Can't both be right?

Is there a God? If so, what is She like?

Moderators: AMod, iMod

User avatar
FlashDangerpants
Posts: 9356
Joined: Mon Jan 04, 2016 11:54 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by FlashDangerpants »

MikeNovack wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 6:47 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 6:23 pm
I can't imagine why the laws of logic fly out the window when you make the subject "religious". There are still only two states of things: existence, and non-existence. Everything else is merely detail that comes afterward. And all the LONC is dealing with here is the question of the existence or non-existence of the posited entity -- whatever entity you may wish it to be.

So let's go with cats.

1. There is only one cat (here, at this time, "cat" meaning the same kind of entity, in the same way, etc.)
2. There is more than one cat.
3. There are no cats.

Can more than one of these be true?
You tell me, IC. What is your answer if the cat is a child's stuffed toy? (some child's "tigger"). What if the cat is pregnant? Does your answer to that last change if it's a pregnant woman in the room and we are asking, how many people in the room? Especially if it does change, you should begin to see what I am getting at.

I don't accept that we can necessarily divide "the divine" into "gods" << that in seeing that division as real we are already basing things on our religious beliefs >>
What kind of slow learner are you? You posed the explicit question about mutually contradictory truths being simultaneously true - which is impossible by virtue of basic logical rules that you must by now understand no matter how dense you could be. This thing with the cats you are trying to pull is a bait and switch, it removes the contradiction instead of making two contradictory statements both true.

It is time for you to accept that you failed with this whole line of argument. If you want a do-over you need to start again, not bullshit that you secretly were arguing something different all along.
User avatar
FlashDangerpants
Posts: 9356
Joined: Mon Jan 04, 2016 11:54 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by FlashDangerpants »

Gary Childress wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 6:33 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 6:23 pm
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 6:13 pm What I am trying to get across is that when split "divinity" into no god, one god, or many gods we have already become entrapped by the "truths" of some particular religious beliefs.
But the Law of Non-Contradiction has no dependency at all on beliefs. It's always true, regardless of whether it's gods, cats or quantum surveyors one is talking about.

I can't imagine why the laws of logic fly out the window when you make the subject "religious". There are still only two states of things: existence, and non-existence. Everything else is merely detail that comes afterward. And all the LONC is dealing with here is the question of the existence or non-existence of the posited entity -- whatever entity you may wish it to be.

So let's go with cats.

1. There is only one cat (here, at this time, "cat" meaning the same kind of entity, in the same way, etc.)
2. There is more than one cat.
3. There are no cats.

Can more than one of these be true?
Well, at least you're not trying to slip the Bible under the door with the LNC. Because the LNC proves nothing substantial about any of the religions that exist in reality except that perhaps some of them are not true, or else all of them are not true (assuming that logic applies to the unknowable). So for once, I can probably agree with you.
If you me and IC all agree that somebody has made the same amazingly obvious error, it would be quite insane to continue pursuing that amazingly obvious error.

Watch in amazement as the fools keep going anyway. People round here just hate to learn from their failures.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Immanuel Can »

MikeNovack wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 6:47 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 6:23 pm
I can't imagine why the laws of logic fly out the window when you make the subject "religious". There are still only two states of things: existence, and non-existence. Everything else is merely detail that comes afterward. And all the LONC is dealing with here is the question of the existence or non-existence of the posited entity -- whatever entity you may wish it to be.

So let's go with cats.

1. There is only one cat (here, at this time, "cat" meaning the same kind of entity, in the same way, etc.)
2. There is more than one cat.
3. There are no cats.

Can more than one of these be true?
You tell me, IC. What is your answer if the cat is a child's stuffed toy? (some child's "tigger").
I can see you missed an important caveat in the LONC. Aristotle stipulates that the contradiction must be genuine, and not merely apparent, meaning that the words in all premises must refer to the same entity, at the same time, and so on. I already reminded you of that, though, in the brackets after premise 1.

