Can't both be right?

Is there a God? If so, what is She like?

Moderators: AMod, iMod

User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 02, 2026 3:42 am
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Sun Nov 01, 2026 1:06 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sat Oct 31, 2026 12:26 am Well, as you know, no Christian believes in three gods, so you can put your heart to rest on that one.
Except the Trinity is presented as three 'persons' in one. It is not unlike the ways that Eastern religious philosophy (specifically of India) conceive of an absolute God with different 'aspects' that are given different names and conceived of as acting separately.
It's actually completely unlike that. Trinitarianism is not belief in "avatars" or demi-gods.
[Sanskrit avatāraḥ, descent (of a deity from heaven), avatar : ava, down + tarati, he crosses; see terə- in Indo-European roots.]
The Christian idea of the descent of God’s “son” into the world, and the conceptual order that this entailed, is completely different from the Hebrew conception. The idea extends far beyond what was, and is, conceived of in Judaism. And the idea, or the fact, of the apparition of Jesus is completely in accord with the Vedic conception of an Avatarah.

It is impossible for you to see this, and the reasons you cannot are various and can be explained.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Immanuel Can »

Gary Childress wrote: ↑Mon Nov 02, 2026 11:49 am
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 02, 2026 4:57 am
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Mon Nov 02, 2026 3:53 am

I am not confused about "what logic requires".
Then you understand the Law of Non-Contradiction? And you understand that it means, impartially and absolutely, that only one of the three options can be true?
So let's say the God of the Bible is the one true God. All the rest of the religious sects out there are misled. Now what?
I'm not asking you to say that yet, Gary. I wouldn't ask you to say it, if I didn't also plan eventually to supply reason for it.

All I've asked so far is for people to recognize that the Law of Non-Contradiction discovered by Aristotle (not by me, and not by Theists) applies. And any rational person should certainly agree with that much.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Immanuel Can »

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Mon Nov 02, 2026 4:33 pm The Christian idea..
I'm not talking about any "Christian idea." Aristotle wasn't a Christian, nor does the Law of Non-Contradiction require a person to believe in any religion at all.

I'm just asking you to be rational.
MikeNovack
Posts: 1453
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by MikeNovack »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 02, 2026 4:41 pm
I'm not talking about any "Christian idea." Aristotle wasn't a Christian, nor does the Law of Non-Contradiction require a person to believe in any religion at all.

I'm just asking you to be rational.
Rational --- studying this human thing called religion (which In can do even if myself a believer IF in spite of that I can look honestly)

a) Religions often (usually) have entities/beings called "gods". Gods may have various powers/attributes.

b) But one thing they do not seem to have is "definite number". Thus believers of a religion might tell you "we have one' but you can plainly see them relating to others similar to how people of different religions relate t gods. Or they might refer to some mystery (old meaning of the term) by which the several are really just one.

Thus I consider none and one possible together and one and several possible together. Even none and several.
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

Fanman wrote: ↑Mon Nov 02, 2026 12:48 am Okay, but that is one possible take, and as far as intuition goes, it feels honest. But from a subjective viewpoint, no matter how profound it sounds, we have to compare it with other spiritual and religious constructs. I think the common theme among the constructs is 'higher-order' thinking, conduct, and states. Now, there are different definitions, takes, and narratives about exactly how those combinations exist within each construct. Still, themes across those who experience it (the purportedly divine) include peace, greater understanding, and resonating with love and compassion. So maybe the divine isn't a place, in the sense of a specific spatial location. As you've alluded to, it may be a state of mind, where we experience reality at its most fundamental state: pure, unblemished, light, and just.
My view is that it is always going to be subjective except where groups decide on a theological picture they align with and seems to answer their most profound questions. So, the Bhagavad Gita is a (relatively) late compendium or synthesis of religious thought. Or you could say a refinement of religious and metaphysical ideas. There is a long history in India of the development of conceptual “pictures” of how reality is constructed. I could share a few of the historical pictures (conceptual orders) from ancient India that would illustrate this fact.

