uwot wrote: ↑Sun May 29, 2022 10:04 pm
Age wrote: ↑Sun May 29, 2022 9:44 pm... let us give you the benefit here and imagine that you REALLY were Truly OPEN...
What a generous soul you are.
Age wrote: ↑Sun May 29, 2022 9:44 pm...then I would begin by seeking clarity from you that redshift means that the objects that are shifted towards the red end of the spectrum are moving away from the 'observer'...
Redshift due to the Doppler effect has been observed in laboratories and planets that probes have visited. Redshift on the scale of the solar system is comprehensively verified.
How long is this going to take?
WHY does it seem IMPOSSIBLE for you to just answer the ACTUAL CLARIFY QUESTION posed to you the FIRST TIME?
Now, “redshift on the scale of the solar system is comprehensively verified“ in relation to 'what', EXACTLY?
IF you are going to say in relation to an expanding Universe ONCE MORE, then we are BACK to the beginning, ONCE AGAIN.
As I have ALREADY NOTED:
Once we have agreed and accepted what red and blue shift 'data' concludes, then we can move along.
So, the quicker you are, the quicker this can be resolved ONCE, and for ALL.
uwot wrote: ↑Sun May 29, 2022 10:04 pm
Age wrote: ↑Sun May 29, 2022 9:44 pm...that is; the instrument taking the 'data', and the objects shifted towards the other end of the spectrum, that is; the blue end, are blue shifted and moving towards the 'observer', correct?
Where do you think the observer is in relation to the "instrument taking the 'data'"?
NOT being IT, but being somewhere ELSE in relation to IT, OBVIOUSLY.
Unless, OF COURSE, you have been PRESUMING there is some instrument within the human body that has a blue end and a red end end to it. Have you?
See, the instrument used for observing red and blue shift could be placed on an out in space telescope and/or on another planet, for example, and the 'data' send back to human beings, but anyway, OBVIOUSLY, the instrument is NEVER EXACTLY where a person, another observer IS.