.........................................................

.

So fucking what? They are our food! Do you think the animals give a damn about their food? Of course not! Did you know that most plants are poisonous? They don't 'want' to be eaten, so they have evolved toxins and bitter tastes so that animals will either be poisoned or discouraged from eating them! Nothing 'wants' to be eaten, not even plants! So fucking what? Meat-eating is part of our evolutionary makeup.Ned wrote:Spend a day in a chicken factory, with your beak cut off, constrained in a tiny space so you can hardly move, and see how you would enjoy being a food animal.
Have you ever had a pet? Would you have kept your dog or cat like that?
If not, why not?
What's the difference between one living thing (a pet) and another (a food animal)?
They are both alive, they both feel fear and pain exactly in the same way.
Think about it -- maybe not too late for you?
So you are a psychopath, without empathy. Of course you can't help that. You were bred to be a jerk. You might be food yourself one day.Melchior wrote:So fucking what? They are food!Ned wrote:Spend a day in a chicken factory, with your beak cut off, constrained in a tiny space so you can hardly move, and see how you would enjoy being a food animal.
Have you ever had a pet? Would you have kept your dog or cat like that?
If not, why not?
What's the difference between one living thing (a pet) and another (a food animal)?
They are both alive, they both feel fear and pain exactly in the same way.
Think about it -- maybe not too late for you?


A man walked up to me on the street last week, and said "I haven't had a bite in a week!" So I bit him.vegetariantaxidermy wrote:So you are a psychopath, without empathy. Of course you can't help that. You were bred to be a jerk. You might be food yourself one day.Melchior wrote:So fucking what? They are food!Ned wrote:Spend a day in a chicken factory, with your beak cut off, constrained in a tiny space so you can hardly move, and see how you would enjoy being a food animal.
Have you ever had a pet? Would you have kept your dog or cat like that?
If not, why not?
What's the difference between one living thing (a pet) and another (a food animal)?
They are both alive, they both feel fear and pain exactly in the same way.
Think about it -- maybe not too late for you?
...and that is where the problem lies. We all know and we don't like to be reminded of it!vegetariantaxidermy wrote:For fuck sake! We all know what goes on. We don't need it shoved in our face you fucking sicko!
Lawrence Crocker wrote:If I were asked to judge the debate so far, I would have to give the palm to the vegetarians.
The argument that the pain of animals bred to be food doesn't count morally invites the objection that second and third generation slaves were bred to be slaves. They would not have existed but for slavery. Still we don't think this justified their being held in servitude.
The vegetarian is at least justified in asking whether non-existence is better than existence as a factory chicken.
I am not sure there is anything inconsistent morally in not being a consistent vegetarian. One might believe that killing a chimpanzee for food was worse than killing a cow which is worse than killing a fish which is worse than killing a snail which is worse than killing a locust. Our theory of levels of consciousness of animals may be a little crude, but it is surely onto something. Nature of pain felt, length of time it is appreciated, ability to anticipate it all seem to be morally relevant variables.
Of course. Hiding your eyes is typical for the demented.Ned wrote:Mel, as of now you are on my ignore list. I don't need to see any more of your malevolent, infantile, idiotic comments.
Don't bother to answer, I won't see it.
I'm not sure whether to say 'yeah right' or 'why doesn't that surprise me?'Melchior wrote: I have a degree in philosophy.
Yes, they have 'feelings', and yes, we eat them without feeling the slightest guilt. Just like other omnivores and carnivores.vegetariantaxidermy wrote:
Being 'bred for food' doesn't render them machines without feelings. I also think you are referring to self-righteous 'faux vegetarians', the ones who claim to be 'vegetarian' but still eat fish and chicken (and secretly probably every other kind of meat), and talk about it all the time. I have a cousin who became a vegetarian at the age of five, as soon as he discovered what meat was. Nothing would induce him to eat it. He's pretty much only lived on nuts ever since. He never mentions it to anyone. He's also a genius.
vegetariantaxidermy wrote:I'm not sure whether to say 'yeah right' or 'why doesn't that surprise me?'Melchior wrote: I have a degree in philosophy.
What have you been presenting then? Irrational garbage and insults about 'hippies'. Did you know that farm animal farts are a big contributor to global warming? Let me guess, you don't believe in global warming either. It's just a 'lefty libtard' conspiracy to stop yanks from fucking up the planet and having fun in hummers, or whatever those huge tanks are called that yanks love to drive around in.Melchior wrote:vegetariantaxidermy wrote:I'm not sure whether to say 'yeah right' or 'why doesn't that surprise me?'Melchior wrote: I have a degree in philosophy.
I don't fall for bad arguments, ever.