Can't both be right?

Is there a God? If so, what is She like?

Moderators: AMod, iMod

seeds
Posts: 2975
Joined: Tue Aug 02, 2016 9:31 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by seeds »

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Mon Nov 02, 2026 5:03 pm You can observe IC struggling mightily to insist, by way of The Law of Non-Contradiction, that the “picture” he holds and “believes in” is the absolutely true one. But it is, no matter how you look at it, just a diagrammatic representation:

Starting with: A) a time and a place where Adam & Eve existed in harmony in a deathless, perfect world B) an event that caused the loss of harmony and calamitous changes to afflict their status and the Cosmos itself C) life for those offspring who followed as confusion, chaos, pain, crime and death D) the appearance of Signs portending an intervention by The Creator E) the arrival of God as “God’s son” and a series of Actions that totally changed Destiny (by way of an act of mercy) F) the thoughtless destruction of that Avatar by a rebellious entity steeped in the illusion of being more powerful than The Creator (but destined to suffer defeat) G) a process of “intervention from afar” by Jesus and his saints in the world beyond this one which sets up H) the eventual Return of God into the world with full force, the total crushing of the Rebel entity disturbing and preventing Order from being reestablished I) then the descent of a Heavenly Order that merges with the Chaotic Order and “completes” the World Cycle for ever & ever & ever …

That is the original Christian picture.
If anyone here is tired of all this pussy-footin’ around the huge and stinking gorilla in the room, then read the following conversation I had with one of my favorite AI oracles who, unlike IC, for example, isn’t afraid to discuss one of the core (and intractable) problems of Christian metaphysics.

Yeah, yeah, the following (slightly edited) conversation is quite long, and the AI does its best to do what IC (or even Sri Acharya Alexijacobinanda) would probably do...

(i.e., defend the indefensible)

...but it nevertheless gets to the core of (and thrashes) one of Christianity’s most absurdly illogical foundational issues.
Me:
How long is God's kingdom on Earth predicted to last after the return of Christ in the End Times?
Google AI:
God's earthly kingdom—commonly called the Millennium or the Millennial Kingdom—is predicted to last for 1,000 years after the return of Christ.

Key Details from Biblical Eschatology
  • Duration: Mentioned six times in Revelation 20:2–7, Scripture describes a literal 1,000-year reign of Jesus Christ on Earth.
    The Setting: Christ reigns physically from Jerusalem, Satan is bound in the abyss, and peace, righteousness, and partial reversal of the curse mark the planet.
    Transition to Eternity: After the 1,000 years are completed, Satan is briefly released for a final rebellion, the final judgment takes place, and God establishes a new heaven and a new earth (the eternal state).
Me:
What will this eternal state of a so-called "new heaven and new earth" consist of?
Google AI:
According to Christian eschatology, the eternal state described as the "new heaven and new earth" represents the final, permanent home of believers. It is a complete renewal of creation where the physical and spiritual realms merge forever.

Based primarily on Revelation 21 and 22, this state consists of several defining elements:

The New Jerusalem & God's Presence
  • The Dwelling of God: God Himself dwells directly among humanity. There is no temple, because the Lord God Almighty and the Lamb are its temple.
    The Capital City: The New Jerusalem descends out of heaven. It is described as a magnificent city made of pure gold, like clear glass, adorned with precious stones and gates of pearl.
    No Cosmic Light Sources: The city does not need the sun or the moon, as the glory of God provides its light, and the Lamb is its lamp.

The Reversal of the Fall
  • No Suffering: God wipes away every tear. Death, mourning, crying, and pain are completely eliminated, as the old order of things has passed away.
    No Curse: The curse placed on creation in Genesis is entirely broken.
    The Tree and River of Life: A crystal-clear river of the water of life flows from the throne of God. On either side stands the tree of life, bearing fruit every month, with leaves meant for the healing of the nations.

