Can't both be right?

Is there a God? If so, what is She like?

Moderators: AMod, iMod

Post Reply
MikeNovack
Posts: 1453
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by MikeNovack »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Oct 30, 2026 8:58 pm
And yes, I understand the Trinity is a religious mystery, along the lines of the three are really one.
I promised to speak of that. But first, we need to get the Law of Non-Contradiction clear in your mind.
Uh, no we don't unless first agreed "applies to the divine". We can't discuss whether "there is one god" and "there are three gods" violates the Law of Non-Contradiction unless we discuss the Trinity, the Threefold Goddess, Hindu beliefs, etc.

You dismiss "The Elephant Story" too readily by not understanding that the "blindness" isn't meant as a disability relative to the normal human condition but normal to the human condition (as Jains believe)
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Immanuel Can »

MikeNovack wrote: ↑Fri Oct 30, 2026 11:35 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Fri Oct 30, 2026 8:58 pm
And yes, I understand the Trinity is a religious mystery, along the lines of the three are really one.
I promised to speak of that. But first, we need to get the Law of Non-Contradiction clear in your mind.
Uh, no we don't unless first agreed "applies to the divine". We can't discuss whether "there is one god" and "there are three gods"
Well, as you know, no Christian believes in three gods, so you can put your heart to rest on that one. But if they did, then the only grounds for criticizing that would be the Law of Non-Contradiction. So you'd have to believe in it, in order even to raise the question.

So do you?
You dismiss "The Elephant Story" too readily

No, I don't. I've known it for years. And it's merely an attempt to describe religious epistemology -- not a good one, but one, nonetheless. It has nothing to do with ontology. For the one thing it insists is on the existence of a real elephant, not two, or three, or ten. So it's saying these fools are "blind," not that no elephant exists, or that if they weren't blind, they couldn't then see the elephant.

Yeah, it's off base in so many ways. It has the appeal to a kind of brainless relativism, but no actual wisdom in it. And it fails to address the Law of Non-Contradiction, bypassing it for a comment about epistemology. That's the bottom line.
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

The story has to be examined and understood from within the intellectual tradition of which it is a part.

Not ‘mindless’ but definitely differently minded. And not based in an Aristotelean formula but on Syadvada.
The Jain parable is called Andha Gaja Nyaya. The teaching of the blind men and the elephant.

Six blind men are led to an elephant. None has touched one before.

One touches the leg and says the elephant is like a pillar.
One touches the tail and says the elephant is like a rope.
One touches the trunk and says the elephant is like a snake.
One touches the ear and says the elephant is like a fan.
One touches the belly and says the elephant is like a wall.
One touches the tusk and says the elephant is like a spear.

Then they quarrel. Each insists he alone is right and all others are wrong.

The Jain meaning is this:

Every man is right in what he affirms.
Every man is wrong in what he denies.
The full truth is seen only when you hold the whole together.

For this reason Jains teach Anekantavada. Truth has many sides. Reality has countless aspects. It is one and also many. It is lasting and also passing. It looks different as you look from different angles.

So the wise person does not say: It is thus in an absolute way. He says Syat. In a certain respect, from a certain view, it is thus. This careful way of speaking is called Syadvada.
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

What is “the whole” when the meaning and if you will the practice of having and living through a religious philosophy is examined and, potentially, understood?
The object of mathematics is simple : it is quantitative ; the object of metaphysics is manifold and infinitely varied : it is qualitative.
— Étiene Gilson
Guénon asserted that an Occidental traditionalism must be based on elements that exist within our own history. We cannot over-impose another tradition since structurally it is foreign. But, the means to understand at a metaphysical level the essences in our own tradition, requires another comparative model, one more fully intellectual.

This is why (as I have said many times) Vedanta works very well because its metaphysics are extremely more developed and thus it provides a wide-ranging nomenclature by which we can talk about what we really mean.

But that is the thing: We never seem to clarify what we mean. I.e. what really is the purpose of engagement in religious and spiritual processes?

The following, when it is taken as a symbol-vehicle is very easy to translate into Vedantic terms that do not have all the intense, overbearing guilt-slinging manipulation we associate with typical, low-order Christian Evangelism (hello IC).
Luke 77-79 wrote:“To give to his people knowledge of salvation through forgiveness of their sins, because of the loving kindness of our God, where from the Orient [rising sun] from on high has visited us, to shine on those who sit in darkness and in the shadow of death, to guide our feet into the way of peace”.
We can examine the Gayatri formula (prayer, mantra) since it is based on the IDEA of the sun (Surya) as the illuminator of the world, obviously, but on metaphysical levels and spiritual level as a luminance that awakens the intelligence. But intelligence understood more deeply. That incorporates intuition, understanding but also a desire or a need to ascend to a higher level of understanding. Buddhi is the term for “intelligence” but it is deeper and more manifold that smartness or wit.
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sat Oct 31, 2026 12:26 am No, I don't. I've known it for years. And it's merely an attempt to describe religious epistemology -- not a good one, but one, nonetheless. It has nothing to do with ontology.
This is an excellent juncture where you can talk about “ontology”.