So taking your stuffed tiger case, then "cat" wouldn't mean "cat," but rather "imitation cat." And that would be an error of amphiboly, rather than an error of contradiction. But in both cases, it would still be fallacy. And it wouldn't be a reasonable illustration of the LONC, of course.
What if the cat is pregnant?
Then there is a plurality of cats. Or, if you don't count kittens-in-utero, then, in your view, there's still one cat. But again, you've only shifted the meaning of the word "cat," not presented a falsification of the trilemma. Once you stabilize your own use of the word "cat," so it's consistent, then you get exactly the same trilemma.
I don't accept that we can necessarily divide "the divine" into "gods"

We're just talking about cats right now. So you can relax on that. We can get to it later.
MikeNovack
Posts: 1453
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by MikeNovack »

I will try to give an example which IS of the mutually exclusive sort (and pertaining to religion) where we are NOT engaging our "truths" from any religion.

a) There is no spiritual, holy, sacred existence, only the material realm.
b) There is a spiritual, holy, sacred existence which may be within the material realm but also exists apart from the material realm.
c) There is a spiritual, holy, sacred existence but not separate from the material realm.

I could hold exactly one of these to be true. The partition does not seem to depend on the "truths" of any religions.

Can you see that "no gods", "exactly one god", and "more than one god" does NOT map neatly to the above? Gods are ONE human understanding of the spiritual, holy, sacred. I can't so easily attach TRUTH to any particular human conception of what a god is, when a god is singular or plural, etc.
MikeNovack
Posts: 1453
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by MikeNovack »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 9:21 pm
What if the cat is pregnant?
Then there is a plurality of cats. Or, if you don't count kittens-in-utero, then, in your view, there's still one cat. But again, you've only shifted the meaning of the word "cat," not presented a falsification of the trilemma. Once you stabilize your own use of the word "cat," so it's consistent, then you get exactly the same trilemma.
I don't accept that we can necessarily divide "the divine" into "gods"

We're just talking about cats right now. So you can relax on that. We can get to it later.
But that's exactly what I have been saying. I can stabilize my use of cat, and you can too, but we are not talking about our PERSONAL versions of the trilemma but your insistence that there is a TRUE (absolute version)

Same when it is gods. You may divide up no god, exactly one god, more than one god in one way and I another. There is no TRUE division because that depends on what we consider no god, exactly one god, or many gods. Our divisions do not agree.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Immanuel Can »

MikeNovack wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 9:31 pm There is no TRUE division...
That just means you don't believe in the cat. So you're an "a-catist." That's option 3.

But that's still a different question from "Is the cat there?" Your belief or disbelief will not change the cat's presence or absence.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Immanuel Can »

MikeNovack wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 9:31 pm Same when it is gods. You may divide up no god, exactly one god, more than one god in one way and I another.
And yet, no matter what conception of God you choose, you get the same problem. Let's do it with Vishnu:

1. There is one Vishnu.
2. There are many Vishnus.
3. There is no Vishnu.

Two of the three will be wrong. Or do Thor:

1. There is one Thor.
2. There are many Thors.
3. There is no Thor.

Same situation. Nothing changes, even when you change the version of "god" you prefer.

1. There is only Hashem.
2. There are many Hashems.
3. There is no Hashem.

Same again.

Every time, it's just the same trilemma.
User avatar
FlashDangerpants
Posts: 9356
Joined: Mon Jan 04, 2016 11:54 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by FlashDangerpants »

MikeNovack wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 9:25 pm I will try to give an example which IS of the mutually exclusive sort (and pertaining to religion) where we are NOT engaging our "truths" from any religion.

a) There is no spiritual, holy, sacred existence, only the material realm.
b) There is a spiritual, holy, sacred existence which may be within the material realm but also exists apart from the material realm.
c) There is a spiritual, holy, sacred existence but not separate from the material realm.

I could hold exactly one of these to be true. The partition does not seem to depend on the "truths" of any religions.

Can you see that "no gods", "exactly one god", and "more than one god" does NOT map neatly to the above? Gods are ONE human understanding of the spiritual, holy, sacred. I can't so easily attach TRUTH to any particular human conception of what a god is, when a god is singular or plural, etc.
What horrible theory of truth are you burdening that nonsense with?

The answer is that you are still smuggling. Those are categorically incompatible if taken at face value with a common-sense theory of truth. They are compatible if you sneak some relativist truth theory.

Your explanation begins with a statement that they are "of the mutually exclusive sort" and then ends with a subjectivist spiel that discounts the exclusivity. This entirely undermines the argument.

You keep outsmarting yourself. Simplify this shit, and take it from the top. Do a new version in a new thread where you don't foolishly try to argue that jealously exclusionary truths can live in harmony and share the facts. What you obviously want to argue is that they are NOT contradictory if properly understood. So give up on the failed argument and do a better one.
MikeNovack
Posts: 1453
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by MikeNovack »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 10:10 pm
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 9:31 pm Same when it is gods. You may divide up no god, exactly one god, more than one god in one way and I another.
And yet, no matter what conception of God you choose, you get the same problem. Let's do it with Vishnu:

1. There is one Vishnu.
2. There are many Vishnus.
3. There is no Vishnu.

Two of the three will be wrong.
What a perfect example. And you really don't see the difference between your examples of Vishnu and Thor.

