What is morality?
-
promethean75
- Posts: 8105
- Joined: Sun Nov 04, 2018 10:29 pm
Re: What is morality?
The effects of entropy on metabolic systems. That's what evolution pretty much is, bro.
The reason why cellular life can arise is that chemical-molecular activities are frequent and strong enough to produce bonds between parts that take a while to break down. That's why a strand of RNA endures after the random chemical combinations that allow it to arrange happen. A certain molecule gets produced that has strong atomic bonds, and its decay rate is slowed.
Okay... here you go. Free radicals. That's the effect of entropy on organic metabolic systems. Solution: antioxidants. If the very first polymeric molecules were able to acquire orange juice, evolutionary change could have taken an entirely different path than it did. Metabolic systems would have been more stable, and gene mutation would have occurred less frequently.
Orange juice, Mannie.
The reason why cellular life can arise is that chemical-molecular activities are frequent and strong enough to produce bonds between parts that take a while to break down. That's why a strand of RNA endures after the random chemical combinations that allow it to arrange happen. A certain molecule gets produced that has strong atomic bonds, and its decay rate is slowed.
Okay... here you go. Free radicals. That's the effect of entropy on organic metabolic systems. Solution: antioxidants. If the very first polymeric molecules were able to acquire orange juice, evolutionary change could have taken an entirely different path than it did. Metabolic systems would have been more stable, and gene mutation would have occurred less frequently.
Orange juice, Mannie.
-
Will Bouwman
- Posts: 1645
- Joined: Sun Sep 04, 2022 2:17 pm
Re: What is morality?
That is your creationspeak 'Atheism' and, by the way you capitalise Naturalism, Physicalism, Materialism and Evolutionism, I imagine you attach conditions to those that they do not carry in English. In English, atheism means 'I don't believe in any god', which is my position, or 'I believe there are no gods', which is not. We are not speaking the same language, Mr Can.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 7:31 pmAtheism "saddles" itself with some sort of Naturalism, Physicalism or Materialism.
Nor are we using the same logic. As I understand logic, it requires at least two premises from which to draw a conclusion. In creationspeak, with the multiple premises imputed, evidently all sorts of inferences can be made. Absolutely nothing follows logically from the English 'I don't believe in any god'. Anything you think might follow is a product of your beliefs.
What belief is that, Mr Can?
All of which are perfectly compatible with evolution. What in creationspeak 'Evolutionism' says they're not?Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 4:11 pmAs for evidence against Evolutionism, the burden of proof is on the Evolutionist. But certainly the red shift effect, the laws of entropy, and things like triadic symbiosis...
Ah well, that's a value judgement. I take it you agree that there are fossils, you just don't think they constitute a 'credible continuum'. I do.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 4:11 pm...to say nothing of the lack of a credible continuum of fossils...
What does creationspeak add to 'someone who thinks evolution is a viable hypothesis' that makes them an 'Evolutionist'?Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 4:11 pmAnd much more can be produced, too. But the Evolutionist is likely to ignore that evidence, and pretend it doesn't exist.
"Batshit fanaticism"? Maybe. Or maybe just unwillingness to look.
- Immanuel Can
- Posts: 30600
- Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm
Re: What is morality?
No. It's routine in English that, like language names such as "English", the labels of particular ideologies receive capital letters: Buddhism, Hinduism, Shintoism, Communism, Socialism...and Atheism, when one is recognizing it as an ideological position.Will Bouwman wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 1:19 pmThat is your creationspeak 'Atheism' and, by the way you capitalise Naturalism, Physicalism, Materialism and Evolutionism, I imagine you attach conditions to those that they do not carry in English.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 7:31 pmAtheism "saddles" itself with some sort of Naturalism, Physicalism or Materialism.
So what if you do not? Do you keep it to yourself, or do you preach to others, as you are doing at the present moment?In English, atheism means 'I don't believe in any god',
These things I have already exposited at length in other threads. But briefly, the red shift proves origin point. The laws of entropy prove ending point. Triadic symbiosis is one excellent demonstration of the impossibility of transitional evolutionary stages. And if you want to know more, research them. I won't repeat them all here, for the sake of not doing over that which has been abundantly done.All of which are perfectly compatible with evolution. What in creationspeak 'Evolutionism' says they're not?Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 4:11 pmAs for evidence against Evolutionism, the burden of proof is on the Evolutionist. But certainly the red shift effect, the laws of entropy, and things like triadic symbiosis...
