Can't both be right?

Is there a God? If so, what is She like?

Moderators: AMod, iMod

Post Reply
MikeNovack
Posts: 1453
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm

Can't both be right?

Post by MikeNovack »

I've seen it expressed here, that if person A has beliefs about the divine, and person B has beliefs about the divine, and these beliefs are mutually contradictory, the following is certain ......... both can be false, one can be false and the other true, but both cannot be true.

Really? Let me tell you a story about a group of blind men and an elephant << text of story omitted --- if you don't already know the story you can easily find it on the web >>

What is this story about? EXACTLY THIS QUESTION. The story is a parable explaining of how/why we humans have such differing understanding of the divine. That the divine is so vast, and our ability to see/perceive it so limited, we can all have true, but contradictory versions.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Immanuel Can »

MikeNovack wrote: ↑Mon Oct 26, 2026 10:40 pm I've seen it expressed here, that if person A has beliefs about the divine, and person B has beliefs about the divine, and these beliefs are mutually contradictory, the following is certain ......... both can be false, one can be false and the other true, but both cannot be true.

Really? Let me tell you a story about a group of blind men and an elephant << text of story omitted --- if you don't already know the story you can easily find it on the web >>
It's soooo...silly. Are you seriously going to trot that one out again? It's so old, and so debunked.

The "six blind men from Hindustan" are all grabbing different parts of the elephant. Not the same parts, and saying opposite things: different parts. And none of them is grabbing the whole. They're not contradicting at all, so don't represent any demonstration of the Law of Non-Contradiction.

Let's try this again. Here are three statements.

1. There is one God.
2. There are multiple/many gods.
3. There are not gods, and not God.

These exhaust the possibilities, rationally speaking. There are no more. And they are, as per Aristotle, genuinely contradictory, genuinely opposite.

Now, how many can be true?
MikeNovack
Posts: 1453
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by MikeNovack »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Oct 26, 2026 10:50 pm
Let's try this again. Here are three statements.
1. There is one God.
2. There are multiple/many gods.
3. There are not gods, and not God.

These exhaust the possibilities, rationally speaking. There are no more. And they are, as per Aristotle, genuinely contradictory, genuinely opposite.
Now, how many can be true?
Well first of all, a minor correction. When you wrote "There is one God" you meant to write "There is exactly one God".

No, the story is about the reality that limited by our perceptual limitations, we can at best perceive the divine as exactly one god, more than one gods, or no gods.

Are you really willing to commit that THE DIVINE cannot at the same time be one God, many gods, or no gods? Explain to me what you mean by "The Trinity".
User avatar
FlashDangerpants
Posts: 9356
Joined: Mon Jan 04, 2016 11:54 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by FlashDangerpants »

MikeNovack wrote: ↑Mon Oct 26, 2026 10:40 pm I've seen it expressed here, that if person A has beliefs about the divine, and person B has beliefs about the divine, and these beliefs are mutually contradictory, the following is certain ......... both can be false, one can be false and the other true, but both cannot be true.

Really? Let me tell you a story about a group of blind men and an elephant << text of story omitted --- if you don't already know the story you can easily find it on the web >>

What is this story about? EXACTLY THIS QUESTION. The story is a parable explaining of how/why we humans have such differing understanding of the divine. That the divine is so vast, and our ability to see/perceive it so limited, we can all have true, but contradictory versions.
I think you've misunderstood by way of a misplaced word. You should have written mutually exclusive really rather than just contradictory. The parable of the blind men describing an elephant with regards only to the small portion of it that each can feel is not a counter to the principle of bivalence found in the Law of Excluded Middle.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Immanuel Can »

MikeNovack wrote: ↑Mon Oct 26, 2026 11:15 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Mon Oct 26, 2026 10:50 pm
Let's try this again. Here are three statements.
1. There is one God.
2. There are multiple/many gods.
3. There are not gods, and not God.

These exhaust the possibilities, rationally speaking. There are no more. And they are, as per Aristotle, genuinely contradictory, genuinely opposite.
Now, how many can be true?
Well first of all, a minor correction. When you wrote "There is one God" you meant to write "There is exactly one God".
"Only," you mean? I think that was evident, was it not?
...limited by our perceptual limitations...
No, no...the statements are ontological, not epistemological. We're not asking what people know, we're asking, what is the case? It's about the truth, not about perception.

