MikeNovack wrote: ↑Mon Nov 09, 2026 5:24 am
Are you thinking MOST atheists are "evangelical"?
I'm not guessing what Will is. I'm asking him.
But there is no shortage of "evangelical Atheists." Richard Dawkins, Sam Harris, Daniel Dennett, Christopher Hitchens...such men are their patron saints; and Dawkins alone has sold 3.3 million copies of "The God Delusion" alone, for which there have also been 13 million downloads. It's in 30 languages. So there is somebody, somewhere, who is listening to the evangelism of the Atheists.
But it might not be Will. Maybe Will is just saying, "I don't personally know God, but if you do, that's fine for you." If he answers the question, then we'll know.
You are reasonable when you ask an "evangelical" atheist "show me your evidence". You are not reasonable demanding all atheists do that, those who believe "no gods exist" just like they believe "Atlantis does not exist".
Actually, I am: if the Atheist in question is making a claim that Atheism is more rational, credible and recommendable than alternatives, then that Atheist owes proof. If the Atheist is only saying he doesn't personally know anything about God, but that he's okay with the possibility that God exists, then he's not an Atheist at all: he's an agnostic.
Now I am not an atheist (you know that) but I can tell you that most atheists would consider it waste of time trying to present you with evidence.
Yes, that's very convenient for them, isn't it? They can be critical of religions, and never have to stand behind what they say. They can substitute mockery for argument, and hope that shame will achieve their goal without the expedient of them actually making an argument. So yes, that's a strategy they have reason to love.
Even your wording: "it's a waste of time," models that very thing. If they had a good argument, it surely would not be a "waste of time" to present it.
They only care when you try to ram your religion down their throats
I always find this phrase quite funny. What you really mean is that they care when a person of good faith unsettles their bad conscience. They feel like something is being "rammed down their throat" when nothing is. They're simply being faced with an argument against which they realize they have poor defenses, and don't like the feeling of having to change their minds...so they refuse, and call it "ramming down my throat," as if the speaker is guilty of some sort of physical violence, rather than of having a better argument.
A fair-minded hearer deals with the arguments, and does not attack the speaker. A resistant hearer accuses his interlocutor of foul play, often for no more than being more logical than he's being.