I am not fundamentally interested in IC’s problem. Ultimately I am only interested in my own relation to the question, and principally at an internal level. Altering IC or his structure of belief is beyond anyone’s capabilities.FlashDangerpants wrote: ↑Sun Nov 08, 2026 4:29 pm You got tangled up in the most basic entry-level logical problem of all time. You are 16 pages in and you can't make Can drop his objection to contradictory truths because why should he drop it? Nor can you work out how to just say they aren't contradictory because you are too stupid to reconsider anything. So now you are just whining.
Can't both be right?
- Alexis Jacobi
- Posts: 9244
- Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am
Re: Can't both be right?
- FlashDangerpants
- Posts: 9356
- Joined: Mon Jan 04, 2016 11:54 pm
Re: Can't both be right?
I can't really be taunted by nazis, I don't care what you write about me.Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Sun Nov 08, 2026 4:49 pmWell then, we are in some sense in accord. Allow me to retort…FlashDangerpants wrote: ↑Sun Nov 08, 2026 4:29 pm
You are a nazi, so I don't care about your ethical concerns. You have no idea about the metaphysics of anything, your opinions on philosophy don't matter in the least.
Using a similar formula:
Would uou accept this? Or is there some part I should modify. I am open to your suggestions.You are a perverted queer with an admitted taste for sodomy with boys. Deranged desire skews you at a psychological level and infects the expression of what you define as “philosophy” but has no connection at all with it. It is ALL rehearsals of ugliness due to something deeply unsettled within your own self.
- FlashDangerpants
- Posts: 9356
- Joined: Mon Jan 04, 2016 11:54 pm
Re: Can't both be right?
It's not his problem. He's beating you, easily.Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Sun Nov 08, 2026 4:54 pmI am not fundamentally interested in IC’s problem. Ultimately I am only interested in my own relation to the question, and principally at an internal level. Altering IC or his structure of belief is beyond anyone’s capabilities.FlashDangerpants wrote: ↑Sun Nov 08, 2026 4:29 pm You got tangled up in the most basic entry-level logical problem of all time. You are 16 pages in and you can't make Can drop his objection to contradictory truths because why should he drop it? Nor can you work out how to just say they aren't contradictory because you are too stupid to reconsider anything. So now you are just whining.
-
MikeNovack
- Posts: 1453
- Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm
Re: Can't both be right?
But you miss why. He simply won't recognize that his own beliefs violate the "many and one at the same time". He would explain this as a special case of the truth of his religion that makes the many really one while at the same time rejecting other religions doing the same thing.
His argument would make more sense coming from say a Ba'hai or a Muslim or a Jew (or if Christian, a Unitarian)
Mind, I am not objecting to his "the three are really one", just to his "and my religion s the only one that can have true beliefs like that".
- Alexis Jacobi
- Posts: 9244
- Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am
Re: Can't both be right?
Both you and he sincerely believe that, I am sure. This is why, to my surprise, I see the two of you as having been cut from a related and similar cloth. Like two strangely connected poles.
- Alexis Jacobi
- Posts: 9244
- Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am
Re: Can't both be right?
Nice. Appreciated!FlashDangerpants wrote: ↑Sun Nov 08, 2026 4:55 pm I can't really be taunted by nazis, I don't care what you write about me.
- Alexis Jacobi
- Posts: 9244
- Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am
Re: Can't both be right?
Nah, I think that the Jain didactic anecdote is quite useful, especially to a mature intellect. I may reach out to “God” from my position within this world, and I may indeed report to you something about my experience, what I perceive, what it is like. And there may be similarities if, say, eight different men do this. Or great discrepancies. But none of this is ultimately verifiable in any way that any of us, including IC, can agree on. Duh! It is obvious why this is.FlashDangerpants wrote: ↑Sun Nov 08, 2026 4:37 pm
They don't need to paraconsistency. All they needed to do was form a coherent argument that gods aren't the sort of thing that can be presented in either singular or multiple format (couldn't care less what mystical bullshit formula they use for that, IC isn't going to accept it anyway), and then just ditch the obviously stupid inclusion of atheism. Excluded middle then just goes away, which gets them out of their stupid LNC trap.
The real issue sailed over your head. The issue itself is of zero concern to you. You only drop in for the game and to exteriorize your derangement and intellectual perversions.
