~ Celebrate – Black History Month! ~

How should society be organised, if at all?

Moderators: AMod, iMod

User avatar
Kayla
Posts: 1206
Joined: Wed Feb 02, 2011 6:31 am

Re: ~ Celebrate – Black History Month! ~

Post by Kayla »

Arising_uk wrote:
What the Europeans did do was introduce racism as a justification for slavery and increased the trade by a fair chunk. But then they also banned it against their interests and in the name of common Christian humanity. So swings and roundabouts I think.
my understanding is that banning it was against the interests of rural landowners but very much in the interest of the rising industrial elite

the whole thing went down pretty much as carl marx suggested such things go down
User avatar
Arising_uk
Posts: 12259
Joined: Wed Oct 17, 2007 2:31 am

Re: ~ Celebrate – Black History Month! ~

Post by Arising_uk »

Kayla wrote:my understanding is that banning it was against the interests of rural landowners but very much in the interest of the rising industrial elite
Maybe in the case of the US but I think that over here there wasn't much slavery in the farming sense, more city based financiers, merchant shippers, etc, so large vested interest in keeping the trade. But I accept that many may also have had investments in plantations. I'd have thought that industry would have made a large profit from not having to pay its workers?
the whole thing went down pretty much as carl marx suggested such things go down
Really? Karl said this how?
Blaggard
Posts: 2245
Joined: Fri Jan 10, 2014 9:17 pm

Re: ~ Celebrate – Black History Month! ~

Post by Blaggard »

Arising_uk wrote:
Blaggard wrote:Let's not forget who perpetrated the crime of slavery in the first place, ...
That'll be the Arabs and the African tribal leaders then. Although Slavery had been around for thousands of years before them.
was it not European imperial machinations that created a need for somewhere like America and then taxed the bugger into rebellion. :P ...
Be fair, all we asked them was to pay a bit towards the cost of beating the French and Spanish.

What the Europeans did do was introduce racism as a justification for slavery and increased the trade by a fair chunk. But then they also banned it against their interests and in the name of common Christian humanity. So swings and roundabouts I think.
Actually that would still be the Europeans, supply and demand, if there was no demand for slaves the Arabs/African slave dealers would not of rounded up whole villages of black races and sold them to the Portuquese and others. The new world demanded workers and you couldn't supply enough, so they went to the slave traders and asked for bodies to make up the numbers when Spain and Portugal who were also at war with each other, were seen to make money the rest of Europe quickly tried to get in on the act and the French, The English and the Dutch amongst many others moved in. The 17th century is the age of war for profit, it also created privateering, sailing under a letter of the marque as a sort of mercenary army or armada, which later became piracy which lasted well into the 19th century although it had been stamped out for the most part in the Caribbean by then; it was still lucrative to attack slave ships and cargo ships off West and East Africa and piracy it seems has resurged again in the Arabian peninsular area, FSM will be pleased. ;)

What actually ended the slave trade was the age of liberalism, it was seen as a hypocrisy by the French in particular that all men being created equal entailed that some were clearly, or thought they were clearly more equal than others. Really Christianity did play a part but a more minor part than you would think
(after all the bible condones slavery so it was often used to justify it), the age of enlightenment, and scholarly admonishment was by far the greater reason for the abolishment of slavery in many countries after such sentiments spread.

This creating of a massive market for slaves can only be laid at one door Europe's, the short fall was often filled with identured servitude usually people who had committed crimes that did not warrant the death penalty but also vast numbers of debtors, the more recidivist criminals and or white paid labour and colonists who had gone seeking profit in the new world and the like, clearly though such labour was not favoured for obvious reasons.

It's interesting to note of course after the American war for independence they sent out slave blockades with limited success to try and end the trade, The Amistad I mentioned before was one such ship caught off Africa which eventually lead to the slave trades abolition and then to the American civil war.



Where profit goes the rats follow.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EZFr4VLPW9Q

You should probably watch this link I gave earlier, it is most interesting. :)

Of course the speech is a matter of legal and historical record, the artistic flair is a matter of taste. ;)
bobevenson
Posts: 7346
Joined: Tue Mar 03, 2009 12:02 am
Contact:

Re: ~ Celebrate – Black History Month! ~

Post by bobevenson »

Blaggard wrote:Where profit goes the rats follow.
Spoken like a true head-in-the-sand socialist.
Blaggard
Posts: 2245
Joined: Fri Jan 10, 2014 9:17 pm

Re: ~ Celebrate – Black History Month! ~

Post by Blaggard »

bobevenson wrote:
Blaggard wrote:Where profit goes the rats follow.
Spoken like a true head-in-the-sand socialist.
Lol I am not even a socialist. You are one weird person, you see everyone who is not a staunch capitalist or neocon or tea party religionist as a socialist, man get your head out of the sand. ;)

Have you ever heard of the rat race?