No, it's purely an empirical one. If there is not a sufficient abundance of transitional forms in the fossil record, it requires an explanation that gradualism simply does not have. And there clearly is not: for every "species" form we have, we ought to have, according to the Evolutionism timeline, at least thousands of intermediate forms, each one almost undetectably different from the next, since the gradual transformation of a creature is supposed to take immeasurably longer than it takes for each species to come into its present form. But we don't find that. And scientifically, the question is, "Why not?"Ah well, that's a value judgement.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 4:11 pm...to say nothing of the lack of a credible continuum of fossils...
It was this problem that led some of the secular Evolutionists of the last century to posit a new evolutionary theory, called "punctuated equilibrium." So sparse for purpose is the fossil record that they decided that evolution must take place in "jumps," punctuated with long periods of stasis. That would explain the gaps, of course; but it amounted to a denial of gradualism, which was a key dynamic of established evolutionary theories, so it has been dropped, it would seem. Still the brief dalliance of secularists with punctuated equilibrium theory betrays a nervousness among Evolutionists, that the fossil record is not providing them with what we should expect, if gradualism were true.
Well, I agree with the secular proposers of punctuated equilibrium, that the observable evidence does not support that belief.I take it you agree that there are fossils, you just don't think they constitute a 'credible continuum'. I do.
-
MikeNovack
- Posts: 1453
- Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm
Re: What is morality?
There is evidence of evolution working now. This is perfectly easy to demonstrate and it does not take millions of years. A common organism used for such demonstrations is a species from the genus Drosophila because the life cycle of fruit flies is short. Easy to have a generation per month.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 4:39 amActually, the opposite is true: there's no demonstration of evolutionary change "working now." That is precisely why proponents insist on long time-frames; to explain why they can't produce such evidence. They need millions of years, and extreme gradualism, so that the theory looks plausible at all.MikeNovack wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 2:20 am
No IC, because evidence (real evidence) can be produced that (biological) evolution works NOW,
You take a population of fruit flies in which there is some easily observable variation, most are of type A (don't have this) and a few are of type B (have this). That is the presumed random variation. We then move this population to another enclosure one at a time, applying a selection criteria, say if an A, transfer with probability 1/6 (roll a die) and if a B, transfer with a probability 5/6. That is the survival differential evolution theory says the environment imposed. Let the surviving flies breed a new generation.
Repeat. It will not be many generations (not much time at one per month) before you would observe that the population is now mostly type B. It has "evolved".
If you deny this, you are irrationally behaving like the Churchmen who refused to look through Galileo's tube (telescope). You can't (reasonably) say "evolution does not work now". You might try "OK, works for Drosophila but not anything else and YOU chose Drosophila". I would counter with "Then you choose any other short life cycle organism you wish and I will repeat the demonstration with those". << the only reason for "short life cycle" is to get the experiment done quickly >>
Your claim "no complete fossil record for the evolution of any organism" is true. But there are intervals of fossil records showing THAT part of the record. So you would be arguing "works now, and worked during intervals in the past, but somehow stopped working during other intervals". Do you really want to argue for that kind of behavior for a law of the natural world? And this "on and off" for evolution would have to be species by species, since a time interval that was a gap in the record for one might not be a gap in the record for another.
NOTE: That evolution works is NOT proof that your God did not create the universe some 5000+ years ago with everything in place to indicate the age of things as we observe them.
Now about those pink, tutu wearing unicorns. Yes you could offer evidence that they do not exist in the material realm. But you cannot offer evidence that they do not exist in the non-material realm, the one where you claim your god exists. I understand, I intentionally chose something preposterous like pink, tutu wearing unicorns precisely because you are unlikely to claim you are agnostic about their existence. You don't think you need to present evidence to support your belief "they do not exist". Then stop demanding the atheist provide evidence for "no gods exist".