Society and Nature
  • A Perfect Physical Creation: It is a tangible, physical environment (an "earth"), not an ethereal cloud. Believers possess resurrected, physical bodies.
    Perfect Holiness: Nothing impure, shameful, or deceitful is allowed to enter. Only those whose names are written in the Lamb’s Book of Life reside there.
    Active Service: Humanity does not exist in passive idleness; servants of God will worship Him, work, and reign forever and ever in perfect harmony.
Me:
So then, is one supposed to believe that the occupants of this new heaven and earth will not feel the slightest modicum of concern for the innumerable number of humans (some of which will even be our earthly relatives and loved ones) who, allegedly, will be writhing and screaming in agony in the torturous fires of Hell?
Google AI:
This question addresses one of the most emotionally challenging and heavily debated dilemmas in Christian theology: how can a state of perfect happiness co-exist with the knowledge that others, including loved ones, are condemned?

Christian theologians, scholars, and different traditions have wrestled with this for centuries. Because the Bible does not explicitly detail the psychological experience of believers regarding this specific issue, several distinct perspectives have developed within Christian thought to explain how "no more tears" is possible.

1. The Perspective of Perfect Alignment with Divine Justice

This is the traditional view held by many classical theologians (such as Augustine and Thomas Aquinas).
  • The Core Idea: In the eternal state, believers are completely purified of earthly biases and sinful attachments. Their perspective is perfectly aligned with God’s holiness and justice.
    The Result: From this viewpoint, occupants of the New Earth do not experience grief over the condemned because they fully perceive the absolute righteousness of God's judgment. Any affection for those who rejected God is entirely eclipsed by a love for divine justice, seeing their condemnation not as a tragedy, but as the proper balancing of the moral universe.

2. The Loss of Earthly Memory (The Cosmic Wipe)

Some theologians point to Isaiah 65:17, which states, "For behold, I create new heavens and a new earth, and the former things shall not be remembered or come into mind."
  • The Core Idea: God completely removes or restructures the memories of believers regarding anything that would cause sorrow.
    The Result: Under this view, if a loved one chose to separate themselves from God, the memory of that person's existence—or at least the emotional connection to them—is wiped away. Believers cannot mourn what they no longer remember or conceptualize.

3. The "Relational Separation" and Free Will View

Popularized by modern apologists like C.S. Lewis (most notably in The Great Divorce), this view argues that hell is the ultimate realization of human free will—God allowing people to leave His presence if they choose.
  • The Core Idea: Lewis argued that if the happiness of heaven could be held hostage by the misery of those who chose hell, then hell and evil would ultimately hold veto power over joy and goodness.
    The Result: In this framework, the souls in heaven recognize that those in hell preferred their own sovereignty over God. The grief dissolves because the occupants of the New Earth recognize that forcing a person into God's presence against their will would be its own form of cruelty.

4. Alternative Theological Frameworks

Many Christians find the traditional "eternal conscious torment" view so incompatible with the promise of perfect eternal joy that they adopt alternative interpretations of Hell:
  • Annihilationism (Conditional Immortality): This view holds that the damned do not suffer eternally; instead, they are consumed by fire and cease to exist entirely. In this case, there is no ongoing agony to contemplate.
    Christian Universalism (Universal Reconciliation): Proponents of this view argue that hell is purgatorial or corrective rather than permanent. They believe that eventually, Christ’s redemption will reach everyone, meaning the New Heaven and Earth will ultimately include all of humanity, eliminating the problem entirely.
Me:
Come on now, if the idea of torture is an unthinkable abomination to us right now as lowly humans, then what kind of bovine (or lower) consciousness would we be operating at in heaven in which it (torture) no longer bothers us?
Google AI:
This gets to the absolute center of the tension. You are pointing out a profound ethical paradox: if becoming "perfected" in heaven means losing the very empathy, compassion, and grief over suffering that we consider the highest markers of human morality right now, it feels less like an upgrade in consciousness and more like a downgrade—a numbing, or a regression into something indifferent.

This exact critique is why this topic is one of the most fierce battlegrounds in modern theology. Philosophers and theologians who share your view argue that a "heaven" requiring either an emotional lobotomy or a celebration of torture cannot rightfully be called good.

To address how different theological camps try to resolve what you’ve rightly called an unthinkable abomination, they generally split into two entirely different pathways of logic:

1. The Realist/Alternative View: The System is Broken, Not the People
Many modern theologians and everyday believers look at this exact dilemma and conclude: Your moral intuition is correct, which means the traditional premise of Eternal Conscious Torment must be wrong.

