MikeNovack wrote: ↑Mon Nov 09, 2026 10:24 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 09, 2026 9:33 pm
A) Then you need to read more Christian apologetics.
A --- No I don't need to read MORE of them.
"Some," then. For if you had read any, you'd not have said what you said.
B) How does departure from realism end up being adaptive or beneficial, when weighted against realism? It seems quite obvious to me that the advantage falls entirely to the realists, at least in the long run. In the short term, a delusion might power a local burst of energy for some sort of short-sighted project, such as propagandizing; but when that burst of energy runs smack into reality...well, the outcome is likely to be anything but beneficial and adaptive.
B --- Your word delusion, not mine. I do not consider religious beliefs delusional.
Use the word you prefer, so long as it's accurate. What would you like? Unreal? Hallucinatory? Made-up? Constructed? Invented? Not actual?
Remember, it is YOU who needs his religion to be TRUE. I only need it to be RIGHT (helping me to be good human, also perhaps as a source of comfort).
Oh. So if it fools you well, then it's working?
...are you thinking of religions as speaking of things in the real world? I don't.
Then you don't understand them the way actually religious people do, I guess.
To me religions might be talking about how we should live in the real world, but are not part of the real/material realm.
"Should"? "Should"? Should by what reckoning?
You see, if you say "should," you're using a moral value term. Thus, you're tacitly employing your own metanarrative, there, and deriving some sense of "shouldness" from it. (You may not know that you are -- many people fail to analyze their own view, and just assume it's "common sense" or "universal truth" of some kind -- but you're employing one, for certain.) And if you do, you need to justify it, if you want anybody to agree with you. If you don't, then I suppose your views are not relevant to anybody but yourself, and you can't be surprised if nobody else takes them seriously. There's no in-common reason why they "should".
And it raises another question: why "should" anybody do something that has no connection to reality?