- FlashDangerpants
- Posts: 9356
- Joined: Mon Jan 04, 2016 11:54 pm
Re: Can't both be right?
I must have missed the bit where you explained why he needs to conform to that view. All I've seen is you plead for it, but nowhere have you shown it is the right view in such a way that alernative views are mistaken.MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sun Nov 08, 2026 5:20 pmBut you miss why. He simply won't recognize that his own beliefs violate the "many and one at the same time".
Plus, you are trying to sell a fraudulent "many and one AND NONE at the same time" imposter anyway.
Are you attempting some sort of partners in guilt manoeuvre? To argue that Christianity holds this many-to-one position and that if he rejects it for all other religions he must reject it also for his own? If so, you have to make them actually equivalent, and that means you have to get rid of this shit idea of including atheism as well.MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sun Nov 08, 2026 5:20 pm He would explain this as a special case of the truth of his religion that makes the many really one while at the same time rejecting other religions doing the same thing.
There's no way you could write his argument out to move fro that input to such a conclusion. You are misrepresenting him here.MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sun Nov 08, 2026 5:20 pm His argument would make more sense coming from say a Ba'hai or a Muslim or a Jew (or if Christian, a Unitarian)
Mind, I am not objecting to his "the three are really one", just to his "and my religion s the only one that can have true beliefs like that".
His argument has relied on some very simple stuff...
1. There being some underlying fact of the matter (one God, many, one with many aspects for whatever nonsense).
2. The common sense version of what makes a proposition true (a proposition is true if it correctly describes that underlying fact).
3. The basic principle of bivalence which tells us that if X is correctly stated to be true then a statement that X is not true must itself be false.
4. Your own unwise use of the word Contradiction in the OP of this thread.
You are causing your problems and refusing to deal with them. You will lose to him for as lonog as you don't deal with this. The evidence thus far indicates you are unable to turn this ship, and so you are doomed.
- FlashDangerpants
- Posts: 9356
- Joined: Mon Jan 04, 2016 11:54 pm
Re: Can't both be right?
If the blind men are only reporting their own experience, none of them is saying the other blind men are wrong.Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Sun Nov 08, 2026 5:54 pmNah, I think that the Jain didactic anecdote is quite useful, especially to a mature intellect. I may reach out to “God” from my position within this world, and I may indeed report to you something about my experience, what I perceive, what it is like. And there may be similarities if, say, eight different men do this. Or great discrepancies. But none of this is ultimately verifiable in any way that any of us, including IC, can agree on. Duh! It is obvious why this is.FlashDangerpants wrote: ↑Sun Nov 08, 2026 4:37 pm
They don't need to paraconsistency. All they needed to do was form a coherent argument that gods aren't the sort of thing that can be presented in either singular or multiple format (couldn't care less what mystical bullshit formula they use for that, IC isn't going to accept it anyway), and then just ditch the obviously stupid inclusion of atheism. Excluded middle then just goes away, which gets them out of their stupid LNC trap.
The OP says
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Mon Oct 26, 2026 10:40 pm I've seen it expressed here, that if person A has beliefs about the divine, and person B has beliefs about the divine, and these beliefs are mutually contradictory, the following is certain ......... both can be false, one can be false and the other true, but both cannot be true.
This shit is really really simple.
- Alexis Jacobi
- Posts: 9244
- Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am
Re: Can't both be right?
Of course. And within the limiting terms that you establish in a “logic game” I agree. But in my view there is more at stake than in a juvenile philosophical board-game. But you have no interest in that. In your case the game is played by a perverse man with perverse ideas about what philosophy is and what it is not. Is this making any sense?
Your entire purpose here is in no sense directed toward understanding but as you say toward “winning”. My view is that there is something not quite right about you. All that you have written I dismiss. It has no bearing on the questions.
- FlashDangerpants
- Posts: 9356
- Joined: Mon Jan 04, 2016 11:54 pm
Re: Can't both be right?
I've only been telling you why you (plural) are losing to IC. Talking mystical woo with nazis isn't one of my interests.Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Sun Nov 08, 2026 6:15 pmOf course. And within the limiting terms that you establish in a “logic game” I agree. But in my view there is more at stake than in a juvenile philosophical board-game. But you have no interest in that. In your case the game is played by a perverse man with perverse ideas about what philosophy is and what it is not. Is this making any sense?