Do you even understand simile?

Is your politics hence just one big dog pile of tea party rhetoric or do you have something else to say, because I am finding it hard to make sense of your bizarre and out of this world political nonsense. No offence.
bobevenson
Posts: 7346
Joined: Tue Mar 03, 2009 12:02 am
Contact:

Re: ~ Celebrate – Black History Month! ~

Post by bobevenson »

Blaggard wrote:
bobevenson wrote:
Blaggard wrote:Where profit goes the rats follow.
Spoken like a true head-in-the-sand socialist.
Lol I am not even a socialist. You are one weird person, you see everyone who is not a staunch capitalist or neocon or tea party religionist as a socialist, man get your head out of the sand. ;)

Have you ever heard of the rat race?

Do you even understand simile?

Is your politics hence just one big dog pile of tea party rhetoric or do you have something else to say, because I am finding it hard to make sense of your bizarre and out of this world political nonsense. No offence.
Exactly what do you have against profits?
Blaggard
Posts: 2245
Joined: Fri Jan 10, 2014 9:17 pm

Re: ~ Celebrate – Black History Month! ~

Post by Blaggard »

bobevenson wrote: Exactly what do you have against profits?
Nothing at all, and why you brought it up kinda bemuses me? I am if anything a liberal pro democracy, pro capitalism within certain limits and pro nothing to do with collectivism or any of that communist guff. :)

All I meant to say was that the rats by which I mean the rat race will always follow profit, I said it badly obviously but I hardly think anything I said meant I was saying communism rules! screw the capitalists, you will be first against the wall come the revolution. Although you seemed to take it so...

Genuinely I am not a Marxist, communist or socialist, why you have pegged me as such seems to be a result of your own biases.

I made £30 on the stock market today in shares, I am well aware of the benefits of capitalism over shared collective wealth. Hell I got quite rich to the tune of £6000 recently off of the stock market so I would be a hypocrite to complain about my accumulated wealth. :P
bobevenson
Posts: 7346
Joined: Tue Mar 03, 2009 12:02 am
Contact:

Re: ~ Celebrate – Black History Month! ~

Post by bobevenson »

Sorry if I put words in your mouth, but you do come across as somebody against free-market capitalism.
User avatar
Kayla
Posts: 1206
Joined: Wed Feb 02, 2011 6:31 am

Re: ~ Celebrate – Black History Month! ~

Post by Kayla »

Arising_uk wrote:
Kayla wrote:my understanding is that banning it was against the interests of rural landowners but very much in the interest of the rising industrial elite
Maybe in the case of the US but I think that over here there wasn't much slavery in the farming sense, more city based financiers, merchant shippers, etc, so large vested interest in keeping the trade. But I accept that many may also have had investments in plantations. I'd have thought that industry would have made a large profit from not having to pay its workers?
if you are a slaver owner you keep needing more slaves

you can get more slaves - such as through the slaver trade - but that can get expensive - if I recall a new healthy slave cost the equivalent of tens of thousands of $$$

slave can of course reproduce but you then have to create the conditions where they can maintain their own population - but then you have to pay for the slave from birth to the point where they can work

but if you have wage slavery all you have to do is pay the workers for the time worked - much easier to work with especially when you have capital based rather than agrarian economy

do you think macdonalds would save any money if they did not have to pay their employees but were allowed to lock them up after the shift is over?
the whole thing went down pretty much as carl marx suggested such things go down
Really? Karl said this how?[/quote]

can't find any specific quote but see above - karl would have agreed with the above

it has to do with his philosophy of history - contradictions of a slave owning society force change
Blaggard
Posts: 2245
Joined: Fri Jan 10, 2014 9:17 pm

Re: ~ Celebrate – Black History Month! ~

Post by Blaggard »

bobevenson wrote:Sorry if I put words in your mouth, but you do come across as somebody against free-market capitalism.
Quite alright Bob I am not one to hold a grudge, I like your posts anyway, and your refreshing candour, it's nice to see someone express something other than the usual operation:mindcrime crap we get from the usual philosopher/suspects who didn't really learn what it was to think for themselves and just- well you get the point.

Keep on keeping on, no one will care but humans are for the most part idiots, you get used to it... :) :P
Post Reply