You're right; the struggle for survival is not the source of change; it is the source of maintaining life itself. On both sides of the predator-prey equation, it is a life-and-death struggle: eat or be eaten. Most changes in the organism come from mutations, which are mostly fatal to the survival of the organism; however, some give the organism an edge in survival and become the norm. Behavioural changes can result through a change of structure and form, but the fairly recent discovery of epigenetics indicates that behaviours can be handed down from one generation to another; through trauma or just some profound experience, it can change the reading of the DNA of the individual organism and is passed down to the next generation; it is adaptation. It dawned on me, though, that the next generation to inherit might not be facing quite the same circumstances, and thus it would not be adaptive. Change in structure and form is entirely through mutations. Behaviour is epigenetics, instincts, and role modeling.
Questioning Evolution
-
popeye1945
- Posts: 3263
- Joined: Sun Sep 12, 2021 2:12 am
Re: Questioning Evolution
Re: Questioning Evolution
Oops. Unfamiliar software.
Last edited by cladking3 on Mon Nov 09, 2026 11:42 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Questioning Evolution
I believe that when typical behavior is eradicated i8n a bottleneck only unusual behavior persists. This unusual behavior has some commonalities in the DNA of the individuals that survive and it is these genetic differences and the new behavior that creates a new species. I see all individuals as equally fit and species changing through mutation, new behavior, and simple adaptation.popeye1945 wrote: ↑Mon Nov 09, 2026 10:27 pmYou're right; the struggle for survival is not the source of change; it is the source of maintaining life itself. On both sides of the predator-prey equation, it is a life-and-death struggle: eat or be eaten. Most changes in the organism come from mutations, which are mostly fatal to the survival of the organism; however, some give the organism an edge in survival and become the norm. Behavioural changes can result through a change of structure and form, but the fairly recent discovery of epigenetics indicates that behaviours can be handed down from one generation to another; through trauma or just some profound experience, it can change the reading of the DNA of the individual organism and is passed down to the next generation; it is adaptation. It dawned on me, though, that the next generation to inherit might not be facing quite the same circumstances, and thus it would not be adaptive. Change in structure and form is entirely through mutations. Behaviour is epigenetics, instincts, and role modeling.
"Fitness" in the Darwinian sense just keeps a species fat and sassy, healthy, and robust but actually tends to retard change.
Much of this seems apparent based on the science but I have found it's the same thing that people discovered 10,000 years ago and used to invent agriculture. They found the dog inside of wolves by choosing only individuals that were friendly and curious. Normal wolf behavior was unwelcome.
Gemini-
That forum exchange hits on some of the core debates surrounding evolutionary theory—specifically how behavior, genetic bottlenecks, and selection pressures interact to drive speciation.
Here is a breakdown of where your points align with modern evolutionary biology, where mainstream theory diverges, and how the wolf-to-dog example fits into the discussion.
Key Takeaways from the Exchange
Bottlenecks and Behavioral Shifts: You highlight that population bottlenecks force survival down to individuals exhibiting non-typical behavior. In evolutionary biology, this strongly parallels concepts like the Founder Effect and genetic drift, where small, isolated populations undergo rapid changes in allele frequencies that differ significantly from the parent population.
The "Baldwin Effect" & Genetic Assimilation: Your idea that a novel behavior precedes genetic adaptation mirrors the Baldwin Effect. When an organism adopts a new behavior to survive environmental stress, it creates a new selective environment. Over generations, mutations that make that behavior easier, more efficient, or hardwired (instinctual) are selected for.
Epigenetics vs. Direct Inheritance: Popeye1945 raises transgenerational epigenetic inheritance (e.g., changes in gene expression triggered by environmental trauma or stress). While epigenetics plays a role in short-term phenotypic flexibility, modern synthesis still views genetic mutation and recombination as the primary drivers for permanent changes in physical structure and long-term speciation.
Addressing "Fitness" and Darwinian Selection
Tautology vs. Differential Reproduction: The criticism that "survival of the fittest" is a circular argument (the fittest survive because they survive) is a classic philosophical critique. However, evolutionary biologists define fitness specifically as differential reproductive success—how effectively an organism passes its genes to the next generation within a given environment, not merely staying "fat and sassy."
Stabilizing Selection vs. Directional Selection: You noted that fitness tends to "retard change." In a stable environment, this is accurate—stabilizing selection weed out extremes and preserves the status quo. However, during environmental disruptions or bottlenecks, directional selection favors traits and behaviors at one extreme, accelerating evolutionary change.