You can observe IC struggling mightily to insist, by way of The Law of Non-Contradiction, that the “picture” he holds and “believes in” is the absolutely true one. But it is, no matter how you look at it, just a diagrammatic representation:

Starting with: A) a time and a place where Adam & Eve existed in harmony in a deathless, perfect world B) an event that caused the loss of harmony and calamitous changes to afflict their status and the Cosmos itself C) life for those offspring who followed as confusion, chaos, pain, crime and death D) the appearance of Signs portending an intervention by The Creator E) the arrival of God as “God’s son” and a series of Actions that totally changed Destiny (by way of an act of mercy) F) the thoughtless destruction of that Avatar by a rebellious entity steeped in the illusion of being more powerful than The Creator (but destined to suffer defeat) G) a process of “intervention from afar” by Jesus and his saints in the world beyond this one which sets up H) the eventual Return of God into the world with full force, the total crushing of the Rebel entity disturbing and preventing Order from being reestablished I) then the descent of a Heavenly Order that merges with the Chaotic Order and “completes” the World Cycle for ever & ever & ever …

That is the original Christian picture.
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 02, 2026 4:41 pm I'm just asking you to be rational.
I love it! 💕
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

Gary Childress wrote: ↑Mon Nov 02, 2026 11:49 am So let's say the God of the Bible is the one true God. All the rest of the religious sects out there are misled. Now what? Do we sit here and "pray" while our world is falling apart? Or if there is a God, then what option has God given us to preserve the Earth and the human species from wildfires, flooding, wars, nuclear proliferation, AI running amuck, a super disease from wiping most of us out or a giant asteroid from heading our way? What's the option that will save us from all the potential sources of destruction around us? Obviously, leftists must be "evil," so do we all rally behind the wealthy and the furtherance of profit? To hell with "socialism"? Is it every man, woman, and child for themselves? No government, just 8 billion people, all doing whatever we happen to want to do? Are Elon Musk and Jeff Bezos going to lead us to salvation and safety (since they and the rest of the top .01% seem to be pulling most of the economic strings)?
Our reasoning faculty, in combo with our intuition faculty, impel us to realize that this world, this plane of existence, Nature itself, the Cosmos, is totally unstable.

It does not matter what you do or don’t do in the grandest sense because out there, lurking, or getting closer by the minute, is THAT which corresponds to the Asteroid careening toward Earth and that brings everything to an end.

It’s always there. Always on the horizon. It is built into the way things are.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Immanuel Can »

MikeNovack wrote: ↑Mon Nov 02, 2026 4:56 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 02, 2026 4:41 pm
I'm not talking about any "Christian idea." Aristotle wasn't a Christian, nor does the Law of Non-Contradiction require a person to believe in any religion at all.

I'm just asking you to be rational.
Rational --- studying this human thing called religion (which In can do even if myself a believer IF in spite of that I can look honestly)
Here's the great thing. You don't even have to entangle your brain with legends about "religion." You can forget it completely.

Do the same operation with cats in boxes, as AJ has proposed. Or anything. In ever case you try, you're going to find that in questions of existence, the Law of Non-Contradiction applies. So use apples...use go-carts...use waffles...it will never matter. The same result will always come out of it.

That's the great thing about logic...it plays no favourites and requires no a priori commitments, other than the determination to stay rational with one's own claims. That's it.
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

We can safely realize that just about everything to do with the speculations of religion (even confining oneself to Judaism snd Christianity) deal in non-rational stories & revelations. Take the experiences of the Prophets. Visions and the like. The recordings of miraculous events involve embellishments for didactic and apologetic purposes.

But, thereafter when the Stories become histories, and when the revelations become imperative, well, then the “reasoning mind” necessarily organizes a theology that is then translated into all different adjacent fields of life. This is done very rationally.

What IC is attempting is kind of perverse if you think about it in a certain way. He defends “reasoning” but in defense of beliefs that are not in any sense reasonable but are fantastic in extremes.

This is why I noted long ago that IC presents as a “modern” (trained in Aristotelean methods) who hops over the entire historical structure of the Occident, and imagines himself, as a “rational man”, in Judea in Gospel times wañking with the Apostles.

Religion and Science must necessarily be one. They cannot, they do not, contradict one another. They cannot. This is why the Adam & Eve story can be viewed ‘scientifically’ as a Natural History of an early anthropoid, “the original mating pair”.
…the determination to stay rational with one's own claims.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Immanuel Can »

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Mon Nov 02, 2026 7:14 pm What IC is attempting...
I can smell your desperation. 8)
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

For those interested, Sri Autobindo (1938) holding forth on the Avatar-idea:
To the modern mind Avatarhood is one of the most difficult to accept or to understand of all the ideas that are streaming in from the East upon the rationalised human consciousness. The rationalist objects that if God exists, he is extra-cosmic or supracosmic and does not intervene in the affairs of the world, but allows them to be governed by a fixed machinery of law; he is pure Spirit and cannot put on a body, infinite and cannot be finite as the human being is finite, the ever unborn creator and cannot be the creature born into the world, — these things are impossible even to his absolute omnipotence.