It would also be much appreciated If you would launch into a variant of the Evangelical tirade & curse about what will happen to those who do not see as you do from limited religious zealousness. “Soon you will know what I am talking about!” — that sort of thing.
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

Fanman wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 8:17 am MikeNovack stated:
What is this story about? EXACTLY THIS QUESTION. The story is a parable explaining of how/why we humans have such differing understanding of the divine. That the divine is so vast, and our ability to see/perceive it so limited, we can all have true, but contradictory versions.
What I'm thinking is, when you say "limited," could you explain that? I wasn’t aware that we could perceive the divine at all. Through what human mechanisms would that be possible?
In my experience as a reader, Vedanta does a better job of explaining what is attempted by Christianity but which seems always incomplete and insufficiently interpreted. Christianity attempts to answer a question and to propose an Rx (remediy, cure, way out) of the existential condition of The Fall. But what, in other terms and through other lenses does this mean?

The Fall can be understood to mean (to picture) a descent into Nature and its processes. That is, a world of energy and matter completely in the grip of determined force. Vedanta describes that as Prakriti and states that we are so enmeshed in Nature, and so much in the current of energy over which we have no control, that we are effectively ‘slaves’. We certainly cannot get out of this condition.

One way or the other we will have to struggle and fight and also to take advantage of other living beings in order to maintain ourselves. We are “subsumed” in this. To the degree that we get ultra-involved in Nature’s processes, is the degree to which we strengthen ‘complicity ’.

Now then, what does “God” mean for that being completely enmeshed in such World as this? True, we have “different understandings” but when seen through the lens or the picture I just described — a Fall into material conditions, and the knowledge of being ‘mired’ and ‘complicit’ in currents that we did not create and over which we do not have power …

… it is there that Vedanta has interesting insight.
I wasn’t aware that we could perceive the divine at all. Through what human mechanisms would that be possible?
According to a strict version of Vedanta (it has philosophical antecedents in different schools of thought) Nature and Prakriti are vastly powerful, or perhaps totalizing is the word. There is no way out or ‘beyond’. Our bodies, our organs, our brains, our emotions, our desires, our aspirations, and all of our thoughts are situated fully in Nature/Prakriti.

However, that is not all. And here is where “Divinity” enters the picture. By way of what “mechanism” does a man have access to anything, and to something, that is outside of Prakriti’s reign? By definition not in his biological self which is a mechanism subsumed in Nature. Nature cannot be the source either, for obvious reasons. (Nature cannot answer Nature).

In Vedanta there is a notion of Buddhi:
Buddhi is best translated as the higher intellect or the power of discernment, the faculty in us that judges, decides and understands. In the classical model of mind there are different layers. The lower mind receives impressions from the senses and vacillates, going back and forth between options. Memory stores those impressions. The sense of self claims them as mine. Buddhi sits above all of these, closer to pure consciousness. It does not merely think, it determines. While the lower mind says maybe this maybe that, buddhi says this is true and this course is right. Its proper work when clear and calm is to distinguish what is real from what only appears real, what lasts from what passes, what frees from what binds. When it is clouded by restlessness, greed or inertia it loses that clarity and uses its sharpness only to justify what the senses want, mistaking the temporary for the permanent. Vedanta (in the Gita) makes a sharp division between two kinds of this intelligence, one that is resolute, single pointed and gathered toward liberation, and another that is scattered, endlessly branching, chasing many desires and producing many contradictory purposes. Yoga is in essence the training and purification of this faculty until it becomes a clear mirror that can reflect the light of the self and guide the whole life.
The problem here for one of atheistic bent is that “Buddhi” as the possibility of gaining a glimmering of the nature of our condition, (an awakening in our consciousness) and a beginning to conceive of what action and motion which is not determined by Nature (or less so), requires an active, existent, and lets say “approachable” divine embodiment that is outside of Nature’s dominion. It also must needs require a “particle” in us that is latent, perhaps submerged, but awakenable.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Immanuel Can »

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Sat Oct 31, 2026 1:40 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sat Oct 31, 2026 12:26 am No, I don't. I've known it for years. And it's merely an attempt to describe religious epistemology -- not a good one, but one, nonetheless. It has nothing to do with ontology.
This is an excellent juncture where you can talk about “ontology”.
I've been doing that all along.