YOU are deciding what is a preposterous notion differently than the atheist. That's all.
- Immanuel Can
- Posts: 30600
- Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm
Re: What is morality?
Yes, I know about these attempts to make a proof. But I'll point out the obvious problem, after you explain.MikeNovack wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 4:52 pmThere is evidence of evolution working now. This is perfectly easy to demonstrate and it does not take millions of years. A common organism used for such demonstrations is a species from the genus Drosophila because the life cycle of fruit flies is short. Easy to have a generation per month.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 4:39 amActually, the opposite is true: there's no demonstration of evolutionary change "working now." That is precisely why proponents insist on long time-frames; to explain why they can't produce such evidence. They need millions of years, and extreme gradualism, so that the theory looks plausible at all.MikeNovack wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 2:20 am
No IC, because evidence (real evidence) can be produced that (biological) evolution works NOW,
You're blending two conceptions of "evolution" without noting the difference.It will not be many generations (not much time at one per month) before you would observe that the population is now mostly type B. It has "evolved".
Intraspecies "evolution" -- is really no more than biological adaptation within a single species. As such, it's not genuinely "evolution" at all, but merely change of a superficial sort. The species continues to have all the essential features of its own kind, and remains interfertile with its own kind, and does not transition species.
I can provide you with an even more graphic example: dogs. No creature on earth has been bred more intensively and deliberately to produce distinctive dog features. From the massive Newfoundland to the tiny chihuahua, dogs have been developed in an intraspecies way to the point where some breeds hardly resemble others at all. Yet they all remain interfertile, and all remain dogs.
But then there's this:
Interspecies evolution -- and this is quite a different thing. This theory holds that it should not only be possible for generations of fruit flies to be bred into different configurations of fruit flies, but that fruit flies, if bred rigorously, should be able to turn into birds, or fish, or men, or some other species -- no longer genetically the same, no longer interfertile with its base species, and completely different, when evolution is complete.
Which one is it that Evolutionism requires? Can Evolutionism be demonstrated on an intraspecies basis, when no substantive change in species is involved? Or does the Theory of Evolutionism ask us to believe that fish can become frogs, frogs can become monkeys, and monkeys can become men?
Which sort is it? One can be done in a lab, and even sometimes happens outside the lab. The other has never been done anywhere, by any number of generations of fruit flies, or dogs, or anything.
Thank you. Yes, it's true. But it's less than I actually said, though it's in quotes. I said the record as a whole is so incomplete as to be rife with "missing links." The fossil record does not reveal at all what the Evolutionist should expect, given gradualism -- namely, thousands or even millions of transitional forms, each one only minutely different from the last, for every single "modern" species we have.Your claim "no complete fossil record for the evolution of any organism" is true.
THAT, we definitely don't find.
No, I'd merely be reciting the attempted rescue-strategy some Evolutionists have used. But the truth is that the fossil record is SO spotty that I don't argue it counts for any evidence of Evolutionism, whether graduated or punctuated.But there are intervals of fossil records showing THAT part of the record. So you would be arguing "works now, and worked during intervals in the past, but somehow stopped working during other intervals".
Let's send them dancing. They're silly. I have no need to respond to such obvious reductios as that, beyond the response I've already given.Now about those pink, tutu wearing unicorns.
To do so would be to stop being scientific. For it is a basic scientific axiom that that which should be believed, at least within the confines of the subjects science can address, must be accompanied by evidence, logic or proof.Then stop demanding the atheist provide evidence for "no gods exist".
So what we are saying is this: that the Atheist pretence to be "scientific" or "rational" is unsubstantiated by any evidence at all. And if we realize that, I have no further objection, until the point when the Atheist begins to recommend his disbelief to others, or to evangelize for it; at which point, he surely owes his listeners some reason to believe him. And since he has none, we are left with a simple question: why should we believe the Atheist knows anything at all about the subject, and why should we listen to him?
-
MikeNovack
- Posts: 1453
- Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm
Re: What is morality?