With Thor, a good example for what you want to show.

With Vishnu, a terrible example.
I could say ALL THREE ARE TRUE. If you don't understand why I say that, you haven't really looked at Hinduism, not a serious look. Don't look from the perspective "my religion is true, so this one is false, don't even have to take is seriously. " But looked at from the perspective of its own terms.

HINT: Look up the meaning of the word "avatar" And understand, to the Hindu, the gods are part of "maya"
User avatar
FlashDangerpants
Posts: 9356
Joined: Mon Jan 04, 2016 11:54 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by FlashDangerpants »

MikeNovack wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 10:38 pm With Vishnu, a terrible example.
I could say ALL THREE ARE TRUE. If you don't understand why I say that....
Why you say that doesn't matter to the logic of the thing. That you say it at all tells us that you don't consider the claims contradictory. Thus you fail again.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Immanuel Can »

MikeNovack wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 10:38 pm With Vishnu, a terrible example.
I could say ALL THREE ARE TRUE.
Well, Vishnu is a mythical concept, so you can pretend anything is true of it. But I'm well aware of the "avatars" thing. It also doesn't change the trilemma. It just means that #2 would be right...if you take "avatar" to mean "another god," and #1 would be right, if you don't think "avatars" are distinct entities.

Things that are real, things that actually exist, have qualities, characteristics and identity of their own. You can't just predicate whatever you want to believe about something that has existence and is thus independent of you.

So, for example, if I say that I believe Mike Novak is a five-foot-tall, female, Chinese acrobat, then it will not make you a five-foot-tall, female, Chinese acrobat. It will merely mean that either a) I'm talking about some completely different "Mike Novak," and/or b) that I don't know you at all. Since you are real, and you actually exist, independent of my beliefs, I can either reconcile with the person you actually are, or continue to believe something stupid and false. Those are my options.

Belief does not change existence. If there's a God, then He, too, has a particular identity, nature, characteristics, etc. And I can either respond to that fact, or I can deny it...but if I deny it, it's not that I "know a different God": it's that I don't know God, as He really is, at all.
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 11:09 pm
Well, Vishnu is a mythical concept, so you can pretend anything is true of it.
Yahweh, Old Bean, is similarly a figure of religious mythology.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Immanuel Can »

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 11:57 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 11:09 pm
Well, Vishnu is a mythical concept, so you can pretend anything is true of it.
Yahweh, Old Bean, is similarly a figure of religious mythology.
You can explain that to Him when you see Him, then.
MikeNovack
Posts: 1453
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by MikeNovack »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 11:09 pm

Well, Vishnu is a mythical concept, so you can pretend anything is true of it. But I'm well aware of the "avatars" thing. It also doesn't change the trilemma. It just means that #2 would be right...if you take "avatar" to mean "another god," and #1 would be right, if you don't think "avatars" are distinct entities.


Belief does not change existence. If there's a God, then He, too, has a particular identity, nature, characteristics, etc. And I can either respond to that fact, or I can deny it...but if I deny it, it's not that I "know a different God": it's that I don't know God, as He really is, at all.
Thor is not a god (as you reckon) NOT simply because mythical but because not meeting your qualifications (Thor is not eternal, immortal). THAT is why I included the child's toy cat. You quickly pointed out the problem with that but blind to it being the same as with gods. But when you do that, you lose the ability to think of atheists different from believers in "false gods" (that may lack the qualifications you consider necessary to a god). But don't you see there must be a problem with your way of thinking if you can't separate an atheist from say a follower of Santeria?

The Jain parable of the elephant is not that you don't know the Elephant as the Elephant really is but that being a human, therefore blind, you CANNOT know the Elephant as the Elephant really is.

The question is, do you want to discuss RELIGION (a feature of human societies) or the one true faith of Christianity? Or should I say your delusion of knowing the truth.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Immanuel Can »

MikeNovack wrote: ↑Thu Nov 05, 2026 4:10 pm ...you lose the ability to think of atheists different from believers in "false gods"
The Atheist's god is himself. That's a false god, alright.
Post Reply