These objections, so formidable at first sight to the reason, seem to have been present to the mind of the Teacher in the Gita when he says that althóugh the Divine is unborn, imperishable in his self-existence, the Lord of all beings, yet he assumes birth by a supreme resort to the action of his Nature and by force of his self-Maya; that he whom the deluded despise because lodged in a human body, is verily in his supreme being the Lord of all; that he is in the action of the divine consciousness the creator of the fourfold Law and the doer of the works of the world and at the same time in the silence of the divine consciousness the impartial witness of the works of his own Nature, — for he is always beyond both the silence and the action, the supreme Purushottama.

And the Gita is able to meet all these oppositions and to reconcile all these contraries because it starts from the Vedantic view of existence, of Goad and the universe. For all here is God, is the Spirit or Self-existence, is Brahman, ekamevadwitiyam, — there is nothing else, nothing other and different from it and there can be nothing else, can be nothing other and different from it. Far from the unborn being unable to assume birth, all beings are even in their individuality unborn spirits, eternal without beginning or end, and in their essential existence and their universality all are the one unborn Spirit of whom birth and death are only a phenomenon of the assumption and change of forms.

The assumption of imperfection by the perfect is the whole mystic phenomenon of the universe; but the imperfection appears in the form and action of the mind or body assumed, subsists in the phenomenon, — in that which assumes it there is no imperfection, even as in the Sun which illumines all there is no defect of light or of vision, but only in the capacities of the individual organ of vision.
_______________

Ekam eva dwitiyam— एकमेवाद्वितीयम्

One alone, without a second.

Not one among many. Not the first one. The only one, so there is nothing else to count it against.

From the Chandogya Upanishad. The Rishis used it for Brahman — that which is, and because of which all seeming appears.

No duality of seer and seen. The camera, the eye behind it, and what it sees — not three.
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 02, 2026 7:31 pm
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Mon Nov 02, 2026 7:14 pm What IC is attempting...
I can smell your desperation. 8)
It’s moving to a nearly unbearable point! Auxilio! Auxilio!

Only the Lord can save me now!
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Immanuel Can »

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Mon Nov 02, 2026 7:47 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 02, 2026 7:31 pm
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Mon Nov 02, 2026 7:14 pm What IC is attempting...
I can smell your desperation. 8)
It’s moving to a nearly unbearable point!
Relativism, inclusivism, universalism...all three are dead...and by the deft hand of Aristotle. Unbearable it is...for all those ideologies.

But you could bear it, if you were willing.
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

A Aristotelian definition of God, Aristotle’s definition of God taken of itself, would not support any part of the mythic picture (of Christianity) I described a few posts up.

And anyway your use the Law of Non-Contradiction is misplaced. I know that you attempt to hold the seat of rational exponent in this thread however I don’t think it is working.
Relativism, inclusivism, universalism
The angle or base from which I desire to understand the religious impulse in humankind definitely induces me to take stances, positions from which to examine a religious theology, a cosmological picture, and all elements that comprise what is best described as a worldview.

That could be taken as “relativism” in the negative, leveling sense that you mean it. But when one reduces a religion to those elements in it that define and defend values, by extracting these one arrives at a better sense of what, really, the religion is about or what it demands. And my position is and always has been that the Christian matrix is unquestionably unique and special.

And yet I very strongly oppose and am appalled by your manner of conduct as an apologist. Religious zealotry is not the proper way of conduct. And neither is a limited absolutism. And certainly an imperious attitude toward the religious view of those in other religious traditions is not a good way to proceed.

But if the conversation is about value-sets, and if there are mature and sincere people with a desire or need to communicate sincerely, then something will come of a critical, comparative conversation.

In the end it all turns on one’s commitments to values. You can call that “inclusivism” or “universalism” if that blows your dress up.
seeds
Posts: 2975
Joined: Tue Aug 02, 2016 9:31 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by seeds »

Gary Childress wrote: ↑Mon Nov 02, 2026 11:49 am So let's say the God of the Bible is the one true God. All the rest of the religious sects out there are misled. Now what?
You chop wood and carry water and hope that you die before reaching the "Age of Accountability" - (see next post).
_______
Post Reply