Wakey wakey, Mr. Polly Parrot. :D 🦜 (Bonus points for recognizing the reference.)
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

But you must proceed to the claims that flow from the proper view of ontology. I sense you drag your feet. Why?
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Immanuel Can »

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Sat Oct 31, 2026 6:57 pm But you must proceed to the claims that flow from the proper view of ontology.
Ooooh. Let's hear about your "proper view" of ontology. Fire away.
User avatar
Fanman
Posts: 162
Joined: Wed Aug 19, 2026 5:43 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Fanman »

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Sat Oct 31, 2026 4:44 pm
Fanman wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 8:17 am MikeNovack stated:
What is this story about? EXACTLY THIS QUESTION. The story is a parable explaining of how/why we humans have such differing understanding of the divine. That the divine is so vast, and our ability to see/perceive it so limited, we can all have true, but contradictory versions.
What I'm thinking is, when you say "limited," could you explain that? I wasn’t aware that we could perceive the divine at all. Through what human mechanisms would that be possible?
In my experience as a reader, Vedanta does a better job of explaining what is attempted by Christianity but which seems always incomplete and insufficiently interpreted. Christianity attempts to answer a question and to propose an Rx (remediy, cure, way out) of the existential condition of The Fall. But what, in other terms and through other lenses does this mean?

The Fall can be understood to mean (to picture) a descent into Nature and its processes. That is, a world of energy and matter completely in the grip of determined force. Vedanta describes that as Prakriti and states that we are so enmeshed in Nature, and so much in the current of energy over which we have no control, that we are effectively ‘slaves’. We certainly cannot get out of this condition.

One way or the other we will have to struggle and fight and also to take advantage of other living beings in order to maintain ourselves. We are “subsumed” in this. To the degree that we get ultra-involved in Nature’s processes, is the degree to which we strengthen ‘complicity ’.

Now then, what does “God” mean for that being completely enmeshed in such World as this? True, we have “different understandings” but when seen through the lens or the picture I just described — a Fall into material conditions, and the knowledge of being ‘mired’ and ‘complicit’ in currents that we did not create and over which we do not have power …

… it is there that Vedanta has interesting insight.
I wasn’t aware that we could perceive the divine at all. Through what human mechanisms would that be possible?
According to a strict version of Vedanta (it has philosophical antecedents in different schools of thought) Nature and Prakriti are vastly powerful, or perhaps totalizing is the word. There is no way out or ‘beyond’. Our bodies, our organs, our brains, our emotions, our desires, our aspirations, and all of our thoughts are situated fully in Nature/Prakriti.

However, that is not all. And here is where “Divinity” enters the picture. By way of what “mechanism” does a man have access to anything, and to something, that is outside of Prakriti’s reign? By definition not in his biological self which is a mechanism subsumed in Nature. Nature cannot be the source either, for obvious reasons. (Nature cannot answer Nature).

In Vedanta there is a notion of Buddhi:
Buddhi is best translated as the higher intellect or the power of discernment, the faculty in us that judges, decides and understands. In the classical model of mind there are different layers. The lower mind receives impressions from the senses and vacillates, going back and forth between options. Memory stores those impressions. The sense of self claims them as mine. Buddhi sits above all of these, closer to pure consciousness. It does not merely think, it determines. While the lower mind says maybe this maybe that, buddhi says this is true and this course is right. Its proper work when clear and calm is to distinguish what is real from what only appears real, what lasts from what passes, what frees from what binds. When it is clouded by restlessness, greed or inertia it loses that clarity and uses its sharpness only to justify what the senses want, mistaking the temporary for the permanent. Vedanta (in the Gita) makes a sharp division between two kinds of this intelligence, one that is resolute, single pointed and gathered toward liberation, and another that is scattered, endlessly branching, chasing many desires and producing many contradictory purposes. Yoga is in essence the training and purification of this faculty until it becomes a clear mirror that can reflect the light of the self and guide the whole life.
The problem here for one of atheistic bent is that “Buddhi” as the possibility of gaining a glimmering of the nature of our condition, (an awakening in our consciousness) and a beginning to conceive of what action and motion which is not determined by Nature (or less so), requires an active, existent, and lets say “approachable” divine embodiment that is outside of Nature’s dominion. It also must needs require a “particle” in us that is latent, perhaps submerged, but awakenable.
Thank you for that insightful and educative post. I understand that as human beings we categorise lower and higher thinking, but to claim that distinction enables us to perceive the divine encounters problems, the first of which, I feel, is: what is the divine? I think that you may be onto something, Alexis. However, I think we require a workable definition of divine before we can rationally progress.
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

Fanman wrote: ↑Sat Oct 31, 2026 7:18 pm Thank you for that insightful and educative post. I understand that as human beings we categorise lower and higher thinking, but to claim that distinction enables us to perceive the divine encounters problems, the first of which, I feel, is: what is the divine? I think that you may be onto something, Alexis. However, I think we require a workable definition of divine before we can rationally progress.
The explanation easily to hand is “The author of existence and being” but of course — unless I am wrong — there is no means available to substantiate the statement. For over a decade on these pages the questions have been argued and, incredible as it is, every single argument offered as “proof” falls flat. If you are not inclined or perhaps predisposed toward an intuited appreciation of the argument, you will not be moved (by ‘you’ I mean ‘people’).