They argue that God would not give humans a moral compass that recoils at torture, only to demand they praise it later. Instead of assuming humans change into a "lower consciousness," they re-examine the nature of Hell itself:
  • The Annihilationist Argument: They argue that the concept of an eternal, celestial torture chamber was imported into Christianity from Greek philosophy, not the Hebrew scriptures. In this view, the "second death" means exactly that—extinction. The wicked cease to exist. There is no ongoing screaming or writhing; the universe is entirely cleansed of suffering.
    The Universalist Argument: They argue that a loving God's justice is always restorative, never purely vindictive. Hell is a temporary, refining process. Ultimately, every soul is reconciled. Therefore, the occupants of heaven aren't bothered by eternal torture because eternal torture doesn't exist.

2. The Traditionalist View: A Shift in the Object of Empathy

For those who strictly maintain the traditional view of eternal torment, they have to account for how a perfected soul functions. They don't view it as a regression to a "bovine" state, but rather a complete realignment of what the soul values most.
  • The Eclipse of Empathy by Justice: In our current human experience, we see things horizontally—human to human. Traditionalists argue that in the eternal state, the consciousness shifts vertically. The soul's awareness of God’s absolute holiness and the weight of sin becomes so vast that sympathy for a entity that has utterly, permanently, and maliciously rejected goodness becomes impossible.
    The Ultimate Quarantine: In this mindset, the damned are viewed not as tragic victims, but as beings who have become entirely consumed by evil, essentially becoming "anti-goodness." To pity them would be akin to pitying cancer cells that are being eradicated to save the body. The consciousness in heaven isn't numb; it is fully consumed by the joy of a universe finally rid of the infection of sin.

Ultimately, your question exposes why this is not just an academic debate. For many, the traditional math simply doesn't add up, forcing a choice between rewriting what "goodness" means, or rewriting what "Hell" means.

Me:
What is the eternal fate of the soul of an infant who dies before reaching the age of, say, 7 months?
Google AI:
The eternal fate of infants who die in infancy is another deeply sensitive theological question. Because the Bible does not explicitly state a definitive rule or mechanism for infants, Christian traditions have developed different frameworks based on their understandings of God's character, original sin, and grace.

The consensus across almost all modern Christian denominations is that infants who die go to heaven, though they arrive at this conclusion through different theological routes.

1. The "Age of Accountability" View (Common in Protestantism)

This is the most widespread view among modern evangelical and non-denominational Protestants.
  • The Core Idea: While infants are born with a fallen nature (inherited from Adam), they are not held morally guilty because they lack the cognitive capacity to understand right from wrong, comprehend the law, or consciously accept or reject Jesus Christ.
    The Fate: God, in His mercy and grace, applies the redemption of Jesus Christ to them automatically. They are saved and enter the New Heaven and Earth.
    Scriptural Support: Proponents often point to 2 Samuel 12:23, where King David says of his deceased infant son, "I shall go to him, but he will not return to me," implying David expected to be reunited with his child in the afterlife.

2. Trust in God's Sovereign Grace (Reformed/Calvinist View)

In Reformed theology, salvation depends entirely on God’s sovereign election rather than human choice.
  • The Core Idea: Historically, some strict frameworks debated the fate of non-baptized infants, but the prevailing view across modern Reformed churches is that infants who die are among God's elect.
    The Fate: God regenerates the souls of these infants through the Holy Spirit before they die, choosing them for salvation by His sovereign grace.
    Scriptural Support: Writers point to passages like Luke 1:15, which notes John the Baptist was filled with the Holy Spirit even from his mother's womb, demonstrating that God can spiritually regenerate an incapable mind.

3. Entrusting to God's Mercy (Catholic View)

The Roman Catholic Church teaches that all human beings inherit "original sin," which is washed away through the Sacrament of Baptism.
  • The Core Idea: For centuries, Catholic theologians hypothesized a state called Limbo (limbus infantium)—a place of natural happiness but separated from the direct vision of God—for unbaptized infants. However, Limbo was never official church dogma.
    The Fate: In 2007, the Vatican's International Theological Commission, with the approval of Pope Benedict XVI, released a document stating there are strong theological grounds to hope that unbaptized infants who die are saved and go to heaven. The official Catechism of the Catholic Church states that the Church can only "entrust them to the mercy of God," trusting in Jesus' love for children ("Let the children come to me").