Now, before we move on, answer the question. Now that you understand the three claims, how many of them can be true?
popeye1945
Posts: 3263
Joined: Sun Sep 12, 2021 2:12 am

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by popeye1945 »

Truth is experience, and always true to the biology doing the experiencing, until it is tested by a group or collective of biological subjects that do not agree with the individual biology's conclusion. Two differing biologies can differ, and both can be right according to their individual biologies, for again, experience/truth is always true to the biology doing the experiencing, and can only be found true or false through further biological evaluations. Remember, biological consciousness measures and gives meaning to all things.
User avatar
Fanman
Posts: 162
Joined: Wed Aug 19, 2026 5:43 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Fanman »

MikeNovack stated:
What is this story about? EXACTLY THIS QUESTION. The story is a parable explaining of how/why we humans have such differing understanding of the divine. That the divine is so vast, and our ability to see/perceive it so limited, we can all have true, but contradictory versions.
What I'm thinking is, when you say "limited," could you explain that? I wasn’t aware that we could perceive the divine at all. Through what human mechanisms would that be possible?
Impenitent
Posts: 6398
Joined: Wed Feb 10, 2010 2:04 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Impenitent »

MikeNovack wrote: ↑Mon Oct 26, 2026 10:40 pm I've seen it expressed here, that if person A has beliefs about the divine, and person B has beliefs about the divine, and these beliefs are mutually contradictory, the following is certain ......... both can be false, one can be false and the other true, but both cannot be true.

Really? Let me tell you a story about a group of blind men and an elephant << text of story omitted --- if you don't already know the story you can easily find it on the web >>

What is this story about? EXACTLY THIS QUESTION. The story is a parable explaining of how/why we humans have such differing understanding of the divine. That the divine is so vast, and our ability to see/perceive it so limited, we can all have true, but contradictory versions.
moral of the story: vote for the elephant

-Imp
MikeNovack
Posts: 1453
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by MikeNovack »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 2:05 am We're not asking what people know, we're asking, what is the case? It's about the truth, not about perception.

Now, before we move on, answer the question. Now that you understand the three claims, how many of them can be true?
No, that Jain story IS about what it is possible for people to know. You are holding that "truth" is meaningful even if it CANNOT be known. Or in very modern terms, either the cat is alive or the cat is not alive, not in some in between state by probability.

Let there be an opaque jar, containing beads. You are allowed to reach in, take hold of a bead, remove it, examine its color, and toss it back in. That is ALL you are able to do << you cannot, for example, dump the beads out and count them by pairs* -- presumed beyond human abilities >>

Your observations having ten times drawn a bead --- nine back and one white. Now it is true that exactly one of these next statements is TRUE

1) There are more black beads than white beads in the jar.
2) There are more white beads than black beads in the jar.
3) There are the same number of white beads as black beads.

Now your observation might cause you to believe "1" is the truth because if ether of the other true your observation unlikely by random chance. But not impossible. You have no CERTAIN knowledge of the truth, and according to the rules (limitation of being human) you CANNOT have that knowledge.

Back to this being a Jain story. Yes, according to the Jains, as long as you are still trapped on the wheel of birth, life, death, and reincarnation you WILL perceive the "ones that are all" as perhaps one god, perhaps several gods, perhaps no gods.




* matching by pairs works even if the number not finite
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Immanuel Can »

MikeNovack wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 3:49 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 2:05 am We're not asking what people know, we're asking, what is the case? It's about the truth, not about perception.

Now, before we move on, answer the question. Now that you understand the three claims, how many of them can be true?
No, that Jain story IS about what it is possible for people to know.
Yes, it is...which is what makes it utterly irrelevant to the question I'm asking. I'm asking what's TRUE, what's REAL, not how many people know it, or how complete or partial their knowledge might be. That's a different issue.
You are holding that "truth" is meaningful even if it CANNOT be known.

Nope. I'm not even opening the question of what we know about the answer. I'm just asking, given the three premises, in theory, what makes logical sense.

So now, let me remove the thing that seems to be misleading you.

1. There is one cat in this box (at this time, in this way).
2. There are some cats in this box (at the same time, in the same sense as above)
3. There is no cat, and no cats, in this box (at the same time, in the same sense as the two above).


