What kind of slow learner are you? You posed the explicit question about mutually contradictory truths being simultaneously true - which is impossible by virtue of basic logical rules that you must by now understand no matter how dense you could be. This thing with the cats you are trying to pull is a bait and switch, it removes the contradiction instead of making two contradictory statements both true.MikeNovack wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 6:47 pmYou tell me, IC. What is your answer if the cat is a child's stuffed toy? (some child's "tigger"). What if the cat is pregnant? Does your answer to that last change if it's a pregnant woman in the room and we are asking, how many people in the room? Especially if it does change, you should begin to see what I am getting at.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Wed Nov 04, 2026 6:23 pm
I can't imagine why the laws of logic fly out the window when you make the subject "religious". There are still only two states of things: existence, and non-existence. Everything else is merely detail that comes afterward. And all the LONC is dealing with here is the question of the existence or non-existence of the posited entity -- whatever entity you may wish it to be.
So let's go with cats.
1. There is only one cat (here, at this time, "cat" meaning the same kind of entity, in the same way, etc.)
2. There is more than one cat.
3. There are no cats.
Can more than one of these be true?
I don't accept that we can necessarily divide "the divine" into "gods" << that in seeing that division as real we are already basing things on our religious beliefs >>
It is time for you to accept that you failed with this whole line of argument. If you want a do-over you need to start again, not bullshit that you secretly were arguing something different all along.