O Canada
- Immanuel Can
- Posts: 30613
- Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm
Re: O Canada
Konstantin Kisin has beautifully explained what's wrong with Canadian politics (except he said it about British politics, from which Canadian derived). He said, "They are like people who think they can save the Titanic by constantly changing captains...but never changing course."
They had Liberal regimes that behaved like Socialists. They have a national-socialist party and a green party -- nobody really votes for either. They have had Conservative governments that behaved like Liberals. They had Trudeau, who could do nothing because he knew nothing. They have Carney, who hasn't done anything really at all...except antagonize the Americans.
The ship keeps sailing in the same direction, because Canadians are the ultimate "go-alongs," and no longer have any vision, direction or principles to which they will commit.
Quebec, the perpetually privileged and aggrieved, gets most of the money and power, and yet continues to rumble about Separatism. Ontario sees itself as the core of Canada, and everybody else as peripheral...except Quebec.
The West is still wounded and angry, but too afraid to force a change.
The Left Coast is still Left.
The Maritimes remain poor and distant cousins, largely ignored and like Alberta, over-regulated so they cannot take advantage of their oil and other resources.
Canada continues to believe that it is a noble place -- much better than its more affluent cousins to the south, but only morally, not situationally -- and continues to believe that whatever happens in the larger world, Canada will always be Canada.
We shall see if they're right. But between their above-replacement rate of migration and their rate of murdering their own citizens, between the interests of China and Europe, between their nationalists and their growing separatist factions...nothing is sure forever.
They had Liberal regimes that behaved like Socialists. They have a national-socialist party and a green party -- nobody really votes for either. They have had Conservative governments that behaved like Liberals. They had Trudeau, who could do nothing because he knew nothing. They have Carney, who hasn't done anything really at all...except antagonize the Americans.
The ship keeps sailing in the same direction, because Canadians are the ultimate "go-alongs," and no longer have any vision, direction or principles to which they will commit.
Quebec, the perpetually privileged and aggrieved, gets most of the money and power, and yet continues to rumble about Separatism. Ontario sees itself as the core of Canada, and everybody else as peripheral...except Quebec.
The West is still wounded and angry, but too afraid to force a change.
The Left Coast is still Left.
The Maritimes remain poor and distant cousins, largely ignored and like Alberta, over-regulated so they cannot take advantage of their oil and other resources.
Canada continues to believe that it is a noble place -- much better than its more affluent cousins to the south, but only morally, not situationally -- and continues to believe that whatever happens in the larger world, Canada will always be Canada.
We shall see if they're right. But between their above-replacement rate of migration and their rate of murdering their own citizens, between the interests of China and Europe, between their nationalists and their growing separatist factions...nothing is sure forever.
Re: O Canada
Quebec thinks.... Ontario sees itself.... The West is still angry....
How does that work? Are there other institutions that also feel emotions? What about my local council? Or the badminton club? Can that get angry too? Can it fall in love?
I find collectivism a deeply confusing ideology.
How does that work? Are there other institutions that also feel emotions? What about my local council? Or the badminton club? Can that get angry too? Can it fall in love?
I find collectivism a deeply confusing ideology.
Re: O Canada
I didn't post about the referendum because I was away, but I did follow it with interest.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Oct 20, 2026 3:39 pm It's early days yet. This story has a loooong way to go, if you understand separatism at all. It's pretty durable in Quebec. We'll have to see how long it lasts in Alberta.
Separatism does tend to be durable, yes. And referendums where the question connects with people's sense of their identity tend to reinforce that identity on both sides and make it a defining feature of politics for a long time. I'm thinking of the Scottish independence referendum of 2014 and the Brexit referendum of 2016 as two examples. In a bitter and divisive contest, the Scottish nationalists got beaten by a convincing margin: 55% to 45%. However that was closer than expected - previously there had never been much more than 30% support for leaving the UK. And afterwards (a) within a few months the nationalists were calling for a new referendum and (b) most of the 45% who had voted to leave the UK transferred their voting support from their previous parties to the Scottish National Party, who then enjoyed a huge boost in support and won the next several elections against a divided collection of pro-UK parties.
Similarly the Brexit referendum - a close run thing, 52% voting to leave the EU and 48% to remain - divided families and friends in the bitterest fashion. It left many people on the losing side coming to define themselves as passionately European, and refusing in a very Trumpian fashion to accept the results of the vote. After the UK finally did leave the EU in 2020, most people on both sides heaved a huge sigh of relief and moved their attention to other concerns, but a hardcore on the losing side are still trying to reopen the issue now and have another vote. That wouldn't be a problem except that one of them is the current Prime Minister.
I am to an extent agreeing with IC here - referendums around separatism reinforce identity, which solidifies political divisions, which leads to calls from the losing side for another vote, and then another, and another....
However, the Alberta referendum was different in that the result wasn't even remotely close. In the two referendums I described, the losing side could say "Ah, we nearly won... we were robbed, we don't accept the result!" In the Alberta case, it is impossible for the separatists to tell themselves that most of their fellow citizens agree with them really, because the gap was too big to allow that kind of illusion. Therefore perhaps Alberta separatism will instead die down or die out. But I'm only speculating - I've never even been to Alberta and I might be totally wrong.
