AI and this forum

Welcome to the forum

Moderators: AMod, iMod

Gary Childress
Posts: 13620
Joined: Sun Sep 25, 2011 3:08 pm
Location: It's my fault

Re: AI and this forum

Post by Gary Childress »

mickthinks wrote: ↑Wed Aug 12, 2026 4:01 pm
Gary Childress wrote: ↑Tue Aug 11, 2026 2:04 pm
mickthinks wrote: ↑Sun Aug 09, 2026 12:20 pmWhy did you decide to post about yourself, Gary?
Because it's true.
Do you really think it’s okay to ignore the forum categories and post about yourself anywhere you like? Really? That’s an astonishing sense of entitlement, Gary!

You’re an attention whore, Gary. And it’s getting boring.
Fair enough. I won't break the forum rules anymore. I apologize for my carelessness and disorderly conduct.
mickthinks
Posts: 2006
Joined: Thu Oct 18, 2007 1:10 am
Location: Augsburg

Re: AI and this forum

Post by mickthinks »

I won't break the forum rules anymore.

We don’t show consideration for other people because of a rule. We do it because that’s who we want to be.
Gary Childress
Posts: 13620
Joined: Sun Sep 25, 2011 3:08 pm
Location: It's my fault

Re: AI and this forum

Post by Gary Childress »

mickthinks wrote: ↑Thu Aug 13, 2026 10:38 am I won't break the forum rules anymore.

We don’t show consideration for other people because of a rule. We do it because that’s who we want to be.
Are you sure about that? What makes you think, for example, that many Iranians would not jump at the opportunity to put a bullet in me if I traveled to Iran right now, in spite of having rules against murder? Rules make a LOT of difference in human conduct when they are believed to be valid, legitimate, and followed. But when they are exposed as arbitrary, they lose that value, and some will gravitate toward destructiveness when rules are shown to be so.
mickthinks
Posts: 2006
Joined: Thu Oct 18, 2007 1:10 am
Location: Augsburg

Re: AI and this forum

Post by mickthinks »

What are you talking about, Gary?

Do you want to be the kind of guy who has consideration for other people, or don’t you?
User avatar
FlashDangerpants
Posts: 9356
Joined: Mon Jan 04, 2016 11:54 pm

Re: AI and this forum

Post by FlashDangerpants »

Gary Childress wrote: ↑Thu Aug 13, 2026 10:58 am
mickthinks wrote: ↑Thu Aug 13, 2026 10:38 am I won't break the forum rules anymore.

We don’t show consideration for other people because of a rule. We do it because that’s who we want to be.
Are you sure about that? What makes you think, for example, that many Iranians would not jump at the opportunity to put a bullet in me if I traveled to Iran right now, in spite of having rules against murder? Rules make a LOT of difference in human conduct when they are believed to be valid, legitimate, and followed. But when they are exposed as arbitrary, they lose that value, and some will gravitate toward destructiveness when rules are shown to be so.
What you ought to avoid (in my view anyway) is the sort of moral reasoning that Immanuel Can frequently displays - or, quite coincidentally of course, psychopaths - which assumes that the only reason why you would chose to do the right thing is a frightening external force that compels.

Most people, and certainly all of the ones we might consider to actually be good people, are motivated by a preference for the right thing rather than a terror of being caught doing the wrong one.
User avatar
RickLewis
Posts: 751
Joined: Mon Oct 08, 2007 10:07 am
Location: London
Contact:

Re: AI and this forum

Post by RickLewis »

Gary Childress wrote: ↑Fri Aug 07, 2026 12:52 am I use a spell and grammar checker to pick up accidental typos and mistypes before I post them. Is that a bad use of AI? I know what I want to say and can tell if the spell or grammar checker is misreading or making incorrect assumptions. I know how to communicate in English; most of the reason I use the spell and grammar checking is that I'm too lazy to more thoroughly proofread my posts before making them. If I took more time and care in posting, I wouldn't need a spell and grammar checker. And of course, if I took more time to proofread my posts, I wouldn't be able to spew out so many knee-jerk responses to so many posts that others make.

So maybe the lesson I should take away is that I should take more time to proofread and make more thoughtful replies. That never hurts. Most of my prolific posts are overreactions and knee-jerk anyway. I need to slow down. But chatting on a forum is so much fun. It would bog me down immensely to take more time and consideration in each one of my posts. Diligence and care are more annoying than fun.

Basically, everything always boils down to: I suck.
I think we're all wrestling with when/if/how to use AI for writing tasks.

For this forum I don't think it matters hugely but if I think that a posting is entirely AI generated (or a forum member pretending to be human is actually a bot) then I'll hit the delete button. Those threads that start: "I asked ChatGPT about XYZ philosophical problem, and this is the dialogue we had about it" for some reason totally bore me and I can't drag my mind through them. However, so far I haven't been deleting those because I can see that some (human) forum members are utterly thrilled/delighted/amazed to see what AIs can do and I don't want to spoil their harmless fun.

