Hobbes' Choice wrote:
MacDonald's sell more burgers than anyone else. What you describe is the same thing.
You can trace the evolution of many bands that show a clear drop in the quality of composition the moment they achieve fame and commercial success. There are notable exceptions, however.
Always felt that way and it seems the common, inevitable fate of contemporary musicians. Once they find their comfort zone of commercial success, won't take chances and the easiest bet is any known musical recipe that appeals to larger audiences.
Hobbes' Choice wrote:
Nonetheless - using commercial success as a measure of quality is absurd in the extreme.
I don't equate commercial success with aesthetic quality (nor with nutritional value), never did. I don't think the opposite is true either, I mean, there's no direct relationship: it can be commercially successful and have a good aesthetic (or nutritional) quality, or it may not. However, as all cultural products, music serves many functions, not only the aesthetic, contemplative one, and it can fit those other purposes in some ways better than others. Music in particular is useful, for example, for inducing mood states, none of which seems to be more valuable than others in terms of aesthetic qualities. That possibility is, however, exploited by the music industry, which designs and packs emotions for every public and all tastes (whether highbrow, midbrow or lowbrow), using well known formal rules of composition that have been around for centuries (typical chord progressions, scales, instrumentation, etc.). A mature, developed music business is often competent and masterful in knowing the rules and delivering the desired effects, while trying to repackage the conventional musical product to appear as something fresh and new (which we know it is not). Sometimes it does not show competence or it goes for the easiest trick (the danceable beat, the emotional emphasis, etc.) which for more sophisticated audiences may ruin everything. That happens with Mexico's "música norteña", which is absolute crap, and sells a lot.
Hobbes' Choice wrote:Take any manufactured "Boy Band", or "Girl Band". endless streams of formulaic repetition.
Using a previous analogy, yes: it's fast food with low nutritional value. Doesn't mean it's not being cooked as it is supposed to be.
Hobbes' Choice wrote:Who the f*** are Fania all stars.? (I looked them up - no need to answer) Traditional music played with heart is always good if not always successful - I imagine you could find their quality on any Saturday night in Rio or Havanna.
Fania All Stars was a musical project from the Fania record label in the early 70's, based in New York. It reunited already established Salsa icons and emerging artists from several Latin American countries in a set of live concerts and records. It's recognized as one of the highest development and major influence of Salsa music and most of its songs and artists are considered "the classics" of hardcore Salsa. Although it borrowed from some popular forms of music in said countries, it actually made original contributions and also fusions with other musical forms as jazz and even disco.
Hobbes' Choice wrote:I think that you come from a different musical tradition, where only the good survive. Things in the west have gone the other way.
Interesting that you think the "Latin world" is not part of the "west". Not that we find that label particularly worthy of something, but the homogenizing factors of capitalists society make most differences somehow irrelevant.
Hobbes' Choice wrote:We have lots of natural talents, as does the Latin world of music, but we have reached to stage of mass market mass production, where carefully packaged products are immediately indistinguishable from the real thing. Where even good musicians pander to the lower common denominator, and record producers can be the key 'artistic' force in the manufacture; through concept design, audition of thousands of singers, and the cobbling together of strangers to form aberrations like The Spice Girls; about as sincere in their music a budget Cola.
Not much different here, I guarantee.
Hobbes' Choice wrote:That is not to say that great music cannot be successful, but this usually comes about more organically, where the bands find each other and present themselves as a package to record companies; or the record companies find them and sign them. It is important that when this happens the band maintains artistic control, as loosing it tends to guarantee loss of conviction.
I completely agree.