Objectivity: Science vs Theology Rated
Posted: Mon Oct 30, 2023 8:28 am
Here is a TENTATIVE and provisional exercise in the rating of degrees of FSK-ed objectivity using the SAME set of main Criteria and Weightages.
There is a long list of necessary criteria and I have not used all here because those left out are not significant.
I have done the ratings on the degree of objectivity [FSK-ed] for the following
From the above, with the scientific FSK as the standard at 100%, the theological FSK's degrees of credibility and objectivity is 0%.
My proposed morality-proper FSK is rated at 83.05 relative to the standard because, whilst NOT dealing with direct empirical evidence, its major input is are scientific facts from the scientific FSK.
The figures below are subject to deliberation and will change but I do not expect the changes to vary significantly.
___________________________________
The Detail Ratings are as follows;
Scientific FSK
Criteria............................W.......Score ....Point
Empirical Evidence:..............0.85....90.......76.50
Predictive Power:.................0.04...90.........3.60
Testability and Falsifiability:....0.04...90........3.60
Reproducibility:...................0.05...90........4.50
Consistency w Existing
Knowledge:........................0.01...90.........0.90
Logical Coherence:...............0.01...90.........0.90
Total: ..............................1.00.............90.00
Because it is tedious I have not align the below like the above.
Theology FSK
Criteria W Score Point
Empirical Evidence: 0.85 0 0.00
Predictive Power: 0.04 0 0.00
Testability and Falsifiability: 0.04 0 0.00
Reproducibility: 0.05 0 0.00
Consistency w Existing Knowledge: 0.01 0 0.00
Logical Coherence: 0.01 0 0.00
Total 1.00 0.00
History FSK
Criteria W Score Point
Empirical Evidence: 0.85 50 42.50
Predictive Power: 0.04 0 0.00
Testability and Falsifiability: 0.04 0 0.00
Reproducibility: 0.05 50 2.50
Consistency w Existing Knowledge: 0.01 0 0.00
Logical Coherence: 0.01 50 0.50
Total 1.00 45.50
Morality Proper FSK
Criteria W Score Point
Empirical Evidence: 0.85 85 72.25
Predictive Power: 0.04 10 0.40
Testability and Falsifiability: 0.04 0 0.00
Reproducibility: 0.05 0 0.00
Consistency w Existing Knowledge: 0.01 90 0.90
Logical Coherence: 0.01 90 0.90
Total 1.00 74.45
______________________
The above are not carved in stones.
Discuss?? Views??
ps. can anyone show how can I post tables in this forum?
There is a long list of necessary criteria and I have not used all here because those left out are not significant.
I have done the ratings on the degree of objectivity [FSK-ed] for the following
If the scientific FSK is the most reliable and objective and taken as the Standard, then the relative degrees of objectivity to the standard are as follows;1. Scientific [the Standard] = 90.0
2. Theological = 0.00
3. History =45.50
4. My morality-proper FSKs =74.75
- 1. Scientific [the Standard] = 100%
2. My morality-proper FSKs =83.05% -[{74.75/90}*100]
3. History =50.55%
4. Theological = 0.00%
From the above, with the scientific FSK as the standard at 100%, the theological FSK's degrees of credibility and objectivity is 0%.
My proposed morality-proper FSK is rated at 83.05 relative to the standard because, whilst NOT dealing with direct empirical evidence, its major input is are scientific facts from the scientific FSK.
The figures below are subject to deliberation and will change but I do not expect the changes to vary significantly.
___________________________________
The Detail Ratings are as follows;
Scientific FSK
Criteria............................W.......Score ....Point
Empirical Evidence:..............0.85....90.......76.50
Predictive Power:.................0.04...90.........3.60
Testability and Falsifiability:....0.04...90........3.60
Reproducibility:...................0.05...90........4.50
Consistency w Existing
Knowledge:........................0.01...90.........0.90
Logical Coherence:...............0.01...90.........0.90
Total: ..............................1.00.............90.00
Because it is tedious I have not align the below like the above.
Theology FSK
Criteria W Score Point
Empirical Evidence: 0.85 0 0.00
Predictive Power: 0.04 0 0.00
Testability and Falsifiability: 0.04 0 0.00
Reproducibility: 0.05 0 0.00
Consistency w Existing Knowledge: 0.01 0 0.00
Logical Coherence: 0.01 0 0.00
Total 1.00 0.00
History FSK
Criteria W Score Point
Empirical Evidence: 0.85 50 42.50
Predictive Power: 0.04 0 0.00
Testability and Falsifiability: 0.04 0 0.00
Reproducibility: 0.05 50 2.50
Consistency w Existing Knowledge: 0.01 0 0.00
Logical Coherence: 0.01 50 0.50
Total 1.00 45.50
Morality Proper FSK
Criteria W Score Point
Empirical Evidence: 0.85 85 72.25
Predictive Power: 0.04 10 0.40
Testability and Falsifiability: 0.04 0 0.00
Reproducibility: 0.05 0 0.00
Consistency w Existing Knowledge: 0.01 90 0.90
Logical Coherence: 0.01 90 0.90
Total 1.00 74.45
______________________
The above are not carved in stones.
Discuss?? Views??
ps. can anyone show how can I post tables in this forum?