Can't both be right?

Is there a God? If so, what is She like?

Moderators: AMod, iMod

Post Reply
Dubious
Posts: 4807
Joined: Tue May 19, 2015 7:40 am

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Dubious »

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Sun Nov 01, 2026 12:23 am
Dubious wrote: ↑Sat Oct 31, 2026 11:31 pm Not least, the type of transformation depends on the pattern one integrates with. Most are opposite to transfiguration of any kind being more akin to mutilation in terms of unconditional acceptance.
This reminds me of an anecdote Jung shared. Some of his patients described dreams in which the Church building was imagined and felt as a prison and the dream involved confinement and the need to escape.

But others dreamt of the Church as a refuge, as a place of safety, or perhaps as a hospital.

The symbolism is clear in each case.
It's also possible that one can dream the opposite on different days or even as consecutive dreams. Symbolism may be clear in each case but considerably less clear when they conflict which is not unusual in dreams.
User avatar
Fanman
Posts: 162
Joined: Wed Aug 19, 2026 5:43 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Fanman »

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Sun Nov 01, 2026 12:16 am
Fanman wrote: ↑Sat Oct 31, 2026 11:08 pm From my perspective, while the divine can be considered (or understood) as a personage, it can also be considered a reality.
That description jibes with ideas in Vedanta, at least it appears so to me. The way these things are described is intricate and rather complex. It is (if you’ll permit me to put it like this) a language game, a game of nomenclature, a way of organizing and thinking about what is outside of conceptualization (?)
Brahman is the Absolute.

It is the word in Vedanta for That which is ultimately Real, beyond which nothing is, from which everything comes.
If one is asked to define how such an abstract ‘reality’ could also be personal, other terms are employed: Ishvara.

I guess we make of these things what we can.
I can't really figure out the point that you're driving at. Perhaps you could clarify?
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

Fanman wrote: ↑Sun Nov 01, 2026 9:03 am From my perspective, while the divine can be considered (or understood) as a personage, it can also be considered a reality.
When God is conceived as "reality" (the totality of existence, everything, and the possibility of existence itself) the term "Brahman" is used. It is conceived of as impersonal.

But people have, or feel they have, a personal relationship with God. And that aspect is described as Ishvara.
I can't really figure out the point that you're driving at. Perhaps you could clarify?
If these concepts (these words) interest you, you'd likely get more benefit looking them up. The reason I refer to Vedantic metaphysics (the terms) is because I think it helps shed light on Christian belief. And the position I have is odd in this sense: I defend Christianity even though it has many defects and I feel inclined to go rather hard on IC who embodies those defects.
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sat Oct 31, 2026 12:26 am Well, as you know, no Christian believes in three gods, so you can put your heart to rest on that one.
Except the Trinity is presented as three 'persons' in one. It is not unlike the ways that Eastern religious philosophy (specifically of India) conceive of an absolute God with different 'aspects' that are given different names and conceived of as acting separately.
User avatar
Fanman
Posts: 162
Joined: Wed Aug 19, 2026 5:43 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Fanman »

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Sun Nov 01, 2026 1:02 pm
Fanman wrote: ↑Sun Nov 01, 2026 9:03 am From my perspective, while the divine can be considered (or understood) as a personage, it can also be considered a reality.
When God is conceived as "reality" (the totality of existence, everything, and the possibility of existence itself) the term "Brahman" is used. It is conceived of as impersonal.

But people have, or feel they have, a personal relationship with God. And that aspect is described as Ishvara.
I can't really figure out the point that you're driving at. Perhaps you could clarify?
If these concepts (these words) interest you, you'd likely get more benefit looking them up. The reason I refer to Vedantic metaphysics (the terms) is because I think it helps shed light on Christian belief. And the position I have is odd in this sense: I defend Christianity even though it has many defects and I feel inclined to go rather hard on IC who embodies those defects.
Okay. Research is needed before I get back to you, but I do think we can get somewhere in this discussion.
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

Since the thread began with a Jain ‘didactic anecdote’ and it has been fruitful to examine the philosophy of an alternative school of religious thought — which I hope can shed some clarifying light on our own tradition and more importantly our own quandary as it pertains to these religious/metaphysical issues — I think the quotation below from Sri Aurobindo’s commentary on the Bhagavad Gita will be helpful.

