Page 1 of 6
Mind cannot be created
Posted: Mon Sep 05, 2016 5:21 pm
by bahman
First definition of mind: Mind is essence of any being with the ability to experience, decide and act.
1) Intellect is utility of mind
2) This means that it is impossible to understand mind because intellect is utility of mind
3) This means that it is impossible to perform an act to create mind
Re: Mind cannot be created
Posted: Tue Sep 06, 2016 10:54 am
by attofishpi
bahman wrote:First definition of mind: Mind is essence of any being with the ability to experience, decide and act.
1) Intellect is utility of mind
2) This means that it is impossible to understand mind because intellect is utility of mind
3) This means that it is impossible to perform an act to create mind
IVF.
Re: Mind cannot be created
Posted: Tue Sep 06, 2016 11:55 am
by Arising_uk
bahman wrote:3) This means that it is impossible to perform an act to create mind
Sex.
Re: Mind cannot be created
Posted: Tue Sep 06, 2016 2:11 pm
by bahman
attofishpi wrote:
bahman wrote:
First definition of mind: Mind is essence of any being with the ability to experience, decide and act.
1) Intellect is utility of mind
2) This means that it is impossible to understand mind because intellect is utility of mind
3) This means that it is impossible to perform an act to create mind
IVF.
That I knew. The problem is that you need to find an error in my reasoning.
Re: Mind cannot be created
Posted: Tue Sep 06, 2016 2:12 pm
by bahman
Arising_uk wrote:
bahman wrote:
3) This means that it is impossible to perform an act to create mind
Sex.
That I knew. I am however interested that how such a thing is possible.
Re: Mind cannot be created
Posted: Tue Sep 06, 2016 2:15 pm
by Arising_uk
bahman wrote: That I knew. I am however interested that how such a thing is possible.
It's called the Theory of Evolution.
Re: Mind cannot be created
Posted: Tue Sep 06, 2016 2:29 pm
by bahman
Arising_uk wrote:
bahman wrote:
That I knew. I am however interested that how such a thing is possible.
It's called the Theory of Evolution.
Again, that I knew. The problem which I raised is that we cannot know what mind is because the intellect is utility of mind hence we are not able to create something which has mind.
Re: Mind cannot be created
Posted: Tue Sep 06, 2016 3:11 pm
by attofishpi
bahman wrote:Arising_uk wrote:
bahman wrote:
That I knew. I am however interested that how such a thing is possible.
It's called the Theory of Evolution.
Again, that I knew. The problem which I raised is that we cannot know what mind is because the intellect is utility of mind hence we are not able to create something which has mind.
You have already been shown two ways we can and do create 'something which has mind.'
Re: Mind cannot be created
Posted: Tue Sep 06, 2016 3:16 pm
by Arising_uk
bahman wrote: Again, that I knew. The problem which I raised is that we cannot know what mind is because the intellect is utility of mind hence we are not able to create something which has mind.
But since 'mind' may well be a function of a body with senses in an external environment we may well be able to use the intellect to create such a body and hence create a mind.
Re: Mind cannot be created
Posted: Tue Sep 06, 2016 3:37 pm
by attofishpi
Arising_uk wrote:.. since 'mind' may well be a function of a body with senses in an external environment we may well be able to use the intellect to create such a body and hence create a mind.
Do you believe if we had a machine that could arrange the molecules required to replicate a human to the atomic level, we would in fact have a human - sensing, breathing and eventually farting?
Re: Mind cannot be created
Posted: Tue Sep 06, 2016 3:37 pm
by bahman
attofishpi wrote:
bahman wrote:
Arising_uk wrote:
It's called the Theory of Evolution.
Again, that I knew. The problem which I raised is that we cannot know what mind is because the intellect is utility of mind hence we are not able to create something which has mind.
You have already been shown two ways we can and do create 'something which has mind.
I don't recall that. Could you please direct me to the thread that I made such a claim?
Re: Mind cannot be created
Posted: Tue Sep 06, 2016 3:40 pm
by HexHammer
bahman wrote:First definition of mind: Mind is essence of any being with the ability to experience, decide and act.
1) Intellect is utility of mind
2) This means that it is impossible to understand mind because intellect is utility of mind
3) This means that it is impossible to perform an act to create mind
Have you lived a sheltered life? ..you should know such things like psychology and neurology ..just to name a few things that spend time on researching the mind.
You are utterly clueless, and kuku!
Re: Mind cannot be created
Posted: Tue Sep 06, 2016 3:54 pm
by bahman
Arising_uk wrote:
bahman wrote:
Again, that I knew. The problem which I raised is that we cannot know what mind is because the intellect is utility of mind hence we are not able to create something which has mind.
But since 'mind' may well be a function of a body with senses in an external environment we may well be able to use the intellect to create such a body and hence create a mind.
That is the point that I am trying to reach with my argument. Is that possible that we understand how we are understanding? In fact the problem that we are dealing is much harder than that since understanding is a faculty of mind.
Re: Mind cannot be created
Posted: Tue Sep 06, 2016 3:55 pm
by attofishpi
bahman wrote:attofishpi wrote:
bahman wrote:
Again, that I knew. The problem which I raised is that we cannot know what mind is because the intellect is utility of mind hence we are not able to create something which has mind.
You have already been shown two ways we can and do create 'something which has mind.
I don't recall that. Could you please direct me to the thread that I made such a claim?
What claim? Please re-read.
Re: Mind cannot be created
Posted: Tue Sep 06, 2016 3:58 pm
by attofishpi
bahman wrote:Arising_uk wrote:
bahman wrote:
Again, that I knew. The problem which I raised is that we cannot know what mind is because the intellect is utility of mind hence we are not able to create something which has mind.
But since 'mind' may well be a function of a body with senses in an external environment we may well be able to use the intellect to create such a body and hence create a mind.
That is the point that I am trying to reach with my argument. Is that possible that we understand how we are understanding? In fact the problem that we are dealing is much harder than that since understanding is a faculty of mind.
So your point is, that it takes a more complex intelligence to create a lower complexity intelligence? A lower complexity intelligence cannot create a higher complexity or more intelligent intelligence?