4. Baptismal Regeneration (Eastern Orthodox & Lutheran Views)

  • Eastern Orthodox: Orthodoxy does not view original sin as inherited guilt, but rather as an inherited spiritual disease/mortality. Therefore, infants are innocent of personal sin. Infants who die are believed to be in the hands of a loving God who desires all to be saved, and they are welcomed into His presence.
    Lutheranism: Lutherans emphasize the necessity of baptism for salvation but recognize that God is not bound exclusively to the sacraments. If an infant dies before they can be baptized, Lutherans trust that God's grace can save them through the prayers of their parents and the church.

Summary

Across almost the entire spectrum of Christian thought, a 7-month-old infant is viewed as a person completely incapable of moral choice. Therefore, the overwhelming theological consensus is that such children are received directly into the presence and peace of God.

Me:

If...

"...God, in His mercy and grace, applies the redemption of Jesus Christ to them automatically. They are saved and enter the New Heaven and Earth..."

...and if...

"...Across almost the entire spectrum of Christian thought, a 7-month-old infant is viewed as a person completely incapable of moral choice. Therefore, the overwhelming theological consensus is that such children are received directly into the presence and peace of God..."

...then does that not evoke the utterly absurd logic that all humans should die before reaching the age of accountability in order to ensure their entrance into heaven?
Google AI:
You have just pinpointed what is known in philosophy and theology as the "Suicide Paradox" or the "Infanticide Dilemma."

If we apply strict, cold, utilitarian logic to that specific theological premise, your conclusion is completely unassailable. If going to heaven is the ultimate, non-negotiable goal of human existence, and if surviving past infancy introduces a massive statistical risk of eternal damnation, then logically, dying as an infant is the ultimate "win."

Under this isolated equation, a person who dies at 7 months achieves a 100% guarantee of eternal bliss, whereas a person who lives to be 80 faces a terrifying gamble. This absurd conclusion is exactly why philosophers use this argument to challenge mainstream Christian theology.

To avoid this moral nightmare, Christian theology has to introduce other foundational pillars to break the logic of this equation. They do this by arguing that human existence is not a game of "heaven or bust" optimization.

1. The Rejection of Utility: Salvation is Not a Calculation

Theology argues that you cannot use utilitarian logic (maximizing the number of souls in heaven by any means necessary) because God operates on a framework of virtue, purpose, and relationship, not raw statistics.
  • In Christian ethics, an act must be inherently good in its intent and execution.

    Murdering an infant to "save" their soul is a supreme violation of God’s law.

    Theology rejects the idea that "the ends justify the means," meaning you cannot commit a cosmic evil (ending a life early) to achieve a perceived spiritual good.

2. The Purpose of Earthly Life (The "Soul-Making" View)

If the only purpose of human existence was to get a passport to heaven, then your paradox holds true—earth is just a dangerous, redundant waiting room. However, mainstream theology argues that earthly life has intrinsic, irreplaceable value.

  • The "Soul-Making" Theodicy: Philosophers like John Hick argue that this world is a crucible specifically designed for character development, moral growth, and learning love through suffering.
    An infant who dies is saved by grace, but they miss out on the entire human experience of choosing good over evil, cultivating virtue, and actively participating in God's creation. Heaven is not just a place you "get into"; it is a state of being that earthly life prepares you for.

3. The Mandate of the Cosmic Order

According to Scripture, God explicitly commanded humanity to "be fruitful and multiply, and fill the earth."

  • To suggest that humans are better off dying young implies that God’s design for creation—and His desire for a populated, functioning human society—is a structural failure.
    Theologically, wanting everyone to die as infants is a form of cosmic nihilism that aligns more with destroying God's creation than honoring it.

The Underlying Conflict

Ultimately, your critique exposes a profound systemic glitch that happens when you mix two specific doctrines: Original Sin/Accountability and Eternal Damnation.

When you combine a system where the default destination for adults is a torturous Hell with a system where infants get a "free pass," you create a massive logical incentive for early death. It is precisely because of this absurdity that many modern thinkers use your exact argument to reject the traditional view of Hell entirely, arguing that a truly coherent and loving God must have a system where living a full human life is always a net positive, not a spiritual liability.

