Harbal wrote: ↑Sun Jun 23, 2024 12:21 pm
Age wrote: ↑Sun Jun 23, 2024 11:21 am
Harbal wrote: ↑Sun Jun 23, 2024 9:20 am
So there is only one mind, but many individual psyches?
There are, obviously, many individual human bodies. And, just as obviously all of those different human bodies have many different individual and invisible thoughts, within.
It is the invisible individual 'thoughts', and 'emotions', within human bodies that is what the words 'individual psyche' means and is referring to, exactly?
Well I consider the mind to be part of the psyche,
Fair enough, 'you' are absolutely free to consider absolutely any thing at all.
Harbal wrote: ↑Sun Jun 23, 2024 12:21 pm
which means one mind per psyche,
So, to you;
What is the 'mind', exactly, to you?
How many other parts are there to 'the psyche', besides the 'mind part'?
What is the 'psyche', exactly? And,
What is the 'psyche' made up of, exactly?
Harbal wrote: ↑Sun Jun 23, 2024 12:21 pm
so there are as many minds as psyches, as far as I'm concerned.
Okay. Do you have any actual proof for this? Or, at least, any evidence, at all?
Or, is this just some thing that you consider to be true, right, accurate, and correct?
Harbal wrote: ↑Sun Jun 23, 2024 12:21 pm
What makes the 'human psyche" is the individual different thoughts, and emotions, within individual different human bodies.
Thoughts occur in minds, to my understanding, and individual bodies are associated with individual minds.
So, to you, 'thoughts' occur in 'minds', and 'minds' are 'a part of psyches'.
Also, obviously to you, 'individual minds' are associated with 'individual bodies'.
Harbal wrote: ↑Sun Jun 23, 2024 12:21 pm
Obviously, human bodies are just physical things, only. Physical things are not 'psyches', themselves. The words 'human psyche' refers to the invisible individual 'thoughts', and 'thinking', within. After all, this is, literally, where different persons, and different personalities, exist, and dwell.
I believe it is widely held that the mind is also part of the "within", and I can't see why you assert its absence.
In what Universe have I ever asserted that the Mind is absent of 'within human bodies'?
I have continually stated that the Mind is within human bodies.
I am, really, struggling trying to understand 'what words' these people here are seeing under the name and label 'Age' here.
How many times does one have to state that the Mind is within, before others stop believing that I am asserting the that the Mind is not within.
.
Harbal wrote: ↑Sun Jun 23, 2024 12:21 pm
The different individual personalities, within different individual human bodies, is what the 'different individual psyche' means, refers to, and is, exactly.
I would still say the mind is part of the psyche.
Okay, and again you are absolutely free to say 'this', or say absolutely any thing else, but why would you, still, say that 'the mind' is part of the 'psyche'.
What actual reason is there why you would, still, say this?
Besides, of course, the reason that 'this' is what you have heard and have been told, most of your life.
Harbal wrote: ↑Sun Jun 23, 2024 12:21 pm
Now, for those who want to insist there are many minds, or different 'my minds', then please explain where and what these different minds are, exactly.
I don't think I can give a satisfactory explanation. Will you explain where the one mind is?
As I have said previous, but which you have obviously missed.
The invisible Mind is within all things. The Mind is like 'knowing' is within a human body. The Mind exists within all human bodies, and which is the invisible thing that always allows all human beings, individually and collectively to learn, understand, and reason absolutely any thing and every thing. This mind is absolutely everywhere in all things.
Harbal wrote: ↑Sun Jun 23, 2024 12:21 pm
For absolutely any one who is interested, every time the word 'mind' is used to refer to some thing about you human beings individually, I can show that what is actually being referred to is the 'thoughts' or 'thinking' within a human body, instead.
Yes, and those thoughts constitute the mind,
To you, 'thoughts' are a part of 'the mind', and 'the mind' is a part of 'the psyche', right?
Also, why did you say and write, 'Yes', here? What I said and wrote is absolutely nothing in line with what you just said and wrote, here.
or are within the mind, I'm not really sure, but, either way, a mind is involved.[/quote]
Do you know what you sound like to me here "harbal"?
If no, then you sound like a "theist" here. you, just like a "theist" will say and claim that a 'mind' exists, but when questioned and challenged over what the 'mind' is, exactly, you, like the "theist" have absolutely no real idea nor clue, at all. Just saying 'it' is a part of some thing, and 'it' has parts itself, is really not saying any thing at all.
What you are doing here is, exactly, what a "theist" does. you have both heard 'things' previously, from others you worship or trust, and then you both just started believing what you have been told is true, and from their 'your beliefs' are stopping and preventing both of you from learning, understanding, and reasoning what the actual Truth is, here.
Harbal wrote: ↑Sun Jun 23, 2024 12:21 pm
The Mind is the thing that allows ALL human beings, equally, to be able to learn, understand, reason, any and every thing, as well as what allows all to do and achieve what 'it' is that is set out to do, and achieve.
I agree that in order to learn and understand, we need a mind, but the ability of minds varies from individual to individual, and all are not equal.
I already 'know' what you believe is true. But, that you cannot back up and support your beliefs at all here, is not helping 'me' to want to follow 'you' in your beliefs here.