-1- wrote: ↑Sun Jul 28, 2019 10:56 am
I thank you for the intelligent reply toward me -1 (I agree fully with all you say in it - but wish to comment on some - not to dissagree, just to clarify me views of film/themes etc.
-1- wrote: ↑Sun Jul 28, 2019 10:56 am
I watched it on Canadian tv back when it was airing brand new.
It is a good movie. Realistic.
The most gripping scene for me was the line "Them bastards... they done it." That actually haunted me for days, weeks, maybe even years.
Threads was shown in PBS in a years later - 85 or 86 (so i've been told, i was around then and rem seeing others Brit works via PBS - watership down for instance - but i missed the Threads offering, and so did not know of it until running accross it via YT around 2012 or so - copied the Netfix DVD rental, shortly after, and then bought the Shout Bluray of the same film a couple of years ago).
-1- wrote: ↑Sun Jul 28, 2019 10:56 am
BUT.
There is no character development.
There is no moral story-line.
It is a documentary, very well made, made as if happened, of a hypothetical future event. That is fine, i have nothing against it. Except it's not an artistic film. It is a documentary, and you have to valuate it as such.
fully agree, its a "disaster flick" and so by its nature cannot offer a smaller picture (well it could it it wanted to - and be A Testement - type film (but the latter film is not so good in character dev (thought its nature was to be so - in otherwords A Testament is decent but not grand, and the former's nature was intended to be more global, so not able nor interested in character devolopment.
I understand the differing natures of films, and thier intend.
I love Threads - though hate disaster films in general because they lack personal/fleshed out characters - i love Threads because it is the most realistic (i.e. Post apocalypse reality on the ground - 10+ plus after - from the poor crops due to nuc winter to the cateracts and luckemia(sp) via loss of ozone, to the evolution of english into a new form due to no reading to fix it in form) - "Gizit" lol
the latter is what stuck with me, the mutation of language into "pig-english" 10 yrs after the complete breakdown of cizilization. (this is a SMART film, and including mutation of language shows this - along with the other 2 points about post war and colapse of civilization will offer the survivers.
-1- wrote: ↑Sun Jul 28, 2019 10:56 am
It is a very good film, a very good documentary.
agreed.
-1- wrote: ↑Sun Jul 28, 2019 10:56 am
When I watch a show I don't like to see a documentary. But that's just me.
ok, i like any good film myself - whatever their form.
The Bridge - about suiciders on the Golden Gate, and Somewhere Between - about Chinese American kids adopted in america stuck in their indentity as American or chinese - both are excellent documentaries with heart, but if you don't like docs, thats ok.
as for me i like any good film regardless of their form.
-1- wrote: ↑Sun Jul 28, 2019 10:56 am
When I saw it on Canadian tv first-run, it was titled not "thread" but "the day after the day after." The Americans had released a similar movie, "the day after" and this is a cover of that movie with a British accent.
I haven't seen the American movie, but I tell you, the British version of movie for tv was much better. The Amy make was too full of religious innuendoes.
don't waster your time with The Day After - i saw it in 83? - it was the usual hollywood pap. you missed nothing Sir.
---------------
I love more personal movies about character dev (in fact my fav films are good dramas)
the best one is The Lives of Others - where the mane character starts out is a true believer/patriot for East Germany (a Stazi agent) - we see him in his bland apartment paying for sex, then later forming an emotional connection with the man he is spying on (and seeing his boss as an opportunist, rather than a true believer), later we see him stealing a book on poetry from the man he is spying on and reading it (and become more that he was prior). i.e. we see him grow in outlook (not character - he was always a good man - just limited by is cultural indocrination as a patriot for East Germany)
its a top 5 movie of all time - due to the above reason.
others great movies are:
A face in the Crowd
Zelary
12 yrs a slave ("the master is a good man"......................."but he is a slaver!" - yes and yes. of course he still sold his slave to another(no man is perfect, even if a good man that owns slaves (and yes per the movie i think the "slaver" figured out his slave was a former freed man - but failed to free him and instead sold him (slaves cost as much money as a car/house)
Burmese Harp (last letter to his former solders near end of movie is very moving letter/scene)
Song of Sparrows - we see a man who first had his head on straight, then let money corrupt him for a time - until he saw the Ostriches in Tehran (the scene where the he has a "big bill" and tries to find change to pay the begger girl is priceless) - then he came back to his true self (a good man - knowing what is important in this life)
Color of Paradise - where a father is ashamed of his son for being a burden and blind - he is more concerned with his own plight - being a widower - fixating upon marrying a women rather than support his son - we see this - and when the father finally understands his son and that he (the father) should and wants to step up, its "too late" (but its not really, for the Father finally became a Father/man in the end).
The Hunt ( here the main character does not grow - he is fully a man of character from the beginning - its all others (outside of his son and his son's godfather - they stand by him from the start and are honourable men) - esp his "best friend" who sells him down the river via that man's wife/peir pressure - some "best friend" (if mine was such a pussy i'd shoot myself - after shooting him first - lol). the "friend" comes around, but long afterward. and a true friend would never had turned in the first place - wife or no wife!
August Evening - about Mex Americans living in west TX
Apu Trilogy (3 movies - all 1950's films) Bengali.
so, ya, i prefer character devolopment type moves over "documentaries" - the former make me feel and relate as human with a heart.
Threads does not do that, nor was intended to.
its intent was to show a realistic picture of a post ww3 world in lands involved in that war.
and with its fully bleak picture it did so fully.
-
two other "docutmentaries" that do so are the older
War Day
and
Culloden
----------------
thanks for reply -1

.