Absolutely right!MikeNovack wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 3:14 pmThere is a fundamental difference between "don't know" and "cannot know". "Don't know" includes the potential of knowing while "cannot know" does not.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Oct 29, 2026 1:18 am You can't disprove the Law of Non-Contradiction by saying, "we don't know which one is true." Because the thing we DO know from the trilemma, and cannot doubt, is HOW MANY ANSWERS CAN BE TRUE.
And that's why the fact that we know there is only one of three answers possible is so important: it's not just the gateway to future specific knowledge (although it is that), it's the gateway to the realization that knowledge is possible at all.
It's very simple. It has the simplicity of truth.And that trilemma is NOT so simple.
Yes, but for this specific point, that observation has absolutely no relevance. Logic is a universal language...or better, a universal operating system. No particular ideology claims it, and all of them have to use it. You're using it right now.You are a Christian.
As for the triune conception of God, I'm happy to make a case for it; but not yet, because I don't want to cloud the central issue with anything that can remotely seem partisan, even at first glance. Even if a particular religion, say Christianity or Judaism, had the dead wrong conception of God, and the Hindus or the Jains or the pagans were right, or nobody was right at all, the Law of Non-Contradiction would be unaffected by that. To contradict one's own basic premise, and then to suppose both could be true, would still be irrational, confused thinking...whoever did it.
That's where we are, right now. We're entertaining three different possibilities: there's one God, there's no God, there is a plurality. We needn't yet pick a horse to ride...we can hold three, for the present moment. What we know is that two are definitely wrong.
Plus, we've now eliminated relativism, universalism, inclusivism, etc. -- that is, if we're taking logic seriously.
That's a huge gain. And it's just the start.