Obviously, my own notion that we are trapped within determined and determining Nature (Prakriti) comes from Vedantic concepts. However, I correlate it with our own notion of The Fall. Because it seems to me that by explicating the idea behind The Fall (a story dealing in metaphysics) we can better understand what Christian metaphysics and ethics extend from and what, let’s say, they demand of us.

Another thought I have is that we live very substantially in a Nietzschean frame of mind. That means in a world that is ethically post-Christian and which impels men to seek their development, growth and satisfaction by way of power-aggressiveness. Kind of like a social and political philosophy “beyond good & evil”. It is inevitable that if we have fallen from a world governed by a Higher Authority, we fall into a world of Nature and the governing powers of nature: material processes in constant struggle and in constant mutation. To the degree that a man loses, or relinquishes, a tangible sense that he serves higher metaphysical principles, the more readily, the more inevitably (?) he sinks as it were into “the material entanglement” which is really (isn’t it?) what “sin” means.

The following is commentary on the Third Chapter of the Gita. The “higher truths” that are spoken of have to do with things conceived of in that “higher metaphysical realm” to which (according to this philosophy) the better man must strive. The topic under discussion is: How can a man, subsumed in Nature, cease to be so much under the influence of determining Nature, and respond, as it were, to higher influences not (so much) determined by Nature.
In fact, these higher truths can only be helpful because there only they are true to experience and can be lived, on a higher and vaster plane of consciousness and being. To view these truths from below is to mis-see, misunderstand and probably to misuse them. It is a higher truth that the distinction of good and evil is indeed a practical fact and law valid for the egoistic human life which is the stage of transition from the animal to the divine, but on a higher plane we rise beyond good and evil, are above their duality even as the Godhead is above it. But the unripe mind, seizing on this truth without rising from the lower consciousness where it is not practically valid, will simply make it a convenient excuse for indulging its Asuric propensities, denying the distinction between good and evil altogether and falling by self-indulgence deeper into the morass of perdition, sarva-jnana-vimudhannashtan achetasah. So too with this truth of the determinism of Nature; it will be mis-seen and misused, as those misuse it who declare that a man is what his nature has made him and cannot do otherwise than as his nature compels him. It is true in a sense, but not in the sense which is attached to it, not in the sense that the ego-self can claim, irresponsibility and impunity for itself in its works; for it has will and it has desire and so long as it acts according to its will and desire, even though that be its nature, it must bear the reactions of its karma. It is in a net, if you will, a snare which may well seem perplexing, illogical, unjust, terrible to its present experience, to its limited self-knowledge, but a snare of its own choice, a net of its own weaving.
Asuric: demonic, but more specifically a fallen entity.

Sarva-jnana-vimudhannashtan achetasah: full translation of Verse 32 Chapter 3 in the Gita:

"But those who find fault with this teaching of mine and do not follow it — know them to be deluded in all knowledge, ruined and mindless."
• sarva-jnana = in all knowledge / wisdom
• vimudhan = bewildered, utterly deluded, confused
• nashtan = ruined, lost, destroyed
• achetasah = mindless, without true consciousness, without discrimination
It is important to draw a parallel between the Christian notion of perdition and “willed sin” and the same notion that is expressed in Vedanta.
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sat Oct 31, 2026 7:06 pm
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Sat Oct 31, 2026 6:57 pm But you must proceed to the claims that flow from the proper view of ontology.
Ooooh. Let's hear about your "proper view" of ontology. Fire away.
Fire away
MikeNovack
Posts: 1453
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by MikeNovack »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sat Oct 31, 2026 12:26 am Well, as you know, no Christian believes in three gods, so you can put your heart to rest on that one.
That I understand. The Christian (you) believes that the three are really one.

What I don't understand why you see it differently when the Hindu says "all these gods are really aspects of the one" or the Neo-pagan says "the Maiden, Mother, and Crone of the Triple Goddess are really one" you insist these folks are polytheists.

