to any Jew.
Christ's answer is that one's "neighbour" is the person in need, be he friend or enemy. In fact, Christ's "tribe" or "kin" come off much worse in the parable, since they ignore the wounded man, and the Samaritan shows the exemplary compassion Christ is encouraging.
The upshot is the the message there is the dead opposite of what AJ is saying it is: it's not "love your kin," or "love the person you want to love," but "love your enemy" -- a message Christ repeated quite often, much to everybody's surprise.
No one has asked for my view.
The story of the Samaritan only proposes a willingness to lend help to that man in need. It does not mean that that man must be allowed into your country and be treated as a neighbor, as one’s true kin.
These men, these interpreters of theology, are deliberately involving themselves in immediate and proximate social and political questions of the day. Such as the radical change of a nation when demography is socially engineered, and when sexual mores and other mores are deliberately modified also by social engineering (the list goes on). I understand them as putting their foot down. Insisting that certain processes begun, must end.
You can “love your enemy” even as you are rounding them up, in accord with established laws, and transporting them back to their own lands. (This is what they in fact say).