nationalism

For all things philosophical.

Moderators: AMod, iMod

Post Reply
bus2bondi
Posts: 1012
Joined: Fri Aug 29, 2008 3:08 am

nationalism

Post by bus2bondi »

i don't see anything wrong with it, unless its something that fuels something beyond, 'oh hey, i live over here yaaaaaay!' or 'i'm helping people out' type of thing.

can you imagine a world without nationalism? would it be kinda like this: 'hi, oh hi, so ummm, where are you from? oh, i'm from earth. huh. the other person says, so where are you from then? and the other person answers, earth.

soooo, how am i gonna get there then?

where?

to your house?

i don't know.
bus2bondi
Posts: 1012
Joined: Fri Aug 29, 2008 3:08 am

Re: nationalism

Post by bus2bondi »

then the other guy says, well, i'm all for maps and stuff, but since were stuck here i'd like to ask you a question. what do you think about the philosophy of fear?

the other guy says, well, all i know about really is that stuff i heard about bin laden.

apparently bin laden is all about the philosophy of fear and that's why we, where i live anyway, are attacking him.

hmmmm. the other guy says. i've never heard of this guy bin laden. doesn't sound like an upright guy to me. using force and fear?

yeah. from what i heard anyway, he was trying to silence the voice and well being of woman. he would hang them on a noose so to speak. that's what i heard anyway.

hmmm. not where i come from. i don't think i appreciate this osama guy very much for that, i come from a place where stuff like that isn't done. i grew up learning that all people like osama is about, isn't like people like us. type of thing.
chaz wyman
Posts: 5304
Joined: Fri Mar 12, 2010 7:31 pm

Re: nationalism

Post by chaz wyman »

bus2bondi wrote:i don't see anything wrong with it, unless its something that fuels something beyond, 'oh hey, i live over here yaaaaaay!' or 'i'm helping people out' type of thing.

can you imagine a world without nationalism? would it be kinda like this: 'hi, oh hi, so ummm, where are you from? oh, i'm from earth. huh. the other person says, so where are you from then? and the other person answers, earth.

soooo, how am i gonna get there then?

where?

to your house?

i don't know.
Yeah poison is okay, its just the dying bit that's bad. And those tsunamis are really pretty, its just the floods and destruction thats bad. And those bullets, really nice its just the holes in the head that's bad huh?

Nationalism is a plague on human thought. You do not have to spend long on Internet forums to realise how ridiculously it twists minds; my country right or wrong, by jingo!
John K
Posts: 194
Joined: Thu Dec 13, 2012 5:19 pm
Location: Gruithuisen's Lunar City.

Re: nationalism

Post by John K »

bus2bondi wrote:i don't see anything wrong with it, unless its something that fuels something beyond, 'oh hey, i live over here yaaaaaay!' or 'i'm helping people out' type of thing.

can you imagine a world without nationalism? would it be kinda like this: 'hi, oh hi, so ummm, where are you from? oh, i'm from earth. huh. the other person says, so where are you from then? and the other person answers, earth.
It's the degree of nationalism that draws my attention. Nationalism itself could be me cheering for my local football team, or Hitler frothing at the mouth in Nuremberg.
bus2bondi
Posts: 1012
Joined: Fri Aug 29, 2008 3:08 am

Re: nationalism

Post by bus2bondi »

hello again other guy, hello. what is all this other stuff about anti-nationalism you speak of?

i was?

oh yeah, well, it seems alright to me at times, but when i grew up i learned to fuck your head off for that mister.

what?

what do you mean. what? what?

exactly what i said@!

shit.
so, let me get this straight. you came from a place where cowboys used to blow peoples heads off in the street?

yeah.

do you do that anymore?

no.

huh.

what were you saying again?
John K
Posts: 194
Joined: Thu Dec 13, 2012 5:19 pm
Location: Gruithuisen's Lunar City.