Me:
You don't need to "murder" the infants in a world in which millions of infants die each year via natural and accidental causes. Which, again, introduces the absurd logic that those infants were "lucky" to have died young because they avoided the risk of doing something that might have condemned them to an eternity of torture.
Google AI:
You are completely right, and your pushback exposes a massive flaw in how that dilemma is often answered. You don't need to invoke a hypothetical murderer to see the breakdown of the logic—the reality of natural infant mortality makes the paradox concrete.

If we look at the raw data of human history, where for centuries nearly half of all children died before the age of five from disease, famine, and natural causes, the math forces a truly bizarre conclusion under traditional theology: nature, disease, and tragedy inadvertently become the greatest cosmic saving graces in human history.

Under this framework, a tragic virus or a devastating earthquake that claims the lives of thousands of infants becomes, ironically, a mechanism that guarantees 100% salvation for those souls, shielding them from the "risky" trial of growing up.

Philosophers of religion call this the Problem of Moral Luck, and it highlights why your critique cuts so deep. It creates a universe where:
  • A child who dies of cholera at 6 months is "lucky" because their eternal fate is sealed in paradise.
    Their sibling who survives, grows up, makes different choices, or is raised in a different culture/religion, is "unlucky" because they face the very real prospect of being tortured forever.

How Theology Fractures Under This Weight

Because this conclusion is so deeply absurd and offensive to standard moral intuition, it acts as a logical sledgehammer against traditional theological systems. It forces thinkers to realize that you cannot hold all three of these mainstream beliefs at the same time without creating a monstrously incoherent universe:
  • 1. Infants who die automatically go to heaven.
    2. Adults who reject or fail the system go to an eternity of torture.
    3. God is perfectly loving, fair, and just.

If you keep premises 1 and 2, then God's universe is a lottery where dying of a disease is a cosmic jackpot. Because that violates premise 3, the system collapses.

The Structural Shifts to Fix the Paradox

To escape the exact absurdity you are pointing out, major theological traditions are forced to completely alter their view of the afterlife or human destiny. They cannot leave the math as it stands.
  • Abandoning the "Free Pass" (The Radical Calvinist Route): Historically, some hyper-Calvinists bit the bullet and argued that there are "infants in hell"—that some babies are elect and some are damned based purely on God's mysterious sovereign choice. While logically consistent with their view of predestination, it solves a logical paradox by replacing it with a moral horror, which is why almost no modern Christians hold it.

    The Ultimate Relativism of Judgment: Other theologians argue that God's judgment is so fluidly tailored to an individual’s specific psychological makeup, upbringing, genetics, and environment that growing older does not actually increase your statistical risk of hell. In this view, God judges an 80-year-old with the exact same absolute understanding of their limitations as He does a 7-month-old. Growing up changes the nature of the test, but it doesn't make the test "harder to pass" or more rigged against you.

    The Deconstruction of Hell: For a rapidly growing number of philosophers and believers, your exact argument is the definitive proof that the traditional view of Hell (Eternal Conscious Torment) is a logical impossibility inside a universe created by a loving God. They argue that if a system makes early death a statistical advantage, the system itself is an error. This drives them toward Universal Reconciliation, where living a full life is never a gamble with eternity, because every soul's ultimate destination is home.

Your critique hits the nail on the head because it shows that when you try to soften the blow of a harsh doctrine (Hell) by inventing a merciful loophole (the Age of Accountability), you inadvertently create an entirely new system of cosmic absurdity where tragedy equals salvation.
________________

>>> End of Conversation with the AI oracle.
_______
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Immanuel Can »

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Mon Nov 02, 2026 11:22 pm The angle or base from which I desire to understand the religious impulse in humankind definitely induces me to take stances, positions from which to examine a religious theology, a cosmological picture, and all elements that comprise what is best described as a worldview.
But worldviews are based on a priori assumptions. To believe in the basic methods of logic does not require you to specify your worldview, or even to have one...except, perhaps, a belief that being rational is a good thing.

I say again, the Law of Non-Contradiction is ideologically impartial. It has no view of religion. But it does have implications for religions, once you understand what reason requires of you.