The Wolf-to-Dog Example (Artificial Selection)
Your example of dog domestication accurately illustrates how altering behavioral criteria drives rapid morphological and genetic divergence:
Selection for Tameness: The famous Dmitry Belyaev silver fox experiment demonstrated that selecting solely for low fear and aggression (tameness/curiosity) toward humans triggered a cascade of developmental changes (the "domestication syndrome"), including floppy ears, changed coat colors, and altered brain chemistry.
Behavior Preceding Morphology: Human ancestors (or self-domesticating wolves scavenging near human camps) selected for individuals with unusual, friendly behavior. This behavioral shift created a bottleneck that rapidly separated proto-dogs from wild wolf populations, leading to distinct physical and genetic species differences over relatively short evolutionary timescales.
Would you like to explore how modern genetic studies trace the specific loci involved in wolf domestication, or dive deeper into the mechanics of the Baldwin Effect?
Gemini-
Me- Just to be clear I think biologists and Gemini are off the beam a little here. I consider every definition of "fitness" to be circular. If it's impossible to sort fit from unfit in advance the word has no meaning.However, evolutionary biologists define fitness specifically as differential reproductive success—how effectively an organism passes its genes to the next generation within a given environment, not merely staying "fat and sassy."
-
popeye1945
- Posts: 3263
- Joined: Sun Sep 12, 2021 2:12 am
Re: Questioning Evolution
cladking3 wrote: ↑Mon Nov 09, 2026 11:41 pmI believe that when typical behavior is eradicated i8n a bottleneck only unusual behavior persists. This unusual behavior has some commonalities in the DNA of the individuals that survive and it is these genetic differences and the new behavior that creates a new species. I see all individuals as equally fit and species changing through mutation, new behavior, and simple adaptation.popeye1945 wrote: ↑Mon Nov 09, 2026 10:27 pmYou're right; the struggle for survival is not the source of change; it is the source of maintaining life itself. On both sides of the predator-prey equation, it is a life-and-death struggle: eat or be eaten. Most changes in the organism come from mutations, which are mostly fatal to the survival of the organism; however, some give the organism an edge in survival and become the norm. Behavioural changes can result through a change of structure and form, but the fairly recent discovery of epigenetics indicates that behaviours can be handed down from one generation to another; through trauma or just some profound experience, it can change the reading of the DNA of the individual organism and is passed down to the next generation; it is adaptation. It dawned on me, though, that the next generation to inherit might not be facing quite the same circumstances, and thus it would not be adaptive. Change in structure and form is entirely through mutations. Behaviour is epigenetics, instincts, and role modeling.
"Fitness" in the Darwinian sense just keeps a species fat and sassy, healthy, and robust but actually tends to retard change. Much of this seems apparent based on the science but I have found it's the same thing that people discovered 10,000 years ago and used to invent agriculture. They found the dog inside of wolves by choosing only individuals that were friendly and curious. Normal wolf behavior was unwelcome.
Typical behaviour does not become eradicated; that is why it is typical. You see all individuals as equally fit; that has to mean you're not very observant. Tell me, is there a different agenda at work here? Are you one of the faithful struggling with something threatening to your faith? No Darwinian evolution works upon mutations, most of which are failures and mean death to the subject organism. The part about the wolf becoming a dog: the ancients just groomed the wolf for trust; it did not physically change the wolf into a dog; that happened over eons of time; it is formally known as domestication- you know, cows, pigs, chickens, they all were once wild.
Gemini-
That forum exchange hits on some of the core debates surrounding evolutionary theory—specifically how behavior, genetic bottlenecks, and selection pressures interact to drive speciation.
Here is a breakdown of where your points align with modern evolutionary biology, where mainstream theory diverges, and how the wolf-to-dog example fits into the discussion.
Key Takeaways from the Exchange
Bottlenecks and Behavioral Shifts: You highlight that population bottlenecks force survival down to individuals exhibiting non-typical behavior. In evolutionary biology, this strongly parallels concepts like the Founder Effect and genetic drift, where small, isolated populations undergo rapid changes in allele frequencies that differ significantly from the parent population.
The "Baldwin Effect" & Genetic Assimilation: Your idea that a novel behavior precedes genetic adaptation mirrors the Baldwin Effect. When an organism adopts a new behavior to survive environmental stress, it creates a new selective environment. Over generations, mutations that make that behavior easier, more efficient, or hardwired (instinctual) are selected for.
