I heard you but just disagree. You CAN infer likelihoods regarding terms given 'memes' because they act as 'genes' that hint at origins. I also ONLY use them to show POSSIBLE rational roots. When you look at multiple names within religious scriptures, especially the collections that became the Judeao-Christian-Muslim sources, you CAN find TOO much 'coincidences' that point to my conjectures. But these are only SUPPORTS of where I come from regarding any religious roots.Maia wrote: ↑Tue Jun 24, 2025 10:35 amGuesswork is not usually recommended as the best way of conducting historical or etymological research. In any case, as I'm sure you must be aware, the German word for Jew, for example, is Jude, which makes its derivation from Judah even more obvious.Scott Mayers wrote: ↑Tue Jun 24, 2025 10:08 am
I can't help that the etymology of words is politically affected. While my own assertion is guesswork to a degree on etymology, we have no choice with respect to terms that DO have a high circumstantial likelihood of being altered. Almost all the names in the Bible(s) are actually secular-based words.
On your school trip thing, I think you are probably not telling us everything. I'm guessing you were intentional to say that you are not an Israeli. But were you on one of the Israelism trips that Israel sponsors for JEWS? Or was it one with some Christian group. WHERE IS YOUR SCHOOL? It has to be nearby if you weren't being sponsored or that trip from living afar would seem an odd place to choose to go ....and with a whole class?
I think you are leaving something out. And why would you assert these as 'thoughts on Israel' in the still obviously weird context of a kind of happy-go-lucky vacation to Disneyland during a hurricane. !
What I actually said is that I'm not Jewish, but since you asked, I'm not Israeli, either. I'm English, and my school is in Worcester, England. The trip wasn't sponsored by Israel, and was funded by the school itself, with parental contributions, as an educational trip for the sixth form. In different years they go to different places, but for us, it was Israel.
If you think I'm leaving something out about the trip, please feel free to ask anything you like. I'm always happy to go on at length about places I've visited.
I am against Israel's state of existence on the basis that it is DEFINED indifferently to 'fascism' as I express in many places. I apologize if this discussion was not what you intended. But I only read it in the first place due to the title alone. I do thank you for HOW you respond respectfully, though. If you feel I am hijacking your intent, just let me know and I'll stop discussing that here.