Those ‘truly convinced’ always refer to personal, subjective experience, and at least in a certain number of cases they are involved in spiritual practice which of course is subjective.
I cannot define for you what God is. I can only say that my work has proved empirically that the pattern of God exists in every man, and that this pattern has at its disposal the greatest of all his energies for transformation and transfiguration of his natural being.

CG Jung -- Letters
User avatar
Fanman
Posts: 162
Joined: Wed Aug 19, 2026 5:43 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Fanman »

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Sat Oct 31, 2026 7:46 pm
Fanman wrote: ↑Sat Oct 31, 2026 7:18 pm Thank you for that insightful and educative post. I understand that as human beings we categorise lower and higher thinking, but to claim that distinction enables us to perceive the divine encounters problems, the first of which, I feel, is: what is the divine? I think that you may be onto something, Alexis. However, I think we require a workable definition of divine before we can rationally progress.
The explanation easily to hand is “The author of existence and being” but of course — unless I am wrong — there is no means available to substantiate the statement. For over a decade on these pages the questions have been argued and, incredible as it is, every single argument offered as “proof” falls flat. If you are not inclined or perhaps predisposed toward an intuited appreciation of the argument, you will not be moved (by ‘you’ I mean ‘people’).

Those ‘truly convinced’ always refer to personal, subjective experience, and at least in a certain number of cases they are involved in spiritual practice which of course is subjective.
I cannot define for you what God is. I can only say that my work has proved empirically that the pattern of God exists in every man, and that this pattern has at its disposal the greatest of all his energies for transformation and transfiguration of his natural being.

CG Jung -- Letters
From my perspective, while the divine can be considered (or understood) as a personage, it can also be considered a reality. So when you say, “The author of existence and being”, I can relate to that and accept it as a reasonable definition of divinity. However, I would add, “and the aspect of reality it inhabits”. In that sense, if it inhabits a higher, let’s say, 'frequency' of thought and action that is layered within our terrestrial reality, it makes sense that if our thoughts and actions resonate with that higher 'frequency' (a working phrase), we have the capacity, at least in part, to access the divine (as we've defined it). Of course, those involved in spiritual practices may have experienced that, er, ‘place’; however, as you say, that is a subjective experience. But in favour of that potential subjective experience, corroboration (or shared experiences) goes a long way. Because subjectivity becomes intersubjectivity.
Dubious
Posts: 4807
Joined: Tue May 19, 2015 7:40 am

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Dubious »

I cannot define for you what God is. I can only say that my work has proved empirically that the pattern of God exists in every man, and that this pattern has at its disposal the greatest of all his energies for transformation and transfiguration of his natural being.

CG Jung -- Letters
If it were possible to reply to Jung, I would counter for such transformations to occur it would need to exclude all forms of dogmatic belief. The pattern as described is not a system but a potential.

Not least, the type of transformation depends on the pattern one integrates with. Most are opposite to transfiguration of any kind being more akin to mutilation in terms of unconditional acceptance.
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

Fanman wrote: ↑Sat Oct 31, 2026 11:08 pm From my perspective, while the divine can be considered (or understood) as a personage, it can also be considered a reality.
That description jibes with ideas in Vedanta, at least it appears so to me. The way these things are described is intricate and rather complex. It is (if you’ll permit me to put it like this) a language game, a game of nomenclature, a way of organizing and thinking about what is outside of conceptualization (?)
Brahman is the Absolute.

It is the word in Vedanta for That which is ultimately Real, beyond which nothing is, from which everything comes.
If one is asked to define how such an abstract ‘reality’ could also be personal, other terms are employed: Ishvara.

I guess we make of these things what we can.
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

Dubious wrote: ↑Sat Oct 31, 2026 11:31 pm Not least, the type of transformation depends on the pattern one integrates with. Most are opposite to transfiguration of any kind being more akin to mutilation in terms of unconditional acceptance.
This reminds me of an anecdote Jung shared. Some of his patients described dreams in which the Church building was imagined and felt as a prison and the dream involved confinement and the need to escape.

But others dreamt of the Church as a refuge, as a place of safety, or perhaps as a hospital.

The symbolism is clear in each case.
Post Reply