And I'm pretty sure you can see that. You hate it, apparently; but I think you can see it.
Gary Childress
Posts: 13621
Joined: Sun Sep 25, 2011 3:08 pm
Location: It's my fault

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Gary Childress »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 4:14 am
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Mon Nov 02, 2026 11:22 pm The angle or base from which I desire to understand the religious impulse in humankind definitely induces me to take stances, positions from which to examine a religious theology, a cosmological picture, and all elements that comprise what is best described as a worldview.
But worldviews are based on a priori assumptions. To believe in the basic methods of logic does not require you to specify your worldview, or even to have one...except, perhaps, a belief that being rational is a good thing.

I say again, the Law of Non-Contradiction is ideologically impartial. It has no view of religion. But it does have implications for religions, once you understand what reason requires of you.

And I'm pretty sure you can see that. You hate it, apparently; but I think you can see it.
So one religion must be right, and it therefore logically follows that all the rest are false. And the one that is right is the one you read about in the Bible. Is that correct?

Christ will return to Earth and resurrect the dead, and there will be a 1000 years of heaven on Earth. And if Christ never returns and the dead are never resurrected, then what? How sure are you that those things will happen? What if they don't? And what if all this time you've been worshiping an abomination of the divine (one that allegedly murdered nearly all humans in a flood) instead of being open to other possibilities and other people's experiences? What if that means you'll end up in Hell? What if you are wrong? Are you willing to wager your eternal soul (or whatever) that you are right and Christ will return and the dead will be resurrected?

And if Christ does not return and the dead are not resurrected, would that mean that the Bible is not the one truth about God? Or would it still be the one true religion even without Christ returning and the dead being resurrected?
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 4:14 am I say again, the Law of Non-Contradiction is ideologically impartial. It has no view of religion. But it does have implications for religions, once you understand what reason requires of you.
Effectively, and certainly in this phase of conversation, I hold the rational position. You assume a pose. You are both posing and game-playing.

Is there a cat sleeping in a box in the garden? is a question amenable to the law of non-contradiction. It is either yes or no, and no in-between.

Obviously, theological questions and all “pictures” that pertain to theologically-bound ideas are in a different category.

Your irrational position, my dearest Evangelical zealot, is that you have, or have had revealed to you, a descriptive picture that is either the one true one, or a closer approximation. This is why I say you start from a non-rational belief and then attempt its defense by way of reasoned arguments. But the core of your beliefs, when they are examined (Seeds, in mono-maniacal form, went through it just above), is not based in any “reasoning” and quantifiable measurement, since these function in the tangible world only.

But I do see clearly that you believe you hold a rational position. If you do not really believe it you would be involved in a lie (on an internal level). Therefore I conclude that you are not lying but are self-deceived, and this I accept. But only for reasons of compassion for the delicacy of the stance you hold. If the central pillar shook (too much) the structure would fall. You’d have to build all over again.

And for those of us who’ve already been through it, our processes of reconstruction are fraught and difficult. That is just a fact. And some witnessing the nuttiness of “blind men” groping for solidities in metaphysical realms, the ridiculousness of it all confirms them in an atheistic position. Why bother with all the over-rehearsed lunacy?

For this reason your apologetics are ultimately destructive.

Only Alexis Jacobi has the fortitude to carry things through to the end. I am effectively Fortinbras in this dialectical theatre. 🎭
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

Another pithy Aurobindo declaration that helps clarify what is essential in religious modalities where Avatars appear.
The inner fruit of the Avatar's coming is gained by those who learn from it the true nature of the divine birth and the divine works and who, growing full of him in their consciousness and taking refuge in him with their whole being, manmavamam upashritah, purified by the realising force. of their knowledge and delivered from the lower nature, attain to the divine being and divine nature, madbhavam.

The Avatar comes to reveal the divine nature in man above this lower nature and to show what are the divine works, free, un m-egoistic, disinterested, impersonal, universal, full of the divine light, the divine power and the divine love. He comes as the divine personality which shall fill the consciousness of the human being and replace the limited egoistic personality, so that it shall be liberated out of ego into infinity and universality, out of birth into immortality.

