Of course there are some forms of political repression that justify violent revolution. When laws are unjust, criminal behavior is often morally sound..Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sat Apr 05, 2025 5:49 pmOh. So you don't know of any such real "protesters" these days, but just hope that today's will turn out to be the good, non-violent kind?
"Vociferously" has never been a problem. But "violently, " that absolutely is. So is "criminally," as when looting, burning, beating and pillaging are reframed as forms of "protest."I could hardly blame them if they object vocifrously to their basic rights being threatened and the separation of governmental powers bring dismantled.
So yeah, I guess we'll see what this lot is: we've already seen what the last lots have been like recently.
The Democrat Party Hates America
Re: The Democrat Party Hates America
- Immanuel Can
- Posts: 27604
- Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm
Re: The Democrat Party Hates America
You'll have to be more specific. Are you suggesting there's "repression" in the present case, and of such a nature that it excuses criminality and warrants violence?Alexiev wrote: ↑Sat Apr 05, 2025 6:00 pmOf course there are some forms of political repression that justify violent revolution.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sat Apr 05, 2025 5:49 pmOh. So you don't know of any such real "protesters" these days, but just hope that today's will turn out to be the good, non-violent kind?
"Vociferously" has never been a problem. But "violently, " that absolutely is. So is "criminally," as when looting, burning, beating and pillaging are reframed as forms of "protest."I could hardly blame them if they object vocifrously to their basic rights being threatened and the separation of governmental powers bring dismantled.
So yeah, I guess we'll see what this lot is: we've already seen what the last lots have been like recently.
It can't be in reference to this little Leftist hissy fit, can it? https://www.youtube.com/shorts/V8YSgWu3e9o
Re: The Democrat Party Hates America
I don't "have to be" anything. The notion that "criminality" is inevitably horrid is ridiculous. I couldn't quite stomach your nauseating video. Wasn't Jesus crucified in accordance with the law? I suppose that was necessary to salvation, but surely you don't approve. Trump's attempts to overrule the judiciary threaten justice far more than a few broken windows.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sat Apr 05, 2025 6:11 pm [
You'll have to be more specific. Are you suggesting there's "repression" in the present case, and of such a nature that it excuses criminality and warrants violence?
It can't be in reference to this little Leftist hissy fit, can it? https://www.youtube.com/shorts/V8YSgWu3e9o
- Immanuel Can
- Posts: 27604
- Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm
Re: The Democrat Party Hates America
Well, you will if you want anybody to be able to know what you're referring to.Alexiev wrote: ↑Sat Apr 05, 2025 6:55 pmI don't "have to be" anything.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sat Apr 05, 2025 6:11 pm
You'll have to be more specific. Are you suggesting there's "repression" in the present case, and of such a nature that it excuses criminality and warrants violence?
It can't be in reference to this little Leftist hissy fit, can it? https://www.youtube.com/shorts/V8YSgWu3e9o
It was a guy just talking, and making a very simple and good point: unless you're in favour of graft and corruption in government, there's no basis for complaint.I couldn't quite stomach your nauseating video.
Well, in America, the "judiciary" is not supposed to make laws; only to interpret and then pronounce the applications of those laws that already exist. Enforcement of that falls on the police and the penal system. They also don't make laws.Trump's attempts to overrule the judiciary...
The president, on the other hand, and the congress, have the right to make laws. So when the judiciary tries to make a law, or to prevent the actions of a democratically elected government, then the judiciary is behaving in an anti-democratic way. They should not be allowed to do that: they're not elected, not democratic, and not the government body appointed for that purpose.
Unless you're a fan of arbitrary judicial tyranny, I think you should have no problem with that.
Then perhaps you should explain just how "broken windows" constitute "protest." It's certainly not obvious that they do. They constitute vandalism, for sure, and often breaking-and-entering, as well. They certainly constitute violence. But it's not at all clear how breaking windows amounts to a political statement. Maybe you can clear that up....threaten justice far more than a few broken windows.
Re: The Democrat Party Hates America
By the way,, if anyone is concerned with criminal behavior, it is Donald Trump who was found guilty of it on 30-somethung counts. A few broken windows or illegal tags are small potatoes.
Re: The Democrat Party Hates America
I'll agree the guy in the video was a simpleton. Good point!Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sat Apr 05, 2025 7:20 pm
It was a guy just talking, and making a very simple and good point: unless you're in favour of graft and corruption in government, there's no basis for
Well, in America, the "judiciary" is not supposed to make laws; only to interpret and then pronounce the applications of those laws that already exist. Enforcement of that falls on the police and the penal system. They also don't make laws.
The President doesn't make laws here either, although Trump seems to think he does. Why don't you worry about your own country (whatever that is)? I'll join the protests about mine. I probably won't break any windows, but if I see you I'll call ICE and have you incarcerated.
- Immanuel Can
- Posts: 27604
- Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:42 pm
Re: The Democrat Party Hates America
Technically, that's so; but pratically, he makes "executive orders" that determine the policy and actual practices of the government. Obama was big on using those.Alexiev wrote: ↑Sat Apr 05, 2025 7:30 pmThe President doesn't make laws here either, although Trump seems to think he does.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sat Apr 05, 2025 7:20 pm
It was a guy just talking, and making a very simple and good point: unless you're in favour of graft and corruption in government, there's no basis for
Well, in America, the "judiciary" is not supposed to make laws; only to interpret and then pronounce the applications of those laws that already exist. Enforcement of that falls on the police and the penal system. They also don't make laws.