You simply have misconceptions about what happens over time. And what a species is.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 5:22 pm Intraspecies "evolution" -- is really no more than biological adaptation within a single species. As such, it's not genuinely "evolution" at all, but merely change of a superficial sort. The species continues to have all the essential features of its own kind, and remains interfertile with its own kind, and does not transition species.
Interspecies evolution -- and this is quite a different thing. This theory holds that it should not only be possible for generations of fruit flies to be bred into different configurations of fruit flies, but that fruit flies, if bred rigorously, should be able to turn into birds, or fish, or men, or some other species -- no longer genetically the same, no longer interfertile with its base species, and completely different, when evolution is complete.
Which one is it that Evolutionism requires? Can Evolutionism be demonstrated on an intraspecies basis, when no substantive change in species is involved? Or does the Theory of Evolutionism ask us to believe that fish can become frogs, frogs can become monkeys, and monkeys can become men?
Which sort is it? One can be done in a lab, and even sometimes happens outside the lab. The other has never been done anywhere, by any number of generations of fruit flies, or dogs, or anything.
ALL species of the genus Castenea will still fertilize each other (and that has been what, 175 million years since Pangaea broke apart). Not all of these crosses will lead to viable hybrid offspring, but this is based on the individual trees being crossed and in which direction (about 50% will result in fully viable hybrid offspring -- in other words, 50% that crossing THIS C. dentata (American chestnut) and THAT C. mollissima (Chinese chestnut) will result in fully viable offspring if the cross is the right one being the male or female). << I am involved in the project trying to breed American chestnuts tolerant of the blight fungus C. parasitica and the "ink disease" fungus P. cinnamomi >>
In other words, you are seeing the species of a genus in the process of splitting to no longer be intrafertile. This tends to take MUCH more time (generations) in plants than in animals. And besides, a generation for a tree species longer than a generation for us humans << though we know how to force this quicker for chestnuts >>
And no, monkeys never became man. The spit between old world monkeys and apes was about 25-30 million years ago. A perfect example were you can argue "no fossil record" since the oldest relevant fossils we have for each line about 20 million years ago,already split << comparison of the DNA of each can indicate "time since LCA" >>
Fish first came on land about 375 million years ago, (and in this case we do have a fossil record). Note that this was relatively early in the evolution of fish species, so no, most of the fish species around today unlikely to evolve to land dwelling tetrapods. HOWEVER, there are still a few species of fish around with the characteristics of those that did evolve into tetrapods so it COULD happen again << say if something wiped out all terrestrial vertebrates >> These species do sometimes leave the water to go about on "land".
-
promethean75
- Posts: 8105
- Joined: Sun Nov 04, 2018 10:29 pm
Re: What is morality?
"I am involved in the project trying to breed American chestnuts tolerant of the blight fungus C. parasitica and the "ink disease" fungus P. cinnamomi"
Lol this is too much. No Slack Novack is actually doing in his backyard the very thing IC denies can happen. On the other hand, IC would fight Novack to the death if Novack insisted the resurrection or the flood didn't happen or that you can't make a person out of a rib bone.
Lol this is too much. No Slack Novack is actually doing in his backyard the very thing IC denies can happen. On the other hand, IC would fight Novack to the death if Novack insisted the resurrection or the flood didn't happen or that you can't make a person out of a rib bone.
- Immanuel Can
- Posts: 30600
- Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm
Re: What is morality?
No, I don't actually. And I know what a species is.MikeNovack wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 6:42 pmYou simply have misconceptions about what happens over time. And what a species is.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 5:22 pm Intraspecies "evolution" -- is really no more than biological adaptation within a single species. As such, it's not genuinely "evolution" at all, but merely change of a superficial sort. The species continues to have all the essential features of its own kind, and remains interfertile with its own kind, and does not transition species.
Interspecies evolution -- and this is quite a different thing. This theory holds that it should not only be possible for generations of fruit flies to be bred into different configurations of fruit flies, but that fruit flies, if bred rigorously, should be able to turn into birds, or fish, or men, or some other species -- no longer genetically the same, no longer interfertile with its base species, and completely different, when evolution is complete.
Which one is it that Evolutionism requires? Can Evolutionism be demonstrated on an intraspecies basis, when no substantive change in species is involved? Or does the Theory of Evolutionism ask us to believe that fish can become frogs, frogs can become monkeys, and monkeys can become men?