- Immanuel Can
- Posts: 30613
- Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm
Re: O Canada
You have to know the history. Alberta, unlike Quebec, is a perversely conservative kind of place. Revolutions, rebellions, separation...usually not their thing. This is the very first time there's even been a serious separatist movement in Alberta, and nothing like this referendum has ever happened, so far. So the very fact that it took place should be a source of amazement.
But it signals a shift in Western thinking, for sure. This is far from the last salvo in this contest, I think you'll find...assuming the Liberal government continues on its Canada-killing course of assuring re-election for Carney et al. by sacrificing the international interests of the country. At some point, the West is going to have had enough -- and we now have evidence that a separatist movement is possible even there.
All to say, this ain't over. And I'm not campaigning for Western separation. But such a thing should never have been thinkable. That it is, is really a warning shot across the bow of Canada.
The truth is that the West of Canada is more "Canadian" now than the east is. Traditionally, Ontario was thought of as the heartland; but it has sold out it's Canadian values, and these remain more alive in Alberta, Saskatchewan or the Maritimes than they do in Ontario. So it raises a question: is Alberta thinking of leaving Canada, or is Canada leaving itself, and Alberta is trying to retain Canada? It's a different way of seeing the controversy, for sure.
-
Impenitent
- Posts: 6401
- Joined: Wed Feb 10, 2010 2:04 pm
Re: O Canada
What is "Canadian"?The truth is that the West of Canada is more "Canadian" now than the east is.
Re: O Canada
Yes, that could be a YouTube sensation.Impenitent wrote: ↑Wed Nov 11, 2026 12:28 amno, no, no!!
disgruntled birdies lining up as far as the eye can see...
although, watching the RCMP return a volley could be an equestrian delight!
-Imp
- Immanuel Can
- Posts: 30613
- Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm
Re: O Canada
Certain kinds of values, really. The kinds of values that make Canadians persistently popular in Europe and elsewhere, when nameless others are busy making themselves a lot less popular.
Re: O Canada
As if Western Canada has vague values like that and Eastern Canada doesn't.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 5:28 pmCertain kinds of values, really. The kinds of values that make Canadians persistently popular in Europe and elsewhere, when nameless others are busy making themselves a lot less popular.
- Immanuel Can
- Posts: 30613
- Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm
Re: O Canada
The East has the traditional values more than most places. The West also has them, with the exception of BC on the south coast. It's the central part -- traditionally, the heartland -- that has lost its way. Ottawa, Toronto and Montreal have become toxically "Woke," and bought into the nonsense that uninhibited economic migration, partnerships with despotic regimes, globalism, exorbitant taxation, free drugs, the so-called "Green" agenda, racism, Socialism and backstabbing your historic allies are good things.phyllo wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 5:56 pmAs if Western Canada has vague values like that and Eastern Canada doesn't.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 5:28 pmCertain kinds of values, really. The kinds of values that make Canadians persistently popular in Europe and elsewhere, when nameless others are busy making themselves a lot less popular.
All that's being lost is Canada...everything it used to be.
-
MikeNovack
- Posts: 1453
- Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm
Re: O Canada
Are we discussing the same place?
"The west except for southern BC" ----- Uh, doesn't southern BC have as large population as all of Alberta?
And you'd have to restrict your description of Manitoba to intermediate term (ignoring the past and the present) to lump it with Alberta and Saskatchewan << or were you unaware that after some time out of power, the NDP has retaken control of the provincial government >>
If you call the Liberals left and green*, what do you consider the NDP
*I mean"green" in its "environmental" sense --- yes I know, in the last year or two now also being used for "Moslem" so we'll have to wait and see which usage holds.
"The west except for southern BC" ----- Uh, doesn't southern BC have as large population as all of Alberta?
And you'd have to restrict your description of Manitoba to intermediate term (ignoring the past and the present) to lump it with Alberta and Saskatchewan << or were you unaware that after some time out of power, the NDP has retaken control of the provincial government >>
If you call the Liberals left and green*, what do you consider the NDP
*I mean"green" in its "environmental" sense --- yes I know, in the last year or two now also being used for "Moslem" so we'll have to wait and see which usage holds.
- Immanuel Can
- Posts: 30613
- Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm
Re: O Canada
I'm speaking of Vancouver, of course. It has recently been very Leftist, and is the major population center of BC. However, the incumbent NDP recently suffered the most humiliating defeat to the Conservatives that it has historically ever had (64 Conservative, 27 NDP, 2 Green)...so there may be some hope that Socialism is wearing out its welcome, even for BC.MikeNovack wrote: ↑Thu Nov 12, 2026 7:20 pm "The west except for southern BC" ----- Uh, doesn't southern BC have as large population as all of Alberta?
They used to be to the Left of the Liberals. Nowadays, NDP stands for "No Darn Point"; because the Liberals have pretty much hijacked their whole agenda from them.If you call the Liberals left and green*, what do you consider the NDP
Re: O Canada
Tommy Douglas in Saskatchewan, paved the road to communism with universal healthcare.And you'd have to restrict your description of Manitoba to intermediate term (ignoring the past and the present) to lump it with Alberta and Saskatchewan << or were you unaware that after some time out of power, the NDP has retaken control of the provincial government >>
- Immanuel Can
- Posts: 30613
- Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm
-
mickthinks
- Posts: 2006
- Joined: Thu Oct 18, 2007 1:10 am
- Location: Augsburg
Re: O Canada
Manny thinks that fictional mockery is proof something can’t work. Bless!