I don't "worry" at all. But practically, the world is affected by what is allowed to go on in America, of course, so everybody has some stake in being interested in what goes on there. However, that's not even relevant: the only question is, what's a real "protest," and what's merely violence, looting, silencing, assaulting, and such? That question has no borders.Why don't you worry about your own country (whatever that is)?
-
promethean75
- Posts: 7113
- Joined: Sun Nov 04, 2018 10:29 pm
Re: The Democrat Party Hates America
"By the way,, if anyone is concerned with criminal behavior, it is Donald Trump who was found guilty of it on 30-somethung counts. A few broken windows or illegal tags are small potatoes."
That would fall on deaf ears, of course. Even though the financial losses caused by Trump (his trials alone probably cost more than all the shattered store front windows and burnt cars combined... forget about his tax evasion and stealing from the government) are much higher and longer lasting, they ignore that part.
A Trumpster can only be a buffoon in too many ways to count, dude. At every turn, there is some nugget waiting to be picked up and pointed out. You just have to wait. Usually, it's not long.
That would fall on deaf ears, of course. Even though the financial losses caused by Trump (his trials alone probably cost more than all the shattered store front windows and burnt cars combined... forget about his tax evasion and stealing from the government) are much higher and longer lasting, they ignore that part.
A Trumpster can only be a buffoon in too many ways to count, dude. At every turn, there is some nugget waiting to be picked up and pointed out. You just have to wait. Usually, it's not long.
-
promethean75
- Posts: 7113
- Joined: Sun Nov 04, 2018 10:29 pm
Re: The Democrat Party Hates America
Btw that was an exercise in sophistry, specifically the employment of a form of pathos in presuading you.
I have no idea what the costs were and if they compare to the costs of the looters damage... but i still had you. If only for a second. You thought, "Holy shit he's prolly right" and it didn't even cross your mind to want to check those numbers. I totally had you bro and you were ready to hate the Don just like that. It was that easy. It was how i said it. So fast, so certainly.
Now remember pathos as a rhetorical device is everywhere in the world of disseminating information. Always be weary of this and learn to identify it.
I have no idea what the costs were and if they compare to the costs of the looters damage... but i still had you. If only for a second. You thought, "Holy shit he's prolly right" and it didn't even cross your mind to want to check those numbers. I totally had you bro and you were ready to hate the Don just like that. It was that easy. It was how i said it. So fast, so certainly.
Now remember pathos as a rhetorical device is everywhere in the world of disseminating information. Always be weary of this and learn to identify it.
Re: The Democrat Party Hates America
Democrat reasoning:Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Thu Apr 03, 2025 8:52 pmDon't you? If not, then maybe you can explain why looting, pillaging, burning, assaulting and trashing cities are not examples of doing evil.Gary Childress wrote: ↑Thu Apr 03, 2025 6:30 pmSo, do you believe that current protests are led by or full of "evil people"?
- Because freedom of speech includes freedom of expression, incendiary rhetoric and incendiary actions both get first amendment protection. Exceptions to the protection become wordy topics for legal debate. This is why flag burning, without a word spoken, is constitutionally protected free speech.
- Democrats figure that realistically, the peacefulness required for assembly, as required by the first amendment of the US constitution, actually means “mostly peaceful,” because complete peace is merely an ill-defined, subjective and relative conceptual ideal.
- Pockets of violence such as an active arson backdrop to a live news report get excused as “mostly peaceful,” because freedom of expression such as arson is as necessary as broken eggs.
- Of course, there is that murky gray conflict with law and morality, but any-means-necessary is a big, self-forgiving umbrella that facilitates the robust and vigorous ignoring of inconvenient rules, regulations and laws.
Re: The Democrat Party Hates America
You are right. Trump is destroying the global economy. Foreigners might not have the right to despise him as much as we Americans, but they are correct in thinking he is a horrible president.Immanuel Can wrote: ↑Sat Apr 05, 2025 9:12 pmI don't "worry" at all. But practically, the world is affected by what is allowed to go on in America, of course, so everybody has some stake in being interested in what goes on there. However, that's not even relevant: the only question is, what's a real "protest," and what's merely violence, looting, silencing, assaulting, and such? That question has no borders.
Re: The Democrat Party Hates America
And everything was moving along so smoothly until he came along.
Here’s another reason why the Swamp shall rise again.
“When the people find that they can vote themselves money, that will herald the end of the republic.” -- Ben Franklin
Here’s another reason why the Swamp shall rise again.
“When the people find that they can vote themselves money, that will herald the end of the republic.” -- Ben Franklin
-
Impenitent
- Posts: 5775
- Joined: Wed Feb 10, 2010 2:04 pm
Re: The Democrat Party Hates America
destroying the global economy by bringing manufacturing back to America...
-Imp
-Imp
Re: The Democrat Party Hates America
What could be more hideous than equitable tariffs for economies geared towards social engineering projects and dependent on ripping off Uncle Sam? Oh, the humanity.Impenitent wrote: ↑Sun Apr 06, 2025 3:59 pm destroying the global economy by bringing manufacturing back to America...
-Imp
Re: The Democrat Party Hates America
What did Dr. Franklin say about dismantling the balance of powers he helped desigb?