Which sort is it? One can be done in a lab, and even sometimes happens outside the lab. The other has never been done anywhere, by any number of generations of fruit flies, or dogs, or anything.
What I'm asking is for an example of interspecies evolution that works NOW. You said such were available. The theory depends on them existing. So where are they?
Interesting, though, that for many years, that idea was Evolutionist orthodoxy. They're desperate to disown that now, but those of us who lived through it never forget. They've now revised the theory, because they were so obviously wrong; but it makes you wonder just how many other ways they are stridently wrong today, doesn't it?And no, monkeys never became man.
-
MikeNovack
- Posts: 1453
- Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm
Re: What is morality?
Uh no, what the popular view of evolution meant has little to do with science. It was always apes. The connection to monkeys is farther back. Both apes and monkeys had a (last) common ancestor. That the person on the street equates monkeys and apes is beside the point. But they separated a long time ago. More than twice as long ago than the LCA of all our current species of "cat".Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 9:08 pmInteresting, though, that for many years, that idea was Evolutionist orthodoxy. They're desperate to disown that now, but those of us who lived through it never forget. They've now revised the theory, because they were so obviously wrong; but it makes you wonder just how many other ways they are stridently wrong today, doesn't it?And no, monkeys never became man.
It's like the "cats" and the "dogs" had a LCA about twice as far back as the one between "apes' and "monkeys".
Do you realize how silly it is to be demanding rational evidence for the non-existence of a god when your understanding of "evidence" is so divergent that you don't accept evidence for a question about the material world. Certainly there is FAR better evidence for the existence of evolution* than there is for any pink, tutu wearing unicorn in the non-material world.
* the note is because evolution applied to systems composed of biological organisms is just a special case of evolution applied to systems composed of anything. Remember, it works if the components are beads.
How about you look up what a "ring species" is. Examples like the Ensatina Salamanders (live AROUND the Central Valley CA) or the greenish warblers of Asia. Neighboring populations can interbreed but when they meet at some point going around the circle, they can't. The American herring gull and the European herring gull are ALMOST a ring species (they sometimes succeed in interbreeding).
- Immanuel Can
- Posts: 30600
- Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm
Re: What is morality?
Oh. So now you'll blame the proles who believed the scientists, instead of the scientists who invented and perpetuated the monkey-to-man theory! Nice trick. But we elephants have long memories.MikeNovack wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 10:36 pmUh no, what the popular view of evolution meant has little to do with science.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 9:08 pmInteresting, though, that for many years, that idea was Evolutionist orthodoxy. They're desperate to disown that now, but those of us who lived through it never forget. They've now revised the theory, because they were so obviously wrong; but it makes you wonder just how many other ways they are stridently wrong today, doesn't it?And no, monkeys never became man.
As silly as saying, "There are no gods," when one has no evidence, at least.Do you realize how silly it is to be demanding rational evidence for the non-existence of a god...
I don't mind pointing out how silly Atheists are. They're so pompous when they declare to know something they couldn't possibly know that they positively invite it.
No wonder the Tanakh says, "The fool has said in his heart, there is no God."
-
MikeNovack
- Posts: 1453
- Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm
Re: What is morality?
The scientists said apes. To common people, apes, monkeys, what's the difference.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 11:27 pm ........
Oh. So now you'll blame the proles who believed the scientists, instead of the scientists who invented and perpetuated the monkey-to-man theory! Nice trick. But we elephants have long memories.
.........
Do you realize how silly it is to be demanding rational evidence for the non-existence of a god..
As silly as saying, "There are no gods," when one has no evidence, at least.![]()
I don't mind pointing out how silly Atheists are. They're so pompous when they declare to know something they couldn't possibly know that they positively invite it.
No IC, you COMPLETELY misunderstood what I was saying about "evidence". I was saying silly of YOU to demand from rational people evidence of anything when you demonstrate you do not accept evidence even for something like evolution.
- Immanuel Can
- Posts: 30600
- Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm
Re: What is morality?
