Can't both be right?

Is there a God? If so, what is She like?

Moderators: AMod, iMod

User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Immanuel Can »

MikeNovack wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 3:14 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 1:18 am You can't disprove the Law of Non-Contradiction by saying, "we don't know which one is true." Because the thing we DO know from the trilemma, and cannot doubt, is HOW MANY ANSWERS CAN BE TRUE.
There is a fundamental difference between "don't know" and "cannot know". "Don't know" includes the potential of knowing while "cannot know" does not.
Absolutely right!

And that's why the fact that we know there is only one of three answers possible is so important: it's not just the gateway to future specific knowledge (although it is that), it's the gateway to the realization that knowledge is possible at all. :shock:
And that trilemma is NOT so simple.
It's very simple. It has the simplicity of truth.
You are a Christian.
Yes, but for this specific point, that observation has absolutely no relevance. Logic is a universal language...or better, a universal operating system. No particular ideology claims it, and all of them have to use it. You're using it right now.

As for the triune conception of God, I'm happy to make a case for it; but not yet, because I don't want to cloud the central issue with anything that can remotely seem partisan, even at first glance. Even if a particular religion, say Christianity or Judaism, had the dead wrong conception of God, and the Hindus or the Jains or the pagans were right, or nobody was right at all, the Law of Non-Contradiction would be unaffected by that. To contradict one's own basic premise, and then to suppose both could be true, would still be irrational, confused thinking...whoever did it.

That's where we are, right now. We're entertaining three different possibilities: there's one God, there's no God, there is a plurality. We needn't yet pick a horse to ride...we can hold three, for the present moment. What we know is that two are definitely wrong.

Plus, we've now eliminated relativism, universalism, inclusivism, etc. -- that is, if we're taking logic seriously.

That's a huge gain. And it's just the start.
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 2:18 pm It even offers us a way to arbitrate disagreements of opinion. Instead of being bogged down in the brainless "I'm okay, you're okay" of the 1970s, it allows us to break some basic cognitive deadlocks between positions. And we have our first big win in this: relativism is false. That's a great launch pad for further thought. And I think we can easily get farther than that...if we're careful and honest in our inquiry.
Except, foolish man, it does not help with the issue as we are defining it and indeed as we live it. No one will not grant you the discriminating power, the clarifying power, of The law of Non-Contradiction within those realms where it is applicable. But your use of it represents an act of intellectual trickery and is dishonest. It is also tied up in the assertion of certainty that “you” (a Christian school of thought, an archive of theology) have in your possession as accurate image and picture of God. You also have determined God’s relationship to man in and through history and, going further, you as Evangelical Christian are an exponent of a maddened notion of final wars in the Holy Land and psychotic fantasies about total destruction, which seem to be implimented by people caught up in the belief-system you say we must adopt if we do not want to wind up in “hell”.

Other religious traditions, other spiritual modalities, put emphasis in other areas. You see IC, I hope you understand that it is not hard for discriminating people to receive your “teaching” and your apologetics and think “This is nuts!”

When the religious impulse is examined in the context of a larger world situation (careening toward dangerous conflagrations and events of enormous consequence) the idea of what “spirituality” is and then what self-renovation and psychological wellness actually is, is brought to the fore.

What a fancy rhetor you are, but how insincere: “Break some basic cognitive deadlocks between positions”.
And we have our first big win in this: relativism is false.
Nice try, but that trick won’t work. The advocates of the “relativism’ proposed by those who intoned “I’m ok, you’re ok” did not have the capability of conducting a careful and unprejudiced examination of each religious platform. So their “bridge” (its all relative) is intellectually corrupt. The real endeavor is to see what in each elucidates and clarifies a point that we might all recognize as “universally valid”.

The function of your endeavor is to UNDERMINE any other perspective not your own, and to insist, if you can — and ultimately with the threat “you’ll go to hell if you don’t!” — that the Christian path is superior to all others. Period.
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

IC wrote:That's where we are, right now. We're entertaining three different possibilities: there's one God, there's no God, there is a plurality. We needn't yet pick a horse to ride...we can hold three, for the present moment. What we know is that two are definitely wrong.
No, that is where you are, not necessarily where I am or “we” are.

Anyway, most you converse with are atheists. Of the religiously inclined who participate here, each has a very different but not entirely dissimilar notion of Divinity. Take for example Seeds or that unusual Australian who was banned. (And I cannot exclude myself since I do have a religious-like orientation. (Novak would have to define his own position).

It is interesting to watch you rehearse this “most reasonable game”. But that’s dishonest.

If one is inclined to believe that “God exists” the next step is not merely theoretical, but a question of examination of one’s lived experience. In what way was Divinity manifested? That is always the key thing. Again refer to Seeds, refer to the Australian. They certainly both believe in God and live from and out of their spiritual position. But their views do not accord with almost anything that you preach. And note: each of them speak at length, exclusively, from their experience. And you never do.

So “picking a horse to ride” is not meaningful — except if you are preaching to 10 and 12 year-olds.

Therefore each reaches out to God (the elephant) and gives you a very different report about what is sensed, what happens, what happened, etc.