Epigenetics vs. Direct Inheritance: Popeye1945 raises transgenerational epigenetic inheritance (e.g., changes in gene expression triggered by environmental trauma or stress). While epigenetics plays a role in short-term phenotypic flexibility, modern synthesis still views genetic mutation and recombination as the primary drivers for permanent changes in physical structure and long-term speciation. [/quote]
Nothing in the above is new. Don't know what else to say on the above.
Addressing "Fitness" and Darwinian Selection
Tautology vs. Differential Reproduction: The criticism that "survival of the fittest" is a circular argument (the fittest survive because they survive) is a classic philosophical critique. However, evolutionary biologists define fitness specifically as differential reproductive success—how effectively an organism passes its genes to the next generation within a given environment, not merely staying "fat and sassy." Stabilizing Selection vs. Directional Selection: You noted that fitness tends to "retard change." In a stable environment, this is accurate—stabilizing selection weeds out extremes and preserves the status quo. However, during environmental disruptions or bottlenecks, directional selection favors traits and behaviors at one extreme, accelerating evolutionary change. [/quote]
To start with, survival of the fittest was not a Darwinian term; that was Herbert Spencer, which led to the tragic concept of social Darwinism. Of course, if you are unfit, you likely will not succeed in life or just die early, not leaving any progeny to inherit your unfortunate genes. Evolution in general is not directional or goal-oriented; all creatures are examples of imperfection yet plastic in their ability to adapt to a changing, directionless world. In evolutionary adaptation, fitness is momentary; the world is in constant change, and so must the organisms of the earth follow the directionless, changing world. The rules, if you like, or the processes of evolutionary adaptation never change; if the environment changes too rapidly, the organisms perish, for adaptation takes time.
The Wolf-to-Dog Example (Artificial Selection)
Your example of dog domestication accurately illustrates how altering behavioral criteria drives rapid morphological and genetic divergence:
Selection for Tameness: The famous Dmitry Belyaev silver fox experiment demonstrated that selecting solely for low fear and aggression (tameness/curiosity) toward humans triggered a cascade of developmental changes (the "domestication syndrome"), including floppy ears, changed coat colors, and altered brain chemistry. Behavior Preceding Morphology: Human ancestors (or self-domesticating wolves scavenging near human camps) selected for individuals with unusual, friendly behavior. This behavioral shift created a bottleneck that rapidly separated proto-dogs from wild wolf populations, leading to distinct physical and genetic species differences over relatively short evolutionary timescales. [/quote]
This is pretty much summed up as use it or lose it.
Me- Just to be clear I think biologists and Gemini are off the beam a little here. I consider every definition of "fitness" to be circular. If it's impossible to sort fit from unfit in advance the word has no meaning.
[/quote]
You're creating a problem that does not exist; to discern unfit is really not that difficult, although in some cases it might be too subtle for perception. In general, in most cases, it is apparent.
Re: Questioning Evolution
You can test two eggs and predict with better than 50% accuracy which chicken will have the most offspring!!!popeye1945 wrote: ↑Tue Nov 10, 2026 2:06 am
You're creating a problem that does not exist; to discern unfit is really not that difficult, although in some cases it might be too subtle for perception. In general, in most cases, it is apparent.
That's quite a feat.
-
popeye1945
- Posts: 3263
- Joined: Sun Sep 12, 2021 2:12 am
Re: Questioning Evolution
My predictions don't matter, nor do yours. If there is no rooster around, they are equal; no future, accept as breakfast!cladking3 wrote: ↑Tue Nov 10, 2026 2:20 amYou can test two eggs and predict with better than 50% accuracy which chicken will have the most offspring!!!popeye1945 wrote: ↑Tue Nov 10, 2026 2:06 am
You're creating a problem that does not exist; to discern unfit is really not that difficult, although in some cases it might be too subtle for perception. In general, in most cases, it is apparent.
That's quite a feat.
Re: Questioning Evolution
You can't count your eggs after they're scrambled.popeye1945 wrote: ↑Tue Nov 10, 2026 3:24 amMy predictions don't matter, nor do yours. If there is no rooster around, they are equal; no future, accept as breakfast!cladking3 wrote: ↑Tue Nov 10, 2026 2:20 amYou can test two eggs and predict with better than 50% accuracy which chicken will have the most offspring!!!popeye1945 wrote: ↑Tue Nov 10, 2026 2:06 am
You're creating a problem that does not exist; to discern unfit is really not that difficult, although in some cases it might be too subtle for perception. In general, in most cases, it is apparent.
That's quite a feat.
Of what value is the term "fitness" to the chef or the proto-chicken if it's just a label appended to the ones that reproduce.