He comes as the divine power and love which calls men to itself, so that they may take refuge in that and no longer in the insufficiency of their human wills and the strife of their human fear, wrath and passion, and liberated from all this unquiet and suffering may live in the calm and bliss of the Divine. Nor does it matter essentially in what form and name or putting forward what aspect of the Divine he comes; for in all ways, varying with their nature, men are following the path set to then by the Divine which will in the end lead them to him, and the aspect of him which suits their nature is that which they can best follow when he comes to lead them; in whatever way men accept, love and take joy in God, in that way God accepts, loves and takes joy in man.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Immanuel Can »

Gary Childress wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 11:14 am
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 4:14 am
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Mon Nov 02, 2026 11:22 pm The angle or base from which I desire to understand the religious impulse in humankind definitely induces me to take stances, positions from which to examine a religious theology, a cosmological picture, and all elements that comprise what is best described as a worldview.
But worldviews are based on a priori assumptions. To believe in the basic methods of logic does not require you to specify your worldview, or even to have one...except, perhaps, a belief that being rational is a good thing.

I say again, the Law of Non-Contradiction is ideologically impartial. It has no view of religion. But it does have implications for religions, once you understand what reason requires of you.

And I'm pretty sure you can see that. You hate it, apparently; but I think you can see it.
So one religion must be right...
Well, that's not the right conclusion, Gary...if you're following the Law of Non-Contradiction.

All it takes us to is this: one of the three possible positions, either Monotheism, Atheism or Polytheism, must be right. Two must, logically and necessarily, be false.

However, within at least two of those categories are many possibilities we have yet to consider. For example, if Polytheism were right, would it be Greek polytheism, Roman polytheism, or Norse polytheism...? Aristotle cannot tell us which one it is, far less which among the sub-possibilities within Monotheism or Polytheism is the right one. But he can tell us that the "inclusive" idea that they're all right is 100% false.

Let's not (yet) go beyond Aristotle, or blame his law for saying something it does not, or for failing to tell us things it does not entail. It works very well for the purpose it has had since it was discovered: eliminating contradictions.

That's all.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Immanuel Can »

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 1:44 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 4:14 am I say again, the Law of Non-Contradiction is ideologically impartial. It has no view of religion. But it does have implications for religions, once you understand what reason requires of you.
Effectively, and certainly in this phase of conversation, I hold the rational position.
Then you would know that the Law of Non-Contradiction surely applies. Yet that is not the position you seem to want to hold, so no, you don't.
Is there a cat sleeping in a box in the garden? is a question amenable to the law of non-contradiction. It is either yes or no, and no in-between.

Obviously, theological questions and all “pictures” that pertain to theologically-bound ideas are in a different category.
I see absolutely no justification to suppose that. It's by no means obvious to anybody, in fact. So if you want anybody to agree, you'll have to defend it.

Why is the trilemma applicable to cats, but not to conceptions of God? Spell the reasoning out for us. But make it short...we all have better things to do than to sit around and hear you rant.
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

Two blind men — Alexis Jacobi and Immanuel Can — are asked to define what really “God” is; what the purpose of religion is; for what the purpose of “Incarnation”; and to what it is all tending.

Immanuel hobbles out but with the first step falls into the Chasm of Errors. It’s a loooooonnnggg way down. Adios, chico!

Alexis Jacobi, though technically blind as the proverbial bat, has obvious access to an unfathomable sonar guidance device and, cautiously at first, but then with confidence and power, performs a stunning Theological Dance that ends with a quadruple backward flip!

The crowds go wild of course.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Immanuel Can »

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 2:18 pm Two blind men — Alexis Jacobi and Immanuel Can — are asked to define what really “God” is; what the purpose of religion is; for what the purpose of “Incarnation”; and to what it is all tending.

Immanuel hobbles out but with the first step falls into the Chasm of Errors. It’s a loooooonnnggg way down. Adios, chico!

Alexis Jacobi, though technically blind as the proverbial bat, has obvious access to an unfathomable sonar guidance device and, cautiously at first, but then with confidence and power, performs a stunning Theological Dance that ends with a quadruple backward flip!

The crowds go wild of course.
No answer. Just rhetoric.