Re: nationalism

Post by John K »

bus2bondi wrote:hello again other guy, hello. what is all this other stuff about anti-nationalism you speak of?

i was?

oh yeah, well, it seems alright to me at times, but when i grew up i learned to fuck your head off for that mister.

what?

what do you mean. what? what?

exactly what i said@!

shit.
so, let me get this straight. you came from a place where cowboys used to blow peoples heads off in the street?

yeah.

do you do that anymore?

no.

huh.

what were you saying again?
Exactly.
bus2bondi
Posts: 1012
Joined: Fri Aug 29, 2008 3:08 am

Re: nationalism

Post by bus2bondi »

your foaming at the other lobes other guy

i am?

yes.

i am?

you are.

i want to get to know you. i want to get to know what you are all about. why is your other lobe foaming?
chaz wyman
Posts: 5304
Joined: Fri Mar 12, 2010 7:31 pm

Re: nationalism

Post by chaz wyman »

John K wrote:
bus2bondi wrote:i don't see anything wrong with it, unless its something that fuels something beyond, 'oh hey, i live over here yaaaaaay!' or 'i'm helping people out' type of thing.

can you imagine a world without nationalism? would it be kinda like this: 'hi, oh hi, so ummm, where are you from? oh, i'm from earth. huh. the other person says, so where are you from then? and the other person answers, earth.
It's the degree of nationalism that draws my attention. Nationalism itself could be me cheering for my local football team, or Hitler frothing at the mouth in Nuremberg.
It is my view that they are both identical; a primitive emotion of tribalism, irrational, dangerous, useful.
Such emotions are immanent, ready to be mobilised to send boys to their deaths at a moment's notice.
John K
Posts: 194
Joined: Thu Dec 13, 2012 5:19 pm
Location: Gruithuisen's Lunar City.

Re: nationalism

Post by John K »

Yes, it's all that, but sometimes much more. But it does sound good. Just let me get my kicks before the whole shithouse goes up in flames (thanks Jim).
bus2bondi
Posts: 1012
Joined: Fri Aug 29, 2008 3:08 am

Re: nationalism

Post by bus2bondi »

John K wrote:It's the degree of nationalism that draws my attention. Nationalism itself could be me cheering for my local football team, or Hitler frothing at the mouth in Nuremberg.
i think cheering for a sports team is harmless. sometimes i've even viewed sports as being an alternative to actual war, because its a diversion from it. back in the day, those human energies were focused on actual bloody killing. i think modern sport is actually helpful and positive. (i'm not using parody or being ironic when i'm saying this)(i'll note from now on when i am to avoid any possible confusion).

in fact, a good portion of my life is spent around various teams of sport and i find myself hoping they win. however, when i just thought of that, i realized that i am unintentionally rooting for the teams going against my hometown :shock:. i want my hometown to win too. i don't think about sports much, if at all, so if i were at an actual sports match, i would be in the bleachers going 'hey! good job team member of the Stallions! and then if the opposing team made a point i would also say, 'hey good job team member of the Bears!' :lol: (pathetic i know) :lol:

so no, i don't find sports in any way comparable, connected or tied to something as serious as Hitler frothing at the mouth.
chaz wyman
Posts: 5304
Joined: Fri Mar 12, 2010 7:31 pm

Re: nationalism

Post by chaz wyman »

bus2bondi wrote:
John K wrote:It's the degree of nationalism that draws my attention. Nationalism itself could be me cheering for my local football team, or Hitler frothing at the mouth in Nuremberg.
i think cheering for a sports team is harmless. sometimes i've even viewed sports as being an alternative to actual war, because its a diversion from it. back in the day, those human energies were focused on actual bloody killing. i think modern sport is actually helpful and positive. (i'm not using parody or being ironic when i'm saying this)(i'll note from now on when i am to avoid any possible confusion).

in fact, a good portion of my life is spent around various teams of sport and i find myself hoping they win. however, when i just thought of that, i realized that i am unintentionally rooting for the teams going against my hometown :shock:. i want my hometown to win too. i don't think about sports much, if at all, so if i were at an actual sports match, i would be in the bleachers going 'hey! good job team member of the Stallions! and then if the opposing team made a point i would also say, 'hey good job team member of the Bears!' :lol: (pathetic i know) :lol:

so no, i don't find sports in any way comparable, connected or tied to something as serious as Hitler frothing at the mouth.
I don't think flag waving, is okay, be it for a football team, a religion or the queen. In ancient Pompeii, the teams were red, blue, green etc.. they did not reflect a town or a place, or ideology, They were pure cult. The after match violence would put the worst Euro-violence to shame. We are talking about murder and rioting. What were they all routing for? A colour??? Really? And that's all it takes.
It's not about the tea, the match, or the playing, its something hideous that lies beneath the human psyche. Deep tribal feelings of belonging. Incipient feelings to destroy all those that stand in your way.
Why do you care about your 'hometown' is does not matter.
None of this is harmless
Post Reply