All those who operate from metaphysical positions (I definitely do) tend to make sweeping, interpretive statements.
You are merely being stubborn: You know as well as I the suppositions that define your atheism. Save me the effort: state them.
All those who operate from metaphysical positions (I definitely do) tend to make sweeping, interpretive statements.
You think that I'm an atheist.Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 5:47 pmAll those who operate from metaphysical positions (I definitely do) tend to make sweeping, interpretive statements.
You are merely being stubborn: You know as well as I the suppositions that define your atheism. Save me the effort: state them.
Talk honestly of your actual position.You think that I'm an atheist.
The first test you encounter is showing that God or god or gods exist.Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 7:40 pm Here’s one thing about you, Phyllo: If you have actual positions you never clarify them. You always seem to hang back. Why is this?
Talk honestly of your actual position.You think that I'm an atheist.
You have not been paying attention to years of discussions here: there is absolutely no way to “prove” such a thing in the sense that you mean. Therefore if one is, say, interested in the question a completely different methodology will be needed. So, in your case, you are back to square one.
More pertinently you can’t. Given your pre-suppositions.You can't even get past that point.
The purpose of “discussing metaphysics”, and we must also say “with people who do not have awareness or comprehension of what is alluded to” is I think to preserve a conceptual pathway to what “all that” portends. Again, my reference is the girl and her story. She presented “a model”, a cosmological picture, and all the elements of her story were just that: pictures. The cereal boxes that represented “entire life experiences” could only have been visualized by a modern American growing up with supermarket packaging.
I know lots of Atheists and skeptics. I listen to them. I don't speak for them. But when they say what they say, I believe they believe it.Gary Childress wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 9:37 amImmanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 5:02 am They seem to be the main ones the skeptics complain about.
Do you ever speak for yourself and stop speaking for other people that you don't understand or know?
"One can choose," is not the way it's expressed in Scripture. According to Scripture, the sinner is enslaved by sin. He can't get himself out of it.Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 12:11 pmThis claim is quite false, just for the record. Traditional Catholicism does state that by genuine work on the self, the work of seeing how far one drifts into the errors of sin (essentially sensuous materialism), that one can choose to drop these, and in that way be granted “Grace”.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 09, 2026 2:14 pm Catholicism shares an unfortunate naiveté with Socialists -- namely, the belief in human perfectibility through institutional reform. Both have an unrealistic anthropology.
I haven't. I've only said they share an erroneous assumption about the ability of man to save himself. In Socialism, the "perfecting" institution is supposed to be the totalitarian State. In Catholicism, it's said to be the religious organization. But in both cases, it's an error.To equate the Catholic social doctrines with “socialism”