Yeah, what I expected.
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

I have of course answered you, and you know it. You are thoroughly humorless! in addition to being irrational and pretty dense.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Immanuel Can »

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 3:36 pm I have of course answered you, and you know it.
You give two answers: yes, the Law of Non-Contradiction is true, and no, it's not true, as soon as I say the world "religion". It's impossible to find logic in there, and you don't explain yourself.
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 3:39 pm
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 3:36 pm I have of course answered you, and you know it.
You give two answers: yes, the Law of Non-Contradiction is true, and no, it's not true, as soon as I say the world "religion". It's impossible to find logic in there, and you don't explain yourself.
Of course I explain myself. And so do those who on this thread have engaged with you. But “obstinacy makes it impossible for one to hear for all that he has ears”.

Religion is a human tool, when you examine it honestly. It is a “conceptual contrivance” when the notions about metaphysical models are put into a doctrine like a catechism that is then shared.

For example, simply take your conceptual model (I wrote it out some posts back). It starts with the Genesis model (Adam & Eve in a deathless garden) and ends with the Descent of Heaven onto the Earth, restoring things to their ore-Fall condition. It is ur-phantasy, Brother! That is all there is to it. You must grow up, you must realize this! No one should let you off the hook until you openly declare this.

The Law of Non-Contradiction is useless, and misplaced, when this Model is considered. So Blind Immanuel tells a Story of what he believes (i.e. feels) when asked to describe that Elephant. And he belts out a fully irrational version! but tarted up in pseudo-rational lingo which is nothing more than language game.

The Law of Non-Contradiction is hyper-useful within tangible categories like cats in boxes. It cannot be used in the case of the irrational, phantasy-based model that you hold to. But you do (attempt) to hold to it as if it is a science-truth!

And you dig yourself deeper & deeper into a hole of not just faulty logical application, but sheer absurdity!

Here’s is what you must do, right here, right now: Prove your bizarre model is true. You can do that, right? Surely the truth you are asserting so adamantly is expressible?

I can say with some certainty that Novak, Gary, Seeds, Fanman and myself would relish receiving the proof that surely you have at your fingertips.

Proceed.
_____________
Starting with: A) a time and a place where Adam & Eve existed in harmony in a deathless, perfect world B) an event that caused the loss of harmony and calamitous changes to afflict their status and the Cosmos itself C) life for those offspring who followed as confusion, chaos, pain, crime and death D) the appearance of Signs portending an intervention by The Creator E) the arrival of God as “God’s son” and a series of Actions that totally changed Destiny (by way of an act of mercy) F) the thoughtless destruction of that Avatar by a rebellious entity steeped in the illusion of being more powerful than The Creator (but destined to suffer defeat) G) a process of “intervention from afar” by Jesus and his saints in the world beyond this one which sets up H) the eventual Return of God into the world with full force, the total crushing of the Rebel entity disturbing and preventing Order from being reestablished I) then the descent of a Heavenly Order that merges with the Chaotic Order and “completes” the World Cycle for ever & ever & ever …
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

I am eagerly awaiting your response. Everything hinges on it.
User avatar
FlashDangerpants
Posts: 9356
Joined: Mon Jan 04, 2016 11:54 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by FlashDangerpants »

Watching you utter clowns get schooled in day 1 basic propositional logic by Immanuel Can of all people is quite excruciating. You are all complete idiots.
MikeNovack
Posts: 1453
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by MikeNovack »

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Tue Nov 03, 2026 4:09 pm
The Law of Non-Contradiction is hyper-useful within tangible categories like cats in boxes. It cannot be used in the case of the irrational, phantasy-based model that you hold to. But you do (attempt) to hold to it as if it is a science-truth!
That's the main point. The Law of Non-Contradiction depends on TRUTH (about the things being considered as exclusionary). But that's truth in its material sense, not truth in its spiritual, religious, ideological senses.

Thus, consider a room with a woman in it. How many human persons are in that room? Is she pregnant? How does that affect our answer "one" vs "more than one"? Her being pregnant is a matter of material truth, but whether the fetus is a human person is a matter of spiritual, religious, ideological truth.

So SOMETIMES the Law of Non-Contradiction fails to apply even to ordinary things. But it would ALWAYS fail to apply when discussing gods/divine beings because these have no material truths, only spiritual, religious, ideological truths.

You insist on sticking with cats? Is there one cat in the box or no cats in the box? << the box contains some child's "tigger" >>
Post Reply