How do you explain to somebody who is not a Christian, not a Hindu, not a Neo-pagan? Notice that "my religion is the true one and theirs false ones" doesn't help much because JUST talking about "the many that are really one" concept.
User avatar
Fanman
Posts: 162
Joined: Wed Aug 19, 2026 5:43 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Fanman »

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Sun Nov 01, 2026 3:01 pm Since the thread began with a Jain ‘didactic anecdote’ and it has been fruitful to examine the philosophy of an alternative school of religious thought — which I hope can shed some clarifying light on our own tradition and more importantly our own quandary as it pertains to these religious/metaphysical issues — I think the quotation below from Sri Aurobindo’s commentary on the Bhagavad Gita will be helpful.

Obviously, my own notion that we are trapped within determined and determining Nature (Prakriti) comes from Vedantic concepts. However, I correlate it with our own notion of The Fall. Because it seems to me that by explicating the idea behind The Fall (a story dealing in metaphysics) we can better understand what Christian metaphysics and ethics extend from and what, let’s say, they demand of us.

Another thought I have is that we live very substantially in a Nietzschean frame of mind. That means in a world that is ethically post-Christian and which impels men to seek their development, growth and satisfaction by way of power-aggressiveness. Kind of like a social and political philosophy “beyond good & evil”. It is inevitable that if we have fallen from a world governed by a Higher Authority, we fall into a world of Nature and the governing powers of nature: material processes in constant struggle and in constant mutation. To the degree that a man loses, or relinquishes, a tangible sense that he serves higher metaphysical principles, the more readily, the more inevitably (?) he sinks as it were into “the material entanglement” which is really (isn’t it?) what “sin” means.

The following is commentary on the Third Chapter of the Gita. The “higher truths” that are spoken of have to do with things conceived of in that “higher metaphysical realm” to which (according to this philosophy) the better man must strive. The topic under discussion is: How can a man, subsumed in Nature, cease to be so much under the influence of determining Nature, and respond, as it were, to higher influences not (so much) determined by Nature.
In fact, these higher truths can only be helpful because there only they are true to experience and can be lived, on a higher and vaster plane of consciousness and being. To view these truths from below is to mis-see, misunderstand and probably to misuse them. It is a higher truth that the distinction of good and evil is indeed a practical fact and law valid for the egoistic human life which is the stage of transition from the animal to the divine, but on a higher plane we rise beyond good and evil, are above their duality even as the Godhead is above it. But the unripe mind, seizing on this truth without rising from the lower consciousness where it is not practically valid, will simply make it a convenient excuse for indulging its Asuric propensities, denying the distinction between good and evil altogether and falling by self-indulgence deeper into the morass of perdition, sarva-jnana-vimudhannashtan achetasah. So too with this truth of the determinism of Nature; it will be mis-seen and misused, as those misuse it who declare that a man is what his nature has made him and cannot do otherwise than as his nature compels him. It is true in a sense, but not in the sense which is attached to it, not in the sense that the ego-self can claim, irresponsibility and impunity for itself in its works; for it has will and it has desire and so long as it acts according to its will and desire, even though that be its nature, it must bear the reactions of its karma. It is in a net, if you will, a snare which may well seem perplexing, illogical, unjust, terrible to its present experience, to its limited self-knowledge, but a snare of its own choice, a net of its own weaving.
Asuric: demonic, but more specifically a fallen entity.

Sarva-jnana-vimudhannashtan achetasah: full translation of Verse 32 Chapter 3 in the Gita:

"But those who find fault with this teaching of mine and do not follow it — know them to be deluded in all knowledge, ruined and mindless."
• sarva-jnana = in all knowledge / wisdom
• vimudhan = bewildered, utterly deluded, confused
• nashtan = ruined, lost, destroyed
• achetasah = mindless, without true consciousness, without discrimination
It is important to draw a parallel between the Christian notion of perdition and “willed sin” and the same notion that is expressed in Vedanta.
Okay, but that is one possible take, and as far as intuition goes, it feels honest. But from a subjective viewpoint, no matter how profound it sounds, we have to compare it with other spiritual and religious constructs. I think the common theme among the constructs is 'higher-order' thinking, conduct, and states. Now, there are different definitions, takes, and narratives about exactly how those combinations exist within each construct. Still, themes across those who experience it (the purportedly divine) include peace, greater understanding, and resonating with love and compassion. So maybe the divine isn't a place, in the sense of a specific spatial location. As you've alluded to, it may be a state of mind, where we experience reality at its most fundamental state: pure, unblemished, light, and just.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Immanuel Can »