But neither was true. And for decades, the poor fools of the public were hoodwinked into things like the "monkey to man" chart, which appeared in every science textbook...and it was all a lie.MikeNovack wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 12:17 amThe scientists said apes. To common people, apes, monkeys, what's the difference.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 11:27 pm ........
Oh. So now you'll blame the proles who believed the scientists, instead of the scientists who invented and perpetuated the monkey-to-man theory! Nice trick. But we elephants have long memories.
.........
Do you realize how silly it is to be demanding rational evidence for the non-existence of a god..
As silly as saying, "There are no gods," when one has no evidence, at least.![]()
I don't mind pointing out how silly Atheists are. They're so pompous when they declare to know something they couldn't possibly know that they positively invite it.
So apparently, Evolutionists are prepared to lie in order to present themselves as knowing.
I understood. I just pointed out that Atheism is the viewpoint that asserts things without evidence, and (as you point out) without even the prospect of being able to prove a negative like "non-existence" of a Supreme Being.No IC, you COMPLETELY misunderstood what I was saying about "evidence".
And I ask, why are they so smug, when they have so little...nothing, really...to go on?
-
MikeNovack
- Posts: 1453
- Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm
Re: What is morality?
I am saying you are missing something. In THIS CASE the atheist is saying "I have no evidence to show the non-existence of ANYTHING in some non- material realm. But suppose the atheist said "here's the evidence". Would you be able to judge whether evidence or not? If you and the atheist are not in agreement with "what is valid/compelling evidence" about evolution, if your refuse to accept his/her evidence abut that, why bother showing you any evidence about anything at all.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 1:19 amI understood. I just pointed out that Atheism is the viewpoint that asserts things without evidence, and (as you point out) without even the prospect of being able to prove a negative like "non-existence" of a Supreme Being.No IC, you COMPLETELY misunderstood what I was saying about "evidence".
And I ask, why are they so smug, when they have so little...nothing, really...to go on?![]()
- Immanuel Can
- Posts: 30600
- Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm
Re: What is morality?
I'm not. I'm saying that what they try to say doesn't make sense.MikeNovack wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 4:55 pmI am saying you are missing something.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 1:19 amI understood. I just pointed out that Atheism is the viewpoint that asserts things without evidence, and (as you point out) without even the prospect of being able to prove a negative like "non-existence" of a Supreme Being.No IC, you COMPLETELY misunderstood what I was saying about "evidence".
And I ask, why are they so smug, when they have so little...nothing, really...to go on?![]()
Right. That's only a personal confession. The Atheist personally has no evidence.In THIS CASE the atheist is saying "I have no evidence to show the non-existence of ANYTHING in some non- material realm.
But so what? That claim has no consequence for anybody but him. Moreover, even for him, it does not imply he could not find evidence in the next five minutes. So what has he really said? Nothing much.
Of course. The evidence would have to be commensurate with the claim. That is how we can know, even before he speaks, that the Atheists is not capable of having that evidence.But suppose the atheist said "here's the evidence". Would you be able to judge whether evidence or not?
Ask yourself: what would the evidence for "no-God" be? Then ask yourself this: what would be the commensurate evidence for the EXISTENCE of God? And which of the two is even potentially doable?
-
MikeNovack
- Posts: 1453
- Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm
Re: What is morality?
But suppose we haven't gotten as far as the atheist's answer. Just as far as you asking for it. You are (in effect) saying......Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 18, 2026 5:02 pmOf course. The evidence would have to be commensurate with the claim. That is how we can know, even before he speaks, that the Atheists is not capable of having that evidence.But suppose the atheist said "here's the evidence". Would you be able to judge whether evidence or not?
Ask yourself: what would the evidence for "no-God" be? Then ask yourself this: what would be the commensurate evidence for the EXISTENCE of God? And which of the two is even potentially doable?
a) Show me evidence of X or non X << let's forget about whether talking about the material or non-material realms >>
b) I will reject as evidence anything that conflicts with my religious beliefs.
At the same time you are saying.
c) Here is evidence backing my belief that God exists.
d) You (the atheist) should accept what I am presenting as evidence to be evidence.
Do you not see that you are disagreeing on "what is (or is not) evidence"?