How many of the cat claims can possibly be true, given it's the same time, same objects being referred to, and all terms other are being used in exactly the same sense.

And your answer is?
Impenitent
Posts: 6398
Joined: Wed Feb 10, 2010 2:04 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Impenitent »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 4:09 pm
MikeNovack wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 3:49 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 2:05 am We're not asking what people know, we're asking, what is the case? It's about the truth, not about perception.

Now, before we move on, answer the question. Now that you understand the three claims, how many of them can be true?
No, that Jain story IS about what it is possible for people to know.
Yes, it is...which is what makes it utterly irrelevant to the question I'm asking. I'm asking what's TRUE, what's REAL, not how many people know it, or how complete or partial their knowledge might be. That's a different issue.
You are holding that "truth" is meaningful even if it CANNOT be known.

Nope. I'm not even opening the question of what we know about the answer. I'm just asking, given the three premises, in theory, what makes logical sense.

So now, let me remove the thing that seems to be misleading you.

1. There is one cat in this box (at this time, in this way).
2. There are some cats in this box (at the same time, in the same sense as above)
3. There is no cat, and no cats, in this box (at the same time, in the same sense as the two above).


How many of the cat claims can possibly be true, given it's the same time, same objects being referred to, and all terms other are being used in exactly the same sense.

And your answer is?
give the cat back to Schrodinger

-Imp
MikeNovack
Posts: 1453
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by MikeNovack »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 4:09 pm
No, that Jain story IS about what it is possible for people to know.
Yes, it is...which is what makes it utterly irrelevant to the question I'm asking. I'm asking what's TRUE, what's REAL, not how many people know it, or how complete or partial their knowledge might be. That's a different issue.
You are holding that "truth" is meaningful even if it CANNOT be known. Correct?

Look, I do understand you, that while this truth cannot be known by "ordinary means" it can be known by "faith"/"belief". You consider truth known that way is meaningful truth. I, and some others, disagree. Hold that if ONLY knowable by "faith"/"belief" what is true not meaningful because somebody else can have different "faith"/"belief".

In other words, you cannot argue with other people "I know the truth and you don't" << they have no good reason to prefer your "faith"/"belief" to their own -- you can give them no good reason >> It might help you understand the situation if we took it away from talk about the divine and tried with something to which you have less emotional commitment.

Consider one of the still unproven conjectures of mathematics << remembering that since Godel, we know might be true but unprovable >> Suppose you were to tell somebody, "It's true", I have faith/belief that it is true". Do you expect them to accept that as an argument?
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Immanuel Can »

Impenitent wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 5:09 pm give the cat back to Schrodinger

-Imp
I'm not sure I can. He may have died.
User avatar
Immanuel Can
Posts: 30600
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by Immanuel Can »

MikeNovack wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 5:24 pm
Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 4:09 pm
No, that Jain story IS about what it is possible for people to know.
Yes, it is...which is what makes it utterly irrelevant to the question I'm asking. I'm asking what's TRUE, what's REAL, not how many people know it, or how complete or partial their knowledge might be. That's a different issue.
You are holding that "truth" is meaningful even if it CANNOT be known. Correct?
"Meaningful"? I only said that truth is truth, reality is reality, regardless of who knows.

Let us pretend neither of us knows how many cats are in the box, if any. Still, the question remains: is it possible for more than one answer to end up being right, when we open the box and see? For at that point, we will know the right answer: but long before that, we will know for certain how many right answers there can possibly be.

When are you going to answer the question?
MikeNovack
Posts: 1453
Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2025 1:17 pm

Re: Can't both be right?

Post by MikeNovack »

Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Tue Oct 27, 2026 6:16 pm Let us pretend neither of us knows how many cats are in the box, if any. Still, the question remains: is it possible for more than one answer to end up being right, when we open the box and see? For at that point, we will know the right answer: but long before that, we will know for certain how many right answers there can possibly be.

When are you going to answer the question?
Well IC, when you die, you will get to find out "the truth" (about your faith/belief). That's the only way to open the box.

How many answers they can be not particularly relevant. That there may be exactly one right answer is of no use if you CANNOT determine which of the possibilities it is.

The Jain story does not deny the one truth of the elephant. But as long as the men are blind, they cannot find that truth. The Jains are saying that blindness is part of who we are. To overcome that blindness is to become free of the wheel.
Post Reply