That was a really bad/unfortunate example. In one of the most well known Buddhist stories about the universality of suffering, Kṛśā Gautamīthe, the woman who has lost her child and asks Buddha to bring him back to life, is a RICH woman << he tells her to bring him mustard seed from a household where none have died to make the medicine >>promethean75 wrote: ↑Sat Nov 14, 2026 4:59 pm Buddhism: what the bourgeoisie do to counter their bad conscience. Wait a minute.... just because I'm rich doesn't mean I don't suffer life you. Do you know how hard it is to decide which stocks to invest in?!
I'm really sorry, but Alexis is quite correct that I was not taking a "secular" position. It is really hard for them to see this, but believers in God tend not to be able to consider the divine/sacred/holy in any other terms but a GOD (a divine being that exists in a realm outside the material as well as possibly within, but the outside is critical). Then they (correctly) label those who disbelieve in such a god to be atheists, but incorrectly assume that means secular (disbelieves in any divine/sacred/holy).
I'll give yes/no examples --- is Spinoza an atheist? His "one substance" allows for no separation between the material and the divine. Are Buddhists atheists? Is an animist an atheist? Are any of these "secular materialists"?