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Sun Nov 01, 2026 1:06 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sat Oct 31, 2026 12:26 am Well, as you know, no Christian believes in three gods, so you can put your heart to rest on that one.
Except the Trinity is presented as three 'persons' in one. It is not unlike the ways that Eastern religious philosophy (specifically of India) conceive of an absolute God with different 'aspects' that are given different names and conceived of as acting separately.
It's actually completely unlike that. Trinitarianism is not belief in "avatars" or demi-gods.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Immanuel Can »

MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sun Nov 01, 2026 5:53 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sat Oct 31, 2026 12:26 am Well, as you know, no Christian believes in three gods, so you can put your heart to rest on that one.
That I understand.
Fine. But the present point is the Law of Non-Contradiction. Do you understand why, regardless of which view we take to be correct, only one can be correct, and the other two must necessarily be false? Or are you still confused about what logic requires?
MikeNovack
Posts: 1453
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by MikeNovack »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 02, 2026 3:45 am
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Sun Nov 01, 2026 5:53 pm
Fine. But the present point is the Law of Non-Contradiction. Do you understand why, regardless of which view we take to be correct, only one can be correct, and the other two must necessarily be false? Or are you still confused about what logic requires?
I am not confused about "what logic requires". You persist "only one can be correct" in spite of the fact that you are a Christian. Sorry IC, saying the three is really one so no contradiction IS equivalent to three and one at the same time.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Immanuel Can »

MikeNovack wrote: ↑Mon Nov 02, 2026 3:53 am
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 02, 2026 3:45 am

Fine. But the present point is the Law of Non-Contradiction. Do you understand why, regardless of which view we take to be correct, only one can be correct, and the other two must necessarily be false? Or are you still confused about what logic requires?
I am not confused about "what logic requires".
Then you understand the Law of Non-Contradiction? And you understand that it means, impartially and absolutely, that only one of the three options can be true?
Gary Childress
Posts: 13621
Joined: Sun Sep 25, 2011 3:08 pm
Location: It's my fault

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Gary Childress »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 02, 2026 4:57 am
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Mon Nov 02, 2026 3:53 am
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Nov 02, 2026 3:45 am

Fine. But the present point is the Law of Non-Contradiction. Do you understand why, regardless of which view we take to be correct, only one can be correct, and the other two must necessarily be false? Or are you still confused about what logic requires?
I am not confused about "what logic requires".
Then you understand the Law of Non-Contradiction? And you understand that it means, impartially and absolutely, that only one of the three options can be true?
So let's say the God of the Bible is the one true God. All the rest of the religious sects out there are misled. Now what? Do we sit here and "pray" while our world is falling apart? Or if there is a God, then what option has God given us to preserve the Earth and the human species from wildfires, flooding, wars, nuclear proliferation, AI running amuck, a super disease from wiping most of us out or a giant asteroid from heading our way? What's the option that will save us from all the potential sources of destruction around us? Obviously, leftists must be "evil," so do we all rally behind the wealthy and the furtherance of profit? To hell with "socialism"? Is it every man, woman, and child for themselves? No government, just 8 billion people, all doing whatever we happen to want to do? Are Elon Musk and Jeff Bezos going to lead us to salvation and safety (since they and the rest of the top .01% seem to be pulling most of the economic strings)?
Gary Childress
Posts: 13621
Joined: Sun Sep 25, 2011 3:08 pm
Location: It's my fault

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Gary Childress »

So here's where we're at:

https://www.oxfam.org/en/press-releases ... 2%80%9Cbig

So socialism and "big government" are a "no-go". Right? What's the God-given option that will make the world a better place? Or is the world a better place with the top 1% owning more wealth than 95% of the rest of the world's population (and being critical of the disparity is simply "envy")?
Post Reply