[And we are all still here. In the same world from which functionally there is no escape.]
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Immanuel Can »

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 4:41 pm
IC wrote:That's where we are, right now. We're entertaining three different possibilities: there's one God, there's no God, there is a plurality. We needn't yet pick a horse to ride...we can hold three, for the present moment. What we know is that two are definitely wrong.
No, that is where you are, not necessarily where I am or “we” are.
Sorry...what I meant was, that's where we should be, if we're actually following the argument.
Anyway, most you converse with are atheists.
Yeah, we'll deal with that...and it won't take long. Just hold on.
If one is inclined to believe that “God exists” the next step is not merely theoretical, but a question of examination of one’s lived experience.
Really? I don't see that that follows at all. You'll have to explain why you expect a person's "lived experience" to illuminate that. It's certainly not obvious why it must.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Immanuel Can »

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 4:22 pm No one will not grant you the discriminating power, the clarifying power, of The law of Non-Contradiction within those realms where it is applicable.
That's all I'm asking. And I've given you two: God and cats. You can pick either one.

And since, as you say, "no one will not grant it..." :lol:
MikeNovack
Posts: 1453
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by MikeNovack »

The problem, IC, is that you seem unable to conceive that when we are talking about divinity all bets are off.

There is one god and at the same time there are three gods is NOT contradictory << I know of religions whose believers claim this >>

Nor are there, strictly speaking, just the three possibilities. The secularist atheist's "there is no god" (or any other sort of non-material being) or the animist's "there is no god in the sense that you (IC) mean by a god". Or the pantheist's "there is nothing except god" (ONE, but not what you mean by God existing apart as well as within)

I am not asking you to give up your "there is exactly one truth about the divine and I know it" but relax it enough to be able to look seriously at what other religions believe (and what the secularists believe) to take these different "observations of the elephant" seriously. Otherwise you will continue to not understand why others are not accepting your "obvious truth".
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Immanuel Can »

MikeNovack wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 5:31 pm The problem, IC, is that you seem unable to conceive that when we are talking about divinity all bets are off.
Oh, that's not the case at all. I mean, it's not the case if you believe Torah, for example.
There is one god and at the same time there are three gods is NOT contradictory

That's exactly what it is. Pure and simple.
<< I know of religions whose believers claim this >>
So what? I know of people who believe in all kinds of things...even that they, themselves are gods...and some of them have cult followings, too. It proves nothing, and doesn't even suggest anything to the point.
Nor are there, strictly speaking, just the three possibilities.
On the question of God's existence, there are only three. There are various claims about his nature. Those are very different questions.

And all I've talked about so far here is God's existence. We can wait to discover His nature. Right now, it's a mere red herring, an allurement to try to escape the inescapable.
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 5:14 pmSorry...what I meant was, that's where we should be, if we're actually following the argument.
News for you: You.do.not.define.the.argument.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Immanuel Can »

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 6:13 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 5:14 pmSorry...what I meant was, that's where we should be, if we're actually following the argument.
News for you: You.do.not.define.the.argument.
News for you: to follow the argument means to be logical, and go with the step that makes sense...not jump nervously to ever irrelevancy you can find.

Sorry chum. Not gonna bite.
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 6:25 pm
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 6:13 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 5:14 pmSorry...what I meant was, that's where we should be, if we're actually following the argument.
News for you: You.do.not.define.the.argument.
News for you: to follow the argument means to be logical, and go with the step that makes sense...not jump nervously to ever irrelevancy you can find.

Sorry chum. Not gonna bite.
Nice attempt to present as the “logical guide” here. Bad news for you though: You are not, nor can you be. You present overt religious enthusiasm as if it is a “rational” thing. The argument you accrete around this, is game.

Occasional clarifying statements must be made every once in a while.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Immanuel Can »

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 6:55 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 6:25 pm
Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 6:13 pm
News for you: You.do.not.define.the.argument.
News for you: to follow the argument means to be logical, and go with the step that makes sense...not jump nervously to ever irrelevancy you can find.

Sorry chum. Not gonna bite.
Nice attempt to present as the “logical guide” here.
Apparently, somebody needs to...and it ain't you, so far.

But you've already conceded the point, claiming "no one" will disagree. I assume that must include you, so we can move on, as soon as Mike sorts it out.
User avatar
Fanman
Posts: 162
Joined: Wed Aug 19, 2026 5:43 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Fanman »

My thoughts on the topic as it evolves: Possibility is a positive metaphysical status when the available data provide sufficient grounds to affirm it. The affirmation remains qualified by the strength and limitations of the relevant data. It does not establish that the proposition is actual, but neither should unresolved (or unproven) actuality be mistaken for an absence of possibility.

The strength of the inference to plausible possibility should be proportionate to the strength of the supporting data.
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 6:59 pm But you've already conceded the point, claiming "no one" will disagree. I assume that must include you, so we can move on, as soon as Mike sorts it out.
No, in order to even get to where we are now you must acknowledge a wide range of points that were brought up. Then you can say you are in the conversation.

IC: you must know that I am on to your tactics. Maybe others here are too, maybe they are not, I’ll leave it to them to say.
User avatar
Alexis Jacobi
Posts: 9244
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2021 3:00 am

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Alexis Jacobi »

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 7:25 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 6:59 pm But you've already conceded the point, claiming "no one" will disagree. I assume that must include you, so we can move on, as soon as Mike sorts it out.
No, in order to even get to where we are now you must acknowledge a wide range of points that were brought up. Then you can say you are in the conversation.

IC: you must know that I am on to your tactics. Maybe others here are too, maybe they are not, I’ll leave it to them to say.
I wrote: “You present overt religious enthusiasm as if it is a “rational” thing. The argument you accrete around this, is game.”
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Immanuel Can »

Alexis Jacobi wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 7:28 pm I wrote: “You present overt religious enthusiasm as if it is a “rational” thing.
Well, that was silly of you. The Law of Non-Contradiction does not require "enthusiasm" for anything. It's just plain true.
Post Reply