Your entire purpose here is in no sense directed toward understanding but as you say toward “winning”. My view is that there is something not quite right about you. All that you have written I dismiss. It has no bearing on the questions.
- Alexis Jacobi
- Posts: 9244
- Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am
Re: Can't both be right?
Fine, but it is still Story. And it amounts to one of the Jain men giving a verbal description. In your case, because you are a Bible literalist, every notion you have did not originate in experience, and the realm of spiritual life, and even life within value-sets, is none of your concern. And — wait for it — your position is quite similar to Flash’s, except the terms or the topic of your adamancies are focused in different areas. In the ultimate instance your theology is a game that you play, and that you play to “win”.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sun Nov 08, 2026 4:22 pm It's not so much a "fallen" condition as an evicted one. Human beings are cast out of the divine and imprisoned in the physical world, which is maya...delusory.
All of these systems of perceiving, relating, recording and communicating metaphysical ideas are in essence gnostic. I know that what you mean is Gnostic and you mean it critically and deprecatingly). Because metaphysics deals in invisibilities and what is referenced by Weaver when he speaks of “Our metaphysical dream of the world”.
The blind men in this sense describe their dream. Just as I will tell you what I gnosis by way of my experience spiritually, in life.
The reason I reject your intolerant and theologically imperious position and attitude is because I believe there is a better and more mature attitude to have.
You cannot be moved from your positions. Fine! Still I assure you that even the Christianity that you profess, despite your denials, is blatantly dualistic.
The “created world” is exactly the world you and I an all of us see out the window. It is the way it is, and will continue to be as it is, effectively forever. You require a “phantasy” to support your doctrine and because you are totally invested in that picture, all other pictures (by other blind men) become the topic of unending disputation!
Yes yes, I know. The other blind man tells a similar Story but with notable differences.It foresees a permanent role for the created world, but not as it presently is, but rather in a restored condition.
- Alexis Jacobi
- Posts: 9244
- Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am
Re: Can't both be right?
Then you can well understand why discussing matters of metaphysics with a perverted freako always turns out to be a dead-end.FlashDangerpants wrote: ↑Sun Nov 08, 2026 6:26 pm I've only been telling you why you (plural) are losing to IC. Talking mystical woo with nazis isn't one of my interests.
And just for the record I have not perceived that I have “lost” in any sense. The discussion has helped me clarify things. As always I choose gain, not loss, and benefit not deficit from engaging here.
- Immanuel Can
- Posts: 30600
- Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm
Re: Can't both be right?
Well, Mike thinks it's not.Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Sun Nov 08, 2026 6:37 pmFine, but it is still Story.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sun Nov 08, 2026 4:22 pm It's not so much a "fallen" condition as an evicted one. Human beings are cast out of the divine and imprisoned in the physical world, which is maya...delusory.
And it's at least as good as your Story, I have to say.
The truth is that EVERYBODY has a "Story," a metanarrative, as Lyotard called it. Even Postmodernism is just a metanarrative about how Modernism failed.
But there's this: for sure, some Story is true. There was some way we got where we are; and while there maybe many guesses at it, one or another Story will be the right one.
- Alexis Jacobi
- Posts: 9244
- Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am
Re: Can't both be right?
In case you are in any doubt, any doubt at all, I believe that I do understand what is at stake in the “competition of meta-narratives”.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sun Nov 08, 2026 6:51 pmWell, Mike thinks it's not.Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Sun Nov 08, 2026 6:37 pmFine, but it is still Story.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sun Nov 08, 2026 4:22 pm It's not so much a "fallen" condition as an evicted one. Human beings are cast out of the divine and imprisoned in the physical world, which is maya...delusory.
And it's at least as good as your Story, I have to say.
The truth is that EVERYBODY has a "Story," a metanarrative, as Lyotard called it. Even Postmodernism is just a metanarrative about how Modernism failed.
But there's this: for sure, some Story is true. There was some way we got where we are; and while there maybe many guesses at it, one or another Story will be the right one.
I do not think I have ever put forward the “story” that I came upon in the course of my own, say, investigations. But if you remember the Carlyle quotes about that which a man really believes in his heart about this “mysterious world”.
Generally, in theology, we deal in stories that have come down to us, not those that we actually discovered for ourselves.