We're currently putting quite a lot of effort into finding the best approach in terms of AI generated submissions to Philosophy Now. Generally, we're against them and our notes for contributors now include this:
9. We do not accept articles written by AI or improved by AI. Philosophy Now is by humans and for humans.
But I think my colleagues and I would all agree that if somebody writes an article and then uses AI purely to improve the spelling and grammar then that shouldn't be a showstopper. Anything more extensive than that in terms of AI revision might introduce the types of characteristic phrasing that make it look like AI writing - and then we reject it on that basis, wrongly assuming the whole article to be AI generated. (Of course, there are still non-AI spellcheckers and to a lesser extent grammar checkers built into apps like Word anyway so those are probably a safer bet.)
Gary Childress
Posts: 13620
Joined: Sun Sep 25, 2011 3:08 pm
Location: It's my fault

Re: AI and this forum

Post by Gary Childress »

RickLewis wrote: ↑Sat Nov 07, 2026 12:41 am
Gary Childress wrote: ↑Fri Aug 07, 2026 12:52 am I use a spell and grammar checker to pick up accidental typos and mistypes before I post them. Is that a bad use of AI? I know what I want to say and can tell if the spell or grammar checker is misreading or making incorrect assumptions. I know how to communicate in English; most of the reason I use the spell and grammar checking is that I'm too lazy to more thoroughly proofread my posts before making them. If I took more time and care in posting, I wouldn't need a spell and grammar checker. And of course, if I took more time to proofread my posts, I wouldn't be able to spew out so many knee-jerk responses to so many posts that others make.

So maybe the lesson I should take away is that I should take more time to proofread and make more thoughtful replies. That never hurts. Most of my prolific posts are overreactions and knee-jerk anyway. I need to slow down. But chatting on a forum is so much fun. It would bog me down immensely to take more time and consideration in each one of my posts. Diligence and care are more annoying than fun.

Basically, everything always boils down to: I suck.
I think we're all wrestling with when/if/how to use AI for writing tasks.

For this forum I don't think it matters hugely but if I think that a posting is entirely AI generated (or a forum member pretending to be human is actually a bot) then I'll hit the delete button. Those threads that start: "I asked ChatGPT about XYZ philosophical problem, and this is the dialogue we had about it" for some reason totally bore me and I can't drag my mind through them. However, so far I haven't been deleting those because I can see that some (human) forum members are utterly thrilled/delighted/amazed to see what AIs can do and I don't want to spoil their harmless fun.

We're currently putting quite a lot of effort into finding the best approach in terms of AI generated submissions to Philosophy Now. Generally, we're against them and our notes for contributors now include this:
9. We do not accept articles written by AI or improved by AI. Philosophy Now is by humans and for humans.
But I think my colleagues and I would all agree that if somebody writes an article and then uses AI purely to improve the spelling and grammar then that shouldn't be a showstopper. Anything more extensive than that in terms of AI revision might introduce the types of characteristic phrasing that make it look like AI writing - and then we reject it on that basis, wrongly assuming the whole article to be AI generated. (Of course, there are still non-AI spellcheckers and to a lesser extent grammar checkers built into apps like Word anyway so those are probably a safer bet.)
OK. So spelling and grammar checking with a machine isn't "AI". I'm fine with that, then. I use AI when someone says something like, "X has never committed a crime in his life" or "Y committed crime Z" just to make fact-checking easier. But I let it be known that I used AI, and other people are free to show me the error if they know what they're talking about. Otherwise, it's difficult to look up the information for myself and read long articles full of fluff that don't get to the point I'm after. Humans produce quantity too, and it's difficult to wade through it all sometimes, especially when titles or headings don't match the evidence or point the writer makes (or tries to make) in their piece.

All told I agree. I would never ask AI to write something for me that I was submitting somewhere. If I can't say it myself, then how am I supposed to know if the AI is saying it right or not?
User avatar
RickLewis
Posts: 751
Joined: Mon Oct 08, 2007 10:07 am
Location: London
Contact:

Re: AI and this forum

Post by RickLewis »

Yes, I agree that AI can also be really useful for fact-checking and for locating relevant material quickly. Of course, then you have to check back with the original sources to make sure they are as quoted and that the AI hasn't just been "hallucinating" or telling you what it thinks you want to hear.I have a friend who uses AI sometimes and always ends his prompts to AI with the words "and don't lie!" He claims that this helps generate more reliable results.
Gary Childress
Posts: 13620
Joined: Sun Sep 25, 2011 3:08 pm
Location: It's my fault

Re: AI and this forum

Post by Gary Childress »

RickLewis wrote: ↑Sat Nov 07, 2026 1:01 am Yes, I agree that AI can also be really useful for fact-checking and for locating relevant material quickly. Of course, then you have to check back with the original sources to make sure they are as quoted and that the AI hasn't just been "hallucinating" or telling you what it thinks you want to hear.I have a friend who uses AI sometimes and always ends his prompts to AI with the words "and don't lie!" He claims that this helps generate more reliable results.
OK. Thanks for the tip. That sounds like it might be helpful. I once asked AI something about what Immanuel Kant believed about something which I've forgotten the particulars of. After it said, "for Kant.... yada yada." I asked it, "Are you sure that is what Kant believed? And it replied, "That's an excellent point, Gary. I cannot be sure of that, and it's difficult to say (or something)."

[facetiousness]Of course, the AI was definitely right when it said, "that's an excellent point, Gary." (Oh no. I've caught Alexis Jacobi disease!) [/facetiousness]
Post Reply